Indian Telecom Service Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Decided On : Oct-31-2005

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Delhi

LAW: Constitution, Rule 37-A of the CCS (Pension) Rules, P-5, Rule 37, Constitution, Article 309 of the Constitution, Constitution, Section 21, Central Act or Regulation, Constitution, Constitution, Article 311 of the Constitution, Constitution, Article 311(1, Constitution, Article, Article 311(1, Article 310, Article 311 of the Constitution, Article 31 of the Constitution, Article 15, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Constitution, P-5, Constitution, Constitution, the Companies Act, Section 4, the Indian Telegraph Act, Rule 10, the Constitutional Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Article 311(2, Constitution, Article 14 of the Constitution

CARDINAL: 1, 24.3.2005, 1963/2005.3, 24.3.2005, 16, 24.3.2005, 30.9.2000, 7, 9, 1, 5, 10000, 6, 1, 10000, 2500, 9, 24.03.2005, 01.10.2000, 20, 01.10.2000, 30.08.2005).6, 30.9.2000, 1.10.2000, more than half, 1, 30.9.2000, 4.10.2005, 4.10.2005, 30.9.2000, 2, four, 22400-24500)(indicated, 30.9.2000, only one, 3, 2,750, 4, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 1.10.2000, two, 25650-30200, 23750-600-28550, four, 10, 18500-450-23900, 17500-400-22300, 6, 30.9.2000, 1.10.2000, 1, nine, 6.8.2002, 298/2002, 2, 24.3.2005, 18.10.2005, 3, 3, 204, 10 and 11, 1998(2, 563, 4, 1, 18, 30.9.2000, 30.9.2000, 14.10.2005, 8), 14.10.2005, 5.7.1989, 14.10.2005, 2, 3, 7, MTNL.10, 16, 1, 30.9.2000, 2, 198O(3, 418, 3, 30.9.2000, 30.9.2000, 30.9.2000, 4, 30.9.2000, 5, 30.9.2000, 333, 6, 840, 30.9.2000, nine, thirty-seven, 13, 311, 309, 1973(2, 650, 12, 2, 13, 31(1, 2, 2, 31(1, 14, 36, 39, 19(1)(f, 41, three, 2003(2, 632, 10, 10, 408, 18, 627, 1999(1, 368, 7544/2001, 8.5.2000, 12.10.2001, 8.5.2000, 8.5.2000, three, three, 20, 22, 8.5.2000, MTNL.21, 56, 17, 1.10.2000, 1998(3)SLJ155(SC),/Cy4/?v.5a//iA'M, 16, 1.10.2000, 17.6.2004, 1.10.2000, 11.9, 8), 30.9.2000, 1, 1, 4, 8), 30.9.2000, 1, 2003(2, 721, 2003(1, 21, four, 1.10.2000, 1.10.2000, 5.7.1989, 3, 3, 24.3.2005, 1.10.2000, 1.10.2000, about four, about 3.97, 8), 30.9.2000, 1.10.2000, 61, more than one, 841, two, two, 1.10.2000, two, 1, 2, 3, 30.9.2000, 4, 5, 1

ORG: TFS, Group, Indian Telecom Service, ITS)/Telegraph Traffic Service, TTS)/Telecom Factory Service, TFS, Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited, MTNL, O.M., MTNL, Clauses 1 to 7, the Department of Telecommunications, DOT, BSNL, O.M., MTNL, Group, TFS, MTNL, DOT, DOT, DTO, DOT, MTNL, MTNL, DOT, DOT, MTNL, DOT, Group, MTNL, Group, MTNL, MTNL, DOT, MTNL, DOT, MTNL, CDA, CDA, MTNL, Advisor, DPE, Group, MTNL, MTNL, IDA, General Terms, Government, Ministry of Personnel, Pension, BSNL/MTNL, CDA, BSNL/MTNL, Group, Presidential Order, O.M., DOT, DOT, Department, Group, MTNL, Telecom Commission, BSNL/MTNL, Learned Senior Counsel, DOT, Higher Administrative Grade, the Higher Administrative Grade, DOT, MTNL, O.M., DOT, MTNL/BSNL/Government, PSU, DOT, MTNL, MTNL, O.M., JAG, Schedule-C, JAG, MTNL, BSNL, BSNL, Counsel, O.M., DOT, BSNL, DOT, UPSC, Government, Engineering Services, the Union Public Service Commission, Building Works Services, Category-Ill Electrical Engineering Group ', Electrical Engineering Group ', Tribunal, Bhattacharjee v. Union of India and Ors, Court, Group, Building Works) Group ', Government, Counsel, DOT, Ministry/Department, Tamtl Nadu and Ors, Orissa State Electrical Engineers Association, Ministries/Departments, the Government of India, continuing.(SC, Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd., Delhi Transport Corporation, DTC, Mazdoor Congress and Ors, MTNL, O.M., Group, CDA, the Central Government, the Central Government, Counsel, Central Public Sector Undertakings/Central Autonomous Bodies, Provident Fund, Government, the Public Sector Undertaking, Counsel, O.M., Government, O.M., Government, O.M., Counsel, Learned Counsel, Clauses 1 to 7, DOT, DOT, MTNL, Group, Ministries/Departments, MTNL, MTNL, UPSC, Counsel, Government, PSU, Government, Counsel, SC, Allahabad University and Ors, DOT, O.M., the Allocation of Business Rules, Government, MTNL, DOT, Bench, O.M., BSNL/MTNL, Counsel, O.M., Counsel, O.M., DOT, Government, DOT, Counsel, BSNL, the Hon'ble supreme Court, Union of India and Ors, SC, Public Service Commission, Counsel, O.M., DOT, MTNL Executives Welfare Association, Additional Solicitor General, Tribunal, the High Courts, Bench, Government, Government, Government, Government, State, Government, Government, The High Court, State, SC, State, State, State, State, State, Government, State, Reliance, SC, Government, Government, Court, Government, Hughes, Health and Social Security, AC 776, Government, w.e.f.1.11.1978, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Food Corporation of India and Ors, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court, Indian Telecom Service Association v. Union of India, MTNL, Tribunal, the Hon'ble High Court, Government, Tribunal, Group A, Tribunal, MTNL, Tribunal, MTNL, the Pension Rules of MTNL, Tribunal, Tribunal, clari fication/instructions, Tribunal, Tribunal, Court, Reliance, Delhi Development Authority, DRJ, a Miscellaneous Application, the Union of India, Bench, the ITS Association, Tribunal, Tribunal, High Courts, Tribunal, Tribunal, Group B, Government, Group, MTNL, Association, MTNL, Government, Reliance, Harcfe/lHr., Committees, the Ministry of Finance, UGC, IDA, the Central Government, Group, Group, Group, Group, Group, Group, O.M., DOT, MTNL, MTNL, Clauses, Clauses, the Department of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare, the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances, Pension, the Department of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare, the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances, Clauses, O., BSNL/MTNL, the ITS Association, SC, Bank of India and, Ors, Counsel, the State Bank of India, Banks/State Bank of India, Brojo Nath Ganguly, Learned Counsel, Government, BSNL, State, State, Government, the Central Government, non-Government, AIR 1970, Hindustan Steel Limited, Hindustan Steel Limited, State, Government, Group C, DOT, MTNL, Department of Pension and Pensioners' Welfare O.M., Central Government Department, a Government Department, Ministry/Department, the Office/Department/Ministry, the Central Administrative Tribunal, O.M., ITS Association (C.W. No, MTNL, Groups, the Central Government, Group A, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Group, UPSC, Groups B, MTNL, Group A or, Reserve Bank of India, K.K. Dutta v. Union of India, Reserve Bank of India, O.M., Government, Government, Government, BSNL/MTNL, Government, CDA, BSNL, MTNL, MTNL, O.M., MTNL, CDA, Rule 37A CCS, SNL, Group, the ITS Association, High Courts, Association, O.M., Group, DOT, BSNL/MTNL, O.M., Department of Telecommunication

GPE: O.A., O.A., O.A., Articles 311, BSNL, Govt, O.M., BSNL, O.A., O.A., Orissa, O.A., Articles 311, O.A., India, O.A. No.1963/2003.12, Kerala, Governmental, Kerala, Rajasthan, O.A., O.A., BSNL, BSNL, O.A., O.As, BSNL, BSNL, O.A., O.A., O.A., BSNL, Delhi, BSNL, M. Ramcmatha Pillai, BSNL, O.As, O.As, O.As.and, O.As, New Delhi

DATE: 1963/2005, 1958/2005, 1972, 14, 4. 12000-375-16500, monthly, Rule 37A, 1972, 1972, 30th Sept. 2000, 1972, 17.6.2004, the year, four weeks', 1994, long years, 1972, less than 10 years', five years', 5.7.1989, the year 2000, 1958/2005, 1972, 14, Rule 37A, 1972, 1980, 1992, 1999, 2002(2, 1999, 1897, 1992, December 20, 1968, 16, 1980(3, 1980, 18, 1985, 1999, 22.3.2002, 21, 1999, 2000, 90, 12.8.2005, 1.1.1986, 2750 per month, 21.5.2004, 21.5.2004, 17.6.2004, 1972, 2004, Rule 37A, 1885, 1150, 1.11.1998, years, 1987, 1958/2005, the year 2000, 1996, ten years', 2750 per month, 21.5.2004, 1972, one month, November 30,2005, three months

PERSON: Deemed, DoT, IDA, Corresponding IDA, Corresponding IDA, IDA, IDA, G.D. Gupta, Gupta, Annexure R-13, Vide O.M., A.K. Panda, Supp, V.S. Balakrishnan, Anr, Brojo Nath, DOP&T O.M., K.C. Mittal, Mittal, BSNL, J.P. Kulshrestha, J&K v. Sudarshan Jamwal, Anr, D.S. Chaudhary, P.P.Malhotra, Benches, Benches, Articles 19, Anr, Articles of, Ramanatha Pillai, Articles, Articles 311(2, Articles 14, Articles, P.U. Joshi, Accountant General, N.C. Singhal v. Union, M. Ramanatha Pillai v. State, J.P. Bansal v. State, Anr, Medokerhe Terhuja, Delhi Law Times, Kanchan Kapoor, Benches of this Tribunal, Benches, Benches, Benches, Benches, Articles 14, view.25, G.P. Singh, A.K. Panda, O.P. Swamakar, Articles 14, K.C. Mittal, P.U. Joshi, S.C. Aggarwal, G.D.Gupta, Surplus Staff, C.N. Sahasranaman, necessari ly, IDA, IDA, Benches

WORK_OF_ART: A" Officers in, Bench, Ahmedabad and Ors

ORDINAL: first, First, Second, Third, Fourth, Fifth, first, 9th

TIME: 2750 pm, 3000 pm, 2750 p.m.

PRODUCT: P-10, Constitutional Bench, merits.40

PERCENT: 6%

EVENT: the Constitution of India