All India Power Engineer Federation and Ors. Vs. Sasan Power Ltd. and Ors. Etc.

Decided On : Dec-08-2016

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Section 63, the Electricity Act, Schedule 11, Article 6, Schedule 11, Article 6 of the PPA, the Electricity Act, Article 6.3.1, Article 6.3.1, Article 18.3 of the PPA, Article, Article 18.1, Section 63, the Indian Contract Act, the Contract Act, Article 18.3 of the PPA, the Contract Act, the Electricity Act, Article 6.3.1 and in|, Unit 620.4 MW, Article 8.2, |the Grid Code, Article, Article 8.2.1, Article 4.7.1 | | |and, Article 6, Article 12, |Article 8, Article 2.5, Article 1.1, Article 6, Article 6.1.1, the Grid System, the Grid System, Article 6.3.1, Article 6.3.1, Article 6.3.3, Article 6.3.3, the Available Capacity of the Unit, Article 6.3.3, Article 8.2.2, Article 6.3.3, Article 6.3.3, the Electricity Act, the Electricity Act, Section 28, the Grid Code, Section 29, Section 61, the Electricity (Supply) Act, Section 62, Section 63, section 62, Article 18, Article 18.1, Article 18.3.12, Article 18.1, Article 18.3.13, the Indian Contract Act, the Indian Contract Act, Statute, Act or Regulation, Section 62, Section 63, Section 62, Section 62, the Indian Contract Act, Section 63, Article 18.3, Article 6, Article 18.3, Section 63, Section 1 of the Contract Act, Section 63, the Contract Act, Section 1 of the Contract Act:“The Indian Contract Act, the Indian Contract Act, Section 63, the Contract Act, Section 63, the Indian Contract Act, Section 26-F, Section 63, the Indian Contract Act, the Electricity Act, Section 61, Section 62 of the Act, Section 61, Section 63, Section 62, Section 63, section 63, the Electricity Act, Section 63, Section 63, Article 6.3, Article 6, Article 6, Article 6, Article 6.3.1, Schedule 5, Article 6.3.2, Article 6.3.1, Article 6, Article 6.3.3, Article 6.3.3, Article 6.3.4, Article 8.2.2, Article 6, Article 6.3.3 and Article 6.3.4, article 6.3.1, Article 6 and, the Schedule 4, article 6, article 6.3.1, Article 6.3.1 of the PPA, Article 6 and, Article 6, Article 6.3.1 of the PPA, the Test Certificate of the Independent Engineer, the Performance Test, Article 6.3.4, Article 6.3.4, Article 11.1 of the PPA, Article 6.3.3, Article 6.3.1, Article 6.3.4, Article 11.1, Article 6.3.4, Article 6.3.1(b, Article 6.3.1(b, Article 6.3.4, Article 6.3.3, Article 6.3.3, Article 6.3.1(b, Article 6.3.1, Article 6.3.4, Article 11, Section 125, the Electricity Act, Article 6.3.1

ORG: THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL, ETC, the Central Government, Power Finance Corporation Limited, Government of India, the Nodal Agency, MW, Madhya Pradesh, Sasan Power Limited, Power Finance Corporation, Power Finance Corporation, Reliance Power Limited, Reliance Power Ltd., the Power Purchase Agreement, Sasan Power Limited, Reliance Power Limited, Schedule 5, Commercial Operation Date, the Effective Date, COD, COD, 16.8.2013, COD, the Appellate Tribunal, 27.3.2013, Sasan, the Western Region Load Dispatch Centre, 30.3.2013, COD, the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, CERC, the Independent Engineer, no.2, MW, COD, CERC, CERC, Certificate, IE, IE, COD, SPL, Commission, CERC, Commission, COD, the Appellate Tribunal, the Appellate Tribunal, COD, AAG, Schedule 5, COD, PPA, Uttarakhand Power, COD, Commission, COD, Sasan Power, the Independent Engineer’s, Sasan Power Ltd., Sasan, COD, the Appellate Tribunal, CERC, the Appellate Tribunal, CERC, Appropriate Commission, |“Date, Procurers, Units, COD, Contract, Operation Date, MW, MW, MW, MW, MW, MW, |the Interconnection Point, Date, the Power| | |Station, MW, Tariff, |Certificate, Independent, Independent, Repeat Performance Tests, CERC, COD, Date, the Power Station, Article| | |8, Schedule 5, Supercritical, Procurers, the Grid System, NTP, Commissioned, Procurers, the Independent Engineer, Procurers, the Independent Engineer, Schedule 5 of this Agreement, Procurers, the Independent Engineer, Independent Engineer, Procurers, Commissioning Test, Final Test Certificate, Final Test Certificate, Commissioned, Procurers, Final Test Certificate, Schedule 5, the Unit’s Tested Capacity, Contracted Capacity, the Effective Date, Procurers, the Independent Engineer, Procurers, Procurers, Procurers, Procurers, Tested Capacity, Procurers, Procurers, Procurers, Performance Test, Contracted Capacity, the Effective Date, the Unit’s Contracted Capacity, Tested Capacity, Quoted Capacity, Contracted Capacity, The Quoted Non Escalable Capacity Charge, Tested Capacity, Contracted Capacity, the Effective Date, Commissioned, Tested Capacity, Contracted Capacity, the Capital Structure Schedule, the Contracted Capacity, the Contracted Capacity, Commissioned, Initial Performance Retest, Performance Test, the Tested Capacity, the Contracted Capacity, Initial Performance Retest, Performance Test, the Initial Performance Retest Period, Performance Test, the Effective Date, the Unit’s Contracted Capacity, Tested Capacity, Tested Capacity, Tested Capacity, Tested Capacity, the Unit’s Contracted Capacity, the Tested Capacity, the Contracted Capacity, Initial Consents, Tested Capacity, the Energy Charges, Schedule 7, the Appropriate Commission, Party, Party, Party, Party, the Contracted Capacity, each Unit a Performance Test, Contracted Capacity, the Effective Date, the Electrical System Limits, the Functional Specifications, the Electrical System Limits, the Functional Specification, the Functional Specification, the Functional Specification, Contracted Capacity, the Performance Test, the Functional Specifications for Ramping rate, Schedule 4, the Performance Test, Supercritical Technology, |Non- |Escalable |Non- |Indexed, |15, |17 |1-Apr-2028 |31-Mar-2029|0.160, Regional Load Despatch Centre, The Regional Load Despatch Centre, The Regional Load Despatch Centre, the Central Commission, The Regional Load Despatch Centre, The Regional Load Despatch Centre, the Central Commission, The Regional Load Despatch Centre, the Regional Load Despatch Centres, the Regional Load Despatch Centres, State, State, State, State, the State Load Despatch Centre, the State Load Despatch Centres, The Regional Power Committee, the Central Commission, the Central Commission, the Regional Load Despatch Centre, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Central Commission, the Appropriate Commission, the National Electricity Policy, the Electricity Regulatory Commission Act, Appropriate Commission, the Appropriate Commission, the Appropriate Commission, The Appropriate Commission, Appropriate Commission, Commission, Appropriate Commission, the Central Government, Sections 1, Commencements.-It, N.V. Internationale Crediet-En-Handels Vereeninging ‘, Baron & Co., Chitguppi & Co., Hindustan Bank, Ltd., Court, Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, • Technical, • Assured, • Force, • Default, • Payment, the Appropriate Commission, Appropriate Commission, CERC, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, COD, Commission, Commission, Schedule 5, Schedule 5, Sasan, Court, Customs, Schedule 5, Schedule 5, Schedule 5, Schedule 5, Schedule 4, Schedule 5, Schedule 5, COD, COD, Schedule 5, COD, COD, COD, Schedule 5, COD, M.P. Power Management Company Limited, Sasan, COD, Sasan, COD, COD, 30.3.2013, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, the Independent Engineer, Lahmeyer International (India) Pvt, Corporate Office & Correspondence, House, 37 Institutional Area, Gurgaon-122002, National Capital Region, MW, MW, Certificate, Sasan Power Limited, SPL, the Power Procurers, IE, SPL, the Contracted Capacity, MW, Holi Festival, MW, MW, MW, MW, MW, The Commissioning Test, Schedule 5 of PPA, the Unit’s Tested Capacity, MW, the Electrical Limits of the Functional Specifications, MW, MW, MW, MW, MW, Capacity of the Unit (, MW, MW, MIN, Original Equipment Manufacturer, Boiler, Turbine & Generator, Contracted Capacity, Supercritical Technology, Main Steam, Main Steam, MW, Turbine, Unit-3, MW, Unit-3, Schedule 4, Lahmeyer International s(India, MW, MW, Schedule 4, CERC, the Independent Engineer, the Independent Engineer, Schedule 5, Schedule 4, the Independent Engineer, MW, 30.3.2013, Unit, MW, the Independent Engineer, MW, Schedule 5, the Effective Date, the Independent Engineer, MW, MW, the Commercial Operation Date, the Independent Engineer, Schedule 5, the Appellate Tribunal, RKS, COD, MW, UMPP Sasan Project, Schedule 5 of PPA, Contracted Capacity, MW, 2nd Floor, Dear Sir, the Independent Engineer’s, MW, MW, Western Region Load Despatch Centre, MW, the Independent Engineer, MW, MW, MW, Procurers, Sd/- Executive, IPC, COD, MW, MW, Schedule 5, MW, MW, 30.3.2013, rights.45, BYPL, BRPL, Reliance Group Companies, BRPL, COD, SPL, BRPL, COD, MW, the Appellate Tribunal, the Appellate Tribunal, Supreme Court, Supreme Court, Supreme Court, COD, the Central Commission, COD, CERF, the Central Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, the Appellate Tribunal’s, the Appellate Tribunal’s, the Independent Engineer’s, the Appellate Tribunal

DATE: NOS.5881-5882, 2003, 10.2.2006, 10.2.2006, 1.8.2007, year, year, 25 years, the first two years, the very day, the period of 25 years, the entire first year, one day, 31st March, the contract year, such year, May, 2013, 27th November, 2012, 2003, the following day, 2009, 16th August, 10.1(c, 10.2(c, March, 2013, 16th August, the month of July, one entire year, one day, the first year, the second year, the second year, 1872, 31st March, 2003, one day, |March 31, 12 months, March 31, the financial year, Year, March 31, 2013, 2013, July 7, 2014, February 7, September, 2015, April 7, 2016, 180) days, 60) days, 30) days, 36 months, the day, 3) day, 15) days, 15) days, 180) days, 15) days, one year, thirty (30) days, seventy two consecutive hours, |(Rs, May 2013|0.21 |0.001 |0.575 |0.001 | |2 |1-Apr-2013 |31-Mar-2014|0.125, 2003, 29, 61, 62, 2003, multi year, 1948, 1998, one year, one year, any financial year, 62, 1872, 1872, the first day of September, 1872, 65, 1918, 1872, 1920, 1931, 1969, 1974, 1971, 1990, 2004, each of the years, 90 days, 17.10.2007, year one, one day, year two, one day, more than year one and year three, more than year two, two years, one year, only one year, one day, 30th March, 11, year one, one day, 2002, the date one day, the first week of March, 2013, between 27.3.2013, the period 1st April to 16th August, 2013, June, 27th March 2013 to 30th March 2013, 27th March 2013, 27th March 2013, 2000, 27th March 2013, seventy two, 28th March 2013, 29th March 2013, 29th March 2013, 30th March 2013, seventy two, 28th March 2013, 1900, 2000, 30th March 2013, 1300, 29th March 2013, March 2013, August, 28.03.2013, 30th March 2013, 30th March 2013, 30th March 2013, 30th March 2013, 12th April, 2013, 2nd April, 2013, 9312147045, 2009, 48, 2003, December 08, 2016

PERSON: R.F. Nariman, J.1, Schedule, Jayant Bhushan, Gopal Jain, M.G. Ramachandran, Purusha Indra Kavrar, Alok Shankar, Articles 3.1.2, Articles, Sasan, Sasan, Sasan, Shri Chidambaram, Sasan, Haryana, Haryana, Seller, Procurer, Schedule 7, Seller, Seller, Seller, Schedule 5, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Performance Test, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Grid System, Seller, Seller, Schedule, |21 |1-Apr-2032 |31-Mar-2033|0.157, |23 |1-Apr-2034 |31-Mar-2035|0.126, |24 |1-Apr-2035 |31-Mar-2036|0.126, Schedule, Juggilal Kamlapat v., Rotterdam, Viscount Haldane, Morris, para 15].15, ILR1948(2, Justice Story, mero motu, Vinaya Kashinath, L.R., Surendranath De, Jagad Bandhu Chatterjee, Nilima Rani, Waman Shriniwas Kini, Ratilal Bhagwandas &, Mohammedan Jurisprudence, P. Dasa, P. Appa Rao, Waiver, para 13].20, Lachoo Mal v., Radhey Shyam, licet renuntiare, Eleventh Edn, para 6].22, Indira Bai, Nand Kishore, para 5].23, Krishna Bahadur v., Purna Theatre, para 9].24, Schedule, Schedule, Virgo Steels Bombay, Sasan, Sasan, Sasan, Sasan, Sasan, Sasan, Sasan, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Schedule 4, Max, Schedule 4, kg, deg C. iii, deg C., Kg, Reheat, Generator, Sd/- R.K. Soni Project, Dated:30, Sasan, Seller, Sasan, Dhirubhai Ambani Knowledge City, Koparkhairane, Appellants, ’s COD, Waiver, Haryana, Sanjay Srivastav, Sanjay Srivastav, V.P., Sasan, Waman Shriniwas, Krishan Lal’s, Sasan, Joseph, Nariman

CARDINAL: 19.1.2005, 1, 3, 5, 15, 660, No.3, 31.3.2013, 69, 11, No.3, 20.3.2013, 30.3.2013, 31.3.2013, 620, 25.4.2013, 1, 101.38, 5, 8.8.2014, five, 6, 31.3.2013, 31.3.2016, 31.3.2013, No.3, 31.3.2013, No.3, 4.4.2(b, 31.3.2013, 31.3.2013, 69, 70, 27.2.2013, No.3, 69, 70, 31.3.2013, 1, 6.3.1, 5, 1, 620.4, 620.4, 620.4, 620.4, 5, 2015;|, |one hundred and eighty, one, 6, at least thirty, 6.1.2, 6.2, less than ten, 6.2.4, 6.2.5, five, five, 6.3, 6.3.1, less than ninety five, 6.3.2, three, fifteen, 6.3.3, at least fifteen, up to eight, 8), one hundred and eighty, fifteen, less than ninety five, 1, 6.4, 18, 18.3, 5, 1.1, 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 11, |18, 10, 28, 63, 1, 2, 3, 4, 1, 2, 1, 3, 4, 5, 1, 6, 2, 3, fifteen, 1, two, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 11, 63, 14, 15, 1, 1, 17, 1, 262, 263, 176, 45, 157, 959, 148, 152, 163, 171, 174, three, four, 667, 17, 3, 226, 5].19, 2, two, one, one, one, 1, 375 and 376, 4, 8, two, 61 to 63, 19.1.2005, 2.3, 26, 4, 4.11, 27, 28, 5.16, 29, 61 to 63, four, 62, 11, 31.3.2013, 11, 1.4.2013, one, 4, 6.3.1, 27.2.2013, 31.3.2013, 31.3.2013, No.3, 31.3.2013, 660, 6.3.1, 15.18, 620.4 MW(ex, 72, 100, 22.19, 150, 50, fifty, about 100, 150, 14.18, 150, less than 101.38, 72, 21.83, 0.89, 1200, 36, two, 101.38, 101.38, 5, 38, only 101.38, 620, 587, 9, 101.38, 587, 5, 8.8.2014, 30.3.2013, 1.1, 101.38, 5, 27.03.2013, 30.03.2013, 101.38, 100, 101.38, 101.38, 28.03.2013, 101.38, 31.03.2013, 31.3.2013, 660, 6.3.1, less than ninety five, 101.38, 41, 2.4.2013, 1, 400 710, 3, 660, 6x660, 31.3.2013, No.3, 101.38, 101.38, 101.38, 101.38, 42, two, 3, 101.38, 101.38, 6.3.4, 101.38, two, 6.3.1, two, 31.3.2013, 101.38, 12.4.2013, 450, 43.58, 660, 46, 660, 31.3.2016, 21, 30.3.2013, 8.8.2014, One

GPE: States, Sasan District, Rs./kwh, |26, India, the State of Jammu, India, England, Glanville, India, juri, pp, Bombay, North Wing, Thane, Navi Mumbai, Delhi, New Delhi

PERCENT: minus 20%, 100%, 95%, 95%, 95%, 95%, only roughly 17%, 95%, 95%, 17%, 95%, 95%, roughly 12%, 65%, 95%, about 95%, less than 95%, 95%, 95%, 95%, 95%, 100%, below 50%, 50%, 1%, 95%, below 50%, 50%, 95%, 95%, 95%, 95%, 95%, at least 95%

WORK_OF_ART: COD, 30.3.2013, COD, |Means the Unit, |(ii, the Grid System, Commissioning Test of each Unit, Commissioning Test of each Unit, Commissioning Test, Initial Performance Retest Period, The Performance Test, the Grid System, Performance Test, the Grid Standards, the Law of Bailments, 4.11 Where applicable, Performance Test, Test Certificate of Performance Test, Dear Sir From Sasan UMPP Delhi

TIME: 72 hours, 72 hours, the minutes, 72 consecutive hours, 72 hours, 15.35 hours, the morning, 21.40 hours, 07.13 hours, hours, 20.00 hours, around 50 hours, 22 hours, 72 Hours Test, 72 Hours Test, 72 Hours Test, one hour, 72 consecutive hours, the morning, 06.00 a.m., 72 consecutive hours, 06.00 a.m., 72 hours, 06.00 a.m.

ORDINAL: first, first, 7th, first, first, first, first, second, sixth, first, second, fourth, fifth, sixth, eighth, eighth, eighth, third, first, eighth, first, first, first, first, first, 7th, first, second, first, first, first, 1st, first

PRODUCT: 31.3.2013, 31.3.2013, the Power Station, Agreement, Laws, |20 |1-Apr-2031 |31-Mar-2032|0.158, Para 5.4, Chaired, 30.3.2013

NORP: CERC, |Means, Tests, Scheduled, Scheduled, declared|, |Means, |Means, Indian, Indian, Indian, Intec

EVENT: Contract Year, the Grid Code, Sections 61, Hourly Net Generation of the|101.38 mw FROM0600HRS

FAC: the Effective Date, the Performance Test, the Performance Test, Belapur Road

LOC: Kashmir

LANGUAGE: English

QUANTITY: 64 deg, 04 deg C.8, 12.39 AM