Reliance Airports Developers P. Ltd. Vs. Airports Authority of India and ors.

Decided On : Apr-21-2006

Court : Delhi

LAW: Article 226, Section 56.The, Constitution, Article 226, Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 14, the Transaction process;Accept or reject

ORG: T.S. Thakur, the Indira Gandhi International Airport, the Chatrapati Shivaji International Airport, Airports Authority of India, Empowered Group of Ministers, Law & Justice, Request for Expression of Interest, RFEOI, Global Technical, Concession Agreement, an Inter Ministerial Group, IMG, Financial, the Ministry of Civil Aviation.4, IMG, ABN, Amarchand & Mangaldas & Suresh A. Shroff & Co., Government, the Airports Authority, the Invitation to Register Expression of Interest, EGoM, EGoM, RFP, RFP, Clause 5.2, RPF, Management Capability, Commitment and Value Add, Development Capability, Commitment and Value Add, RFP, Phase-IV, 5.4 Assessment of Technical Pre-QualificationThe Technical, Management Capability, Commitment and Value AddDevelopment Capability, Commitment and Value Add, the Technical Pre Qualification, Bidders, GOI, Offer, Bidder Management DevelopmentTechnical, GMR-Fraport, Sterlite-Macquarie, Essel-TAV, Bidder Management DevelopmentTechnical, GMR-Fraport, Sterlite-Macquarie, Essel-TAV, the Government Review Committee, GRC, IMG, GRC, GRC, IMG, IMG, EGoM, IMG, IMG, IMG, Cabinet, Member Secretary Planning Commission, Department of Economic Affairs, Department of Legal Affairs, Group of Eminent Technical Experts, the Sreedharan Committee', Committee, Delhi Metro Rail Corporation, Ministry of Railways, Infrastructure Limited, G.M.R. Infrastructure Ltd., GMR, Delhi Metro Rail Corporation, Delhi Metro Rail Corporation, SPV, Airports Authority of India, SPV, SPV, Government, Government, Maruti Udyog Ltd., Consultants, the Committee of Secretaries, G.M.R. Infrastructure Ltd., The Committee of Secretaries, Bidder CodeDELHI AIRPORTManagement Development, Marks, Marks, Marks, Technical, Marks, Marks, Marks, Technical, EGoM, RFP, the Bid Opening Committee, Reliance, the Board Room of AAI, Committee, the Competent Authority, Committee, GMR Infrastructure Ltd., GMR, RFP.(c, GMR, GMR, GMR consortium3, Committee, the Consortium Financial, GMR Consortium, Reliance Consortium, Macquarie Consortium, the Consortium Financial, GMR Consortium, Reliance Consortium, GVK Consortium, GMR Consortium, RFP, D.S. Constructions, the Union Cabinet, Fraport, Piatco, Fraport, the Supreme Court of Philippines, the Supreme Court of Philippines, Counsel dis-entitle, Development Capability', Government, the Government Review Committee, OECD, Development Capability, RFP, RFP, Union of India, the Government Review Committee, the Inter Ministerial Group, the Committees of Secretaries, the Empowered Group of Ministers, Court, RFP, the Development Planning Principle, the Operation Management and Development Agreement, the Initial Development Plan, IMG, Government, GMR Infrastructure Ltd., the Airports Authority of India, the Government of India/AAI, Committees, GRC, IMG, the Committee of Secretaries, the Government of India, Reliance, the Supreme Court, Nagubai Ammal, the Supreme Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Commonwealth Games, AAI, Executive, Court, GMR Infrastructure Ltd., the Development Planning Principles, IDP, IGI, the Supreme Court, Tefcon Projects, Union of India and Ors, RFP, Government, the Evaluation Committee, The Evaluation Committee, Court, State, the Supreme Court, Court, Court, Tata Cellular v. Union of India, Tribunal, Court, Court, the Supreme Court, Air India Ltd., Cochin International Airport Ltd., Court, State, Government, Court, International Airports Authority of India, Kamgar Union, Union of India, CCE, Dunlop India Ltd., Tata Cellular v. Union of India, AIR1997SC1236, Raunaq International Ltd., I.V.R. Construction Ltd., AIR1999SC393, State, State, State, State, the Supreme Court, Master Marine Services, Metcalfe & Hodgkinson, Court, Tata Cellular, Tata Cellular v. Union of India, State, State, Court, Court, Court, the Group of Eminent Technical Experts, RFP, RFP, Regulatory Authority, Airports Authority of India, a Court of Law, AAI, the JV Company, Government, Directors/Managers, Fraport, the Supreme Court of Philippines, Fraport, Piatco, Government of Philippines, the Philippines Supreme Court, Expression of Interest, Fraport, Fraport, Suffice, Fraport, Respondent No.3, Fraport, Fraport, GMR - Fraport, Bechtel, Fraport, Piatco, Court, the Philippines Supreme Court, Fraport, Fraport, Court, the Airports Authority of India, AAI, RFP, the Airports Authority of India, RPF, the Airports Authority of India, RPF, the Airports Authority of India, RFP, the Airports Authority of India, Court, RFP, the Airports Authority of India, the Government/AAI, the Airports Authority of India, AAI, the Airports Authority of India, the Airports Authority of India, Airports Authority of India, Airport Planning Pty. Ltd., OBJECTIVES, Contract, Technical Advisory Services, GTA, the Ministry of Civil Aviation, MCA, AAI, the Ministry of Civil Aviation, AAI, TERMS, REFERENCE1.0 Scope, GTA, the Ministry of Civil Aviation, MCA, AAI, GTA, MCA, AAI, ABN AMRO Asia Corporate Finance, AAI, OBJECTIVES, AAI, AAI, AAI, Ministry of Civil Aviation/Airports Authority of India, the Government of India, RFP, The Government of India, the Airports Authority of India, AAI, AAI, the Government of India, the Government of India, AAI, AAI, RPF, AAI, RFP, the Airports Authority of India, AAI, process.54, DISCLAIMER1, AAI, AAI, GOI, AAI, GOI, AAI, XXX8, AAI, AAI, RFP, RFP, the Airports Authority of India, the Government of India, Consortium, AAI, AAI, Other AAI RightsAAI/GOI, AAI, AAI, AAI, the Airports Authority of India, AAI, Government, AAI, Government, an Inter Ministerial Group, the Empowered Group of Ministers (EGoM, Committee, AAI, the Government Review Committee, Government, Government, the Government Review Committee, Committee, GRC, GRC, Committee, GRC, GRC, GRC, RFP, IMG, GRC, IMG, IMG, the Planning Commission, IMG, IMG, IMG, the Government Review Committee, the Planning Commission, IMG, GRC, EGoM, EGoM, IMG, GRC, IMG, RFP, RFP, IMG, IMG, IMG, the Ministry of Civil Aviation, IMG, IMG, IMG, IMG, RFP, the Ministry of Civil Aviation, IMG, IMG, IMG, IMG, IMG, the Member, Planning Commission, the Ministry of Law, Airports Authority of India, Ministry of Civil Aviation, DEA, IMG, the Government of India, IMG, Joint Venture, Cabinet, Planning Commission, Government of India, The Committee of secretaries, IMG, Committee, Committee, Cabinet, COS, IMG, Delhi Metro Rail Corporation, Ministry of Railways, Directorate General of Civil Aviation, Inter Ministerial Group, Joint Venture Partners, the Government Review Committee, the Inter Ministerial Group, Government, Committee of Secretaries, Court, the Government of India, IMG, Government, GRC, IMG, The Committee of Secretaries, Development Capability Commitment and Value Add, Management Capability Commitment and Value, GTA, AAI, the Government of India, GRC, IMG, GRC, the Initial Development Plan, Business Plan, the Initial Development Plan, the Initial Development Plan, Airplan Development, Bidders, GRC, The Initial Development Plan, GRC

NORP: J.1, Indian, Indian, South African

CARDINAL: 2., two, ten, two, nine, only eight, ten, four, two, 5.4, two, two, one, only one, eight, only six, five, only two, two, 80.22, 84.7 92.73, 57.0, 29.46, 81.02, 84.7 80.13, 73.1, 57.0 61.95, five, eight, 12, only two, One, 3, two, one, two, 6, 6.1, one, two, 1:1, 2:1, 6.2, one, two, 3, 15, only two, 3, One, two, one, two, 5.4, 5.4, four, two, 2, two, 45.99%3, 40.15%4, 37.04%MUMBAI, 33.03%2, 21.33%3, 38.7%4, 28.12%18, 1.5, only one, 4, 3, 4, 3 and 4, 500, 19, 3, 3, 3, 3, 3, 20, 3, 3, 3, 3, 1, two, two, two, 3, 6.7, 23, one, two, one, six, five, 5.4, 451, 3, two, 3, five, two, 4.5, 3, 3, 4, three, 4, 4, 13, 4, 6, 651, three, 2000]1SCR505, 1979)IILLJ217SC, 1981)ILLJ193SC, 1985ECR4(SC, 6, one, 11, three, 1, 3, 5.4, 3, 4, 137, 3, 3, three-fold, more than one, 3, 3, 3, half, 3, five, 4.2.1Implementation, 1, 2 43, two, 5, 3 and 4, four, 5.2, two, 5, 5.1, 1.1, two, two, two, 1.1, 1., one, two, 1.2, two, one, 6.7, 6.7, 6.12, thus:6.12, 58., 59, one, 3 and 4, 60, 3 and 4, two, only two, one, two, One, nine, 64, 4., 12, three, 68, 71, 2, 3, 72, four, one, two, 73, 40,000, 75, No.2, one, two, 76, two, 4.9, 6.1, 6.5, 30.2 434.10, 6.1 to 6.5, 4.11, 4.11, half, half, 79, 3, 3, 4

DATE: September, 2003, a little later, February, 2004, February, 2005, April, 2005, 81.0, 10th October, 2005, 2nd December, 2005, December, 2005, 21st December, 2005, 7th January, 2006, the year 2010, 12th January, 2006, 17th January, 2006, 31st January, 2006, 1st February, 2006, February, yesterday, January 2006, 1st February, 2006, May, 2002, 1956, at least one year, 2004, 1995]1SCR908, 1994, 1994, the year 1997, the following year, the end of 2002, annual, 46, 20 year, 10 to 20 year, 2nd December, 2005, 2005, two weeks, three months, 13, 14, 16th December, 2005, 9th December, 2005, 9th December, 2005, today, 12th December, 2005, between 12th to 16th December, 2005, 24th December, 2005, 27th December, 2005, 7th January, 2006

GPE: Delhi, Mumbai, Airport, Delhi, Hong Kong, Singapore, Seoul, Delhi, Mumbai, New Delhi-110009, Delhi, Mumbai, Delhi, Mumbai, Mumbai, Frankfurt, Manila, Manila, Manila, Manila, Mumbai, Delhi, Mumbai, Delhi, Mumbai, Delhi, Mumbai, Mumbai, mala fides.(vi, intervene.33, down.12, Wednesbury, Manila, Manila, Fraport, Germany, Manila, Manila, Manila, Manila, Washington, Manila, Manila, Fraport, Germany, Uzbekistan, Germany, partner.41, Manila, Manila, Frankfurt, Lima, Hahn, Athens, Manila, Delhi, Frankfurt, Lima, Athens, Manila, Fraport, Manila, Manila, Manila, Mumbai, Delhi, Delhi, Mumbai, Mumbai, Delhi, Mumbai, rights.56, Delhi, Mumbai, Delhi, Sreedharan, Mumbai, Delhi, Mumbai, Delhi, Delhi, India, Mumbai, South Africa

ORDINAL: first, first, fourth, 5th, first, second, second, second, fourth, fourth, second, second, second, second, first, second, third, Firstly, first, Secondly, third, Firstly, Secondly, third, third, first, 5th, first, first, fourth

FAC: Request, Mumbai Airport, the Airport at Delhi, IGI Airport, Mumbai Airport, Metro, Delhi Airport, Mumbai Airport, Delhi Airport, the Mumbai Airport, Delhi Airport, Delhi Airport, Mumbai Airport, the Airport of India, Metro, Delhi Airport

WORK_OF_ART: Shareholders Agreement, 'Stage 2 Offers'

PERSON: Airplan Australia, Para 5.4, Bidder C, Bidder A, Bidder F, Bidder C, Bidder A, MCA, E. Sreedharan, R. Sivadasan, GETE, GETE, Rohtagi, GETE, GETE, Tenderer, Vehicle, Chennai, Kolkata, GETE, Marks, Marks, Kind Attn, J.P. ChalasaniDirector, Bhawan, Nehru Place, Bidder, Para 5.4, Airport, Mukul Rohtagi, Rohtagi, Rohtagi, Rohtagi, GETE, GETE, GETE, Rohtagi, Rohtagi, Rohtagi, Gopal Subramaniam, Subramaniam, Subramaniam, Subramaniam, Subramaniam, K. Parasaran, GETE, Parasaran, K.K. Venugopal, A.M. Singhvi, Venugopal, Singhvi, Singhvi, Singhvi, Dushyant Dave, Madan Lal, Dave, Louis Berger, Wednesbury, Ramana Dayaram Shetty, Fertilizer Corpn, Ramniklal N. Bhutta v. State, Bench, ground?(2, Serialtim, Appendix D-2, Rohtagi, Rohtagi, GETE, Rohtagi, Airplan, XXXe, XXXOther, a. assist, Contract, Delhi airports.51, XXX3, XXX4, Document, XXX, XXX9, XXX10, XXX11, Document, Offer, GETE, GETE, GETE, Shri E. Sreedharan, R. Sivadasan, Satendra Singh, GETE, Rohtagi, GETE, Rohtagi, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, GETE, Rohtagi, Rohtagi, Offer, Offer, Appendix J. 80, Offer

PERCENT: at least 80%, 80%, 80%, more than 80%, 80%, less than 80%, 50%, 50%, 37.6%, 40.4%, 41.4%, 84.7%, 81.7%, 80.1%, 73.1%, 73.3%, 70.5% - D 57.0%, 23.5%, 61.9%, 80.9%, 74.8%, 81.0%, 35.5%, 38.3%, 29.4%, 84.7%, 81.7%, 92.7%, 73.1%, 73.3%, 54.7%, 57.0%, 53.5%, 65.1%, 81.0%, 74.8%, 80.2%, 76.0%, 73.0%, 59.3%, 80%, 38.7%, 21.33%, 28.12%, 30%, 0.5%, 80%, 80.1%, 50%, 80%, 50%, 38.7%, 21.33%, 80%

LOC: Phase-III

MONEY: 100 marks, 59.3DELHI, 41.410, 2006Reliance Airport Developers Pvt, 0.3 marks, 1.1 marks, 0.3 marks, 1.1 marks

PRODUCT: Para 1.5, Respondent No.3, Para 5.4, Respondent No.3, Para 1.1, F, Para 4.7

EVENT: the Olympic Games

LANGUAGE: XXX2

TIME: 1730 hours, the minutes, the minutes