State of West Bengal and anr. Vs. West Bengal Regn. Copy Writers Assn. and anr.

Decided On : May-08-2009

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Article 309 of the Constitution of India, Article 14, Constitution, the Registration Act, the Registration Act, Article 227, The Registration Act, Section 80A., Section 2, the Registration Act, Rule 6, Copywriter, Copywriter, Rule 5, Rule 5, Rule 9, Rule 19, Rule 24, Article 309, Rule 3 of the Copywriters' Rules, Rule 5, Rule 14, Article 14 and 16, Article 309 of the Constitution of India, Section 69, Section 124, Section 53(A, Chapter VI of the Regulation, Article 310, Article 311, Article 311, Chapter I, the Article 16, Section 203, the Factories Act, Article 309 of the Constitution of India, Article 309 of the Constitution of India.vi

PERSON: V.S. Sirpurkar, J.1, LDC.7, Tehsildar, Bench, Shri Kanakchandra Dutta, Chandra Prakash Pandey, Shri Bhaskar P. Gupta, Reasons, Registration, Bill, Shri Gupta, Shri Jayant, Kumar Mitra, Kumar, Shri P.P. Rao, Kumar Jena, Shri Jayant, Kumar Mitra, Gazette, Deed Writers, Notification Nos, Copywriter, Copywriter, Challan, Draft, Order Receipt, District Registrar, Copywriter, Copywriter, Copywriter, Copywriter, Copywriter, Copywriter, necessary.(2, Copywriter, Shri Jayant, Kumar Mitra, Copywriter, Registering Officer, Shri Bhaskar P. Gupta, Shri Gupta, Kumar Mitra, Copywriting, Shri Bhaskar P. Gupta, Shri Bhaskar P. Gupta, Prayer, the Writ Petitioners, The Writ Petitioners, Writ Petitioners, Writ Petitioners, the Writ Petitioners, Prayer, The Writ Petitioners, Shri Jayant, Kumar Mitra, Shri Mitra, Prayer, Shri Mitra, Shri Mitra, Shri Mitra, Shri Mitra, Copywriter, Shri Mitra, Mauzadars, Mauzadari, Mauzadar, Mauzadar, Mauzadar, Mauzadar, Mauza, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Settlement Officers, Articles 309, Shri Jayant Mitra, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Shri Mitra, Shri Mitra, Girish Jayanti, Short, Morren, Swinton, Morren, Chandra Prakash, Anr, Raman Lal Keshav Lal Soni, Shri Mitra, Basu v. Sankari Prasad Ghosal, Audh Narain Singh, D.R. Gurushantappa v., Abdul Khuddus Anwar, Hon'ble Bhagwati, Hon'ble Bhagwati, J., Shri Mitra, Anr, Raman Lal Keshav Lal Soni, Shri Jayant Mitra, Rao, P.K. Rajamma, Canteen, Shri Mitra, Ram Singh v. Union Territory, Shri Gupta, Chander Hass, Shri Mitra, Mehar Chand Polytechnic v., Anu Lamba, Shri Mitra, Shri Gupta, Shri Mitra, Shri P.P. Rao, Kumar Jena, Shri Gupta, Shri Gupta, Purba Medinipur, Paschim Medinipur, Uttar Dinajpur, Dakshin Dinajpur, Writ Petitioners-Copywriters

DATE: 2007, 12048, 1998, 1998, 2377, 1999, 4636, 1999, 1996, 1982, 1982, 1999, 1999, 1979, 1979, the year 1978, 1984, 1982, 1999, 4636, 1999, 1999, 1982, 1999, 1979, 1982, 1977, 16, 1999, 1968)ILLJ288SC, Articles 14, 16, 21, 1996, 1998, the years, three months, six months', 1908, 1981, 1986, 1979, 1999, 1908, 1981, 1978, 1982, 1982, 1982, 1986, 1982, 23335, 23336, 1999, 1996, 1999, 1982, 1999, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, 17, 19, 21, 24, 1908, eighteen years of age, 35 years of age, less than three years, year, year, the month of November each year, Rule 9, two consecutive years, thirty days, 1979, 1999, 3 years, Rule 12, Rule 26, 1982, 1999, 1999, the present days, 2304/1996, 1998, 1982, 1999, 1996, the year 1995, 16, 20.6.1995, about 1979, 21, 35 years, para 31, 1982, 1999, 36, 2001, 1312 of 2001, 2001, 1,000/- a day, 50 a day, weekly, monthly, weekly, 1886, a period of, six months, 30 years, two years, 1951, 1946, 1965, 1968, 1970)IILLJ499SC, more than 15 years, 1967, 1957)ILLJ477SC, 1979, 2008, daily, daily, 2006)IILLJ722SC, 1999

CARDINAL: 2007.2, 826, 22.6.2001, 391, 392, One, two, two, 2, two, 22.6.2001, 826, 308, five, 2001]2SCR506, 308, 391, one, 1.1.1993, 2(3, 3, 26, 16, 7.6, 1, 1, 1, 1, two, 100, 6.00, 1);(3, 100, 4.00, 20.00.26, 1, 9, 3, 5, 6, 9, 10, 17, 20(2, 1982.21, 392, 7, 7, 14, 14, 15, 17, 18, 26, 28, 30, 826, two, 826, 16, one, 115, 159, 310, 311, 10, one, 1, 174, 417, four, 2, 3, 15, 23, 1, 15, 1983)ILLJ284SC, 27, 1964]4SCR311, 1964]7SCR89, 1969]3SCR425, 560, one, two, one, one, 10 and 11, 1977]3SCR678, 2000)IILLJ1109SC, 2004)1SCC126, only one, 2004)IILLJ253SC, 37, 98, about 22,000, 1, 683, more than 6000, six, 6466, 1200, 20,000, 40,000, 1100

ORG: the Calcutta High Court, the High Court, Tribunal, The High Court, Tribunal, the High Court, The State of West Bengal, the High Court of Calcutta, W.P., the Registered Association of the Copywriters, W.P. No, Tribunal, Tribunal, the High Court, the West Bengal Registration Copywriters' Association, the West Bengal Registration (Copywriters) Rules, the West Bengal Registration (Copywriters) Rules, the West Bengal Registration (Filing of True Copies) Rules, Association, Lower Division Clerk, LDC, Association, the Registration Department, Copywriters, Association, the High Court, Tribunal, Lower Division Clerks;(b, Lower Division Clerk, Lower Division Clerks, Lower Division Clerk, the Lower Division Clerk;(f, the State of West Bengal, the Association i.e. Copywriters, the State of West Bengal, Tribunal, Copywriters, Copywriters, the Registration Office, Registrar, Copywriters, the State Government, the First Pay Commission, Tribunal, the State Government, the State Government, the Writ Petitioners, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Copywriters, Copywriters, Copywriters, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, the State Government, the State Government, Tribunal, LDC, Recruitment Rules, the Recruitment Rules, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Calcutta High Court, the Division Bench, the Calcutta High Court, The High Court, the State Government, The High Court, the Writ Petitioners, Tribunal, The High Court, Government, State, the High Court, the State Government, the High Court, the High Court, the High Court, State, The High Court, Court, The State of, U.P., the State Government, the High Court, the State Government, The High Court, Copywriters, The High Court, the State Government, Departments, Association, The High Court, Government, The High Court, the High Court, The State Government, Government, the High Court, the Writ Petitions, Learned Senior Counsel, the State of West Bengal, the State of West Bengal, the Statement of Objects, The Learned Senior Counsel, Copywriters, Copywriters, The Learned Senior Counsel, The Learned Senior Counsel, Copywriters, the Learned Senior Counsel, the Learned Senior Counsel, the High Court, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Counsel, High Court, the High Court, the High Court, The Learned Senior Counsel, the High Court, the State Government, Central, State, State, XIIIBB, the Inspector General, Copywriters, the State Government, the State Government, Licensing Authority', the School Final, Class VI Examination, Copywriter's Licensing Test, Court, Court, or(d, the District Register, Treasury, the District Registrar, Copywriter:-, Register, Copywriter's Licensing Test', Learned Senior Counsel, Copywriter', the Learned Counsel, Learned Counsel, the Learned Senior Counsel, Copywriters, the State Government, The Learned Senior Counsel, Government, the Government Organization, the Registration Office of State, the Learned Senior Counsel, the State Government, Statute, Court, Copywriters, the State Government, Shri Jayant, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Senior Counsel, Government, Government, Government, Copywriters, the High Court, Learned Senior Counsel, Tribunal, Association, Government, State, the Writ Petitioners, the Office of Registrar, the State Government, the Writ Petition, Government, State, the Writ Petitioners, LDC, the Writ Petition, Government, the Writ Petition, Government, Tribunal, Learned Senior Counsel, the State Government, the State Government, Government, the Writ Petition, the Writ Petitioners, Government, Government, Government, the High Court, the High Court, the High Court, Tribunal, the High Court, the Writ Petitioners, Tribunal, the Calcutta High Court, the High Court, Tribunal, the State Government, the State Government Organization, Government, the Government Rules, Tribunal, Tribunal, the State Government, the State Government, Prayer Clause, the Writ Petitioners, the Learned Counsel, High Court, the Writ Petition, the State Government, Tribunal, the Writ Petitioners, The Learned Counsel, the High Court, Tribunal, Learned Senior Counsel, the High Court, the High Court's, the High Court, the High Court, Court, Tribunal, the High Court, The High Court, the High Court, the High Court, Government, the Writ Petitioners, Copywriters, Department, Government, Government, Government, Government, Government, the Learned Senior Counsel, Government, Transfer Applications, Learned Senior, the Government., Learned Senior Counsel, Kanakchandra Dutta, Assam Land Revenue Manual, 6th Edition, Mauzadar, Gaonburas, Government or Local Board Ferries, the Civil Surgeon, Gaonburas, Court, Court, Court, State, State, State, State, State, State, State, Learned Senior Counsel, Copywriters, The Learned Senior Counsel, Copywriters, State, Mauzadars, Copywriters, Government, Court, State, State, State, State, Emphasis, Mauzadar, Court, Court, Government, Copywriters, State, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Senior Counsel, Union Public Service Commission, Kanakchandra Dutta, the Administration of a Union Territory, Government, Court, Drug Inspector, Government, the High Court, Government, Cassidy, Ministry of Health, Court, Court, J.W. Henderson Ltd., Court, Pendlebury Borough Council, Court, Court, Argent, Social Security, Court, Kanakchandra Dutta, State, Court, Kanakchandra Dutta, General Provident Fund, Court, State, U.P., the State Government, Kurk Amins, Court, Government, Kanakchandra Dutta, State of, Municipalities, State, the State Government, Learned Senior Counsel, Court, State, State, U.P., Kanakchandra Dutta, S.L. Agarwal, G.M. Hindustan Steel Ltd., Court, the Panchayat Service, State, the High Court, G.L. Shukla, ILR, the State Government, State, State, State, Legislature, State, State, State, State, State, State, Court, Government, Court, Learned Senior Counsel, Government, State of, Learned Senior Counsel, Dharamgadhra Chemical Works Limit, Madhya Pradesh, Court, the Learned Senior Counsel, State, the State Government, The Learned Senior Counsel, Post Masters, Court, Post Masters, Post Masters, G.B. Pant University of Agriculture v. State of, Uttar Pradesh, University, Copywriters, Government, Workmen of Nilgiri Cooperative Marketing Society, T.N., Nilgiri Cooperative Marketing Society, Court, Court, Cooperative Marketing Society, Society, Society, Society, Society, Court, Society, Court, Learned Senior Counsel, Divisional, Golf Club, Tractor Drivers, Tractor Drivers, the High Court, Court, Court, Learned Senior Counsel, AIR2006SC3074, Court, the High Court's, Court, Learned Senior Counsel, Copywriters, State, the State Government, State, Haryana v. Navneet Verma, Court, the High Court, Court, Copywriters, Learned Senior Counsel, Ors, High Courts, Central Government, Government, the Central Government, Court, State, Umadevi, Court, Court, the High Court, Court, the Central Government, Central Government, the Official Liquidators, the Central Government, Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Counsel, State Government, Copywriters, judgment.46, Departments, Government, Copywriters, Registration Office, Learned Counsel, Stamp Vendors, the Government Service, State, Government, Government, Government, The High Court, the High Court, the High Court, Tribunal

PRODUCT: W.P.S.T., Registrars, Registrars, Registrars, x8, Registrars, Registrars, Articles 14, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Mauzadars, Copywriters.iii

GPE: O.A., O.A., O.A., O.A., LDCs.10, India, Rules, Clause, West Bengal, Rules, Copywriting, LDCs.24, India, Gujarat, Gujarat, Gujarat, Cafeteria, Malis, Malis, Principal, Dayananda, Kerala, Burdwan, Maldah, Governmental, the State of West Bengal

NORP: Extra, Extra, Extra, Extra, Rules, Rules, Extra, Extra, Extra, LDCs.11, Rules, Extra, Extra, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Extra, Rules, Rules, person:(i, Copywriter, Copywriter, Copywriter, Copywriter, Rules, Copywriter, Rules, Rules, Rules, Copywriter, Copywriter, Copywriter, Rules, Extra, Extra, Extra, Extra, Extra, Copywriter, Rules, Extra, Rules, Extra, Extra, Extra, Extra, Prayers, Extra, Extra, Extra, Copywriter, Rules, Copywriter, Copywriter, Copywriter, Mauza, Mauza, Canteen, Aravali, Clerks, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules

ORDINAL: first, first, firstly, first, first, secondly, firstly, firstly, firstly, first, first, firstly, secondly, first, first, Firstly, Secondly, first, firstly, secondly

WORK_OF_ART: the Registering Officers, Copywriters, 'the Deed Writers' Rules of 1982' for short, the Writ Petitioners, Copywriters, Copywriters, a Writ Petition, The Superintendent of Post Offices, the Official Liquidator, Districts the Xerox, Government.v

MONEY: eight per cent

TIME: their working hours, working hours, hours, no working hours, working hours

LOC: the Writ Petitioners, the Writ Petitioners, the Writ Petitioners, the Writ Petitioners, Assam Valley, the Assam Valley, the Assam Valley

FAC: the Writ Petition, the Writ Petition, Mauzadar

QUANTITY: 45 kg