K.C. Shukla Vs. Indian Airlines and ors.

Decided On : May-29-1991

Court : Delhi

LAW: the Air Corporations Act, section 44, section 45, section 45, Regulations 4, Rule 10, section 34, the APA marks, Article 14 ofthe Constitution, section 45, section 45, section 44, section 45, Chapter Ii of R & P Rules, Rule 10, the Industrial Disputes Act, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution

PERSON: D.P. Wadhwa, Appendix, Appendix, Schedule, Cadre Vi, Cadre Vi, Cadre Vi, Cadre, Grade Xix, Grade XVII, Appendix, Schedule, 30/07/1970, Audit Departments, Headquarters, Headquarters, Grade Ii, Headquarters, sd/-(Dev Swarup, Apa, Performance Appraisal, S. C. Rastogi, V. P. Singh, R.N. Tandon, J. K. Deb Burman, Shri S. C. Rastogi, V. P. Singh, R. N. Tandon, Shri J. K. Deb Burman, Petitioner, R. N. Tandon, Reference D.O., Para 4, Shri B. Israni, Agm, Shri Lisely, Pers.sd/- K. T. SatarwalaG.M., Jaitley, Hans, Jaitley, Jaitley, Appendix, 30/07/1970, Grade Xvii, Appendix, Schedule, Officers, Daya Narain, R. N. Tandon, Daya Narain, 30/07/1970, Headquarters Office(b, Cabin Attendant, Communications Superintendent, Check Pilot, Hans, 30/07/1970, 30/07/1970, Nargesh Meerza, Cadre Iii, Grade XI(Radio Officer, Ajay Hasia, Khalid Mujib Sehravardi, Lila Dhar v State, AshokKumar Yadav, Haryana, AIR1987SC454, Lila Dhar, Lila Dhar, Kumar Yadav, Lila Dhar, R. K. Bhargava, A. A. Siddique, J.R. Singh Managerial, A.A. Siddique, K. Bhargava Managerial, J. R. Singh, R. S. Adhikariv, Articles 14, Nanik Karamchandani, Tracy Aranha v., C.W.P. No.59, Nanik Karamchandani, Digvijay Singh Dube v., Digvijay Singh Dube, Grade Xiii, Articles 14, Kumar Yadav

ORG: the Indian Airlines, the Board of Directors, the Central Government, the Central Government, Indian Airlines Employees, Flying Crew, Indian Airlines, Flying Crew, Indian Airlines Employees, Aircraft EngineeringDepartment, Flying Crew, the Indian Airlines, First Officer, Operations, Operations, Recruitment and Promotion Rules, OperationsDepartment, First Officer, CheckPilot, Operations, Operations, Operations, the Chief Pilot, Directorecruitment, the R & P Rules, the Board of Directors, Account, the Recruitment and Promotion Rules, Direct Recruitment or Promotion', as'Direct Recruitment, Direct Recruitment', Airlines, CHAIRMAN, Management, the Operations Department, Board, OperationsManager, Operations, Board, the Recruitment & Promotion Rulesas, R&P, Administrative, Personnel Branch, Grades I and Ii, the Notice Board at Local Offices of the, Corporation, Regions, Corporation, Recruitment Boards, asfollows:-, Recruitment Board, Department, the Promotion Committee, the Regional Departmental Heads, Managerial, Recruitment Board for Technical, Board, the Recruitment & Promotion Board, Recruitment Board, Engineering Department, the Competent Authority, the Instrument of Delegation, Committee, the Direct Recruitment Committees, Promotion Committee, the Promotion Committee, the 'Instrumentof Delegation, Crossing the Efficiency Bar under Rule, Selection Grade, the R & P Rules, Central Government, Indian Airlines, Airlines House, Operations, Indian Airlines, the' Indian Airlines, as50, the Selection Committee, HQrs, Operations, Hqrs, Hqrs, NorthernRegion.3, Operations, the R & P Rulesstipulated, Reliance, the Board of Directors, OperationsManager, the Selectior Committee, APA, ManagingDirector, OperationsManager, Operations, Commanders, Commanders, the Recruitment & Promotion Rules, the Selection Board, -1, G/M.Ref, Personnel Deptt, Board, Hqrs, the Head ofPersonnel & General Administration Deptt, the Personnel Deptt, the Recruitment and Promotion Rules, ofDy, Dir, the Supreme Court, theHigh Courts, Court, Indian Airlines, Schedule turn & P Rules, the Board of the first, DeputyOperations, the Board of the Indian Airlines, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Board of the Indian Airlines, R&P, CentralGovernment, the Central Government, the Selection Committee, the interview board, OPERATIONSManager, Airlines, DeputyOperations Managers, Personnel to Regional Directors, Hyderabad, Executive Pilots,, Engineers and Pilot, the R & P Rules, Ground Operations, Aircraft Engineering Department, Traffic Department ', Costing & Statistics Department(vi, Internal Audit Department ', General Administrative Department, Administrative & Personnel Branch(b) Catering & Cabin Servicing Branch(c, the Operations Department, Flying Operations, Air Hostess, Radio Officer, OperationsManager, Flying Operations, Operations, the Ground Operations, NavigatorInstructor, the Engineering Department, Driver, the Central Government, the Board of Directors, the Central Government, the Board of Directors, the R & P Rules, Commanders, Commanders, the Board of Directorsof, Commanders, the R & P Rules, Reliance, ManagingDirector, the Operation Managers, OPERATIONSManager, Board, the Board of Directors, Operations, the Board of Directors, Operations, Board of Directors, the Board of Directors, the Recruitment Board, the Selection Board, the Supreme Court, Court, Viva, Air India.another Corporation, OperationsManager, Air India, Indian Airlines, Air India, the Supreme Court, Corporations-Indian Airlines, the Central Government, Corporations, Air India, the other(Indian Airlines, Corporations, Corporations, the Khosla Tribunal, Indian Airlines, Air India, the Central Government Industrial Tribunal, NewDelhi, Indian Airlines, Air India, Tribunal, the Air India.(21, Flying Operations, Operations Department, the Board of Directors, Operations, Commanders, Commanders, Commanders, Apa, Operations, Operations, the Head of the Department, Commanders, Commanders, Commanders, the Supreme Court, the High Courts, The Supreme Court, State of, the Rajasthan Administrative Service Rules, Rajasthan Police Service Rules, Rajasthan Forest Service Rules, The Administrative and Police Services, the Police Service, Administrative, Police and Forest Services, AshokKumar Yadav, the Rajasthan Judicial Service Rules, the High Court, the Public Service Commission, theSupreme Court, Haryana Civil Service, the Haryana Public Service Commission, Marks, Kothari Commission, the Indian Administrative Service, Indian Administrative Service, the Haryana Public Service Commission, the Indian Administrative Service, the Supreme Court, the R & P Rules, AdvanceSociology, Contemporary Indian Society and Culture, Industrial Sociology, the Recruitment Board, Board, the Recruitment Board, the Interview Board, the Interview Board, the Recruitment Board, Commanders Capt, the High Courts, Indian Airlines Corporation, 26/03/1984, the Engineering Department, the Indian Airlines, the Indian Airlines, Court, Corporation, Corporation, TheIndian Airlines, Indian Airlines, Commanders, the Indian Airlines, Air India Corporation, the Air India, S. V.Puranik v., Indian Airlines, the Bombay High Court, Traffic Officer, Bench, Calcutta High Court, Indian Airlines, Court, C.P. Kalra v. Air, Court, Calcutta High Court, the Indian Airlines, the Supreme Court, Operations, the Flying Operations of, the Operation Department of Indian Airlines, Selection Board, Operations, the High Court, OperationsManager, the Flying Operations of, the Operation Department, the Indian Airlines, Operations, the Air India, IAS/IPS, SupremeCourt, Haryana Civil Service, Central Government, Indian Airlines, the Central Government, Indian Airlines, theCentral Government, the Indian Airlines, the Administrative Ministry, the Indian Airlines, the R &P; Rules, the Rap Rules, Indian Airlines, the Recruitment Board, Interview Board/Selection Board/Recruitment Board, IndianAirlines, The Supreme Court, today.(31, the Supreme Court, AshokKumar Yadav, The Indian Airlines, the Indian Airlines, InterviewBoard, the Interview Board

ORDINAL: first, first, first, First, first, first, first, first, first, Second, first, Second, first, second, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, second, first, first, first, first, 96th, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, third, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first

CARDINAL: 2 to 22, 34/90, 10-4-1990, 3, 2, 1, 2, 3, 7, 9.Chairman, 50, 10.The, 11.As, 12.After, 3, 11,12, 13, 37, 10.There, 1, 1, 2,In, 11.The, 12.The, 13.The, 17 to 20, 18.The, 19.The, 20.Promotion, 21.No, 22.Promotions, 4, 2CMO-86, 3.It, 5, 50, 30, 70, 1, 2, 3, 6, 10, 17, 2, 23, 13, 23, 17 to 20, 21, more than three, 3, 21candidates, 60, only 31, 10, six, two, 4., 5, 10, 3, one, 13, 8, two, 2, 3, hundred nay thousands, 100, 3, 30, 20, one, two, one, two, two, two, two, 22, 60, 29, one, 60, 50, 18, 50, 7, 30, 69, 60, 20, 22, 22, one, one, 23, 1981)ILLJ103SC, 2, 3, 4, 1400, 180, 1,80marks, two, 22.2%in, eight, one, 12.2%m, 60, four, 30, 20, 21 10(12, 18Professional 10(12, 12, 10(16, 163, 15, three, 9, 17, 22, 6, One, 16, 3, 28-6-1990, 8), five, 12, 9, .100, 16, 2.Appointment, one, 6.Number, 10.APAs, 28, 2, 22, 2, 22, 2, 22, 12.2, 50, 50, 60, 2, 22, 2, 22

DATE: 1/02/1990, 1953, the year 1971, the year 1971, Grade 16B, one year, every three months, 22, 9/01/1987, December 1988, the last three years, the last three years, December 1988and, 23/11/1970, that30, 1964, 1970, 2/05/1991, last 3 years', last 3 years, 6/12/1988, last 3 years', 2 years, year, year, year, 23/11/1970, 21/12/1970, 1981)IILLJ314SC, 1947, 1550-2480, 1720-2580, all these years, 1973, the last 3. years ofAPAs, 1981)IILLJ297SC, past 3 years, 12D 2, 1081, the last two years, 1988, 1674of 1990, 1988, 1990, 1/04/1991, 10/04/1990, last 3 years, one month, today, one month, three months, today

GPE: Grade XVII, Grade I and Ii, Grades, New Delhi, I.A., Selection, G.M., G.M., G.M., Pilots, the remaining50%, G.M., AIRIndia, Rajasthan, Rajasthan, Mehmood, marks56, Hasia, M.A., Delhi, recruitment25%, Bombay, Division Beach, India, unconstitutional.(33

PRODUCT: Grade, Grade 15, Grade 15, Grade 17, Memorandum, Boards, Rule 9, Boards, Flight Steward, 30/07/1970, Flight Engineers, Grade VII/

LOC: Grade Xvii, Grade 15, Grade 15, Northern Region, Grade 17, Single, Single

TIME: 5 of these minutes, 21-10-86, the minutes, these minutes, twenty minutes, an hour, about20 minutes, the minutes, Those minutes, 20 minutes, 20 minutes, 5 to 10 minutes, 10/25 minutes, 10 to 20 minutes

NORP: Grade X, Indian, R., THEfirst

WORK_OF_ART: Powers and Functions of Indian Airlines

QUANTITY: 9-1-87.The

MONEY: 50 per cent, 30 per cent, 70 per cent, 50 per cent, 50 marks, 50 marks, 50 marks, 50 marks, 32 marks, 38 marks, 50 marks, 50 marks, 60 marks, 180 marks, 33.3 per cent, 33 per cent, 700 marks, 200 marks, 15 10(14, 50 marks, 30 marks, less than 60 marks, of70 per cent marks, 40 per cent marks, 70 per cent, 70 per cent marks, 40per cent, 30 per cent, 50 per cent, 70 per cent, 50 per cent marks, 12.2 per cent, 87.8 marks

PERCENT: 50%, 50%, 50%, 30%, 50%, 50%, 33%, 33%, 11.9%, 33%, only 11.9%, 25%, 25%, 33.3%, that15%, 33.3%, 22.2%, of22.2%, 12.2%, 22.2%, 12.2%, 50%, 75%, 30%, 50%, 50%, 70%, 50%, 70%, 40%, 40%

FAC: Resolution, Ajay Hasia, Ajay Hasia