The State of Madhya Pradesh and ors. Vs. Gopal D. Tirthani and ors.

Decided On : Jul-28-2003

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Article 14 of the Constitution as, Article 14 of the Constitution, Section 10, Section 10 of Act No, Section 10, Madhya Pradesh Act No, Constitutional, Article 14 of the Constitution, the Constitution Bench, the Constitution Bench, the Regulations and Regulation 9, the MCI Regulations, Article 14 of the Constitution

PERSON: R.C. Lahoti, Madhya Pradesh, para-medicos, Mantralaya, Gazette, Rule 2, Priti Srivastava, Adhiniyam, merit cum, Bench, Anr, Tamil Nadu, K. Doraiswamy's, Bench, Ashok Sharma, Madhya Pradesh, Preeti Srivastava, Anr, Ajay Kumar Singh, Nivedita Jain, K.L. Narasimhan, Sadhna Devi, Anr, Bajrang Soni, Bajrang Soni's, Preeti Srivastava's, Recourse, merit inter, Dinesh Kumar, Bench, Bench, Snehelata Patnaik, Bench, Narayan Sharma, Anr, Pankaj Kr, Lehkar, Snehelata Patnaik's, inter se merit

NORP: J.1, Physicians, Physicians, manner?and(4, K.

ORG: the Constitutional Courts, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the State Government, the High Court, Court, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the High Court, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the State of Chhattisgarh, State, State, ANM, MBBS, Block/Tehsil Headquarters, Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Paediatrics, CHC, FRU, Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Paediatrics, Specialist/District Health Officer', the State of Madhya Pradesh, the Medical Council of India, the University/Institution, the State Government, the State Government, National, MBBS, a State Government, the Department of Medical Education, Government of Madhya Pradesh, the Madhya Pradesh Medical, Dental Post Graduation Entrance Examination Rules, P.G. Entrance Examination Rules, Madhya Pradesh Government Gazette Extraordinary, hereunder:-'MADHYA PRADESH MEDICAL, DENTAL, Medical Education, Government of Madhya Pradesh, Degree/Diploma Course, Dental College, the State of Madhya, Madhya Pradesh Medical, Dental P.G. Entrance Examination Rules, SC/ST, UNRESERVED, Government of Madhya Pradesh, Degree/Diploma Courses, The Public Health and Family Welfare Department of Government of Madhya Pradesh, the Madhya Pradesh Medical, Dental Post Graduation Admission, the Madhya Pradesh Government Gazette Extraordinary, hereunder:-'MADHYA PRADESH MEDICAL, F-2, Department of Medical Education, Government of Madhya Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh Medical, Dental Post, Post, the State of Madhya Pradesh, Post, Government of Madhya Pradesh, Post Graduation, Degree/Diploma Courses, the State Government for Degree/Diploma Courses, Medical & Dental Colleges, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the State Government, the Department of Public Health and Family Welfare, Government of Madhya Pradesh Mantralaya, Post, Medical & Dental Colleges, the State of Madhya Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh Medical, Dental Post Graduate, Admission Rules, State, xxxSelection, the Government of Madhya Pradesh, Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Madhya Pradesh Professional Examination Board, xxxTerms, the Madhya Pradesh Professional Examination, the State Government, P.G. Degree/Diploma Course, the State Government, The P.G. Entrance Examination Rules, the State Government, the State Government, State, Department, The P.G. Admission, the State Government, Department of Medical Education, P.G. Entrance Rules, the State Government, The PG Admission, the Public Health and Family Welfare Department, Madhya Pradesh Professional Examination Board, the Assistant Surgeons, the State Government, the P.G. Entrance Examination, the State Government, Pre-P.G. Entrance Examination, M.P. Professional Entrance Test Board, PET Board', the High Court of, Madhya Pradesh, P.G. Entrance Examination Rules, P.G. Admission, The High Court, the High Court, The High Court, the P.G. Admission, Regulations, the Medical Council of India, Regulation, the Medical Council of India, the High Court, the Medical Council of India, Court, the High Court, the State Government, the Madhya Pradesh Medical, Dental Post Graduation Entrance Examination Rules, the Madhya Pradesh Government Gazette Extraordinary, Madhya Pradesh Chikitsa Shiksha, Bar, the State Government, State, State, P.G. Examination Rules 2002, Bar, P.G. Entrance Examination Rules, hereunder:'MADHYA PRADESH MEDICAL, Madhya Pradesh Chikitsa Shiksha, State Government, Post Graduate Medical (MD & MS, Dental, MDS, the State of Madhya, Madhya Pradesh Medical, Dental P.G. Entrance Examination Rules, the 'Gazette of Madhya, Madhya Pradesh.8.1 Reservation, SC/ST, UNRESERVED, the Government of Madhya Pradesh, the Public Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Madhya Pradesh, PET Board, the High Court, the State Government, Court, PET Board, the High Court, State, the High Court, Advocate General, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the State Government, the High Court of, the State Government, the MCI Regulations, The State Government, the State Government, PET Board, MBBS, P.G. Admission Rules 2002, the State Government, State, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the High Court of, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, Court, Court, State, The State Government, State Government, The Court held:-(i, Court, AIIMS Students' Union, Court, Court, Medical Services, Court, State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, The Medical Council of India, Ors, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education & research, Chandigarh and Ors, Court, U.P., Medical Sangharsh Committee, mae, Medical Council of India, Bench, State of Punjab v., Dayanand Medical College & Hospital and Ors, the Medical Council of India, Court, the Medical Council of India, the Medical Council of India, The State Government, the Medical Council of India, Court, the Central Government, Council, Court, the MCI Regulations, State, the Medical Council of India, the Medical Council of India.25, The Medical Council of India, The State of Madhya Pradesh, the Medical Council of India, State, State, the Central Government and/or Medical Council of India, Court, Dayanand Medical College, Hospital, State, the State of Madhya Pradesh, State, State, The High Court, the State of Madhya Pradesh, Bar, Ors, Motilal Nehru Medical College, Allahabad, the Government of India, the All India Entrance, Court, Court, the All-India Entrance Examination, Court, the All-India, State, Lordships, AIR2000SC72, the State Health Services, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Uttar Pradesh and Ors, Pradip Tandon and Ors, State, Advocate General, the State of Madhya Pradesh, State, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the State Government, Obstetrics & Gynaecology, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the Universities of Madhya Pradesh, Medical Council of India Regulations, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the Medical Council of India.5, the State Government, the High Court, MCI Regulations, Bar, the High Court, the High Court, the State Government, the High Court, Pre-PG Test, the State of Madhya Pradesh, the State Government, Authority, Court, State, Authority, Court, the High Court, State Government, The State Government, Medical Education, Public Health and Family Welfare, the Pre-PG Entrance Examination, the Pre-PG Entrance Examination, the High Court, the PG Entrance Test, the PG Entrance Test

DATE: today, November 1, 2000, 8835, 302134, or(iii, 14th January, 2002, 2002, 2002, 14.1.2002, 2002Bhopal, the 14th January 2002No, F-5-7-2002-LV-M.E.-1.--Department, F-5-7-2002-LV-M.E.-1, 14th January 2002, 2002, three years, 2002, 2002, 28th March, 2002, 14th January 2002, 2002, 28-03-2002, 2002, 5 years, three consecutive years, five years, less than five years, every 6 months, five years, five years, 20 marks.c, another 5 years, 2002, 2002, 2002, hereinafter.11, the year 2005-03, 16.6.2002, 2002, 2002, 20th February, 2003, 2002, 2002, three years, 2002, 2003-2004, 18th February, 2003, 2003, 2003, 18.2.2003, 1973, 1973, 2003, 2003, F-5-62-02, 1973, 2003, the year 2003-2004, the first week of February 2003, 20.2.2003, 20.2.2003, 9.3.2003, 2003, 20th February, 2003, 2002, the year 2002, the year 2002-2003, the year 2002, year 2002, 2003, 15.5.2003, 20.2.2003, the present year, the present year, the subsequent year, the year 2002, the year 2003, three consecutive years, another five years, August 14, 2001, October 11, 2001, years, 3 years, three years, five years, '31, at least five years, '10, five years, 33, five years, 3 years, three consecutive years, 3 years, the year 2002, the year 2002, 45 years, the year 2003, 2003, the year 2002, the year 2003, about one month, this year, the previous year, a period of, one month, 2003, a period of, one month, today, the year 2002, 2003, 36

CARDINAL: five, 620, 537, 89, 51,806, 313, 3000, 5000, 1194, around 50,000, 20,000, One, 229, 169, 4670, 805, 9, 9, 2002No, 3.00, two, two, 24.3.2002, two, one, two, 19, 14, 4.2.2003, 108, only 101, Two, 36, 9(2)(iii, only one, five, five, 9(2)(iii, 4, only one, three, 2001]1SCR489, two, two, one, two, three, two, two, 229, 169, two, three, two, only one, two, two, two, one, two, 1994]3SCR57, 1982]1SCR759, 1997]2SCR186, two, two, 9(1, only one, only one, one, five, ten, two, two, two, Four, II, 1986]3SCR345, two, three, 1992]1SCR335, three, 20, 10 to 20, 1975]2SCR761, one, two, two, only one, five, more than one, 36, 53, 108, 36, 2003.38, one, two, 36, 36, 36

GPE: Surgery, Anaesthesia, Anaesthesia, non-Governmental, Bhopal, Anaesthesia, supplied)10, Pre-PG, 20%.(5, India, held:-', P.G., MD, Orissa, Pradip, Tandon, Uttrakhand, Pradip, Tandon, India, Anaesthesia, P.G., P.G.

TIME: the first second

ORDINAL: third, first, second, third, first, second, third, third, first, second, third, first, second, third, Firstly, secondly, Firstly, Secondly, Thirdly, third

MONEY: fifty per cent, 2 marks, 30 marks, 40 marks, 30 marks, 30 marks, Qualifying marks, 15 per cent, 15 per cent, 15 per cent, 5 per cent

PERCENT: fifty percent, fifty-percent, 21%, 15%, 14%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 20%, 20%, 30%, 30%, 40%, 20%, 40%, 20%, 16%, 14%, 30%, 40%, 50%, 20%, 30%, 30%, 30%, 20%, 20%, 50%, the remaining 50%, 33%, 50%, 50%, 20%, 20%

FAC: the Gazette of Madhya Pradesh, the Pre-PG Test, the Pre-PG, the Pre-PG Test, the Pre-PG Test, the Pre-PG Examination

QUANTITY: 45 years.xxx xxx

PRODUCT: Rule 8.6.2

WORK_OF_ART: The 'In-Service Rules', Regulations

EVENT: Regulation 9(2)(iv