Dongfang Electric Corporation Vs. Reliance Energy Limited and ors.

Decided On : Jan-27-2006

Court : Punjab and Haryana

LAW: Section 1 of the Bid Document, Constitution, Article 19 of the Constitution, Article 14 of the Constitute, Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 14, Article 19 of the Constitution, Article 14, Article 19 of the Constitution and State of Jammu, Article 226 of the Constitution, Article 226, the Companies Act

ORG: D.K. Jain, DEC, Corporation, the Haryana Power Generation Corporation Limited, Reliance Energy Limited, Government of Haryana, MW, Engineering Procurement and Construction, EPC, EPC, MW, Steam Generator and Steam Turbine Generator, MW, SG, STG, SG, STG, EPC, Steam Generator, SG, Steam Turbine Generator, STG, SG, STG, SG, STG, SG, STG, DEC, SG, STG, DEC, DEC, Boiler, Turbine and Generator, BTG).6, DEC, DEC, DEC, BTG, JDU, DEC, DEC, DEC, China Chamber of Commerce for Import & Export of Machinery & Electronics Products, DEC, DEC, the Government of India, BTG, DEC, DEC, State, DEC, DEC, Court, another Chinese Company, Shanghai Electric (Group) Corporation, Class Power Plant Equipment Manufacturing Company, DEC, DEC, Shanghai Electric (Group) Corporation, DEC, DEC, DEC, Counsel, Reliance, Poddar Steel Corporation, Learned Counsel, DEC, Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd., Learned Counsel, DEC, JDU, Learned Counsel, State, the Supreme Court, ABL International Limited v. Export Credit Corporation of India Ltd., Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi, Ors, U.P., The International Airport Authority of India, Tata Cellular v. Union of India, DEC, JDU, the Supreme Court, Indo-China Steam Navigation Co. Ltd., Union of India, Advocate General, DEC, DEC, JDU, Advocate General, Counsel, DEC, State, the Apex Court, Asia Foundation, Construction Ltd., Trafalgar House Construction, the High Courts, Sterling Computers Ltd., M & N Publications Ltd., Union of India, Dinesh Engineering Corporation, the Apex Court, Air India, Cochin International Airport Ltd., Tata Cellular's, Lordships of the Supreme Court, State, Court, Court, Court, Court, Master Marine Services, Metcalfe and Hodgknison, DEC, Owner, Emphasis, DEC, DEC, DEC, DEC, DEC, inter alia, DEC, DEC, DEC, DEC, DEC, BTG, DEC, DEC, the Advocate General, the State Government, DEC, DEC, Shanghai Electric (Group) Corporation, Committee, Shanghai Electric (Group) Corporation, Committee, conditions:-(i, DEC, State, HPGC, CEA.(v, AG& SP, HPGC, DEC, HPGCL, HPGCL, Council of Civil Service Union, the Civil Service, DEC, JDU, DEC, Bar Council of India, AIR2004SC2227, Union of India, Board of Mining Examination, the Supreme Court, DEC, the Apex Court, NIB, DEC

PERSON: Counsel, Articles 226/227, REL, Bid, REL, REL, JDU, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, Articles 226/227, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, A.K. Chopra, REL, REL, REL, REL, Ramana Dayaram Shetty, Rajiv Atma Ram, REL, Yusuf Abdul Aziz v. State, Ghulam Mohd, Anr, H.S. Hooda, Haryana, Joint Undertaking, REL, REL, REL, Ramana Dayaram Shetty's, Counsel, Bidder, REL, Counsel, REL, Haryana, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, REL, Haryana, REL, REL, REL, Unit-1, Unit-2, REL, REL, Lol, E.R. 935, REL, REL, Tulsiram Patel

GPE: India, People's Republic of China, China, Yamunanagar, China, India, China, Counsel, Bombay, Counsel, Kerala, Ramjee, judgment.27

DATE: 18.9.2005, 14.8.2004, 19.8.2004, 28.8.2004.8, 30.8.2004, 13.6.2005, quashed.10, 14.8.2004 and 19.8.2004, permitted.11, 1994, 2004)12SCC327, 27 and 30 months, 30 and 33 months, 3 months, about a year, the day, 1956, 13.6.2005, 25.6.2005, 14.4.2005, 27 months, 30 months, seven days, 1985

CARDINAL: 2, 1, zero, 20.8.2005, 20.5.2004, 3, 2x300, few hundred, more than one, 2, 210, 2, 250, at least two, 15.12.2004, 15.6.2005, 11.8.2005, zero, zero, 209, 150, 1.22.0, 1991]2SCR696, 18.8.2005, 2, 2004)3SCC553, 1979)IILLJ217SC, 6, 651.13, 3, 1964CriLJ234, 1954]1SCR930, 2097/-, one, zero, 2000]1SCR505, 1.22.2, 1.22.6, 1.23.1, 1.24.0, 1.20.8, 18.8.2005, 15.12.2004, 15.6.2005, 11.8.2005, 15.12.2004, 20.8.2005, Zero, 20.00, 2, two, 11.8.2005, 3, 298, 1977]2SCR904

WORK_OF_ART: 'Deed of Joint Undertaking of Consortium Members', 'Constitution of the Bidder', GoH, Wednesbury

LOC: bid.7, mala fides.23

PERCENT: 15%, 10%, 15%, 5%

NORP: Chinese, Chinese

ORDINAL: second, second

FAC: International Competitive Bidding

PRODUCT: Bidder, Bidder

TIME: the minutes, the minutes