Maganbhai Ishwarbhai Patel Etc. Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and anr.

Decided On : Jan-09-1969

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Article 32 of the Constitution ', Article 32 of the Constitution, The Indian Independence Act, Article 1 :, Article 3 :(, article 2(vi, article 3(ii, Article 1 of the Agreement, Article 3 of the Agreement, the Indian Independence Act, Section 311, Constitution, Map A.It, Constitutional, Constitution, Article 37, Article 19(1)(d, Constitutional, Constitution, Constitutional, Constitution, Title VI, Article 52, Article 53, Article 55, Constitution, Constitution, Article 54, Constitution, the Constitutional Charter of 1830, the Indian Evidence Act, Constitution, Constitution, Section 113, the Evidence Act, the Indian Constitution, Constitution, Article 1 of the Constitution, Constitution, the Seventh Amendment, Article 3 enables, Article 253, Article, Article 73(1, Constitution, Constitution, Constitutional, Constitution, article 3 of the Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, article 3 of the Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Article 3 of the Constitution, Article 368, Constitution, Article 368, Article 3, Article 3, Article 368, Article 3, Constitutional, Constitution, the 9th Amendment, Constitution, the 9th Amendment, Constitution, Constitution, Section 290-A of the Government of India Act 1935, Constitutional, Constitutional, Article I, Constitutional, Constitutional, Constitutional, Constitution, Constitutional, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Constitutional, Constitutional, Article 1, Constitution, Constitution, Constitutional, Constitutional, Constitutional, Constitutional, Constitution, Constitutional, Constitution, the Indian Independence Act, Section 2(2, Article 1 of the Agreement of Merger the Maharao, Constitution, Constitution, Section 290A, Constitution, Section 8(1)(e, the States Reorganisation Act, the Bombay Reorganization Act, Article 1--'There, Article 3--(i, Article 3(iii, Constitutional, Constitutional, Article 73, Constitution, Constitution, Article 253, Article 253 occurs, Constitution, Article 245

PERSON: M. Hidayatullah, Manikant Tiwari, Shiv Kumar Sharma, Madhu Limaye, Gulabshankar Amritlal Dholakia, Node Sadi, Rau, Shiv Kumar Sharma, Singh, Maganbhai Ishwarbhai Patel, Kanjarkot, Chhadbet, Dharabanni, Priol Valo Kun, I. N. Shroff, A. S. Bobde, C. B. Agarwal, Shiv Kumar Sharma, Madhu Limaye, Manikant Tiwari, C. K. Daphtary, Wav, Rann, Ales Bebler, Nasrollah Entezam, Gunnar Lagergren, Maps, Map B., Creek, Creek, Sind, Rann, Dhara Banni, Pirol Valo Kun, Kanjarkot, Vighokot, Sarifbela, Map A. Pakistan, Rann, Sind, Ales Bebler, Nosrollah Entezam, Entezam, Entezam, Entezam, Sind, Dharabant, Parkar, Nagar Parkar, Award, Creek, Ales Bebler, Entezam, Nagar Parkar, Nagar Parkar, Thar Parkar, Parkar, Map, Nagar Parkar, Bebler.16, Dharabanni Chhadbet, Award, J. H. Rolston, Pacta Sunt Servanda, Recourse, Stuyt, Darby, Moore, Nantwi, Madhu Limaye, Madhu Limaye, Madhu Limaye, contentions.21, Award, Municipal Law, Kings, Kent, Forsyth, Forsyth, Forsyth, Grotius, Belli, Livy Vol, Lough, Pahnerston, Debates Vol, Phillimore, Robert Phillimore, Beige, Baird, Atkin, Ruondaulandi, Ponsonby, Reyswick Hudson Bay, Hertslett, Scindia, Pudokottah State, Aitche, Vol, Vol, Deoram Kanji, Ruler, Nos, XI, Vol, Harwell, Foster, L.R., Algot Bagge, Majesty, Jawaya Kapur v., Ramkishore Sen, Debiganj Thana, Chilahati, Mukerjee, Schedule T. The, Radcliffe, Schedule, Dharabanni, Nagar Parkar, Kutch, Appendix XXIX, Ruler, Kutch, Order, Kutch, Dhorna, Halara, Rampur, Vasatava, Dhara Banni, Kanjarkot, Madhu Limaye, Shri Lal Bahadur Shastri, Kanjarkot, Dhara Banni, Map, Ales Bebler, Nasrollah Entezam, Mosaic Map, Map, Sind, Macdonald, Rann, Award, Map, Kanjarkot, Madhu Limaye, Dhara Banni, Map, Dhara Banni, Dhara Banni, Dhara Banni, Huber, Ecrehos, Award, Award, J.C. Shah, J.59, Schedule, Award, Award, Sind, Charles Napier, Sind, Sind, Pullan, Macdonald, Sind, C. F. Erskine, Macdoland, Rahim ki Bazar.65, Sind, Creek, Sind, Order, Schedule, Sind, Map, Schedule, Virtue, implementation.71, Map, Creek, Sind, Rann, Rann, Sind, Map, Award, Award, Gunnar Lagergrcn, Nasroilah Entezam, Rann, Rann, Map, Map, Dhara Banni, Chhad Bet Sector;(3, Nagar Parkar, Gunnar Lagergren, Pirol Valo Kun, Dhara Banni, Chhud Bet, Item, Gunnar Lagergren, Municipal Law, Jaw, Robert Phillimore, Baird

CARDINAL: five, three, 234/68, 403/68, 409/68, 2118/68, 1900/68, 1528/68, two, 1528/68, 1900/68, 403/68, three, two, two, two, two, 2, seven, two, two, two, two, two, three, One, two, two, two, about 10,000, about 350, 9, one, half, two, two, 350, two, two, two, one, two, 6n, two, seven, two, 407, one, two, 171, three, 80, 2, 253, 1057.25, 175, two, II, 12, 1, 224, 21, 260, 14, 261, 262.27, 230, 5, 1, 2, One, two, 113, 3, 331, 4, 214, 99, 1, 3, 3, 15, 14, 253, 14, 15, 73(1, 309, two, 408, 1900, 811, 1960]3SCR250, 1960]3SCR250, two, Three, 1, 2, 368, 3, 368, 2, half and half, two, two, 13, 1960.39, six, 13, 13, 13, 13, two, 1,253, 73, 14, 15, 7, one, two, two, two, 118, 17,249, a little over half a million, 2, 1, seven, 17,249, 8,788, 171, Over 350, about 3,500, about 350, only one, three, two, less than 25, 2, 867, 78, one, 1882.64, 9, two, two, 2, two, two, three, One, two, two, two, three, two, 7, a mosaic, two, 137, one, two, 3, two, two, 6, three, 1, Two, two, 152, 3, 40, 924, 274, 275, 4, 197, 1, 2, between two, 14

ORG: the High Courts of, C.A. No, the Gujarat High Court, The Gujarat High Court, Court, the Government of India, Parliament, Tharparkar, Tribunal, The Union of India, the British Parliament, the Tribunal, Proceedings, the Government of India, the Government of Pakistan, the Governments of India, THEREFORE, GMT, Governments, the Rann of Kutch, Kutch, Governments, Tribunal, Government, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Government, the United Nations, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Government of India, the Constitutional Court of Yugoslavia, the Government of Pakistan, the General Assembly of the United Nations, Tribunal, the United Nations, the Court of Appeal for Western Sweden, Counter-Memorials and, Verbatim Records, Tribunal, Map C. Maps, Tribunal, Tribunal, the North-Eastern Trijunction, The Government of Pakistan, Tribunal, the Sir Creek, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, State, Tribunal, the Tribunal on the basis of rules, the Government of India Act, Rann, Rann, Tribunal, Parliament, Tribunal, the Survey Maps, Tribunal, Tribunal, State, Rahim ki Bazar, Erskine's Survey, Tribunal, Kutch, The Kutch State, Custom, Rann, Point, Rann, Map C. Between Points 'L' and 'M', Points 'N', Map C, Point, Map C.At, Tribunal, the Government of India, Mixed Commissions, Commissions, the Sainte Croix Piver, the Alabama Arbitrations, Court, Diplomatic Notes, the Government of India the Award, State, Legislature, State, State, Senate, Nation, Foster v. Nielsen, the Constitutional Council, British Institutions, Blackstone, Nation, Crown, Crown, Parliament, Vattel Vol, Crown, State, Parliament, the House of Commons, Crown, Crown, Parliament, Banca, Parliament, Parliament, Parliament, Crown, A.C. 491, Parliament, Parliament, State, Municipal Laws, The Civil Court, Parliament, Crown, Parliament, Parliament, Crown, Parliament, Crown, Parliament, Houses, Parliament, Houses, Crown, Parliament, The Orange River Territory, Council, the Treaties of Stockholm, Guadelope, Parliament, Sambalpur, the Maharaja of Nagpur, Crown, Ponsonby, the High Court, the Imperial Parliament, the British Courts, the French Constitutions, Crown, Parliament, the French Constitutions, First Schedule, States;(b, Union, Parliament, State, State, State, Distribution of Legislative Powers, Parliament, Parliament, International, Parliament, Parliament, the Government of India, Parliament, State, the Legislature of the State, laws.34, Court, Indian Territory, Midnapore Zamindary Co. Ltd., State, The Federal Court, the supreme authority of every, State, The Federal Court, Globe Venture Syndicate Ltd., the Foreign Office, the High Court, Sovereign, Viscount Finlay, Duff Development Co., Kalintan Government, A.C. 797, Court and Government, Municipal Courts, The Berubari Union and Exchange of Enclaves, Court, the Berubari Union, Berubari Union, Tribunal, The Bagge Tribunal, Berubari Union, the Indo-Pakistan Agreement, the Government of India Act 1935, Order in Council, Extra-Provincial Jurisdiction Act, Court, Parliament, Parliament, Exchange of Enclaves, Court, Parliament, Parliament, Parliament, Parliament, Parliament, Union, the Indo-Pakis-tan Agreement, Berubari Union, Berubari Union, the Union Government the Indo-Pakistan Agreement, Reliance, the Executive Government, State, Court, the Indo-Pakistan Agreement, Court, Awards, Court, Countries, the Indo-Pakistan Agreement, Court, Court, v. Union of India, the Calcutta High Court, Court, Chilhati, Chilhati, the Indo-Pakistan Agreement, Chilhati, the High Court, Court, Debiganj Police Station, Chilhati, Court, Court, Court, the Dominion Government, State, State, State, State, Order.40, Court, the West Bengal Government, Nations, Court, The Union Government, Berubari Case.42, State, Court, Executive, Parliament, International Law, Nations, Executive, Nations, Constitutions, Chhadbet, the First Schedule, Kutch, C State, the Government of India Act, Kutch, Kutch, State, Central, State, State, State, State, State, Centrally, the Dominion Government, the States Merger, The State of Kutch, Kutchlgarh, Saurashtra, the Adhoi Mahal of Morvi, Kutch, Kutch, Kutch, Bombay State, Kutch, Kutch, the State of Gujarat State, Chhadbet, Ward, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, Chhadbet, Council, Kutch State, the Kutch-Sind, Kutch, Tribunal, Maps B32, Maps, Tribunal, hostilities;(b, Rann, Sind.53, Chhadbet, Tribunal, Tribunal, Chhadbet, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Watch, the two Dominions, the International Court of Justice, I. C.J. Reports, Tribunal, Parliament, Government, Tribunal, The Union of India, State, Kutch, Kutch, Rann, Rann, Rann, Kutch, the East India Company, the East India Company, Division of the Province of, Maharao, the Department of Survey of India, Kutch, the State of Kutch, Kutch State, Sind, The Government of India, the Government of the Province of, Division, Kutch State, the Foreign Department of the Government of India, the Government of India, the Kutch Durbar, the Government of Bombay, Political Department, Maharao, the Government of India (Constitution of Sind, the Division of Sind, Division, Sind, State, Order, the Onmaston Survey, Eastern, Dominions of India, the State of Kutch, the Dominion of India, the Dominion of India, State, the Government of India, the States Merger, the Government of India Act, Kutch, the State of Bombay, State, the Governments of India, the Government of India, the Government of Pakistan, GMT, the Rann of Kutch, Kutch, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Government, the United Nations, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, State, the United Nations Organization, the Government of the Union of India, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Government of India, the Sir Creek, Tribunal, Tribunal, State, States,'73, Rann, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Agents of India, the Representatives of the, Tribunal, the Tribunal on February 19, 1968, Tribunal, the Government of India, the Government of Pakistan, Maharao, Tribunal, Kutch, the State of Kutch, Tribunal, Rahim ki Bazar, the Kanjarkot Sector;(2, Rann, Map 'C', Rann, Kutch, Rahim ki Bazar, Kutch, Parliament, the Permanent Court of International Justice, Phillips, Parliament, the Admiralty Court, The Parlement Beige, the Court of Appellation, Post, Crown, the Parlement Beige, Crown, A.C. 491, Judicial Committee, the Supreme Court, State, the Captain of, The Judicial Committee, the Government of the day, Parliament, State, Parliament, State, Union, Parliament, State, State, State, Parliament, State, Bar, State, Distinction of Legislative Powers

GPE: Gujarat, Delhi, Pakistan, India, India, India, Pakistan, the States of Kutch, Santalpur, Tharad, Suigam, Jodhpur, India, Pakistan, Bombay, India, Gujarat, West Pakistan, Pakistan, Gujarat, Pakistan, Gujarat, West Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan, West Pakistan-, India, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, Iran, Pakistan, India, India, Pakistan, India, West Pakistan, Gujarat, India, Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan, Jodhpur, Jodhpur, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, the Province of Sind, the Indian States, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, the Indian States, Pakistan, the Province of Sind, India, Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan, Chhadbet, India, India, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, Chhadbet, Pakistan, Pakistan, India, India, Jodhpur, Khori Creek, Pakistan, Pakistan, Tenninu, India, India, India, Kanjarkot, Pakistan, India, India, Athens, Locarno, Great Britain, the United States of America, the Hague Convention of 1907, Lapradelle, Pakistan, Pakistan, India, India, India, Pakistan, India, the United States, France, the United Kingdom, India, the United States of America, the United States, the United States, France, England, France, Spain, Britain, Spain, Senegal, Minorce, Florida, the United Kingdom, Canada, India, India, India, the United Kingdom, Netherlands, Great Britain, Sumatra, Bencollen, Honduras, Netherlands, Spain, Nicaragua, Broach, Tanjore, Scindia, Jhansi, the United Kingdom, India, Bombay, India, India, the United States of America, England, the United Kingdom, India, Native States, Burma, Ceylong, the United States of America, India, India, India, States, India, Province, Bengal, mind.37, States, Oppenheim, Morocco, Morocco, Morocco, India, West Bengal, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, Berubari Union, Pakistan, Province, Province, Berubari Union, India, India, Pakistan, the Berubari Union, the Berubari Union, India, the District of Jalpaiguri, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, Chilhati, Jalpaiguri, Pakistan, Chilahati, Chilahati, Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan, India, Berubari, West Bengal, West Bengal, Chilahati, Pakistan, West Bengal, Province, Province, States, States, States, States, West Bengal, West Bengal, Chilahati, West Bengal, West Bengal, West Bengal, Pakistan, West Bengal, Pakistan, States, Chilahati, West Bengal, Chilahati, Pakistan, West Bengal, Pakistan, West Bengal, West Bengal, Pakistan, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, Australia, Britain, India, India, Chilahati, the United States of America, India, Kanjarkot, Berubari, Berubari, Kutch.44, States, the United State, Adhoi, Gamdan, Lakhpat, boundaries.46, Chhadbet, India, India, India, India, Pakistan, India, Berubari, India, claims,(d, India, India, India, Chhadbet, India, Chhadbet, Pakistan, Pakistan, India, India, administration.56, Palmas, India, Gujarat, India, West Pakistan, Pakistan, the State of Gujarat, Bombay, the Province of Sind, Bombay, India, Council, the Tharparkar District, the States of Western India, the State of Gujarat).69, Pakistan, Pakistan, the Province of Sind, Pakistan, Gujarat, India, Pakistan, Gujarat, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, States, India, Pakistan, Jodhpur, Jodhpur, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, the Province of Sind, India, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, Pakistan, Delhi, Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan, India, Pakistan, States, Oppenheim, States, States, the United Kingdom, Newfoundland, the Republic of France, Newfoundland, Canada, A.C., the British Empire, States, the British Empire

DATE: 109/68, 14 May, 1968, 18 March, 1968, 19 February, 1968, My 18, 1947, August 15, 1947 two, the year, July 1948, April 1965, June 30, 1965, 30 June, 1965, 1 January, 1965, 1 July, 31 December 1964;(iv, 1 January 1965, 1 January 1965, the monsoon period, 1964;(v, January 1960;(vi, January 1960, later than one month, two months, 24 October, 1959, four months, three months, September 15, 1966, July 14, 1967, June 30, 1965, today, 1947, 1855, November 19, 1794, 1776, 1871, between 1794 and 1938, 1967, some ten years ago, October, 1958, 1863, the end of wars.28, 4P.D. 129, 1892, 1937, August 5, 1924, 1925, 21 days, 1924, 1824, 1859-60, 1867, 1697, 1813, 1872, 1872, 1803, 1806, 1871, 1876, '32, 1956, today, 14, 1949, 1924, August 12, 1947, 26 January, 1950, 1952, September 10, 1958, 1947, 1955, December 28, 1935, the year, May, 1948, 1st June, May 4, 1948, June 1, 1949, July 29, 1949, 1949, November 1, 1956, May 1, 1960, 1957, 1961, March 3, 1956, May 11, 1965, 1935, 1914, 34, 35, 36, 37, the year, the year, April 4, 1928 :, 1953, February 19, 1968 of, about four months in the year, the year, years, Between 1816 and 1819, 1819, 1843, 1855, 1870, 1876, 1879, 1886, 1904-05, About the year 1907-08, February 24, 1914, 1924, 1935, 1936, '67, 1938-39, 1947, May 4, 1948, June 1, 1949, 1949, 1935, 1956, 1960, July 1948, April 1965, June 30, 1965, 1 July, two months, 24 October 1959, four months, three months, '72, today, the northern half, later than two weeks, 76, 1879, 1880, 1876, 1892, 1937

LOC: Western Bombay, North, West, South, Khori, the Khori Creek, the South East, North West, Kanjarkot, the South East, South, West, East, South, Executive, the Channel Islands, East Florida, the Bay Islands, British India Section, the District of Kullanelly, East, Indian States, the Island of, Executive, the Arabian Sea, the Khori Creek, the Indian States, Ch

NORP: British, British, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Pakistani, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, British, French, English, British, British, Ionian, British, British, Indian, British, British, Tanganiyika, Belgian, British, French, British, British, British, British, British, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Saurashtra, Indian, Watch, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Minquiers, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, British, British, Indian, Gujarat, Indian, Indian, Indian, British, Indian, English, Belgian, British, British, Indian

PRODUCT: Crown, Agreement, B-37, B-19, B-20, Award, B-37, B-20, Map B-44, Map B-44, Award, P.D. 197, Crown, matter.33, Mukherjee, 1 S.C.R. 225, Award, Geo, B-37, B-19, B-79, Map B-44, Map B-44, Award, F, Crown

FAC: the Great Rann, Chhad Bet, the Gujarat-West ', the Radcliffe Award, the Debiganj Thana, the Radcliffe Award, The Great Rann, the Macdonald Survey, the Macdonald Survey, the Badin-Jati-Rann, the Macdonald Survey, the Great Rann, the Great Rann, the Great Rann;(b, the Great Rann, the Great Rann, International Law, Constitutional

TIME: 0030 hours, minutes, 0030 hours

ORDINAL: 24th, third, 24th, first, 24th, fourth, fifth, 4th, first, second, first, First, first, first, first, second, first, first, second, first, second, second, 4th, first, fourth, 2nd, 24th, third, first, first, first

QUANTITY: some 3,500 square miles, a mosaic, 825.8 metres below pillar, about 512 acres, about 512 acres, 8,461 miles, some 3,500 square miles, 825.8 metres below pillar, approximately 3,500 square miles, as to 350 square mile-., more than 325 square miles

WORK_OF_ART: Verrawah, Moore, La Fontaine, the Municipal Law, Mosquito Shore, Berubari Case, the Award of the Tribunal, The Ministerial Conference

EVENT: the Jay Treaty, the French Constitution, the Seventh Amendment, the Bombay Reorganisation Act

MONEY: about ninety per cent