indira Sawhney Vs. Union of India and ors. - Semantic Analysis by spaCy

Decided on: Dec-13-1999

Court: Supreme Court of India

LAW: Section 3, Article 16 of the Constitution, Section 4, Section 6, Constitution, Article 14, Article 16, the Constitution of India?(5, Article 15(2, Article 16(4, Article 16(4, Article 16(4).Identification, Article 16(4, Article 16(4, Constitution, the Kerala Act, Article 16(4, Section 6 of the Act, Constitution, Section 3, Section 6, Section 6, Article 16(4).(iii, Backward Classes Act, Act 4 of 1994, Article 16(4, Article 16(4, Section 5, Section 3, Article 309 of the Constitution....(c, Article 16 of the Constitution.(4, the Kerala Act, Section 3 of the Act, Section 4, Section 6, Section 3, Section 3 of the Act, Constitutional, Article 31C, Article 31C, Section 3, Section 3, Section 3, Section 3, Section 3 of the Act, Section 3, Point 1, Section 3, the Kerala Act, Section 3, Section 3, Section 3, Section 3, Section 3: Inadequate, Section 3, the Kerala Act, Section 3, Article 16(4, Article 335, Constitution, Article 16(4, Article 335, Article 335, Article 16(4, Constitution, Article 14, the Constitution Bench, Article 16(4, Section 3, Section 3, Section 4 of the Act, Section 4, Section 2(b, Article 309 of the Constitution, Section 4, Section 4, Section 3, Section 3, Section 4, Section 3, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4 of the Act, Section 6:63, Section 6 of the Act, Once Section 3 of the Act, Section 4, Section 6, Section 6, the Constitution of India.65, Article 14: (and Article 16, the Constitution of India:68, the Constitution of India, Constitution, Constitution, Constitutional, Constitution, Constitution, Article 14, Article 16(1, Article 14, Constitution, Constitutional, Section 3 of the 1995 Act, Section 3 of the Act, Article 16(4, Section 3, Para 22C, the Kerala Act, Article 16(4, Constitution, Constitution, Article 141, Constitution, the Rule of law and the Constitution, Constitutional, Article 16(4, Article 16(1).98.

PERSON: M. Jagannadha Rao, J.1, Indira Sawhney, Indira Sawhney, Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Backward, Articles 14, Articles 14, Indira Sawhney, Indira Sawhney, O.M., Backward Classes, Sri, K.J. Joseph, Sri K.P. Mohammed, Adv, Sri K. Aravindaksha Menon, Retd, Sri K. Asokan, Retd, Sri Gopal Subramaniam, Sri K.K. Venugopal, Articles 14, Sri Rajeev Dhawan, Sri A.N. Rajan Babu, Lilly Thomas, Sri V.J. Francis, Indira Sawhney, Articles 14, Articles 14, Indira Sawhney, Backward Classes, Articles 14, K.J. Joseph, K.J. Joseph, Caste, Bench, Backward, Indira Sawhney, J., J., Jeevan Reddy J., Backward, Jeevan Reddy, J., interalia, Jeevan Reddy, J., Backward, Indira Sawhney, Jeevan Reddy, J., M.N. Venkatachaliah, A.M. Ahmadi, Kuldip Singh, judgments.16, Tamil Nadu, Jeevan Reddy, Jeevan Reddy, Creamy, Jeevan Reddy, J., J., J., Kuldip Singh, Jeevan Reddy, Sahai JJ.-, Sri Rajeev Dhawan, Jeevan Reddy, J., Indira Sawhney, Kumar Thakur, Indira Sawhney, Indira Sawhney, Kumar Thakur, Indira Sawhney, Articles 14, Articles 14, Articles 14, Indira Sawhney, Kumar Thakur, Indira Sawhney, Articles 14, Kumar Thakur, Kumar Thakur, Schedule II, Schedule III, Schedule II, Plantations, Para VI, Schedule, the Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Schedule, Backward Classes, the Backward Classes, Indira Sawhney, Bill, Kerala, Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Articles 14, Keshavananda Bharati, Palekar, Khanna, Mathew, Beg, J., Chandrachud, J., Ray, J., Palekar, J., Charles Russell v., Khanna, J., Mathew, J., Beg, J., Chandrachud, J., Huxley, Indira Sawhney, Backward Classes, K.J. Joseph, Indira Sawhney, Indira Sawhney, Indira Sawhney, Kumar Thakur, Indira Sawhney, Kumar Thakur, Articles 14, Backward Classes, Sri Rajeev Dhawan, Jeevan Reddy, Backward Classes, Sri Rajeev Dhawan, Schedule Tribes, Indira Sawhney, Backward Classes, Backward Classes, J., Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Schedule Castes/Tribes, Backward Classes, Sawant J. In, Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Indira Sawhney, Indira Sawhney.56, Articles 14, Indira Sawhney, Ashok Kumar Thakur, Backward Classes, Backward Classes, Indira Sawhney, Articles 14, Articles 14, Articles 14, Articles 14, Indira Sawhney, Articles 14, Keshavananda Bharati, Ray, J., Jaganmohan Reddy, J., Khanna, J., Mathew, J., J., Chandrachud, K.J. Joseph, Bill, Backward Classes, Indira Sawhney, O.M, Indira Sawhney, Viswakarma, Government Departments, Backward, O.M., Malayan, Bobi Mukayan, Backward Classes, Joseph Committee's, Indira Sawhney, Backward, Backward, Justice K. J. Joseph, Kumar Thakur 's, Backward, Backward, Schedule, Indira Sawhney, Kumar Thakur, K.J. Joseph Committee, K.J. Joseph Committee, Indira Sawhney, Anthony Mason, Jeevan Reddy, reservation.96, Krishna Iyer, J., Karamchari Sangh v. Union, W.P.(C, Nos, W.P.(C

WORK_OF_ART: the Backward Classes, the Backward Classes, the Backward Classes, Ashok Kumar, Ashok Kumar Thakur.(iv, the Backward Classes, the Backward Classes, The Queen, the Backward Classes of the State of Kerala, the Backward Classes, the Constitution of India, the Backward Classes, Indira Sawhney, the Constitution of India, the Constitution of India, the Backward Classes, the Backward Classes, VI, the Backward Classes, the Backward Classes

GPE: the State of Kerala, The State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Kerala, the State of Kerala, Kerala, India, the State of Kerala, Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, India, India, Judges, Kania, Sahai, the States of Bihar, Kerala, Sahai, Ashok, Ashok, Ashok, Bihar, Ashok, Bihar, India, India, India, Ashok, Bihar, Bihar, the States of Bihar, the States of Bihar, Bihar, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of, Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Kerala, Dwivedi, were)(see, pp, Kerala, Sawant, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Ashok, the State of Kerala, Ashok, Kerala, the State of Kerala, Ashok, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Kerala, Grover, the State of Kerala, The State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Kerala, Kerala, P.O., Kerala, the State of Kerala, Thachar, Malabar District, Malabar, Sadu Chetties, Valan, Nulayan, Paniakkal, above.84, question.86, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Ashok, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Ashok, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Rules, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, the State of Kerala, Australia, the State of Kerala

ORG: Indira Sawhney v. Union of India, State, Commission, Court, State, Court, Commission, the Kerala Legislature, State, State, WP, the Nair Service Society, K. Ramaswamy, the Elavami Community of Kerala, the State Government, Commission, Court, Kerala High Court, the High Court, the High Level Committee, Committee, Court, the Supreme Court, Court, the State Government, Committee, Court, the Government of India, 8.9.93 Ministry of Personnel Public Grievances and Pensions, the Central Government, the High Level Committee ', the High Court, the High Level Committee, Committee, Sri O.C. Vincent, IAS, Public Relations, Committee, Court, Kerala State, Court, us.4, the suo motu, Amicus Curiae, Sri P.Krishna Moorthi, Sri EMS Anam, Sri K.N. Raval, Additional Solicitor General, Central Government, O.M., Court, the Kerala Legislature, Sections 3,, Sections 3,, the High Level Committee Report, the State of Kerala?Point 1:7, State, State, State, Court, Indira Sawhney v. Union of India, Barium Chemicals v. Company Law Board, inter alia, Question 3(b, Court, CJ, Court, Court, IAS, IPS, All India Services, The Central Government, State, Rubicon, State, IAS, IPS, All India Services, State, the Central Government, Court, State of Bihar and Ors, Indira Sawhney, the Central Government, the Central Government, Central, Sections 3, Legislature, Court, State, Court, Court, Central Government's, Court, Uttar Pradesh, State of Bihar and Ors, the Legislatures of Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Posts and Services, the U.P. Public Services Reservation for Schedules Castes, UP, Court, Court, Indira Sawhney the Government of India, Commission, the High Court of Patna, the Supreme Court, High Courts, UPSC, State Public Service Commission, Comptroller, Auditor-General of, Group A/Class, All India Central Services, State Services, Group B/Class II, Public Sector Undertakings, Banks, Insurance Organisations, Armed Forces and Para-Military Forces, Trade and Industry, O.M., O.M., Court, Court, Court, U.P. Legislations, U.P. Legislatures, Court, U.P., Court, Court, State, Court, Uttar Pradesh, the Central Government's, O.M., Uttar Pradesh, The Validity of the Kerala Act:32, the Kerala Legislature, the Kerala Legislature, the State of Kerala.(iii), the Kerala State Commission, the Kerala State Commission, Subordinate Services Rules, the Government of Kerala.(d, State, the State of Kerala.(3, State, State, Subordinate Services Rules, Commission, the Kerala State Commission, the Legislative Assembly, Subordinate Services Rules, Commission, Court, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, State, the Justice Khalid Committee, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Cabinet, Standing Committee, Legislature, State, Courts, Court, Court, Legislature, AC 829, Queen Inswane Co., Court, Dwivedi, J., Courts, Court, State, The Kerala State, Court, Commission, Kerala Act 11 of 1993, Commission, Commission, Justice Khalid Committee, State, State, the State of Kerala.(c), Court, State, State, the High Level Committee, Court, The Kerala Legislature, IAS, IPS, All India Services, O.M., O.M., State, Kerala State, the Kerala Government, IAS, IPS, the Central Government's, O.M., State, the All India Services, IAS, the Kerala Legislature, State, this p Court, State, State, State, the Supreme Court, Subordinate Services Rules, Court, Court, Ashok Kumar Thakur, State, Court, Parliament, the State Legislature, Court, Court, Ashok Kumar Thakur, Legislature, Sections 3 and 4, Sections 3,, accordingly.66, CJ, Hegde & Shelat, Preamble, Dwivedi, Parliament, The Kerala Legislature, Parliament, State, Court, Committee, Malayalam, Committee, Committee, the High Level Committee, The State Government, Committee, the High Level Committee, Committee, The Subjects-Committee, Legislature, Committees, State, Legislature, The High Level Committee, the Kerala Public Service Commission, Public Services, the Public Service Commission, Public Service Commission, The High Level Committee, the Economic Review, the Kerala Government, Committee, Lower Primary Schools, Lower Primary Sections, Upper Primary Sections, the High Level Committee, Engineering, Medical Colleges and Nursing, Committee, the Central Government's, O.M., Ashok Kumar Thakur, the Kerala Artisans Development Corporation Ltd., Committee, Committee, O.M., Court, Committee, the Central Government's, O.M., Central, the All India Services, 5th Pay Commission, Committee, Trade and Business and Industry, the Central Government, O.M., Ezhava/Thiyya, Nadar, OBC, Community, Government, the High Court, Supreme Court, Council of Ministers, Council of Ministers, Central, Group I and Group, Para Military, Professional Classes and Trade and Industry, Cooperative Societies, VI, the Central Government's, O.M., Ashok Kumar Thakur, Ashok Kumar Thakur, the Justice Joseph Committee, State, Peroorkada Chetties, Manai Chetties, Mukaya, Mukaveeran & Valinjiar, Committee, the High Level Committee, Committee, the Committee's Report, Court, the High Level Committee, State, State, Court, State, Court, The Kerala Government, Court, Court, Court, Sections 3,, Court, Court, State, State, the High Level Committee, Committee, the Government Departments of, Undertakings/Government, Companies/Co, Societies/ Autonomous Bodies, Service Rules, unconstitutional.89, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, the Kerala Government, the Kerala Legislature, Court, State, State, Governments, Governments, Cabinet, Commission, Indira Sawhney, Court, the Kerala Government, Courts, Backward Classes, Court, Akhil Bhartiya, Party, W.P., Amicus Curias Sri Gopal Subramaniam

DATE: 1992, more than three years, 35, years, 1995, 1958, 1995, 1995, 1995, three months, 16, 4, 4, 4, 1992, four A months, four months, today, annual, 4, 1995, 5 of 1995, 1994, annual, every 3 years, the 12th day of March, 1993, the 2nd day of October, 1993, 1958, 1958, 1993, 11 of 1993, 1958, 1993, 1958, 16, 1882, 1878, three weeks, the last about 40 years, Articles 14, 1958, 1958, 1958, 1992, 1958, 1958, 1992, 1995, 1995, 4, 1159, 1471, 1621, 1882, 1883, 2086, December 1996, para 22 and 22A, para 22B(xiii, 1991-96, 29, 1991, 1996, 2964, 2573, 1995-96 21.98, 1995-96, 1996, 2954, 22F, between 1992, 1996, 31, 32, 4, Para 36, 1958, 13-17, an year, annual, every three years, 16.1.1998, 1995, 16.1.98, today, 1992, 1995, 4, 16.1.1998, today, today, 1958, today, this day, 16, today, today, Years, 35, 36

CARDINAL: 10.7.1995, 36, 11.9.1995, 4, 16, 699, one, 16, 2.9.95, 4.11.96, more than 4, 16(1, 16(4, 2, 16, 3, 6, 16/95, 16, 4, 6, 6, 3, 6, nine, 3, 174, 539, three, 798, 1967]1SCR898, 783, 4, 796, 3, eight, nine, five, three, five, 2, 5.17, 791, two, 4).18, 3(d)(paras 790, 792, 793, 10, 843, 844, 790, 792, 793, 10, 847, 859, 3(d, 5, 861, 553, 553, 522, 287, 295, 296, 323, 385, 629, six, eight, three, six, nine, 8.9.93, a dozen, 812, one, 2, 3, two, 16(1, 16(1, 16(4, 520), 16(1, 6, 16(1, 8.9.93, 8.9.93, 1, 17)The, 8.9.93, six, 1995.(ii, 1992.(2, 11, 1993).(b, 4, 14 to 17, II, 14 to 17, II, 20.3.95, 10.7.95, 93, 17.4.93, 13.10.93, 10.5.94, 8.7.95.34, 10.7.95, 11.9.95, 13.7.95, 14.7.95, 27.7.95, 31.8.95, 2.9.95, 304, 7, 3, 27.7.95, 27.7.95, 16.7.1995, 4, 5, six, nine, six, 8.9.93, 16(1, two, two, 791, 16, 434, 434, between two, two, 233):it, 16(1, 16(4, 2.10.1992).59, 16(1, 16(4, 16(1, 16(1, 16(4, 3, 16(1, 16(4, 2, 3, 506, 520, 648, 652, 886, 5, 114, 596, 15.1.97, 177, 13.1.97, 22, 22, 68, 893, 27, 557, 346, 3, 6728, 18.12, 16.16, 56.27, 17,250, 211, 1.17, 48,635, 79,638, 8206, 22F, 28, 30, 1.50, 3000-5000, 2500-4000, 2200-4000, 3, 5, 17, 1 to 4, 13-17, 19, 1.50, 20, 20, 5, 4, 1.50, 3, 1.50, 5, 10, 2, 3, 6, five, 16.1.98, 14 to 17, II, one, 14, 684, 1981)ILLJ209SC, 699/95 and, three

NORP: Pandian, Paragraph, Urban, Mandal, inflation.43, Artisans, Indira, Converted Christians, Kumbarans, Muslim, Boyan

PRODUCT: Para 860, Point 1, Memorandum, Constitutional, Government.(d, Backward, Yogam, Schedule, Articles 14 and 16(1, Constitution.57, Point 4, the Backward Classes, Para 33, Report, Para VI, Report, Report, Report, Report, Report, Report, Report, Report, Report, 727/95

ORDINAL: Secondly, first, second, second, first, second, second, First

LOC: Executive, the Central Govt, the Scheduled Castes, List III, concerned.81

FAC: the Bihar Ordinance, the Backward Classes, the Backward Classes, the Backward Classes

TIME: 6 of the Act

LANGUAGE: English

MONEY: 40 per cent, 40 per cent

PERCENT: 91%, almost 100%, 39.06%, the 40%, 40%