Samira Kohli Vs. Dr. Prabha Manchanda and anr.

Decided On : Jan-16-2008

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Section 21, Section 33

PERSON: R.V. Raveendran, J.1, Lata Rangan, Lata Rengen, Zutshi, Puneet Bedi, Sumi Kohli, Sudha Salhan, Latha Rangan, Shiela Mehra, Gynaecologist, Lata Rangan - respondent, Lata Rangan, Lata Rangan, Zutshi, Taber, Schoendorff, Andrew Grubb, Murray, Goff, Curry 1933, xxxYou, Scott L.J., Leland Stanford, McNair J., Hunter, Hanley, Clyde, Bridge, Bridge, Scarman, Haribhau Khodwa v. State, Vinitha Ashok v., Lakshmi Hospital, V.P. Shantha, Vinitha Ashok, Law, Rogers, Scarman, Robert W. Shah, death.35, Lata Rangan, Lata Rangan, Lata, Samira Kohli, Samira Kohli, Lata Rangan, Prabha Manchanda, Prabha Manchanda, Samira Kohli, Samira Kohli, Lata Rangan, Manchanda, Ring Road, Lajpat Nagar, Somi Kohli, Somi Kohli, Gynaecologists, Lata Rangan, Puneet Bedi, Sudha Salhan, Laparotomy, Lata Rangan, CW1, RW1, Sudha Salhan, Gynaecologist, Histopathology, Hysterectomy, Puneet Bedi, Gynaecologist, Sudha Salhan, Gynaecologists, Sudha Salhan, Hormone Therapy, Hormone Therapy

ORG: the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, facts2, the Operation Theatre, Commission, a Harmone Replacement Therapy, New India Assurance Co. Ltd, Obstetrician & Gynaecologist, Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Association of Obstetricians, Anaesthetist, Commission, Appellant, Blood Grouping, PCV, CT, ECG, ii)14, Dentist, Dental, Cyclopedic Medical Dictionary, the United States Courts, District of Columbia Circuit, Society of New York Hospital, the House of Lords, Principles of Medical Law, Oxford University Press -- Second Edition, the Supreme Court of, BC, Courts of Appeal, Marshell, the Supreme Court of, the Medical Council of India, the Central Government, Indian Medical Council Act, the General Medical Council of U.K., Hospital, Bowater v. Rowley Regis Corporation, the Bolam Test, Friern Hospital Management Committee, Jury, thus:(i, SC, Bethlem Royal Hospital Governors, the House of Lords, Court of Appeal, The House of Lords, the Court of Appeal, Court, Maharastra, Court, Court, Court, Indian Medical Association, Court, State, Reibl v. Hughes, the Canadian Supreme Court, the High Court of Australia, Hackney HA, AC 232, Pearce, United Bristol Healthcare NHS Trust, Sidaway, the Operation Theatre, Admission, OPD, Rs.39,325/-, appellant.46, OPD, OPD, RW2, Commission, Commission, Commission, v):48, Hormone Replacement Therapy, Head of Department (Obstetrics and Gynaecology, the Association of Obstetricians, Commission, Commission

CARDINAL: 12/1996, 3., 15.5.1995, 4., 5.6.1995, 18.7.1995, 11.9.1995, 5., 9.5.1995, 9,000, 8., two, 10, 11, 15.5.1995, 464, 772, 211, 125, 545, 2, 3, 260, 17, 18, 13, 20, 1944, 1, 21, only two, 22, 118, 23, 200, one, three, three, 1, three, 26, 28, 29, millions, one, several hundred or thousands, four, more than one, 30, more than one, 32, 33, 3d, 1, 109, 625, 48, 118, 867, 36, 16.2.2002, 16.2.2002, hysterectomy.15, 38, 5.6.1995, 4, 41, 42, 1, two, 10.5.1995, 9.5.1995, 9.5.1995, 9.5.1995, 50, 15.5.1995, 51, more than one, one

DATE: 1986, 9.5.1995, 44 years, nine days, the same day, the next day, 10.5.1995, 23.5.1995, 15.5.1995, Rs.39,325/-, 12.7.1995, 19.1.1996, 19.11.2003, the same day, the next day, 10.5.1995, 10.5.1995, a month, 14.5.1995, 9.5.1995, a few months, 40 years of age, the fourth decade, 10.5.1995, 40 years, 1972, 2d, 1914, years, 1949, 1956, 10.5.1995, 1957, 1957, 1955, 1985, days, months, the days, 1980, 1998 1, 1998, 10.5.1995, 9.5.1995, same day, the next day, 37, 9.5.1995, 10.5.1995, 10.5.1995, 10.5.1995, 3, 10.5.1995....3, 10.5.1995, 10.5.1995, salpingo-oopherectomy.44, 45, 10.5.1995, 47, the age of 44 years, about two years, 2002, 49, 44 years of age, 44 years, 44 years old, 54, Rs.25,000/-, 19.11.2003

ORDINAL: first, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, First, secondly, thirdly, First, Second, Third, Secondly, second, 9th, 10th, first, first

GPE: anesthesia, anesthesia, anesthesia, Delhi, anesthesia, anaesthesia, Obstetrics, Hemoglobin, BT, UK, America, UK, Canterbury, Canada, England, NS, Canada, Salgo, Canterbury, States, USA, Canterbury, Canterbury, England, Sidaway, Canterbury, Canterbury, India, Achutrao, Sidaway, Achutrao, Canterbury, India, Government, India, India, India, India, India, Canterbury, Canterbury, Canada, Australia, Canterbury, England, Sidaway, Sidaway, Canterbury, England, Bolitho v. City, Canterbury, India, Canterbury, anaesthesia, New Delhi, anesthesia, Delhi

PRODUCT: Appellant, Respondent, Appellant, 30.4.1995, Para 3.04, Consent, 9.5.1995, Lesion, Endometriosis

NORP: Rs.25, Laparascopic, Rs.8000, Laparoscopic, Rules, American, English, caesarian, caesarian, English, Bolam, Scottish, Bolam, Bolam, Bolam, Bolam, Bolam, Bolam, American, American, American, Bolam, Bolam, Bolam, Obstetrician, Obstetrician, Rs.5,000

TIME: the evening, 4 to 5 minutes, the same evening, the same evening

LOC: Bilateral Salpingo, Hysteroscopy

LANGUAGE: English, English, English, English

WORK_OF_ART: 2 All, 1 All ER 643

PERCENT: 2%, 10%, 90%, 10%, 10%

MONEY: 114 DLR