Deb Narayan Shyam and ors. Vs. State of West Bengal and ors.

Decided On : Dec-01-2004

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Surveyors, Article 309 of the Constitution, Surveyors, Article 226/227, Article 226/227, Article 32, Rule 1 of Order XXIII, Article 142 of the Constitution of India, Article 142 of the Constitution of India, Article 142 of the Constitution of India, Article 142 of the Constitution of India.26

PERSON: A.K. Mathur, No.9.3, Surveyors, Abdul Bari, Civil Rule No.3470, Subhas Chandra Sen, Notification No.5472-F, Amin, Amin, Jalpaiguri Range, Satya Brata Sinha, Madhyamik, Amin, Amin, Surveyors, Surveyors, B.P. Banerjee, Banerjee, Sanyal, Sanyal, Rs.340-, Altamas Kabir, Gora Chand De, Surveyors, Abdul Bari, Subhas Sen, Amin, Amin, Surveyor, Amin, Amin, Madhyamik, Scale No.7, Madhyamik, Surveyors, Samir Ghosh, Scale No.6, Madhyamik, Amin Grade-I, Scale No.8, Scales Nos.6,7, Ziaul Haque, Memo No.4884,, Amin, Surveyor, Surveyors, Banerjee, Altamas Kabir, Calculators, Moharrirs, Surveyors, Banerjee, Surveyors, Calcutta CollectorateAmin, Surveyors, Amin, Amin, Amin, Surveyor, Madhyamik, Amin, Amin, Surveyor, Amin, Amin, Amin, SURVEYORS, Calcutta L.A.55-130, Wingand ManagementWing, L.R. Deptt, Amin, ii)With, Surveyors, Surveyor, Amin, Surveyors, Surveyors, J.P. Chaurasia, Shyam, Ram Gopal Agarwal, Tarun K. Roy, Amin, Surveyor, Anwarul Haque, Abdul Bari, Subhas Sen, Jalpaiguri Range, Jalpaiguri Range, Surveyors, Abdul Bari's, Banerjee, Abdul Bari's, Subhas Sen, Benches, P.J.Fitzgerald, Gerard v. Worth, Wilfrid Greene, Anr, Pawan Kumar, Abdul Bari, Jalpaiguri Range, Banerjee, Rajeev Dhawan, R.Venkataramani, Mohd, Shaji Bari, Shri Dipankar Gupta, Gupta, Abdul Bari, Jalpaiguri Range, Benches, Gupta, Gupta, M. Bhaskar, M. Bhaskar, Surveyors, Madhyamik, Madhyamik, xx xx(iii

NORP: J.1, Rs.300-600/-, Bengali, No.9.9, Integrated, M.Bhaskar

ORG: Amins, Amins, the High Court of Calcutta, Amins, Amins, Amins, the High Court of Calcutta, Md. Anwarul Haque and Ors, Civil Rule No.3469(W, Amins, the Land Records and Surveyors, Directorate, Government of West Bengal, Amins, the Department of Finance, Government of West Bengal, the Calcutta Gazette Extraordinary, the West Bengal Service (Revision of Pay and Allowance) Rules, Departments under Government of West Bengal, Amins, Amins, Amins, Learned Single, Learned Single, Amins, Amins, Amins, Learned Single, the Government of West Bengal, Department of Finance, Surveyors, Amins, Amins, the State Government, the State Government, Court, the State Government, Amins, the High Court of Calcutta, Md.Anwarul Haque's, the State Government, Court, Anwarul Haque's, Court, the State Government, the Government of West Bengal, The State Government, the High Court, Amins, Amins, Amins, the High Court, Amins, the High Court of Calcutta, Amins, Department, Single Judge, Learned Single, Learned Single, Amins, Industrial Training Institute, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, the Second Pay Commission, Overseer, Amins, the Second Pay Revision Committee, Amins, Learned Single, the State Government, State, Justice B.P. Banerjee &, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Court, Court, the High Court of Calcutta, Court, Overseer, School Final, Calcutta High Court, the State Government, the Calcutta High Court, Court, Amins, the Calcutta High Court, the Division Bench of Calcutta High Court, the State Government, Court, the High Court of Calcutta, Bench, the State Government, Amins, Court, Pay Commissions, Amins, the State Government This Division Bench, Md. Anwarul Haque and Ors, Ors, Civil Rule, the High Court, the State Government, Amins, the State Government, the State Government, Amins, Amins, Pay Commissions, Amins, the Pay Commissions, Court, the State Government, Court, Court, the Pay Commissions, Amins, Amins, the Technical Rules and Instructions, Amins, Division Bench, Rs.1040-1920/-, Amins, Amins, Amins, No.7 &, the State Government, Amins, the State Government, Special Leave, Special Leave, Appeals, Amins, Amins, the State Government, Amins, Amins Grade-I, Amins, Career Advancement Schemes, Amins, Court, Amins, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, Courts, the State Government, State, the Pay Commissions, Amins, Amins, the State Government, the State Government, the Division Bench, Amins, Courts, the Expert Committee, Court, Amins, Court, Amins, Scale No.7, the High Court, the Government of West Bengal, Finance Department, Amins, the Land & Land Reforms Department, the Land & Land Reforms Department, the Refugee Relief & Rehabilitation Department of the Government of West Bengal, Amins, Land Reforms, Amins, Department, School Final, the Recruitment Rules, Amins, the Land & Land Reforms Department, School Final Amins, Scale No.5, School Final Amins, the Land Acquisition Office, Refugee Relief and Rehabilitation Department, Amins, Departments, School Final, Government, Amins, the Basic Grade, Revision of Pay & Allowance Rules, Amins, Amins, the Basic Grade, Scale No.6 under Revision of Pay & Allowance Rules, Amins, the Basic Grade, Career Advancement, the Career Advancement Scheme, Revision of Pay & Allowance Rules, 01.01.1996, Amins, Amins, the Revision of Pay & Allowance Rules, Departments, Amins, Amins, Court, Amins, Court, nio.7, Amins, Government of West Bengal, S & S, School Final/ Madhyamik, the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education, Amins, Grades III & IV, Government of West Bengal, School Final and Non-School Final, the District Magistrate, Collector of the District and District Settlement Officer, Amins, Amins, the Land Acquisition Offices and Land Reforms Circles, the Land & Land Reforms Department, Special Recruitment Rules, the Government of West Bengal, Recruitment Rules, Amins, School Final/ Madhyamik Examination, Board of Secondary Education, Amins, Court, Amins, Amins, the High Court, Amins, Amins, Amins, the Division Benches, Amins, Amins, Circular, Surveyors & Amins, Amins, Amins, the Additional District Magistrate, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Surveyors & Amins, the High Court, Anwarul Haque's, the State Government, the High Court, Amins, Amins, the High Court of Calcutta, Amins, Amins, State, State, Amins, State, Single Judge, the Division Bench, Court, the Division Bench, Court, Amins, State, the Second Pay Commission Report, Third Pay Commission Report, the Fourth Pay Commission Report, Commissions, Amins, Land Acquisition Office, Calcutta, Surveyor & Valuer 11Amin, 4th Pay Commission, Group, Amin is Madhyamik, Certificate, Institution, Amins, no.9, Court, no.9, Amins, Trade Certificate, Industrial Training Institutes or Senior Survey Certificate, the Survey Institutes, The Fourth Pay Commission, Amins, Amins, Amin is Madhyamik, Industrial Training Institute or Senior Survey Certificate, the Survey Institute, Amins, Amins, SCALE NOAMIN, L &L.R.Deptt, None None 5Amin Grade, Wing and Management Wingof, Amins, ITIor Survey Institute, Bandel.iii, Survey School Higher, Survey School, the Division Bench, the High Court, Amins, Amins, The Technical Rules, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, The Technical Rules and Instructions of the Settlement Department, Amins, Amins, Amins, Surveyors, Amins, the High Court, Amins, Amins, Amins, U.P., Ors, Finance Department, Ors, West Bengal Registration Service Association, v. Union of India, Ors.4, State of W.B., Ors, Hari Narayan Bhowal, Union of India, Ors.6, Union of India, Amins, Court, the State Government, State, Court, State, State, Court, Amins, Amins, Court, Amins, Amins, Md.Anwarul Haque's, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, the State Government, Md.Anwarul Haque's, Amins, the High Court, The State Government, Letters Patent, the State Government, the Finance Department, Court, Court, State Government, Court, the State Government, the Special Leave Petition, the State Government, the Justice Sinha, Courts, the High Court, State, Md.Anwarul Haque, the State Government, the State Government, State, B. Point B, the Court of Appeal, the Court of Appeal, M.R., Court, Amins, Amins, the High Court, the State Government, Special Leave Petition, Court, the Division Bench, Court, the Division Bench of Calcutta High Court, Court, the Division Bench of Calcutta High Court, the Australian High Court, The State of Orissa, Sarguja Transport Service, State Transport Appellate Tribunal, the High Court, Supreme Court, CPC, AIR, Court, Amins, Amins, Amins, Court, State, State, the State Government, State, Amins, State, State, Md. Anwarul Haque's, the State Government, Court, Md.Anwarul Haque's, Court, Court, Union of India and Ors, Traffic Apprentices, CAT, the Supreme Court, Traffic Apprentices, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Traffic Apprentice, Lordships, Union of India, Amins, Amins, the Division Bench, the High Court, Amins, Nos.7 & 8, the Division Bench, Amins, Court, Amins, Amins, the State Government, the State Government, the Division Bench, State, State Government, the State Government, Amins, the Division Bench, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, Amins, The Division Bench, Amins, Amins, Amins, Surveyors, Amins, the High Court, Survey School, School Final, Amins, the High Court, Amins, the Division Bench, the State Government, Amins, State, the Division Bench, the High Court, Amins, the State of West Bengal, the Division Bench, the High Court, Amins, Amins, Amins, Nos.6,7, & 8

ORDINAL: first, first, 1st, 1st, first, first, Second, first, first

CARDINAL: one, two, 36, 100, about 3-4 months, two, 25-8-1993, two, two, two, two, 4., 2001.'In, 36, 36, two, No.7, 36, 1993/94, 01.10.2001, 9, 8, No.8, No.9, 36, two, two, 340, 100-140, 980-1755, 5, 340, 50-80, 100-140, 340-750, 280, 340, 1.4.81, 300, 360, 340, 125-250, 100-225, 175, 80, 5practicalexperience, 1981.14, 15, two, two, 1998]1SCR202, 2004)ILLJ421SC, 36, 36, two, one, one, hundred, One, two, 36, 36, 1987]1SCR200, 141, 22, 36, two, one, 7, two, 23, thousands, 36, one, 2, 186, 17, 18, 36, 36, two, No.7, three, 36

DATE: 1982, 1982, June 6,1985, December 27,1961, January 2,1962, 1961, July 29,1981, 1982, August 16, 1989, two years', February 16,1995, June 8,1987, June, August 25,1993, two weeks, today, 4 weeks, today, arrear, 3 months, today, 1982, 1982, 1st January, 1986, 1998, October, 2001, October, 1989, April 24, 1990, 2001, 2003, 1998, January 1,1996, 1998, 1990, 1998, 1998, 1998, 8, 1998, June 22,1990, 1992, 2003, 2003, No.7, 10 years, 20 years, 25 years, April 1,1981, 1973-1980, 25-30 years, September 18, 1956, February 26, 1964, April 25, 1975, October 29,1980, February 5, 1983, February 16,1995, April 6, 1998, November 28,2000, September 28,2001, 1040-1920, 1920, '13, 1950-51, 1970 1981 1989 1990 1998, 980-1755, 3150-5680, 3150-5680, 1989, 3150-5680, 1140-2160, 1920, 3350-6325, 3150-5680, 1140-2160, 1260-2610, 1260-2610, 1140-2160, 1140-2160, 990-1755, 3150-5680, 1981, 1981, two- year, six months or so, two years, '17, 1986 to 1993, August 16,1989, today, 1661, 1976)IILLJ266SC, today, Thoday v Thoday, 1964, '21, 36) 1949, 2001, '25, 1996)4SCC416, October 1, 2001, October 1,2001, October 1,2001, 1981, 1981, 1981.'27, 1981

LOC: Single Judge, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single Judge, Single, the Scale No.5, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single Judge, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single, Single, Single Judge

WORK_OF_ART: Surveyors and Amins, Surveyors and Amins, Surveyors and Amins, Bench, Surveyors and Amins, Surveyors, Surveyors and Amins, Surveyors, Amins, Surveyors, Calculators and Moharrirs, L.R. Circle Officers, Surveyors, Calculators and Muharriors, Surveyors, Topographic and Hydrographic, Jurisprudence

GPE: Single, the Cooch Behar District, Guntur, Single, Vidyanand, Single, No.7, No.7, No.7, Integrated, Burdwan, Burdwan, Jalpaiguri, Jalpaiguri, Jalpaiguri, Jalpaiguri, Purulia, No.9.12, Govt, No.7, Guntur, Ors.2, Jalpaiguri, Jalpaiguri, Paris, Twisden, Md., Single, instance.19, M.P., Scale, Md., Jalpaiguri, the Indian Railways, West Bengal, No.7, No.7, No.7, No.7, No.7, No.7, No.7, No.7

QUANTITY: 20 metre, 280-617, 280-617, 280-617, 280-617 980-, 280-617

PRODUCT: Bench, Bench, Surveyors, Scale No.6, Scale, Districts, Calcutta, Grade II 5District Collectorate, Surveyors, Surveyors

FAC: the Fourth Pay Commission, Scale No.7, Scale No.7, Raja Sri Sailendra Narayan Bhanja Deo, Laxmi Narain Gododia

PERCENT: 75%, 25%