Gujarat Water Supply and Sewerage Board and anr. Vs. Ketanbhai Dinkarray Pandya

Decided On : Jun-16-2003

Court : Gujarat

LAW: Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, 321of, 323of, 327of, 337of, PremjibhaiGohil StoreChowkidar 1-11-199144903-35, 347of, 350of, Section 25, the I.D. Act, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 25, the I.D. Act, Section 10, the I.D. Act, the Minimum Wages Act, Minimum Wages Act, the I.D. Act, the I.D. Act, Section 10, Section 33C(2, the I.D. Act, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Dispute Act, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, Section 33C(2, Sections 13, the Minimum Wages Act and Rule 25, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, Article 226 or under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the Industrial Disputes Act, Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C, the Minimum Wages Act, the Minimum Wages Act, the Minimum Wages Act, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, the I.D. Act, the I.D. Act, Section 33C(2, the I.D. Act, the Minimum Wages Act, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 10, the Industrial Disputes Act, Section 33C(2, Article 227 of the Constitution of India, Article 227 of the Constitution of India, Article 227 of the Constitution of India, Article 227 of the Constitution of India, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Section 2(i, the Minimum Wages Act, Minimum Wages Act, Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, Article 227 of the Constitution of India, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, the I.D. Act, the Minimum Wages Act and Rule 25, the Minimum Wages Act, the I.D. Act, the I.D. Act, Section 33C(2, the I.D. Act, Section 20, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 20, the Minimum Wages Act, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 10, the I.D. Act, Section 33C(2, the I.D. Act, the I.D. Act, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, a Constitutional Bench, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, the Industrial Disputes Act, Section 20(1, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, Section 20(1, Section 33C(2, Section 20(1, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, Section 20(1, the Minimum Wages Act, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 20(1, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, Section 33C(2, the Industrial Disputes Act, Section 33C, Section 24, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 33C(2, Section 33C(2, Section 10 of the Act, the Minimum Wages Act, Section 10, the I.D. Act, Section 33C(2, the I.D. Act, Section 33C(2, the I.D. Act, the MinimumWages Act, Section 10of, the I.D. Act, the I.D. Act, the I.D. Act, the Industrial Disputes Act, the Industrial Disputes Act

PERSON: B.J. Shethna, H.K. Rathod, D.H. Waghela, J., H.K. Rathod, S.K. Keshote, J.R. Nanavati, Shri Munshaw, P.H. Pathak, Shri N.R. Sahani, Popat, Attendant, Line Man, Store Chowkidar, Nos, R.M. Doshit, H.K. Rathod, D.M. Dharmadhikari, Attendant, Store Watchman, Store, Recovery Appln, NagjibhaiDhandhal Chowkidar11-5-1991, JodhabhaiJigrana Attendant31-2-1992, Line Man6-1-1992, Line Man1-1-1991, Mevada Line, Ashokkumar Trivedi Line man1-2-, Kadcha Line, Mevada Line, JayantilalSavaliya Storeman11-2-199151899-85, Mohan Bagarda, Attendant, Watchman, Line Man, Chowkidar, Store Watchman, Shri Ketan, Exh, Nos, Exh, Pandya Exh, Shri J.K. Waghani, Line, Shri Gandhi, Exh, Line, Shri Ketan Pandya, Shri Ketan, Shri Pathak, workman-Shri Ketan Pandya, Shri Pathak, Keshavlal Maneklal Shah, Shri Pathak, Patel, Taluka Development, Gopal Bhiva, Pathak, Shri Nanavati, Ram Chandra Dubey, Romnikbhai B. Waghela, Anr, Shri Ketan Pandya, Shri Nanavati, Shri Ketan Pandya, Shri Nanavati, Shri Ketan, Counsel Shri Pathak, Bench, Counsel Shri Pathak, Shri Pathak, Award, Chandra Dubey, Pathak, Athani, Somiben Mathurbhai Vasava, Lalji Hakka Parmar, Pathak, Pathak, Pathak, Anr, Pathak, Pathak, Athani, Pathak, Somiben Mathurbhai Vasava, Lalji Hakka, Chandra Dubey, P. S. Rajagopalan, Jamnagar, Chowkidar P. Gagji, Sagar Lake, Award, Tribhuvan Golak, Award, Award, H.K. Rathod, Jamnagar

CARDINAL: 1, 3946, 43, 866 to 908, 318, 368, 26, 26, as many as 40, 26, 8-5, 1998, 61 176, 10, 31, 11, 57193-20, 13, 28, 59522-20, 10, 5, 30, 95, 43, between 25-2-1989, 31, 352, 22090-20, 95055-85, 347, 22, 31, 26, 43, only one, 318, 31, 20, 10-11-1988, 42, 54,606-15, 31, only one, 43, one, 43, one, 31, 27, 3, 2, 43, only one, 43, 42, 14, 2, 1, 2, 996, one, 1, 235, 1, 31, 2, 173, 2, 2, 358, 42, 43, 226, 227, 227, two, two, 15, 1, 235, one, 218.(2, 1, 236.(4, 1, 235, 5, 644, one, 337, 1, 8, 8, 31-3-1982, 3946 to 3950, 1-8-1976, 1, 31, 50,720/-, 26

ORG: Labour Court, Court, side?2, the Letters Patent Appeals, Coram, Sewerage Board, Court, the Gujarat Water Supply and Sewerage Board, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Jamnagar Municipal Corporation, the Letters Patent Appeals, Diesel, Chowkidar, Diesel, Labour Court, Amreli, Board, Separate Recovery ApplicationNos, Labour Court, the Labour Court, Amreli, Court, Coram, the Labour Court, H.K. Rathod, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Lordship, Board, Labour Court, Letters Patent Appeals, the Labour Court, Coram, C.J. & J.M. Panchal, Board, the Labour Court, Diesel, Chowkidar, Applicant & DesignationDate, JoiningAmount, KetanPandya, BharatbhaiMehta ElectricalOperator, YashvamrayGohil, RafikbhaiParmar, 325of, KanubhaiVala, Himatbhai Makwana -40054-20, RameshbhaiMakwana ElectricalOperator, 329of, ArvindbhaiBalva ElectricalOperator, 331of, OsmanChauhan Chowkidar10-4-1992 39907, GokulbhaiSingal Line Man31-1-1990, 336of, Valjibhai Panaliya Line Man23-3-1989 72445, GordhanMavani Line, Mansukhbhai Parnaliya, KarbhaiAdedra Line, DhirubhaiGangadiya, OfficeChowkidar, RajnikantRathod Heavy, Prembhai Vaniya Line, MuljibhaiVaniya Line, RajeshSisodiya ElectricalOperator, JagaMegha Line man10-8-1991 62485-80, KarimbhaiJamalbhai, MohanChauhan ElectricalPump, HardevsinhHemubhai Chowkidar28-1-1991, 357of, Laljibhai Parmar Line man20-, MukeshbhaiDangar Line roan10-2-1992, BhikhabhaiSaiyed, Diesel Operators, Electrical Operators, Storeman, the Labour Court, Recovery Application No, Recovery Application, Labour Court, Board, Recovery Application, Board, Board, the High Court, Board, Recovery Application No, the Labour Court, Board, Applications, Applications, Dolatbhai Parmar's Committee, Board, the Labour Court, Recovery Application, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Dolatbhai Parmar's Committee, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Board, Gufaniya, Chowkidar, the Labour Court, Recovery Application, Recovery Application, Board, Application, Board, Executive Engineer, the Labour Court, Court, the Labour Court, the Board, the Labour Court, Chowkidar, Dam, Chowkidars, Pumping Stations, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Application under Section 33C(2, Court, the Labour Court, Application under Section 33C(2, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Board, Board, Board, the Labour Court, Board, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, The Labour Court, Counsel for 'the Board', the Labour Court, Court, Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Board, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Labour Court, Court, Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Court, Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, AIR 1964, Bombay Gas Co. Ltd., Court, Government, the Labour Court, the Apex Court, Court, High Courts, Statute, the Apex Court, Patel Ishwarbhai, Panchayat, the Labour Court, The Labour Court, the Labour Court, Section 33C(2, Counsel Shri Nanavati, Board, Board, the Labour Court, Recovery Applications, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, State Bank of India, AIR 2000, SC, Court, Naranji Peraji Transport Co., the Labour Court, the Labour Court, The Labour Court, Rathod Engineering Works, Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Board, Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Recovery Applications, the Labour Court, the Letters Patent Appeals, the Labour Court, Board, Court, Court, Letters Patent Appeals, Court, Court, Letters Patent Appeals, Letters Patent Appeal, Letters Patent Appeals, Board, Court, Court, Letters Patent Appeals, Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Court, the Labour Court, Sections 13, Section 33C(2, Labour Court, Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Recovery Application, the Labour Court, Court, Court, the Workmen's Compensation Commission, Application, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Recovery Application's, the Labour Court, Court, Labour Court, Court, Labour Court, Ganesh Razzak's, Ganesh Razzak's, Delhi Municipal Corporation, Section 33C(2, the Labour Court, the Delhi Municipal Corporation, the High Court, Special Leave Petition, the Delhi Municipal Corporation, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, S.L.P., Appeals, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, The Labour Court, the Labour Court's, Court, the Labour Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Ganesh Razzak's, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, State Bank of India v. Ram, AIR 2000, SC, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Labour Court, Labour Court, East India Coal Co., Rameshwar and Ors, AIR 1968, Town Municipal Council, Labour Court, Hubli, R.L. Kalathia & Co., GLH 644.(5, Central Bank of India, P.S. Rajagopalan, AIR 1964, SC 743.He, a Labour Court, Central Bank of India, P.S. Rajagopalan, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Apex Court, Court, Municipal Corporation, the Apex Court, a Labour Court, The Apex Court, Court, the Apex Court, Central Bank of India, P.S. Rajagopalan, Labour Court, Court, East India Coal Co. v., Rameshwar, AIR 1968 SC 21,8, Learned Advocate, Paragraph 5, Town Municipal Council, Labour Court, Hubli, the Labour Court, the High Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Apex Court, the Labour Court, a Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Apex Court, the Labour Court, the Apex Court, R.L. Kalathia & Co., State of, the Labour Court, Court, the Minimum Wages Notification, Court, the Apex Court, State Bank of India v. Ram, AIR 2000, SC, the Apex Court, Central Bank of India, Municipal Corporation, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Court, the Labour Court, LabourCourt, Recovery Application, the Labour Court, Corporation, the Labour Court, Chowkidar of the Corporation, Chowkidar, Treasury, Corporation, the Labour Court, Application under Section 33C(2, the Labour Court, the Recovery Application under Section 33C(2, the Labour Court, Corporation, the Labour Court, the Corporation the Labour Court, the Recovery Application, Corporation, the Labour Court, Chowkidars, the Labour Court, Corporation, the Labour Court, Corporation, the Labour Court, Labour, Corporation, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Labour, Labour Court, Court, the Labour Court, Recovery Application, Court, the Labour Court, Coram, Board, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, the Labour Court, Amreli, the Labour Court

TIME: 9-5-200,0, 9-5-2000, 9-5-2000, 9-5-2003, 12 hours, 8 hours, four hours, more than 8 hours, 12 hours, 9-10-1991, 8-00 p.m., 8-00 a.m., 12 hours, 8 hours, 12 hours, only 8 hours, 12 hours, only 8 hours, 9-10-1991, 24 hours, 12 hours, 12 hours, 12 hours, only 8 hours, 2 to 3 hours, 5 to 7 hours, 2 hours, 5 to 6 hours, 12 hours, 12 hours, 12 hours, 12 hours, only 8 hours, 4 hours, some hours, 12 hours, 3 hours, 4 hours, 5 hours, the duty hours, 8 hours, 12 hours, 8 hours, 8 hours, 4 hours, 12 hours, 8 hours, 4 hours, 12 hours, 8 hours, 8 hours, the working hours, working hours, many hours, particular hours, 4 hours, 4 hours, 2-3 hours, 8 hours, 12 hours, 8 hours, 4 hours, 6 hours, 4 hours per day, how many hours, 6 hours, 6 hours, 6 hours

DATE: 2327, 3950, 3966, 1985, 1987, 10-10-2000, 9-5-2000, 4-12-1996, 3117, 3119, 1994, 1995, 1995, 1999, 8826, 1999, the same day, two months, 9-5-2000, 9-8-2000, the month of September, 2000, 9-5-2000, 8-5-2003, a day, the next day, last working day, 1998, 1998, 59663-30, 1998, 1998, 4-1990, 1998, 1998, 1992, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1992, 1998, 1998, 50910-00, 1998, 50109-15, 1998, 42690-85, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1990, 1998, 1998, 1991, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 48213-90, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1991, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 44247-00, 1998, 1998, 1998, 1998, 104-1992, one day, 9-8-1995, 1998, 1998, daily, daily, 1998, 8, daily, daily, 16, last 8 years, daily, 5 years, daily, last 8 years', last 3 years, 9-10-1991, 30 days, 29 days, last 3 years, the day, a day, 1989, 1990,, 1991, 1992, so many years, day, daily, 1998, 1983, 1998, 1948, 1947, '23, 1995, 1998, six months, 1989, (i) 1997, 1998, 1353, 2000, all these years, every day, few days, few months, so many years, 1989, 1992, 1995, one day, all these years, daily, 1948, three months, '28, a period of, 3 months, 6 months, 6 months, 1995, 1989 to 1992, 1995, daily, daily, '31, 1969, 1990, 1984, 1995, 8, 1969, 1335, days, 35, 1984, 2327, 1984, 1982, 1975, 26 years, 1985, 14-1976, 1985, 3969, 1985, 1985, 1984, 1987, 9-5-2000, 1999, 2327, 1984, 3946, 1985, 3966, 1985, 1984, 1987

WORK_OF_ART: Gujarat Water Supply and Sewerage Board, Shri Suresh Chauhan, Shri Suresh Chauhan, Recovery Applications, the Recovery Applications

NORP: Amreli, Hon'ble, Amreli, Rules, Valve, Valve, Rules, Amreli, Amreli

GPE: J.10, Tal, I.D., Ishwarhhai, Prahladbhai, Delhi, Velji Govabhai, Counsel, India, India, Bhavnagar, Gujarat, Delhi, Bhavnagar, Gujarat, Delhi, period.46

PRODUCT: DieselOperator 9-11-1991, ElectricalOperator 1-11-1990, AshokkumarPandya Attendant26-11-1991, BhupatbhaiVaghela, 15-9-1991, 25-2-1989, PumpOperator 2-2-1991, Recovery Applications, 3734, Shri Nanavati, Articles 226, Award, 3734, 3734, Award

ORDINAL: first, Firstly, first, first, first, first, first

MONEY: 1) xxxx

EVENT: SC 1335.(3

LOC: Paragraph, the Municipal Garden