Chandra Prakash Tiwari and ors. Vs. Shakuntala Shukla and ors.

Decided On : May-09-2002

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Article 309 of the Constitution ?5, Article 309 of the Constitution and, Article 309, Section 2, Article 309, Section 2, the Police Act, Section 2 of the Act of 1861, the Police Act, Article 372(1, Constitution, the Indian Independence Act, Article 372, Article 395, Constitution, Constitution, Article 313 of the Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Section 46, the Police Act, Article 309, Article 309, Article 309, Article 309, Article 309 of the Constitution, Constitution, Article 309 of the Constitution and Section 39 of the Act, Article 309, Article 309, Article 309, Article 309, Article 309, Section 39, Article 309, Article 309 of 1994, Article 309 - agency, Article 309, Article 309, Section 7 of the Act, Article 309, Section 46(2, the Police Act, Section 2, Rule 1 of the General Rules, Rule 1, Section 69, Section 69, Section 69, Section 69, Section 69, Section 69, Article 309, Article 309, Constitution, Article 309, Section 2 of the Act, Article 311 of the Constitution, Article 311 of the Constitution, the Police Act, Section 12 of the Act, Section 12, Section 46, the Police Act, Section 2, the Police Act, the Police Act, Article 309, Constitution, the Police Act, Article 309, Constitution, Section 2, the Police Act, Section 46(2, Section 2, Section 2, Section 46(2, Section 2, the Police Act, Article 309, the Police Act, Article 309, Item 2, Constitution, Article 309, the Police Act, Section 46(2, Section 46(2, Regulation 5

NORP: J.1, Rules, Latin Maxims, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, arise.33, Rules

ORG: Court, Court, Sub-Inspector, the State of, U.P., Court, Selection Committee, the Sub-Inspectors, Allahabad, the Departmental Selection Committee, Sub Inspectors, Civil Police, Inspector, Civil Police, Head of Department, unfit?2, the Uttar Pradesh Government Services Criteria for Recruitment by Promotion Rules, Court, the General UP Government Service, Criteria for Recruitment by Promotion) Rules, Sub-Inspectors, UP Sachiv, Uttar Pradesh ShasanTo, Uttar Pradesh Allahabad/LucknowDated Lucknow, the U.P. Police Commission Report, the Police Regulations, Sub Inspectors, Sub Inspector, Sub Inspectors Civil Police, The Departmental Selection Committee, Sub Inspectors Civil Police, the Departmental Selection Committee, Committee, the Departmental Selection Committee, the Police Regulations, Uttar Pradesh, U.P. Government Service, Criterion for Recruitment by Promotion) Rules, State, the U.P. Gazette (Extraordinary, KA, the Head of Department, Head of Department, promotion - Recruitment by Promotion, Head of Department, the Head of Department, U.P. State, Police Force, State Government, the State GovernmentSubject, the State Government, the Government of India Act, State, the State Government, the State Government, Broom, Emphasis, Emphasis, the Government of a State, State, Legislature, Court, Court, Maxwell, Interpretation of Statutes, legislature.10, the General Recruitment Rules, Maxwell, Interpretation of Statutes, specialibus, Court, Maharaja Pratap Singh Bhadur, State, Contra, Legislature, State, the Official Gazette, Section 46(2, Dayanandalal K. Dayanandalal, Ors, Court, the Kerala Civil Services, Control and Appeal) Rules, Kerala Police Service, Kerala Police Subordinate Service, the Kerala Police Service, the Kerala Police Subordinate Service, Kerala Police Service, the Kerala Police Subordinate Service, Schedule II, the Kerala Police Subordinate Service, the State and Subordinate Services Rules, the Kerala Police Subordinate Service, State, Subordinate Services Rules, the Kerala Police Subordinate Service, Police Subordinate Service, State, Subordinate Services Rules, Scope of the General Rules, State, the State Government, State, the State Government, the Kerala Police Subordinate Service, State, the Kerala Police Subordinate Service, the State and Subordinate Services, State, Subordinate Services Rules, the Kerala Police Subordinate Service, Kerala Police Gazette', The Kerala Police Gazette, the Office of Inspector General of Police, the State Government, the Inspector General of Police, Kerala Police Gazette, the State Gazette, the State Government, the Kerala Police Gazette, the State Gazette, the State and Subordinate Services Rules, the State and Subordinate Services Rules, the High Court, Court, Shish Ram and Ors, Court, Tribunal, Government, Respondents 3, Shish Ram, Court, Court, the State and Subordinate Service Rules, the Kerala Civil Services, Control and Appeal) Rules, Kerala Police Subordinate Services Rules, State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the Inspector-General, District Superintendents of Police, the State Government, the State Government, the Inspector General of Police, the Police Force, Uttar Pradesh, Home, U.P. Administration, U.P. Police Headquarters, Allahabad, under:'In, the Police Department, Police, Police, Home (Police) Section, the Personnel Department, the Home Police Section of U.P. Administration, Allahabad, State Government, Police Force, the State Government, the State Government, Government, the State Government, the Home Department, the Ministry of Home Affairs, the State Legislature, the Government of Uttar Pradesh, Order, the High Court, Court, Tata Iron & Steel Co. Ltd., Union of India and Ors, Banerjee, the English Courts, Sears, the Privy Council, Sarat, Seton, Laing Co., the High Court of Australia, Craine v. Colonial Mutual Fire Insurance Co. Ltd., C.L.R., C.L.R., Turner, Central Newbury Car Auctions Ltd., Unity Finance Ltd., ER, Pickard, Sears, Mercantile Bank, Central Bank, AC 287, National Westminster Bank, Barclays Bank International 1975, Q.B., the House of Lords, Moorgate Mercantile Co. Ltd., Twitchings, AC 890, Court, Court, Court, Court, Commission, the Selection Committee, Court, the High Court, the Interview Committee, High Court, Bar, the General Rule, the General Rule, The General Rule, all State Government, the State Legislature, List I.'37, State, the State Government, the General Rules, Legislature, General Rules, the Official Gazette, Order, Union of India and Ors, Court, Syed Khalid Rizvi v. Union of India, the Selection Committee, the State Civil Service Officers, Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, Committee, the State Civil Service, Uttar Pradesh, State, Court

DATE: 1997, the period between 1992 and 1996, each year, that year, 1996-97, 1994, 1994, November, 1965, 1994, November, 1965, November 5, 1965, August 18, 1964, 1960, less than 10 years, 50 years of age, the 1st day of January of the year, every year, August 2, 1962, an earlier year, two years, 1994, 10th October, 1994, October 10, 1994, 1996, 1998, 1965, 1994, 1861, 1861, 1861, 1947, 1935, '10, '11, 1861, the year 1998, the year 1994, '13, 1884, 1977, '11, 1884, 1992, '13, '15, 1965, the year 1998, 1994, 1998, November, 1965, 10.10.1994, November, 1965, 1861, 9, 1957, 17.12.1958, 17.12.1958, Rule 10(ii, Rule 10(ii, '18, '19, Rule 10(2, Rule 28(b)(10, 1957, '22, '7, one month's, fifteen days, '23, '24, 21st September, 1996, 1861, 1991, '26, 1994, 13th April, 1998, '28, 26th April, 1999, 1861, 26th April, 1999, '29, 1994, 1965, 1994, 2001, 1837, 1887 19, 1920 28, 1956, 1939, 64121, 1844 13, 1837, 6 Ad, 1848, 1938, 1977, 1935, 120]'32, 1995]1SCR908, '34, 1965, 1994, the year 1993, the year 1994, 1965, 1993)ILLJ887SC, every year, the first day of January of the year, a particular year, that year, a particular year, each year, that year, that year, '41, annual, a later year

LOC: Single Judge, Single, Single, Single, Shri Poti, Estoppel, justice.42, Single

WORK_OF_ART: Bench, Om Prakash Shukla

ORDINAL: secondly, 5th, 5th, first, first, first, 5th, 5th, first, Secondly, 7th

GPE: Lucknow, Lucknow, India, Karnataka, Vera Cruz, Generalia, Vera Cruz, Vera Cruz, Eileen, P.S., Kerala, Kerala, Kerala, Dayanandalal, namely:-(a, Police, G.Os, Governmental, Governmental, Pickard, Shand, Grundt, Vipinchandra, Clause

PRODUCT: Bench, Article, Seward, Seward, Memorandum, 905

CARDINAL: 3., 1, 1, 1, 2, 4., 246, four, 403(3, 13/34/19, 4, one, two, one, 1, 2, 3, one, two, two, two, two, two, 1998]1SCR157, 168, 1, two, 168, 10, 1, 1966]3SCR663, 10.10.1994, 1996)9SCC728, 8, 26.5.1958, 26.5.1958, 26.5.1958, II, Rules.10, 17.5.1963, 17.5.1963, 17.5.1963, 17.5.1963, 17.5.1963, 17.5.1963, 10, 28(bb, 28(bb, 1996)10SCC166, 5, 160-400, 225, 160-400, 450, two, 500, 13.6.1973, 620-1200, 570-1080, 500, 28(bb, 1957.21, one, 2, 41, one, 20, 6Ad, 469, three, one, 59, 641, 3, 59, 285, one, 469, 2, two, 1986]1SCR855, Three, 1986]1SCR855, three, 2A, 1993.38, Two, one, 11, 2

PERSON: Shri R.K. Dar, Range, Sd/- R.K. Dar, 6700/-, Rajiv Dhawan, Dhawan, Dhawan, Government,12, 11th Edn, 11th Edn, Louise Nicolle v., John Winter Nicolle, Dhawan, Misra, Misra, Misrs, Schedule, Schedule, Rule, Gazette, Gazette, Gazette, Gazette, Gazette, Stenographers, Head Clerks, Head Clerks, Stenographers, Force-, Subject, Dhawan, Chunder Dey, Gopal Chunder Laha, J., Spencer Bower, Dixon, J., Grundts, Lyon v. Reed, Freeman, Exc, Square v. Square, Dhawan, Bench, Madan Lal, Dhawan, Gazette, Dhawan.40, Hiralal Shah, Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah, Dhawan

FAC: the Official Gazette, Schedule II

EVENT: AC 59, the 1957 Rules, the 1957 Rules, Regulation 5

MONEY: 372(1

PERCENT: 50%

QUANTITY: 305 Dixon