P.R. Nayak Vs. Union of India (Uoi)

Decided On : Dec-07-1971

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Article 133(1)(c, Constitution, Article 226 of the Constitution.2, Rule 3, Article 226 of the Constitution, Constitution, Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 565 of the Civil Services Regulations, Article, Article 563.]11, Rule 3, Rule 3, Rule 7 of the Service Rules, Article 389, Rule 5(2, Rule 5(2, Rule 7, Rule 5(2, Rule 5(2, Rule 3, Rule 3, Rule 3, Rule 12, Article 309 of the Constitution, Rule 7 of the A.I.S. (D & A), Rule 12, Rule 3(1)(a, Rule 3(1)(a, Section 21, Article 226 of the Constitution.28, Rule 3, Article 226 of the Constitution in the Delhi High Court, Article 314, Rule 3, Rule 3(1)(a, Article 14 of the Constitution.41, Article 14, Fundamental Rule 56, Fundamental Rule 56, Article 565 of the Civil Service Regulations, Article 565, Article 565 of the Civil Service Regulations, Article 565, Article 299 of the Constitution, Fundamental Rule 86, Fundamental Rule 56, Fundamental Rule 56, Article 565 of the Civil Service Regulations, Rule 8, Rule 3, Rule 7, Rule 5(2, Rule 6, Article 314

CARDINAL: 1, 9, one, nine, 14, 1971.4, 5., 6, 60, 56(f, five, 351, 351, 3, two, 3, forty-eight, 1, 1955.16, 1, 1971.19, 3, 1, 4, 4, 5, 6, 1971)ILLJ299SC, two, 25, 589, 5(3, 1, two, 12, two, 56(ff, one, 1, 2, 9, 1971.35, 1971.36, 14, 56(ff, two-fold, four, two, five, 1971.47, 56(f, 56(c, Prior to, 56(c)(i, 56(c)(i, five, 56(c)(i, 56(f, 56(f, two, 56(f, 56(f, two, two, two, 86, 56(f, 56(ff, 56(f, 56(ff, 56(ff, 56(ff, 56, 56(f, 56(f, 56(f, 56(ff, 56(ff, 56(ff, 56, 56(ff, 56(f, 56(f, 56(c)(i, 4, five, 56(c)(i, 1, one, three, 27, one, 8, 3, seven, 3, two, 3, 8, 3, two, 8, 6, 1967)IILLJ219SC, 3, 7, 3, 8, 1971)ILLJ299SC, one, 8, 9, 1964)ILLJ752SC, 6, 1966)IILLJ164SC, two

ORG: the High Court, the Indian Civil Service, State, Fundamental Rule 56(f, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Refineries Ltd., the Oil and Natural Gas Commission, the Government of India, the Ministry of Petroleum and Chemicals, the Ministry of Works,, Housing and Urban Development, the Indian Oil Corporation, Shri S.N. Rao, the Parliamentary Committee on Public Undertakings, the Pipeline Division, the Indian Oil Corporation, Parliament, Government, Government, Commission, the Commissions of Enquiries Act, the Parliamentary Committee on Public Undertakings, the Ministry of Petroleum and Chemicals, the Takru Commission, Commission, the Government of India, The Takru Commission, Cabinet, Pipeline, the Indian Oil Corporation, the Public Undertakings Committee of Parliament, Shri Takru's, the Indian Civil Service, ICS, the All India Services, Central, the High Court, The High Court, the Indian Civil Service, the High Court, All India Services, the High Court, Court, the High Court, the Indian Administrative Service, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Administrative Service, F.R. 56, F.R. 56, the High Court, the Indian Civil Service.9, Court, Fundamental Rules, State, Council, the Government of India Act, the Fundamental Rules, State, the Government of India, a Chief Court, the Indian Civil Service, Chapter IX of, the Fundamental Rules, Government Servants, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Administrative Service, the Indian Police Service, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Police, Government, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, Civil Service Regulation, All India Services, Government, the Central Government, Government, Government, the Central Government, the Ministry of Petroleum and Chemicals, Works, Housing and Urban Development, the Indian Civil Service, the Government of India, Indian Civil Service, the Government of India, Works, Housing and Urban Development, Works, Housing & Urban Development, the Government of India, the All India Services, Takru Commission, the All India Services, Government, Government, Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Ors, the All India Services, Tarak Nath Ghosh's, the All India Service Conduct Rules, the Government of Bihar, Government, an All India Service, the All India Services, an All India Service, a State Service, Court, Tarak Nath Ghosh's, Government, Court, S. Govinda Menon, the High Court ', Court, All India Services, Court, Government, Government, Court, Court, I.A.S., Board of Revenue, Kerala High Court, the Sree Pulapally Devaswom, the X-Branch, the X-Branch, the Board of Revenue, I.A.S., Board of Revenue, the All India Service, Government, the State Government, the Fundamental Rules, Court, Government, the Central Government, Court, the Central Civil Services, Control and Appeal) Rules, Proviso, Government, Court, C.C. & A., A.I.S. (D & A), C.C.S., C.C.S., The Appointing Authority, Government, A.I.S. (D & A) Rules, C. C. & A.) Rules, C.C. & A) Rules, Court, the Patna High Court, C.C. & A) Rules, Railway Protection Force Rules, the Central Government, the Railway Protection Force Act, the High Court, Government, the Indian Civil Service, Indian Refineries Ltd., the Indian Refineries Ltd., the Ministry of Petroleum and Chemicals, Ministry of Works,, Housing and Urban, the Indian Civil Service, Indian Civil Service, the Central Government, the Central Government, Central Vigilance, Central Vigilance, Government, the Parliamentary Committee on Public Undertakings, the Pipeline Division, the Indian Oil Corporation, Parliament, Committee, the Indian Refineries Ltd., Bechtel, Bechtel Corporation, Consultants, the Board of Directors and Government, the Parliamentary Committee on Public Undertakings the Government of India, the Commission of Inquiry Act, the Allahabad High Court, Bechtel, Government, Bechtel, Bechtel, the Board of Directors, Bechtel, the Indian Refineries Ltd., Bechtels to Indian Refineries Ltd., Government, Commission, Commission, the Government of India, the Ministry of Petroleum and Chemicals, the Takru Commission, the Parliamentary Committee on Public Undertakings, the Government of India, the Ministry of Petroleum and Chemicals, the Government of India, the Takru Commission, the Takru Commission, Shri Takru, Government, Charge III, the Government of India, ICS, the All India Services, the Central Government, the Government of India.38, Fundamental Rule 56(ft, the Indian Civil Service, the Government of India, Ministry of Works, Housing and Urban Development', Fundamental Rule 56, the Indian Civil Service, the Government of India, the Commission of Inquiry, the Government of India, the Indian Civil Service, the All India Services, The High Court, the Indian Civil Services, Court, Fundamental Rule 56(ff, Court, the High Court, the High Court, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Fundamental Rule 56(f, the High Court, Court, Court, the High Court, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule 56, the All India Services, Fundamental Rule 56, Fundamental Rule 56, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Fundamental Rule 56, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule, State, the Government of India, Fundamental Rules, Fundamental Rules, the Indian Civil Service, a Chief Court, Fundamental Rule, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Historically Civil Service Regulation, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule 56(f, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule, Fundamental Rule, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Fundamental Rule 56(f, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Fundamental Rule 56(f).51, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Fundamental Rule 56(f, Government, Government, Government, Cabinet, Government, Government, Fundamental Rules, Fundamental Rules, the Indian Administrative Service, the Indian Police Service, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Police, Fundamental Rule 56(ff, Fundamental Rule, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule, Fundamental Rule, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule 56(ii).57, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule 56, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule, Fundamental Rule, the Indian-Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, Government, Fundamental Rule 56, the Indian Civil Service, the Ministry of Petroleum and Chemicals, Ministry of Works,, Housing and Urban Development, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule, the Indian Civil Service, Government, Fundamental Rule 56(f, State, State, the Central Government, the Indian Civil Service, General of Ministry of External Affairs,, Government of India, Cabinet, Government of India, Cabinet, Planning Commission, Government of India, the Government of India, Ministry of Industrial Development, Cabinet, the Government of Maharashtra, Ministry of Works,, Housing and Urban-Development, the Indian Civil Service, Government, Fundamental Rule 56(f, the Indian Civil Service, Fundamental Rule 56(f, the Civil Service Regulations, Fundamental Rule, the Indian Administrative Service, the Indian Administrative Service (, State, the Indian Civil Service, the Government of India, the Indian Civil Service, Central Government, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, the All India Services, Government, Government, Government, Government, Government, Government, Government, the Indian Civil Service, The Takru Commission, the Takru Commission, the High Court, the Commission the Government, Government, the Takru Commission, Government, Government, the All India Services, the All India Services, Government, Government, Government, Government, Government, the Takru Commission, the All India Service, the All India Services, Death-CM/H-Retirement Benefit, the State Government, Indian Civil Service, the Indian Civil Service, The Union of India, the Board of Revenue, The State Government, the All India Services, the All India Services, the All India Services, Government, Court, the All India Services, Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, Ors, Court, Government, Court, Government, an All India Service, All India Service, an All India Service, a State Service, the All India Services, Government, The Union of India, Court, Government, Government, the Takru Commission, The Takru Commission, the Takru Commission, the All India Services, Death-Cum-Retirement Benefit, Government, R.P. Kapur v. Union of India, Court, Government

GPE: Delhi, London, India, India, India, India, Bihar, West Bengal, India, F.R., New Delhi, Delhi, F.R., F.R., F.R., India, India, India, F.R., F.R., India, Clauses, F.R., Clauses, India, India, F.R., F.R., F.R., Counsel, S. Govinda Menon's, Halsbury, New Delhi, C.C.S., C.C.S., C.C.S., C.C.S., A.I.S., I.L.R., C.C.S., Delhi, India, Haldia, West Bengal, Haldia, Snam, New Delhi, India, India, F.R., India, India, India, India, India, Clauses, India, India, Govinda Menon's, Govinda Menon's, Govinda Menon's, Champaklal

DATE: May 6, 1971, 1934, November 25, 1935, 35 years', the end 35 years', less than five years, five years, November 25, 1970, October, 1963, August, 1964, January, 1965, February, 1969, June, 1967, April, 1970, April 30, 1970, August, 1970, 1952, October, 1970, November 7, 1970, November 16, 1970, 19th December, 1970, 5th January, 1971, January 13, 1971, March 23, November 3, 1970, April, 1970, the next few months, about 4 months, the 25th November, 1970, November 23, 1970, March 25, 1971 :, 35 years', the 25th November, 1970, the 25th March, 1971, March 23, 1971, 1969, March 25, 1971 end, the end of 35 years', five years, March 25, 1971, 1969, October, 1970, August, 1962, 1919, January, 1922, 1922, thirty-five years', less than five years, five years, five years, June 26, 1970, 56, three months', thirty-five years', the end of, thirty-five years', less than five years, five years, October 6, 1970, November 1946, August 1962, August, 1962, October, 1970, 1946, 1970, August, 1962, 1969, '3, January, 1965, February, 1969, 35 years', 35 years, less than five years, January, 1965, less than five years, November 23, 1970, November 25, 1970, November 23, 1970, February, 1969, five years, February, 1969, March 25, 1971, November 23, 1970, five years, 1960, March 23, 1971, March 23, 1971, March 25, 1971, March 25, 1971, March 25, 1971, March 25, 1969, 1955, 1969, 1967)IILLJ219SC, 31st July, 1964, June 6, 1963, '5(2, Rule 5(2, Rule 5(2, 12th 'February, 1963, 1955, 1969, 1959, 1957, 1955, 1957, 1965, 1957, 1965, Rule 7(1)(a, 1955, 1969, 1969, 1957, 1965, 1955, 1966, 1957, 1959, 1957, 23 of 1957, Rule 3(1)(a, intention.25, November 25, 1970, March 25, 1971, 6 May, 1971, 23 March, 1971, 25 March, 1971, 23 March, 1971, 24 November, 1935, 1960, the month of October, 1963, the month of January, 1965, 22 February, 1969, 25 November, 1935, 35 years, 24 November, 1970, 35 years, 23 November, 1970, 25 March, 1971, 23 March, 1971, the month of August, 1968, 20 August, 1968, 23 August, 1968, 21 August, 23 August, 1968, 16 April, 1970 Shri N. S. Rao, 30 April, 1970, 1952, 22 August, 1970, 26 September, 1963, the month of October, 1970, 17 October, 1970, 26 September, 1970, 7 November, 1970, 26 September, 1970, the middle of the month of February, 1971 ', the middle of the month of January, 16 November, 1970, 30 November, 1970, December, 1970, 7 December, 1970, 19/21 December, 1970, 5 January, 1971, 4 January, 13 January, 1971, 23 March, 1971, 1969, 24 March, 1971, 30 March, 1971, 25 March, 1971, 24 November, 1970, four months, 25 November, 1970, 23 November, 1970, 25 March, 1971, 23 March, 1971, 25 March, 1971, 1969, 5 years, 5 years, 23 March, 1971, five years, 1969, 35 years, 25 November, 1935, 23 November, 1970, 35 years, the 25th November, 1970, the 25th March, 21 July, 1965, 1 January, 1922, 1922, 35 years', less than live years, five years, 1 January, 1922, 35 years', less than five years, 1965, thirty-five years', the end of, thirty-five years', less than five years, 35 years', the end of, thirty-five years, the end of thirty-five years', thirty-five years', the end of 35 years', the end of 35 years', the end of 35 years', 35 years, five years, thirty-five years, Thirty-five years', the end of 35 years', 35 years', 35 years', 35 years, 35 years', the end of 35 years, the month of November, 1970, 3 November, 1970, about four months, 25 November, 1970, 23 November, 1970, 3 'November, 1970, 25 March, 1971, four months, 25 November, 1970, 23 March, 1971, the end of 35 years, 35 years, 35 years, the end of, thirty-five years', less than five years, five years, the month of January, 1965, 22 February, 1969, five years, 21 February, 1974, 23 November, 1970, 25 March, 1971, five years, 56, the end of 35 years', less than five years, five years, 1922, four months, 35 years', 1 month, 22 days, 1 year, six months, 1 year, 11 months to 4 years 10 months, 27 days, 27 January, 1947, 35 years', 24 November, 1950, one year, six months, 4 years 10 months, 27 days, 25 August, 1958, 35 years', 6 December, 1960, one year 4 months, 10 days, 3 years 7 months, 22 days, 22 April, 1965, 35 years', 20 November, 1966, 7 months, 2 years 2 months, 9 days, 13 March, 1967, 35 years', 23 November, 1969, 1 month, 22 days, 2 years, 10 months, 2 days, 1 January, 1969, 35 years', 30 November, 1969, 1 year, 1 year 'and 11 months, 5 September, 1967, 35 years', 24 November, 1970, 6 months, 3 years 8 months, 20 days, 22 February, 1969, 35 years', 25 November, 1970, four months, 2 years 1 month, 35 years', five years, five years, 1954, 1955, 1955, the end of 35 years', five years, 5 years, 5 years, 1969, early in the year 1971, 23 March, 1971, 1969, 1969, Rule 3(1)(a, Rule 3, Rule 8, 1969, Rule 3, 1958, an earlier date, 1955, 1969, 1955, 1967)IILLJ219SC, 1967)IILLJ219SC, 1955, 1969, Rule 5(2, 1955, 1969, 1967)IILLJ219SC, 1969, 1958

PERSON: Shri S.N. Rao, Shri S. Dutt, Shri J. N. Takru, Shri S. Dutt, Shri J. N. Takru, Shri B. Sivaraman, Shri, Shri P.R. Nayak, Shri P.R. Nayak, Shri P.R. Nayak, F.R. 56, F.R., Daftry, Court, G. K. Mitter, A. N. Ray JJ, Tarak Nath Ghosh, S. Govinda Menon v. Union of India, Shri S. Govinda Menon, Shri S. Govinda Menon, S. Govinda Menon's, Govinda Menon, Tarak Nath Ghosh's, Tarak Nath Ghosh's, Tarak Nath Ghosh's, Pat 749, A.N. Ray, J.27, Shri N. S. Rao, Shri Rao, Shri Rao, Shri N. S. Rao, Shri Rao, Shri Rao, Shri Rao, Shri Rao, Shri J. N. Takru, Charge XIII, Shri P.R. Nayak, Shri P.R. Nayak, Order, Shri P.R. Nayak, B. Lal, Shri Takru, Shri G. S. Bajpai, Shri Vishnu Sahay, Shri G.R. Kamath, Shri N. N. Wanchoo, Shri B. Sivaraman, Shri B. B. Paymaster, Js, Schedule, S. Govinda Menon, Anr, Rules 8, Tarak Nath Ghosh, Discipline, Anr

ORDINAL: 7th, first, third, second, First, First, First, first, first, second, third, First, Second, Third, Fourth, first, Second, Third, First, Secondly, First, Second, Third, Fourth, first, First, Secondly, first, second, first, second, first, first, secondly, second, first, secondly, First, Secondly, first, secondly, second, third, first, second, third, first, first

LOC: Shri P.R. Nayak, Shri P.R. Nayak

PRODUCT: Shri P.R. Nayak, Rule 3, Rule 4(1, Rule 4, Memorandum, Shri Takru, Shri P.R. Nayak, this:-A, Rule 3

WORK_OF_ART: Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules, Discipline and Appeal) Rules

FAC: Railway, the Haldia-Barauni-Kanpur, Haldia-Baraunj, the Governor-General

EVENT: O.P. 2306/62

NORP: Rules, Rules, American, American, Rules, Constitution.39, follows:-(f, Rules

TIME: more than 48 hours