Khoday Brewing and Distilling Industries Ltd. Vs. State of Tamil Nadu and Others

Decided On : Apr-28-1989

Court : Chennai

LAW: Rule 16, Rule 16, Rule 16, Constitution, Rule 16, Rule 16, Constitution, Constitution, Rule 16, Constitution, Constitution, the Companies Act, the Indian Companies Act, Constitution, the Companies Act, Constitution, Article, The Constitution Bench, a Constitution Bench, Constitutional, the Constitution Bench, Article 19(1)(g, the Companies Act, Constitution, Article, Constitution, MLW 383, Act 19 of 1952, Constitution, the Constitution Bench, Constitution, Commissions of Inquiry Act, Constitution, Rule 16, Rule 16

ORG: ORDERSathiadev, IMFS, IMPSProducts, the State of Tamil Nadu, IMPS, IMFS, Delhi Administration, Canteen Stores Department, IMPSproducts, State, Earnest Money Deposit of Rs.5,00,000/-, State, the Negotiating Committee, Committee, W.P. No., W.P. No, Court, W.P. No, W.P. Nos, W.P. Nos, Advocate General, IMFS, TASMAC, Corporation, State Undertaking, the Government., IMFS, State, Corporation, Government, a Tender Negotiation Committee, Committee, Press, Court, the High Court, Government, the Negotiation Committee, Corporation, the Corporation, Hence, the Earnest Money Deposit, W.P. Nos, W.P. Nos, Government, IMFS Products, the Tamil Nadu Distillery Rules, Prohibition & Excise, Accountant-General, Prohibition & Excise, Home and Prohibition and Excise, Government, Home, Corporation, Corporation, TASMAC, Positions, Committee, Corporation, State, State, Corporation, State, Arts, Corporation, Corporation, State, the Negotiating Committee, Corporation, Delhi Administration, Government, the High Court, Corporation, IMPS, State, State, Canteen Stores Department, Delhi Administration, Delhi Administration, State, State, the Delhi Administration, State, Learned Advocate-General, Decisions, Commrcl, AIR 1963 SC, the State Trading Corporation, Divisional Forest, Bishwanath Tea Co. Ltd., State, Tata Engineering v.State of Bihar, Corporation, Corporation, the Supreme Court, Tata Engineering, Locomotive company Limited, Barium Chemicals Ltd., Company Law Board, Municipal Committee, D.C. & G. M Co. Ltd, v. Union of India, Bench, the Supreme Court, General Mills Co. Ltd., AIR, the High Court, State, U.P., Court, State, Extra Commercium', arise.12, the Supreme Court, State, AIR 1951, State of Assam v. A. N. Kidwai, Court, the Supreme Court, E&T, Commr, Constitution Benches, State, Public, the High Court, the Supreme Court, AIR, Court, AIR 1951 SC 318, State, State, Das, Das, Supreme Court, State, State, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, D.C.&G.M. Co. Ltd., Union of India, prohibition & Excise, the State of Tamil Nadu, Arts, the Legislature of a State, State, Atiabari Tea Co. Ltd., State of Assam, the Assam Taxation, the State of Assam, Kalyani Stores, State, State, State, Tamil Nadu General Sales Tax Act, the State of Tamil Nadu, State, Tamil Nadu Government Lottery, the Supreme Court, the State Government, Cement, A.P. General Sales Tax Act, the State of Andhra Pradesh, State, State, W.P. Nos, State, State, the Supreme Court, State, Independent Dy, State, State, Orissa, Government, State, Society, the Supreme Court, State, State, State, Southern Pharmaceuticals, Chemicals, Counsel, the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act, State Government, S. 2.1, theCommissioner, State, Learned Advocate-General, State, State, State of Orissav, State, State, Extra Commercium, Arts, Intercourse, Das, AIR, Court, AIR 1951 SC 318, State, State, State, Welfare, Court, State, State, State, State, the State of Tamil Nadu, State, Punjab Liquor Licence Rules, AIR, State, AIR, State, State, the State Government, Court, Government, the State Government, Legislature, Court, Government, Learned Counsel, the Supreme Court, Government, Corporation, State, arbitrariness.29, Kashmir Government, State, State, the State Government, State, State, AIR, State, State, State, State, State, State, Government, State, State, State, State, State, Industries, State, State, Arts, State, State, State, enforceable.34, State, Legislature, Court, State, State, Court, Canteen Stores Department, State, State, State, State, Corporations, Learned Advocate-General, Corporation, Corporation, Statute Book.36, Court, Court, Corporation, State, Tamil Nadu State Marketing Corporation, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court

NORP: J.1, Rules, Mandamus, Mandamus, AIR):'These, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Hari, Rules, Rules, R., R.

PERSON: W. P. No, Tamil Nadu State Marketing Corporation Limited, Madras, Tamil Nadu Indian Made Foreign, Tamil Nadu, Tamil Nadu, ,'(1, Murthy, W. P. Nos, P&E;(III, litre under S. 18-B, Tamil Nadu, Art, Rule, M. N. Padmanabhan, Art, Art, Art, Art, Art, S. T. Corpn, Art, Art, Art, Art, Art, Delhi Cloth, Art, Art, Art, Art, Ram Chandra Trivedi, Art, Art, R.M.D. Chamarbaugwala, M.N. Padmanabhan, F. N. Balsara, Cooverjee, Excise Commr, Ajmer, Krishna Kumar v. State, Amar Chandra Chakraborty, Art, Har Shankar v. Dy, Balsara, Coverjee, Kidwai, Nagendra Nath's, Amar Chakraborty's, Nashirwar, Nashirwar, Art, Art, XIII, Art, Art, Art, H. Anraj v. Govt, Tamil Nadu, Art, Vadivelu, Excise Acts, P. A. Aliyar Saheb v., Tahsildar, Hari Narayan, A. C. Chakraborty, Art, InNashirwar v. State of M.P., K. Vadivelu, Tamil Nadu Indian, Hari Narayan, Har Shanker v. Dy, Art, Art, Har Shankar v. Dy, C. J., Balsara, Cooverjee, Kidwai, Nagendra Nath's, Amar Chakraborty's, Nashirwar, Har Shankar v. Dy, Art, Art, M.N. Padmanabhan, Art, Art, Guruswamy, Art, Mohanlal, Swaiman Singhji, Art, Ram Krishna Dalmia, Jistice Tendolkar, P. N. Kaushal v. Union, Art, M. N. Padmanabhan, Bhushan v. State, Lal Lakshmi Reddy v. State, Tamil Nadu, Art, Art, M. N. Padmanabhan, para 9(c, consideration.37, W. A. No, W.P. Nos, W.P. Nos

DATE: 13918, 1988, 16-9-1988, 1988, 1982, 1986, 1983, 11-7-1988, 1-9-1988, one year, l-10-1988, 16-9-1988, 60 days, 16-9-1988, 21-9-1988, 16-9-1988, 10647, 1988, 1988, May, 1988, 12226, 1988, 10647, 13056, 20835 to 20838 of 1988, 13918, 1988, 12884, July, 1983, June, 1988, June, 1988, 25th July, 1988, 1st and 2nd September, 1988, 16-9-1988, 16-9-1988, 22-9-1988, 10647, 10648, 1988, 4-11-1988, 13918, 1988, 1989, 1910, 1981, 1986, 4-10-1982, 80 erores, 1910, 10-11-1988, July, 1988, 1-9-1988, 12 months, 22-9-1988, 1910, 10-11-1988, May-September, 1988, 1811, 32, 32, 1030-31, 1958, 1132, 1132, '13, 1910, 1954, 1959, 1957, 13918, 1988, 1989, 1975, 1950, 1937, 1981, 1132, 1132, 30, 1981, 23/12/1981, 1910, 14, 1910, the 1st, 14, 14, 14, 14, 14, the months of May and September, 1988, many years, Para 9(c, 2004, 14, a year, the 1st, November, 1988, years, November, 1988, 13918, 1988, 12884, 1989, 1910, 1989, 13918, 1988, 13918, 1988, 1989, 12884 to 12886 of 1988

CARDINAL: 10-11-1988, 23-12-1988, one, five, 1, 1, One, five, five, one, five, 4, 11, 28, 13, Forty four, one, 44, one, 11-11-1988, 1, 2, 1, 2, 1988,etc.4, 1-6-1983, 1, seven, five, one, two, five, 44, One, 1910,Prohibition, 10-11-1988, 10-11-1988, two, 514, 515, 10-11-1988.5, 12, 1, 753, 2, 921, 24, 29, 218, 14-2-1989, 23, 711, 207, 13-2-1989, 14, three, 217, 315, 14-24989, 3-3-1989, three, 25/-, 55/-, 299, 28, only five, two, 4, 1-6-1989, 8, 23, 19, 14, 301, 19, 301 to 304, 26-8-1988, 1, five, 26, 96, 44, 3.00p.m, 16-9-1988, 19(6, 19.9, 19, 1981]3SCR662, 19, 1981]3SCR662, 7, 1964]6SCR885, one, two, 1967]1SCR898, 1969]3SCR447, 19, 1983]3SCR438, three, 226, 943, 19, 226, 1977)ILLJ200SC, 1957]1SCR874, 1954]1SCR873, 1957]1SCR295, 1967]3SCR50, 1973]1SCR533, five, 1975]3SCR254, five, 1967]3SCR50, five, 1954]1SCR873, 1957]1SCR295, 1973]1SCR533, 1957]1SCR874, 1972]3SCR784, 1975]2SCR861, 1957]1SCR874, 1975]2SCR861, Two, 1983]3SCR438, 19, 10-11-1988, 301, 301, 303, 304, 301, 1961]1SCR809, 301, 304, 304, 301, One, 1988]2SCR574, 301.17, 514, 88, 1972]3SCR784, 1973]1SCR533, 14, 1975]2SCR861, 1982]1SCR519, 298, 1972]3SCR784, 1975]2SCR861, 298, 1975]3SCR254, 1957]1SCR874, one, 301, 301, 301, 1975]3SCR254, 1954]1SCR873, 1957]1SCR295, 1973]1SCR533, 1957]1SCR874, 1972]3SCR784, 1975]2SCR861, 538, 23-12-1981, 1975]3SCR254, 10-11-1988, 301.25, 10-11-1988, 1955]1SCR305, 1962]1SCR702, 1959]1SCR279, 1979]1SCR122, 1468, 1987]1SCR1, 14, 279, three, five, five, 12(e, 44, 1987]1SCR1, three, 1980]3SCR1338, five, 1-6-1983, more than one, one, three, 14, 1987]1SCR1, 16, 14, 19and, One, 16, five, 100, 16.35, one, five, 514, 515, 1988.W.P., 514, 515, 514, 515, 10-11-1988, 10-11-1988

ORDINAL: second, second, second, second, second, second, second, second, second, first, second, second, second, second, First, second, 16th, first, First, Second, First, first, first, first, first, second, first, third, 2nd, first, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 1st, third, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 2nd, 1st

GPE: India, IMFS, States, States, States, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra, W.P.Nos, States, India, Delhi, Delhi, Counsel, India, Art, India, Art, Amritsar Municipality v. State of Punjab, Art, Bombay, Counsel, Bombay, Jammu, Pp, Krishnakumar, Jammu, Jammu, R.M.D.C., R.M.D.C., Pp, Delhi, India, I.M.F.S., Art, India, India, Orissa, Bihar, Orissa, India, Orissa, Art, Art, Bihar, Kerala, Nashirwar v. State of M.P., it.21, R.M.D.C., Art, Art, Art, R.M.D.C., W.A., Art, buyI.M.R.S., Art, India, India, I.M.F.S., India, India, Jammu, Kasturi, I.M.F.S., India, G.C., I.M.F.S., States, I.M.F.S., States, I.M.F.S., Delhi, W.A.

WORK_OF_ART: Indian Made Foreign Spirits, Prohibition and Excise, Excise Duty, Home and Prohibition and Excise, Prohibition and Excise, Home and Prohibition and Excise, Prohibition and Excise, Prohibition and Excise, Collector of Excise, Government of Tripura, G.O., Collector of Excise, Prohibition and Excise, Prohibition and Excise, G.O.

FAC: Tamil Nadu, Tamil Nadu, Tamil Nadu, Tamil Nadu, the Tamil Nadu Prohibition Act

PRODUCT: Murthy, Art, Art, a Full Bench, Judgment

LOC: W.P. Nos, the Excise Revenue, Kashmir, Kashmir, Harinarayan Jaiswal's, Sat Pal, Executive

MONEY: five Constitution Benches

PERCENT: 20%, 10%

EVENT: Prohibition Act