Mrs. J. Zeenath Bivi, Proprietrix N.V.K.M. Traders Rep. by Her Power of Attorney Holder Mr. J. Zackaria Vs. M. Khader Ibrahim and ors.

Decided On : Dec-24-2003

Court : Chennai

LAW: the Companies Act, section 46, 'Trademarks Act', section 24, the Trademarks Act, section 24, the Trademarks Act, the Trademarks Act, section 46, the Trademarks Act, section 24, the Trademarks Act, section 24, the Trademarks Act, section 24, the Trademarks Act, the Trademarks Act, the Trademarks Act, section 46, the Trademarks Act, section 46(3, section 24, the Trademarks Act, section 24, the Trademarks Act, section 24, the Trademarks Act, section 24, the Trademarks Act, the Trademark Law, the Companies Act, section 48, the Trademarks Act, the Trademarks Act, the Trademarks Act, section 46, the Trademarks Act, section 46, section 46, section 46, section 48

PERSON: N.V. Balasubramanian, N.V.K.M., Zeenath Bivi, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Zeenath Bivi, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Nos, Nos, Zeenath Bivi, Rs.75, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, O.P. Nos, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, N.V.K.M., Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, O.P. Nos, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, N.V.K.M. Traders, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, G. Masilamani, Zeenath Bivi, M.K. Rao, G. Masilamani, Zeenath Bivi, G. Masilamani, appellant.15, M.K. Rao, Law, Chennai, M.K. Rao, G. Masilamani, M.K. Rao, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, N.V.K.M. Khader Ibrahim, Khader Ibrahim, Khader Ibrahim, Khader Ibrahim, Khader Ibrahim, M.K. Rao, Khader Ibrahim, Khader Ibrahim, Khader Ibrahim, Khader Ibrahim, N.V.K.M. Khader Ibrahim, facie, N.V.K.M. Khader Ibrahim, N.V.K.M. Khader Ibrahim, facie, G. Masilamani, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, G. Masilamani, G. Masilamani, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Bench, G. Masilamani, Zeenath Bivi, Zeenath Bivi, Nos, S. Revathi, Partner R. Varadarajan, Jafer Sait, M. RAMALINGAM, AIR1958Bom56 Chagla, Dunn, Eno, Dunn, Eno, Eno, Fruit Salt', Eno, Dunn, G. Masilamani, G. Masilamani, G. Masilamani, G. Masilamani, M.K. Rao, M.K. Rao, G. Masilamani, B.N. Kirpal, Law, Zeenath Bivi, G. Masilamani, G. Masilamani, Nos, M.K. Rao, M.K. Rao, Kadher Ibrahim, RAJA, Nos, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Mohamed Sultan Rowther, Zeenath Bivi, P. Narayanan Law, Passing Off, 4th Ed, Lakshmanan, Chakraborty, P. Narayanan(4th Edn, Sen Raleigh, Sen Raleigh, Nos, G. Masilamani, G. Masilamani

CARDINAL: 1, 30 to 37, 730, 733, 727, 444 to 447, 455, two, one, 727, 455, 2., eight, 4., one, 22.1.1946, 1.4.1966, 455, 18.7.1966, 1.4.1966, 30.7.1966, 29.10.1966, 1.4.1966, 5, 1.1.1984, 12.7.1984, 12.7.1984, 6, 961, 962, 1.4.1993, 5.7.1995, 961, 962, 11.9.1995, 124, 688, 6.2.1996, eight, 24.3.1996, 8, 5.2.1998, six, 688, 64, 17.11.2000, 23.2.2001, 2.3.2001, 688, 14.5.2001, two, two, 88, 688, 8.4.2002, 2.12.2002, 87-88/2001, 11.5.2002, four, 1, 31, 10, 22.6.2002, 24.6.2002, 406 to 411, 8.7.2002, 455, 75, 444 to 447, 727, 730, 733, 455, 31.12.2002, 31.1.2003, 444 to 447, 730, 455, 2, 455, 3., 1, 13, 104, 111, one, one, 14, 12.7.1984, 88, 6.4.1998, 1.4.1990, 31.3.1991, 455, 88, 25,000/-, 30, one, one, one, 88, 455, 88, 49, 5.7.1995, 961, 962, 961, 962, 961, 962, 8.4.2002, 8.4.2002, 8, 17, one, 455, 727, 455, 18., 455, 88, one, 455, 88, 20, 961, 962, 5.7.1995, 961, 962, 28.8.1995, 22, one, one, two, 1, 116, one, one, 24, 11.5.2002, 25, one, one, two, 27, 118, 109, 29, 30, 32, 33, one, one, one, two, 34, 11.9.1995, 5.7.1995, 8.2.1995, 1.4.1993, 8.2.1995, 8.2.1995, 961, 962, 5.7.1995, 12.7.1984, 12.7.1984, one, 12.7.1984, 2.3.2001, two, 5.7.1995, 36, 37., one, 41, 42, 43, 25,000/-, more than 24, 3,4, 6, 730, 733, 1, 3, 45, one, 88, 75, 11.9.1995, 47, 1, 4, 12.7.1984, one, 12.7.1984, 31.3.1991, 49, 88, 50, 334, 21.82, 386, 3, 56, 88, 57, 2.3.2001, 5.7.1995, 59, 88, two, 62

DATE: 2003, 2002, 2002, 2002, 2002, 2002, 31.12.2002, a month, 31.1.2003, 2002, 1942, 2002, between 1966 and 1986, the same day, five years, 24.9.1986, 23.9.1986, five years, 1986 to 1992, 14.3.1992, 24.9.1986, 23.9.1991, 23.9.1991, 1992, 1992, 1992, 1934, 1992, 28.8.1995, March, 1996, March, 1996, 1992, 1034, 1998, 1996, 24.3.1998, 24.3.1998, 13.4.1998, 1994, 1998, 1034, 1998, 22.4.1998, 2000, 1992, 1998, 87, 88 of 2001, 14.2.2002, 87, 2001, 1577 of 1992, 2001, 14.2.2002, 87, 88 of 2001, 2002, 1541 of 2001, 2002, 1541/2001, 2002, 2002, September, 2002, 2002, 2002, 2002, 2002, 2002, 2002, 1996, seven years, 87, 88 of 2001, decades, a month, 12.7.1989, 12.7.1989, 12.7.1989, 1958, five years, one month, 23.9.1991, 28.8.1995, 27.10.1995, 1995, the year 1995, July, 2002, 1995, 1995, 1995, 1995, 1995, 87, 2002, 1995, 2002, 87, paragraph-33, annual, 11.5.2002, 1995, 87, 2002, 87, 2002, 48, 12.7.1989, the year 1993, 1995, 1992, 1992, 1995, 1992, 1577 of 1992, 1992, 2000, the expiry of five years, one month, April, 2002, 12.7.1989, the year 1992, 8.4.2002, 8.4.2002, 2002, 17.10.2003, 2003, 28.10.2003, 2002, 26.11.2002, 2002, 2002, 14.2.2002, 2002, 87, 1995, the year 1995, 1577 of 1992, November, 1992, 1992, 1992, 27.10.1995, 1994]1SCR708, 87, 88 of 2001, 1999, 23.4.2003, 1992, 1995, '26, '28, five years, one month, 1995, 1995, five years, one month, five years, one month, five years, one month, the year 1989, the year 1992, the expiry of five years, one month, 87, 88 of 2001, 28.8.1995, 1934, 1934, 1.11.1991, 1992, 87, 88 of 2001, 35, 1995, five years, 14.3.1992, 23.9.1986, 23.9.1991, 12.7.1989, 24.9.1986, 14.3.1992, 14.2.2002, 8.4.2002, 8.4.2002, 1994]1SCR708, '39, 87, 88 of 2001, 2002, 44, 1992, 1577 of 1992, 87, 88 of 2001, 87, 88 of 2001, 87, 46, 1984, five years, 12.7.1989, 24.9.1986, 87, 88 of 2001, 12.07.1989, the 24th of September 1986, 48, 83, 1958, Para 20.16.P.335, '51, '52, '54, 1954, 55, 87, 2002, the year 1992, 1992, 14.3.1992, 58, 87, 88 of 2001, 8.4.2002, 87, 2002, 87, 88 of 2001, 8.4.2002, 8.4.2002, 8.4.2002

GPE: O.A., C.S., O.A. Nos, C.S., C.S., C.S., C.S., C.S., Dindigul, C.S., C.S., O.A., O.A., O.A., O.S., Dindigul, C.S., C.S., I.A., C.S., I.A., C.M.A., C.S., C.S., C.M.A., C.S., C.S., C.M.A., O.S.A. Nos, C.S., O.A., C.S., O.A. Nos, C.S., O.A. Nos, C.S., C.S., O.S.A. Nos, O.S., C.S., O.A., O.A., C.S., O.A., O.S., C.S., C.S., C.S., C.S., C.S., C.S., Chennai, C.S., O.A., O.A., supari, Salem, Bungalow Street, L.P.A., C.S., O.A., NEW DELHI, O.A., C.P., C.S., O.S.A. Nos, Narayanan, C.S.

ORG: Court, Court, ROJA, Court, N.V.K., ROJA, RAJA, KERA, N.V.K., N.V.K., the State of Tamil Nadu, N.V.K., the Trademark Registry, N.V.K., S. Ameen Bibi, N.V.K.M. & Sons, Court, the N.V.K.M.& Sons P. Ltd., ROJA, RAJA, KERA, Court, Court, the High Court, District Munsif, Court, Court, N.V.K.M. & Sons, N.V.K.M. & Sons, O.S. No, City Civil Court, Chennai, the City Civil Court, the City Civil Court, Chennai, Court, Court, C.R.P. No, Court, Court, Learned Judges, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, C.R.P. No, The Supreme Court, the High Court, C.R.P. No, OSA, Court, Mohamed Sultan Rowther & Sons', Roja Betelnut Manufacturing Company' ', Court, Learned Single, Learned Single, Learned Single, Learned Single, Learned Single, Learned Single, Learned Single, the Division Bench, Learned Single, Learned Single, Learned Single, the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, Original, Court, the Supreme Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, M/s. Vaigai Trading Co. Ltd., M/s. Jaleel Traders, M/s.M.S.R. Co., M/s. Roja Finance and Investment Ltd., M/s. Rose Agency, Court, the Division Bench, Court, Bench, Court, Court, the Division Bench, the Division Bench, Court, Court, Special Leave Petition, the Supreme Court, Court, the Special Leave Petition, N.V.K.M. & Sons, the II Metropolitan Magistrate, the Supreme Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, The Registry of this Court, Court, Court, Chennai, Court, Chennai, Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, DACK BACK', DACK BACK', Court, Supreme Court, Court, the Supreme Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, the Supreme Court, SUMEETH MACHINES PVT, the Supreme Court, the Division Bench, Court, the Division Bench, the Division Bench, Court, Court, Court, the Division Bench, Court, Court, Court, Learned Single, Court, The Supreme Court, CIBA LTD, Bench, Court, The Bombay High Court, House of Lords, ENO, DUNN, Court, the High Court, The Supreme Court, HARDIE TRADING LTD, CHEMICALS LTD, AIR 2003 SCW 4788, The Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Court, Court, Bench, Court, Court, Court, Court, N.V.K.M. & Sons, Court, Court, Court, RAJA, Court, Court, the Supreme Court, Special Leave Petition, the Supreme Court, the Special Leave Petition, Court, the Division Bench, Delhi High Court, Statute, Court, The Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Court, Court, Court, N.V.K.M. & Sons, Court, Kerala Court, Court, ROJA, KERA, Court, Court, N.V.K., N.V.K., Sons, N.V.K., Mohamed Sultan Rowther & Sons, N.V.K., Mohamed Sultan Rowther & Sons, N.V.K., Court, Court, Court, the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, Court, the Supreme Court, COCA COLA COMPANY, the Supreme Court, 4th Edn, FATIMA TILE WORKS v. SUDARSAN TRADING COMPANY LTD, the Calcutta High Court, CYCLE CORPORATION OF INDIA LTD, INDUSTRIES PVT. LTD, The Calcutta High Court, Court, Legislature, the Calcutta High Court, the Supreme Court, INDIA LTD, T.I. RALEIGH INDUSTRIES PVT. LTD, the Supreme Court, Court, the Law of Trade Marks, Court, Registrar, The High Court, The High Court, the High Court, the High Court, the Supreme Court, HARDIE TRADING LTD, ADDISIONS, CHEMICALS LTD, AIR 2003 SCW 4788, Court, Court, Court, Chennai, Court, Court, Court, Court, the Division Bench, Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Special Leave, the Supreme Court, Special Leave Petitions, Court, the Supreme Court, Court, the Supreme Court, Court, the Supreme Court

LOC: Single, Single Judge, Single Judge

ORDINAL: second, second, second, second, Secondly, first, second, second, second, second, first, second, second, second, first, 4th, 5th, first, third, first, 14th, Secondly

FAC: Proprietrix

NORP: Trademarks

PRODUCT: Raleighs, Registrar

PERCENT: nearly 95%