Duncan Industries Ltd. and anr. Vs. Union of India (Uoi)

Decided On : Feb-10-2006

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: the First Appellant', the Essential Commodities Act, the EC Act', Section 3, the EC Act, the Retention Price Scheme, the First Appellant, the First Appellant, the EC Act, Article 14 of the Constitution, the EC Act, Article 14, the First Appellant, Article 14, Article 14, Article 14, the Retention Price Scheme

PERSON: B.N. Srikrishna, S.S. Marathe, Input, Retention Price, Scheme, subsidy and/or otherwise;3., Phosphoric, relates.8, Fertilisers, Y.K. Alagh, Civil Miscellaneous Writ, Civil Miscellaneous Writ Petition, Rajeev Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, sic), J.31, Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, Retention Price, Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, Dhavan, Bhavesh D. Parish v., Bhai Parmar, Holmes

NORP: J.1

ORG: CC No, the 'Retention Price Scheme', the Respondent-Union of India, M/s Duncan Industries Ltd., Indian Explosives Ltd., ICI India Ltd., The Fertilizer (Control) Order, The Fertilizer (Control) Order, Government, Government, Committee, the Marathe Committee', The Marathe Committee, the Marathe Committee, Government, the Retention Price Scheme, the Retention Price Scheme, The Retention Price Scheme, Scheme, Retention Price, the Marathe Committee, the Retention Price, Conversion, The Retention Price Scheme, the Fertilizer Price Fund Account, Retention Prices, the Fertilizer Price Fund Account, Fertilizer, the FIC Committee', The FIC Committee, The Operation of the Retention Price, the Retention Price Scheme, the Official Gazette, M/s Indian Explosives Ltd., the Retention Price Scheme, Government, Indian Explosives Ltd., M/s Indian Explosives Ltd., the Government of India, the 'Government', Nitrogenous and Phosphoric, Scheme, the Government of India, FPEC, Government, the Fertiliser Industry Coordination Committee, the 'Committee', Government, IFL Ltd., Committee, the Government/Committee, the Government (Ministry of Chemicals, Committee, Nitrogenous and Phosphoric, the Government of India, Ministry of Chemicals, the Retention Price Scheme, the Retention Prices, the Retention Price, the FIC Committee, the Retention Price, the Retention Price, the Retention Price, the Retention Price, 31.3.2003, the Retention Price, the Alagh Committee', Government, FIC Committee, the Retention Price, Retention Price, the Retention Price, the FIC Committee, the FIC Committee, Base Years 1997-98 and, the High Court of Judicature, Allahabad, Retention Price, Scheme, 3.4.2002, the Retention Price, Government, the High Court, the High Court, the High Court, the Retention Price Scheme, the Fertiliser (Control) Order, the High Court, the Retention Price Scheme, Counsel, the Retention Price Scheme, Government, Government, Additional Solicitor General, the High Court, the Retention Price Scheme, the Retention Price Scheme, the High Court's, the Retention Price Scheme, Retention Prices, Government, Government, Scheme, the Retention Price Scheme, the Marathe Committee, the Retention Price Scheme, Court, Neyveli Lignite Corporation Ltd., Commercial Tax, the Retention Price Scheme, the Government of India, Ministry, Government, the Retention Price Scheme, the Retention Price Scheme, the Retention Price, Retention Prices, Committee, the Retention Price Scheme, Government, the Retention Price Scheme, the Retention Price, Scheme, Government, Scheme, M/s Indian Explosives Ltd., Scheme, the Retention Price Scheme, M/s Indian Explosives Ltd., M/s Indian Explosives Ltd., Committee, the Retention Price Scheme, the Fertiliser (Control) Order, the Retention Price, the FIC Committee, the Retention Price, the High Court, Reasonableness and Legitimate Expectation38, the FIC Committee, the Doctrine of Legitimate Expectation, Learned Counsel, Government, the FIC Committee, the FIC Committee, the Retention Price, Government, Scheme, Court, BALCO Employees' Union (Regd, Union of India, Union of India, Peerless General Finance, Investment Co. Ltd., Reserve Bank of India, State, Delhi Development Authority, Scheme, Noble State Bank, the High Court, the Wednesbury Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd., Wednesbury Corporation, the High Court, the Retention Price Scheme, the FIC Committee, Additional Solicitor General, M/s Nagarjuna Fertilisers and Chemicals Ltd., Nagarjuna Fertilizers, SLP, the High Court of Andhra Pradesh, SLP, Court, Nagarjuna Fertilizers, the High Court

DATE: 1993, 1957, 1955, 1957, 1.11.1977).5, the First Appellant, 29th October, 10.12.1977, every month, a period of, 45 days, the last day of the month, three years, Sixty-sixth, 16.12.1994, the previous year, 1.4.1994 to 30.6.1997, 24.7.1997/5.8.1997, 1.4.1994 to 30.6.1997, period.14, the base year, the last year, 2000-2001, Eighth, the years 1997-98 to 2000-01, 1999-2000, 43934/2001, 13.11.2001, 2001, 2002, 40383/2002, monthly, the month of January 2002, 43042/2002, 10.12.1977, the First Appellant, 10.12.1977, 20721/2003, 18242/2002, 17.11.2003

GPE: M/, supplied)10, India, Kirpal, Counsel, done.39

WORK_OF_ART: The Second Appellant, The Retention Price, the Variable Cost, the Retention Price, the Retention Price, the Retention Price, The Case of MM Nagarjuna Fertilizers43, 'Nagarjuna Fertilizers', The Final Findings44

ORDINAL: First, Sixth, Sixth, Sixth, Sixth, Sixth, Seventh, Seventh, Eighth, Seventh, First, Seventh, Eighth, First, Seventh, Eighth, First, Seventh, Eighth, Firstly, Third, first, first, Firstly, Secondly, Seventh, Eighth, Seventh, Eighth

CARDINAL: three, twenty-one, 1.11.1977, 24.10.1977, 1.11.1977, 1977.11, 31.3.1982, five, 31.3.1991, 1.4.1991, 31.3.1994, 1.4.1991, Six, 1.4.1991, 31.3.1994, 1.7.1997 to 31.3.2000, 1.4.2000, 1.4.2000, 2303, 923, one, 7.8.2002, 8.8.2002, 184.01, 127.21, 56.80, 56.80, 10, 12, 24.10.1977, 24.10.1977, 3, 2002)ILLJ550SC, 2000)5SCC471, 1991CriLJ1391, 1987]1SCR1, 1980]2SCR704, 219, 1948, 1, 223, only two, One, 25.7.2003, two

PERCENT: 12%, 80%, the 12%, 2.5%, 12%, 12%, 12%

EVENT: the Six-A, the Six-A period

TIME: 2:30 PM