Girnar Traders Vs. State of Maharashtra and ors.

Decided On : Aug-27-2007

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: the Land Acquisition Act, the Central Act 68 of 1984, Chapter VII, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, The MRTP Act, the Entries 5, Constitution, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, Section 126, Section 49, the MRTP Act, Section 12(2, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 11A, Section 6 of the Act, Section 126(1)(c, the MRTP Act, Section 4(1, Section 165, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, Section 126(4, Section 6, Section 126(4, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Act 68, Section 6 of the Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 6, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the MRTP Act, Section 11A, the Land Acquisition Act, the Amendment Act 68 of 1984, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 11A, Section 11A of the Land Acquisition Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the MRTP Act, Chapter VII, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 125, Section 4(1, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 126, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 6, Section 126, the MRTP Act, Section 126, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 126, the MRTP Act, Section 126, the MRTP Act, Section 6, Section 127, Section 127, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 126, Section 125 of the Act, Section 126(2, Section 4(1, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 6, Section 125 of the Act, Section 126, the MRTP Act, Section 126 of the Act, the MRTP Act, Section 129, the MRTP Act, The MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 4(1, Section 6 of the Act, Act 68 of 1984, Section 6, Section 4(1, Act 68 of 1984, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 6, Section 4(1, the MRTP Act, Section 126, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 6, Section 4(1, Section 6 of the Act, Act 68 of 1984, the MRTP Act, Section 126, Section 125, the MRTP Act, Section 126, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 126, Section 126, Section 6, Section 11A of the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Improvement Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 54, Section 54, Section 54, the Land Acquisition Act, the Improvement Act, the Improvement Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Act 19, the Land Acquisition Act, the General Clauses Act, the Central Act, Central Act, Section 55, the Calcutta Improvement Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Act 68 of 1984, Section 6, Act 68 of 1984, Act 68, the Land Acquisition Act, the State Act, the State Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Act 68 of 1984, the Improvement Trust Act, Article 14 of the Constitution for the State, the Land Acquisition Act, the Improvement Trust Act, Section 23, Section 23, Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 14, another Acquisition Act, Article 14.Thus, the Town Planning Act, Section 34(1, Section 34(2A, the Town Planning Act, Section 12, Section 33, the Land Acquisition Act, the Improvement Act, the MRTP Act, Section 11A, the MRTP Act, Section 11A, Act 68 of 1984, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, Constitution, Article 246(1, Constitution, Constitution, Article 246(3, Constitution, Constitution, Article 246(2, Constitution, Constitution, the Indian Constitution, the Indian Constitution, Constitution, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the Land Acquisition Act, the MRTP Act.28, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 126(1)(c, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, Section 6, Section 126(2, Section 127, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, Section 127, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, a Constitution Bench, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the LA Act', the MRTP Act', the LA Act, the LA Act, Section 11A, the LA Act, Section 23, the LA Act, the LA Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the Indian Partnership Act, Section 4(1, the MRTP Act', Section 127, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 127, Section 127(1, the MRTP Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the LA Act', Section 126(2, Section 6, the LA Act, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, the LA Act, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, Section 126, the MRTP Act, Section 6, the LA Act, Section 126(2) &, the LA Act, Section 90(1) &, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, the LA Act, Section 126(2, Section 126, the LA Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the MRTP Act, Section 11A, the LA Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 11A, the LA Act, the MRTP Act, Section 11A, the LA Act, Chapter VII, the MRTP Act, Section 11A, the LA Act, the MRTP Act, Section 127, Section 126, Section 127, Section 11A, the LA Act, Section 2(19, the MRTP Act, Chapter VII, Chapter VII, the LA Act, Section 126, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the LA Act, the MRTP Act, the LA Act, Section 129(1, Section 126(2, Chapter VII, Section 126, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 113A, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 49, Section 113A, Section 6, section 6, Section 40, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 126, the MRTP Act, the LA Act, the LA Act, the LA Act, the LA Act, the LA Act, the LA Act, the LA Act, Section 8, Section 28, the LA Act, Section 126, the LA Act, Section 126(1, Section 126, the LA Act, Section 126, Section 126, the LA Act, Section 127, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the LA Act, Section 127, Section 127, Section 127, Section 126, the MRTP Act, Section 127, Section 127, Section 127, Resolution No, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, Section 127, Section 127, the MRTP Act, the LA Act, Section 127, Section 127, Section 127, Section 127, Section 127, Section 127, Section 126(1, Section 126(1, the MRTP Act, Section 127, the MRTP Act, Section 126, the MRTP Act

PERSON: P.K. Balasubramanyan, Anr, Joginder Singh, Greater Bombay, Anr, Joginder Singh, Counsel, Anr, Joginder Singh, Counsel, Counsel, Westbury, Dover Railway v., supplied)19, Howrah v. Shalimar Wood Products, Anr, Ujagar, Nathella Sampathu, Bench, Jainul Islam, Schedule, Adhiniyam, Adhiniyam, Adhiniyam, Bench, Nagpur, Jainul Islam, Anr, Vithal Rao, T.M. Peter, Shri Raghavan, Anr, Joginder Singh, Anr, Joginder Singh, Anr, Joginder Singh, Anr, Joginder Singh, Bench, M.V. Narasimhan, Brothers, Bench, P.P. Naolekar, P.K. Balasubramanyan, wherein, Benches, Bench, Jainul Islam, Anr, Bench, Anr, Joginder Singh, Bench, Balasubramanyan, J., Anr, Bench, Mantralaya, Malabar Hill, Sd/-CHIEF ENGINEER(DEVELOPMENT, Anr, Anr, Joginder Singh, Bench, Joginder Singh Case, Floor Space Index, Floor Space Index, Gazette, Floor Space Index, Gazette, Gazette, Gazette, Gazette, Shri Shekhar Naphade, Shri Bhim Rao Naik, Shri Soli J. Sorabjee, Gazette, Kesvananda Bharati, Murthy v. Susheelabai, Anr, Sat Ram Das, Tirath Singh v., Bachittar Singh, Bangalore, J.H. Gotla, Cotton Mil, Leela Jain, justice26, Jabalpur v. Shivakant Shukla

NORP: J.1, Punjab, Hon'ble, J.1, Maharashtra, sq.mt

ORG: Special Leave Petition (Civil, Girnar Traders, Special Leave Petition (Civil, Special Leave Petition (Civil, State of Maharashtra, Regional Planning Boards, Development Authorities, State, Counsel for the State of Maharashtra, the Town Planning Scheme, Draft Development Plan, Draft Development Plan, the High Court, the High Court, Notice, the Writ Petition, The High Court, the Writ Petition, the Planning Authority, Court, a Petition for Special Leave to Appeal, Malabar Hill Division, the Bombay Town Planning Act, the Bombay Municipal Corporation, the Government of Maharashtra, the Government of Maharashtra, The Bombay Town Planning Act, 7.2.1967, Sections 126, the Land Acquisition (Amendment, the State Government, the Special Land Acquisition Officer, the Bombay Municipal Corporation, Land Acquisition Officer, the State Government, inter alia, the State Government, Act, the Municipal Corporation, the State Government, the State Government, the High Court, the High Court, the Writ Petition, the Writ Petition, the High Court, State of Maharashtra, Court, Petition for Special Leave to Appeal, the State of Maharashtra, Court, Government, the High Court, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, Hakimwadi Tenants Association and Ors, the State of Maharashtra, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, Land Acquisition, the State Government, the Planning Authority, Development Authority, Appropriate Authority, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Legislature, Section (4, Government, the State Legislature, State, Learned Counsel, State, Learned Counsel, State, the State List, State Legislation, Central, the State Legislature, Parliament, the Central Legislation, the State Legislation, the Privy Council, State, Hindustan Cooperative Insurance Societies Ltd., the High Court, The Privy Council, Rangoon Botatoung Company v., the Privy Council, the High Court, the Privy Council, the Privy Council, the High Court, the Privy Council, the Privy Council, The Privy Council, Lordships, State, Lordships, the Bengal Legislature, Lordships, the General Rules of Construction, State, Craies on Statute Law, Edn, Lordships, Wandsworth Board of Works 8, Lordships, the State Legislature, Lordships, the Municipal Commissioners, Court, v. Union of India and Ors, Court, State, Hindustan Cooperative Insurance Society, Bolani Ores Ltd., State of, Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd., Union of India, Collector of Customs, New Central Jute Mills Co. Ltd., City Improvement Trust, Court, U.P. Awas Evam Vikas, the Privy Council, State, Hindustan Cooperative Insurance Societies Ltd., the Privy Council, the State of Uttar Pradesh, U.P., State, M.P. v. M.V. Narasimhan, Lordships, Adhiniyam, Nagpur Improvement Trust, Court, the Privy Council, Uttar Pradesh, the Town Planning Acts, Lordships, U.P. Awas Evam Vikas, Nagpur Improvement Trust, Court, Court, Nagpur Improvement Trust, the Bombay High Court, Court, the High Court, The High Court, State, Trust, Court, an Improvement Trust or, State, State, Ors, Court, the Kerala Land Acquisition Act, The High Court, the High Court, Court, Court, Court, Bench, Bench, Lordships, State of Maharashtra, Learned Counsel, State of Maharashtra, State of Maharashtra, State, the Privy Council, State, The State of Madhya Pradesh, Parliament, Parliament, State, State, Parliament, the State Legislatures, State Legislature, Craies on Statute Law, the State Legislature, State, the State Legislature, Parliament, the State Legislature, the State Legislature, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, Hakimwadi Tenants Association and Ors, the State Government, Sections 126, a State Government, the Town Planning Acts, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, Authority, the State Government, the State Government, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, Hakimwadi Tenants Association and Ors, Court, the Bombay High Court, Authority, Government, Girnar Traders, Court, the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, Court, Nagpur Improvement Trust, U.P. Avas Evam Vikas, Court, the State Government, State, S.L.P., S.P. Building Corporation, City Survey No., Malabar Hill Division, Bombay Municipal Corporation, the Bombay Town Planning Act, Corporation, Government of Maharashtra, Corporation, the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, the State Government, the Municipal Corporation, the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai, the Municipal Corporation, the Municipal Commissioner, the Municipal Corporation, the Improvement Committee, the Improvement Committee, the Municipal Corporation, the Chief Engineer (Development Plan, the State Government, the State Government, the Bombay Municipal Corporation Act, Corporation, the Chief Engineer (Development Plan, Urban Development Department, Corporation, the State Government, Urban Development Dept, CHE/ACQ/C/962 dtd, Corporation, State Govt, State Govt, CHE/ACQ/C/962 dtd, the State Government, the High Court of Judicature, S.P. Building Corporation, the Bombay High Court, the Bombay High Court, the Improvement Committee, the Municipal Corporation, Court, State of Maharashtra, Supp, S.L.P., the Bombay High Court, Court, C.A. No, Court, Court, the Bombay High Court, C.A. No, the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai, the Bombay Municipal Corporation Act, the State Government, the State Government, plans.-, Regional Plan, Town Planning Scheme, the Planning Authority, Development Authority, Appropriate Authority, the Planning Authority, Development Authority, Appropriate Authority, FSI, Transferable Development Rights, TDR, Floor Space Index, the Final Development Control Regulations, the State Government, Floor Space Index, the Planning Authority, Development Authority, Appropriate, the State Government, the State Government, the Official Gazette, Regional Plan, Scheme, the Development Authority, the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning, the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning, the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning (Amendment) Act, the State Government, FSI, Transferable Development Rights, TDR, Floor Space Index, the Final Development Control Regulations, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, Bombay Municipal Corporation, the State Government, the State Government, under:127, reservations.-, Development Plan, the Planning Authority, Development Authority, Appropriate Authority, the Improvement Committee, the Municipal Corporation, the Municipal Corporation, the State Government, the Municipal Corporation, the State Government, the Chief Engineer (Development Plan, Urban Development Department, Government of Maharashtra, State, the Municipal Corporation, the Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai, the State of Maharashtra enclosing, Shri U.U. Lalit, Court, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, Hakimwadi Tenants Association and Ors, the Planning Authority, Court, Development Plan, Customs v. Digvijaysinhji Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd., Court, American Home Products Corporation v., Mac Laboratories Pvt. Ltd., State of Punjab, Court, the Supreme Court, Income Tax, Andhra Cotton Mills Ltd., Lakshmi Ganesh, State, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, Hakimwadi Tenants Association and Ors, State, Court, Court, Additional District Magistrate, observed:394, AC 495, Sudhansu Sekhar Misra, Court

DATE: 11446, 2003, 14.10.2004, 2003, 2003, 1894, 1966, 6, 10, 13, 14, 17, 18, 23, 24, 28, 33, 20, 31, 2003, 22.11.1983, 6.3.1987, 19.1.1989, 15.10.1991, 31.3.1997, one year, 1894, two years, 1954, 7.7.1958, 6.1.1967, 11.1.1967, 6.1.1979, 1984, 16.9.1991, 23.9.1986, 3.2.1998, 10 years, 16.9.1991, 10 years, 15.3.2002, 13.9.2002, 20.11.2002, 19.9.2003, 6.1.1967, 24.6.2004, 20.11.2002, 1894, 1894, 1984, two years, two years, six months, 1894, the year 1966, the expiry of one year, one year, one year, ten years, 1894, six months, ten years, a period of, ten years, ten years, six months, 10 years, six months, one year, the expiry of ten years, the expiry of, six months, one year, a period of, two years, the year 1984, one year, a period of, two years, Section 11A, a period of, two years, 1894, one year, two years, one year, one year, two years, 1894, the year 1921, 1894, the year 1921, 1921, 1911, 1921, 1897, 1864, 1947, 1911, 1984, 1894, 21, 1973]3SCR39, 1980]3SCR290, 1932, 1961, long years, three years, that day, that day, the day, six months, 1894, six months, six months, ten years, the six months, 2003, 1894, 1984, 1966, 1932, 18/738, 7.7.1958, 1954, 1954, 9.1.1964, 7.2.1967, 11.1.1967, 1966, 1954, 1984, 16.9.1991, ten years, 16.9.1991, ten years, 15.3.2002, ten years, 16.9.2001, 1894, 13.9.2002, 1888, 17.9.2002, 17.9.2002, 20.11.2002, two years, 9.9.2002, 13.9.2002, 2005, 2003, 2003, the period of six months, 10 years, six months, 15 days, 1894, 1894, 1894, 1894, one year, 1972, 1972, 1993, 1894, one year, one year's, one year, ten years, 1894, six months, 10 years, six months, six-month, the period of six months, 16.9.1991, 10 years, 15.3.2002, 19.3.2002, 13.9.2002, 10 years, 17.9.2002, 17.9.2002, the period of six months, 18.9.2002, six months, six months, six months, the period of, 10 years, a period of, six months, 10 years, 10 years, six months, the period of, six months, 1299, the period of, six months, six months, 1901, 1970)ILLJ662SC

CARDINAL: 2005.2, 2004)8SCC505, 11.7.2005, one, 1995]2SCR242, 3, 35, 42, 4, 24.2.1984, 5., 22.3.1994, 10.2.1999, 15.2.1999, 822, 6, 9.1.1964, 8.7.1964, 2, 126(4, 24.9.1984, 6.7.1991, 2.8.1993, 18.10.2000, 9.9.2002, 6.1.1979, 3703, 2003.8, 1988]2SCR21, three, One, 2, 128, 1894.13, more than one, two, one, two, two, 2, 2, 3, 16, 17, 18, 3, 349-50, two, 33, 1963]1SCR47, two, One, 2, 777, 1979]2SCR1038, 1978]3SCR561, 1983ECR2198D(SC, 1978(2)ELT393(SC, 1977]1SCR549, three, 1996)IILLJ679SC, 2002]SUPP2SCR636, three, one, 22, 10(2, 10(3, 2, one, two, one, two, more than one, one, 24, two, 25, two, at least two, three, one, 223, 27, 127, 3, 2002]SUPP2SCR636, 1996)IILLJ679SC, 1, about 5387.35, 8.7.1964, 6.1.1967, 1954.5, 24.9.1984, 6.7.1991, 3.2.1998, 18.10.2000, 19.3.2002, 9.9.2002, 1, 183, 4, 2, 3, 956, 4, 3, 4, 956, approximately 4504.52, 126(1, 3, 4, three, 4, 2, 8, 353, 2, 475, 11.7.2005, 2, 10, 12, 125 to 129, three, 13, 126, 127, 1, 4, 1, 2, 3, 2, 2, 3, 1, 2, 2, 3, 3, 3, 2, 4, 4, 4, 2, 4, 15, two, 16, 17, 15.9.2001, 18.9.2002, 9.9.2002, 17.9.2002, 18, 956, 19, 20, 1988]2SCR21, 22, two, one, two, two, two, 1983ECR2163D(SC, 899, 166, 66, 833, 7, 1985]156ITR323(SC, 11, 1988]2SCR21, 11, 1, 1976CriLJ945, 163

ORDINAL: second, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, secondly, First, Secondly, first, second, Second, second, first, first

GPE: Regions, Carmichael Road, Mumbai, section.12, pp, India, India, Ex, St. Sepulchre, L.J., London, Chatham, Orissa, Bhajiya, Kerala, City, States, Brothers, States, 16.9.2002, Govt, Bombay, 16.9.2002, 16.9.2002, Kerala, Narashimaha, The Earl of Halsbury, L.C., Quinn, the State of

WORK_OF_ART: Plan, another Writ Petition, No, Collector of Rangoon 39, Amending and Repealing Acts, Collector of Central Excise, Vasantrao and Ors, Vasantrao and Ors, Travancore Act 4 of 1108, Vasantrao and Ors, Open Space and Children's Park, Plan

QUANTITY: 2593.36 square meters

LOC: Regional, Regional, Regional, List III, the MRTP Act.30

TIME: a later Act, the earlier Act, the later Act, the earlier Act, the later Act, a later Act, the later Act, under this Act

MONEY: one Acquisition Act

EVENT: List II, the LA Act, L.A. Act 1894

PRODUCT: Bench, Bench, Bench, Bench

FAC: Carmichael Road, Resolution, Children Park, Children s Park, the Official Gazette