Fomento Resorts and Hotels Ltd. and anr. Vs. Minguel Martins and ors.

Decided On : Jan-20-2009

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Section 4(1, Land Acquisition Act, Section 5A, Section 6, Rule 4, Rule 4 of the Rules, Section 41, the Land Acquisition Act, Section 40, Section 49(1, Section 44(3)(c, Section 44(1)/49(1, Rule 13, Section 46, Section 44, Section 16, Article 51(g, Section 40(1)(b, Section 40(1)(b, Section 16, Section 40(1)(aa, Section 40(1)(b, Section 40(1)(b, Section 40(1, Section 4(1, Section 4(1, Section 16, Section 40(1)(b, Section 40(1)(aa, Section 40(1)(b)?(ii, Section 16, Section 4, Section 5A(2, Section 39, Section 41.12, the Constitution Bench, Section 40(1)(b, Section 40(1, the Constitution Bench, Section 41, section 4, Section 41, Section 40(1, Section 40, the Code of Civil Procedure, Section 40, Section 40, Section 40(1, Section 40(1, Constitution, Section 40(1, the Constitution Bench, Section 6, Section 41, Section 40, Section 40, Section 41, Section 40(1)(aa, Section 41, Section 40(1)(b, Section 6, Section 40(1, Section 40(1, Section 41, Section 41, Section 40(1)(aa, Section 40(1)(aa, Rule 15, Section 52, Section 42

ORG: G.S. Singhvi, the High Court, Ors, Fomento Hotels, Resorts Limited, Fomento Resorts, M/s. Gomantak Land Development Pvt. Ltd., Village Taleigao, Gram Panchayat Taleigao, Diu, Dona-Paola-Bambolim Road, Hotel Cidade de Goa, Site Development, firstClusterJan.80 to Site Development, Central Facility, Jan.81, Complete, Facility, the Town and Planning Department, the Gram Panchayat, Court, the Court of Civil Judge, Taleigao, Government of Goa, Village Taleigao, State, a Yoga Centre,, Health Club, Hotel Project, Hotel Building, the Government of Goa, the State Government, the State Government, the High Court, Fomento Resorts, Hotels Ltd., the High Court, Court, Clauses 3, Company, Curla, Vainguinim, Company, the Government of Goa, Plan, -Tourism Development Project - construction, Curla, Vainguinim, Taleigao, Company, Company, Company, Government, Eco-Development Council of the Government of Goa, Diu, Government, Company, Company, Company, Panjim Planning and Development Authority, `the Development Authority', `Town & Country Planning Act', EEC, EEC, Smt, the Eco Development Council, Council, the Development Authority, the Town and Country Planning Act, Shri/Smt, Hotel Building, Taleigao Village Town, the Planning & Development Rules, Authority, the Town and Country Planning Act, EEC, Hotel Cidade de Goa, Board, the State Government, the Development Authority, the Development Authority, the Development Authority, the State Government, Village Panchayat Taleigao, the Chief Town Planner, CRZ, the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, the Environment Protection Act, Civil Suit, Junior Division, Special Civil Suit, The Goa Foundation, the State of Goa, the Goa Foundation, Taleigao, Special Civil Suit No., Dona, Development Authority, the Development Authority, CRZ Regulation, the High Court, The High Court, the High Court, the State Government, the High Court, W.P. No, the State Government, the Development Authority, the Development Authority, Special Civil Suit Nos, Special Civil Suit, the High Court, High Court's, Court, SLP, the High Court, the Chief Town Planner, the Gram Panchayat, the State Government, Court, High Court, Development Authority, the Development Authority, the High Court, Special Civil Suit, the High Court, Special Civil Suit, Special Civil Suit, Court, Nagubai Ammal, Allahabad High Court, the State of Goa, the State Government, State, the Goa Foundation, the High Court, the Development Authority, Court, Dona-Paola-Bambolim Road, Special Civil Suit, the State Government, the High Court, Court, the State Government, the State Government, the High Court, land?Re, Government, U.P., Lakshmi Ratan Engineering Works Limited, Government, Government, Government, Act, Government, the Land Acquisition (Amendment) Act, the Collector under Section 5A, Company, Company, Company, Uttar Pradesh and Ors, Court, Parliament, Parliament, Court, Parliament, State, Calcutta High Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Government, Clauses 1 to 5, State, Court, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, Curla, Vainguinim, Taleigao, the High Court, State, Cove.22, site.2J. The Plaintiffs, Plaintiff, Machadio Survey No., Eastern, Eastern, Court, red pencil, Engineers, Dona-Paola-Bambolim Road, Special Civil Suit, The High Court, the High Court, Special Civil Suit, Court, Nagubai Ammal, the Allahabad High Court, Order VI Rule, Order VI Rule, Smt, the State Government, Order VI Rule, Civil, Smt, Special Civil Suit, Special Civil Suit, the State of Goa, the High Court, the High Court, Dona-Paola-, the High Court, the State Government.28, Nagubai Ammal's, Nagubai Ammal's, Court, the Supreme Court, Court, Reliance, Anurag Misra's, the Allahabad High Court, Court, Allahabad High Court, Order VI Rule, the High Court, the High Court, the State Government, Shri Pallav Shishodia, the State of Goa, Court, the Gram Panchayat, the State Government in Clause, Government, State, State, State, The Public Trust Doctrine, the Public Trust Doctrine, The Public Trust Doctrine, Illinois Central Railraod Co., the United States Supreme Court, State, the Illinois Central Railroad, The Supreme Court, State, State, State, State, the Government of the State, Public Works 244, the Supreme Judicial Court, the Public Works Department, National Audubon Society v. Superior Court of, the Supreme Court of California, the Department of Water and Power of the City of Los Angeles, Los Angeles Water Diversions, The Supreme Court of, State, Court, State, State, Court, State, State

NORP: J.1, Pedestrian, Southern, Roman

CARDINAL: 25.4.2000, 330, 141, 803, 246/2, 1, 803, 246/2, 787, 2, 2, 1, 1.8.1978, 1, 2, 22.8.1978, 1, 1.12.1978.(iv, 1, 787, 79, 79, 81, 1, 1, 1, 1, 2, four, 787, 803, 804, 806, 807, 788, 789, 787, 805, 769, 1, 2, 787, 805, 1, 790, 788, 789, 20.12.1978, 1, 15.11.1978, 788, 789, 803, 804, 806, 807, two, 787, 805, 150, 100, 787, 787, two, 788, 789, two, 787, two, two, two, two, two, 803, 805, 787, 806, 807, 805, 29.10.1980, 803, 246/2, 27.10.1983.(xi, 2, 1, 67, 76, 805, 803, 804, 1985]2SCR937, 26.3.1985.(xiii, 1, three, 6, six, 1, 8, 26.3.1985.(xv, 1, 787, 788, 789, 246/2, 1, 246, 1, 3, 4, 1, 2, 3, 803, 246/2, 17.5, 1, 1, 803, 246/2, 20.4.1992, 1, 2, 3, 4, 10, 1, 792, 242/1, 1, 1, 1, 2, 787, 803, 3, 1.8.1978, 22.8.1978, 1, 5, 7, 1, 2, 803, 1, 2, 1, 2, 1986.(xxii, 1, one, 792, 67, 792, 792, 803, 803, 1, 792, 803, 2, 792, 803, 67/1986, 9, 792, 803, 242/1, 787, 2, 803, 141/1992, 1., 1, 803, 246/2, 803, 246/2, 803, 33, 141, 803, 246/2, 284/91, 37/92, 792, 803, 246/2, 803, 1, 67/1986.6, 1, 803, 246/2, 1, 2, 246/2, 49, 803, 246/2, 803, II, 803, 803, 804, 805, 1.8.1978, 787, three, 803, 792, 803, 803, 246/2, 2, 803, 1956]1SCR451, 803, 246/2, 803, 803, 1, 1, 803, 803, 1, 803, 803, 792, 803, 1, 803, 1, 803, 1.8.1978, 22.8.1978, 787, 803, 803, 246/2, 804, 803, 246/2, 1, 803, 246/2, 803, 246/2, 1, 803, 246/2, 111, 41, 6 to 37, 2, 149, 41, 41, 13, 41, 1, 2, 5, 2, 1, 1, 4, 803, 246/2, 1, two, two, two, 1964]6SCR784, 1980]3SCR783, 1971]3SCR871, 1995)2SCC442, 1, 5, 1, more than one, three, more than one, three, three, 803, 246/2, 1, 803, 246/2, 787, 805, 1, two, 788, 789, 1, 803, 1, 1, 803, 246/2, 1, 1, 1., 221, 803, 246/2, 803, 6, 2, two, two, 2, 803, 803, 803, 2F, 2O, 2R, 2S, 3E, 3H, 2, 803, 804, 787, 788, 789, 805, 803, 787, 803, 787, 803, 803, 792, 2H, 803, 804, 788, 789, 2H, 788, 789, 803, 803, 806, 803, 804, 806, 806, 806, 807, 792, 806, 807, 805, 807, 804, 803.2R., 787, 803, 803, 2(H).2S., 2H, 2P, 787, 803, 787, 803, 2(k).[Emphasis, 2, 2, 787, 807, 787, 790, 798, 800, 801, 802, 805, 2, 5, one, 803, 792.24, 1, 803, 67/1986, 803, 2, 2A, 2E, 2F, 2S, 15, one, 2, 3, 46/1999, 15(2, 2, 792, 803, 803, 803, 15(2, 803, 2, 792, 803, 2, 792, 803, 6, 669, 151, 581, 34, 100, 2, 15, 803, 246/2, 803, 1.12.1978, 787, 803, 787, 803, 803, 246/2, 804, 805, 803, 246/2, 1, 803, 246/2, 787, 1, 803, 246/2, 804, 787, 1, 787, 803, 246/2, 32, 803, 246/2, 2d 577, four, five

PERSON: Goa Bench, Shri Minguel Martins v. Sociedadee Fomento Industries Pvt, Anr, Gram Panchayat, Hotels Limited, Alvaro Remiojo Binto, District Tiswadi, Goa, Nos, Nos, Gustavo Renato da Cruz Pinto, Nos, Nos, Town Planner, Daman, Panaji, Goa, the Gram Panchayat, lakhs1978Jan, Approx Rs.40, Jan.82, Complete, Complete, Shri Gustavo Renato da Cruz Pinto, Surana Pepfira Pinto, Befta Sara Da Costa, Alvaro Remiojo Binto, Nos, Nos, Nos, Panaji-Dona Paola-Bambolim, Nos, Nos, Shri Shankar Laad, Nos, Nos, Dona Paula, Paragraphs 3 to, Nos, Nos, LQN/315/78, Gazette, Gustavo Renato da Cruz Pinto, Nos, Gustavo Renato Da Cruz Pino, Dona Paula, Goa, Daman, Diu, Schedule, Daman, Timblo, Nos, 246/4, Nos, Timblo, Daman, Diu Town and Country Planning Act, Nos, Shri Minguel Martins, Nos, Nos, Shri Minguel Martins, the Gram Panchayat, Nos, Nos, Nos, Shri Minguel Martins, Nos, Nos, Alvaro de Souze Macahdo, Panaji, Victor Albuquerque, Minguel Martins, Gram Panchayat, Nos, Gustavo Renato da Cruz Pinto, Nos, Nos, Alvaro De Souza Machado, Anr, Anr.(xxiii, Claudo Alvares, Vainguinim, Nos, Nos, Vainguinim beach.(xxiv, Gustavo Renato da Cruz Pinto, Gustavo Renato da Cruz Pinto, Vainguinim, Paula jetty, Timblo, Shri Moraed Ahmed, Exh, Cove, Gram Panchayat, Counsel, Shri Anil B. Divan, Nos, Shri Divan, Shri Divan, Nos, 20.4.1992, Shri Divan, B. Shama Rao, Ravindra Singh, Anr, Pallav Shihsodia, Shri Anil Divan, Indira Jaising, Jaising, 20.4.1992, Jaising, Nos, Jaising, Shri Divan, Nos, R.L. Arora v. State, R.L. Arora, R.L. Arora's, and(5, Gazette, Nos, R.L. Arora v. State, R.L. Arora's, R.L. Arora's, R.L. Arora, R.L. Arora, Anr, Surendra Nath Bhattacharya, Anr, R.L. Arora's, Somwanti, R.L. Arora's, Jage Ram v. State, Haryana, Bajirao T. Kote v. State, P.N. Talukdar, Nos, Nos, Nos, Nos, Nos, Nos, Nos, Nos, Goa, Minguel Martins, Avdhut Kamat, Gustavo Renato da Cruz Pinto, Gustavo Renato da Cruz Pinto, Avdhut Kamat, Paula jotty, Paula jetty, Taluka, Paula, Panaji, Paula-Bambolim, Taluka llhas, Shri Avdhut Kamat, Shri Kamat, Fomento, Shri Kamat, Nos, Shri Anil Divan, Panaji, Alvaro De Souza Machado, Anr, Anr, Panaji, Alvaro De Souza Machado, B. Shama Rao, Ravindra Singh, Anr, Timblo, Timblo, Nos, Timblo, Nos, Nos, Nusserwanji Rattanji Mistri's, Shri Divan, Abdul Huq, Nanjunda Rao, Chandra Kunwar, Chaudhri Narpat, Chandra Kunwar, Rajah Makund Singh, Abdul Huq, O. S. No, Nos, Shri Anil Divan, Indira Jaising, Joseph L. Sax, Illonois, Robbins, Fowl Meadows, Mono Lake

GPE: Bombay, Vainguinim beach, the Vainguinim Beach, Approx, Approx, Approx, Approx, Approx, 246/4, Bombay, to.(xxi, Machado, Machado, India, it.4, I.As, Machado, Machado, Anurag Misra, Kanpur, observations:.If, Sections, Sections, Sections, or(aa, Company.(3, Clause, Clause, paris, India, work.19, Clause, Machado, Machado, Machado, Calapur, Calapur, St. Cruz, Machado, Anurag Misra, 2C, Machado, Machado, Baron Park, Slatterie, E.R. 579, Rani, Rani, L.R., India, The State of Illinois, the State of Illinois, the United States, Massachusetts, California, California

DATE: 1992, 1992, 246/1, 245/1, May, 1983, 29.9.1979, 29.9.1979, 246/2, 245/2, 1894, 1963, 79, 26.10.1983, 4, 1894, one year, three years, one year, 26.10.1983, 1984, 1974, 246/1, 246/3, 23rd, 11.6.1987, 11.9.1987, 14.10.1987, 10.7.87, 11.9.87, 1974, 1977, 1974, 15.4.1988, 246/1, 20.6.1991, 12.7.1991, 246/1, 15.4.1988, 15.4.1988, 26.10.1983, 1974, 1986, 1979, 26.3.1985, 15.4.1988, 246/2, 26.10.1983, 26.10.1983, 15.5.1990, 26.10.1983, 246/2, a period of, eight weeks, today, two weeks, ten weeks, 1992, 67/1986, 26.10.1983, 13.3.2006, 26.10.1983, 29.10.1980, 26.10.1983, 1962, 41, 41, 1961, 1961, 42, 1908, 8042, 1961, 1963]2SCR774, 29.10.1980, 26.10.1983, one year, three years, the year 1980, many years, the last seventy years, the last fifty years, Para 2P, Para 2P, Para 2F, Para 2H, 13.3.2006, 1921, 1928, 1926, 1933, 1938, 1920, 1920, 1932, the subsequent years, 1840, 1906- 07, 27, 1919-20, question.29, 1980, 1970, Today, the year 1869, 1869

LOC: Vainguinim, the District of Tiswadi, the Goa Town and Country Planning Board, Machado, South, North, East, Sea, Single, Northeast, Lake Michigan

PRODUCT: the Gram Panchayat, the Gram Panchayat, 805, B'].7, Gram Panchayat, 805, Plaint, Para 2H, resources.33

FAC: the Gram Panchayat, Beach Resort Hotel Complex, Machado Cove, Sections 40, Bambolim Road

ORDINAL: first, first, third, fourth, first, second, first, first, first, first, first, second, second, first, second, second, 10th, first, first, fifth, second, second, first, second, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, second, third, third, second

QUANTITY: 10,000 Kg, 19,114 square metres, 200 meters, about 1000 meters, 1000 square meters, 1000 sq. meters, one mile

WORK_OF_ART: The Sarpanch of the Gram Panchayat, 26.6.1984, Cove', Cove, Cove, Cove, Cove, Cove

EVENT: the 1894 Act, the 1894 Act, the 1894 Act?(iv, the 1894 Act

LANGUAGE: English