N.R. Yadav Vs. Union of India (Uoi) and ors.

Decided On : Jun-03-2002

Court : Central Administrative Tribunal CAT Jaipur

LAW: Section 19, Regulation 3, Regulation 3 of the Promotion Regulalions, the Promotion Regulations, Rule 9, Regulation 5, Rule 8, Regulation 10, Regulation 3, Regulation 5, Regulations 5, Regulation 5, the Regulations 5, SLJ 86, the Promotion Regulations, the Promotion Regulations, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 7, the Promotion Regulations, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, the Promotion Regulations, the Promotion Regulations, the Promotion Regulations, Regulation 5, the Promotion Regulations

CARDINAL: 1, 23.01.95, 14015/54/95, 2, 23.01.95, 23.01.95, 7(2, 19, 6, 1 to 16, 23.01.95, 304, 17, 38, 23.01.95, 1, 12.01.96, 16, 19, 1, 1, only 16, 23.01.95, 22.01.96, 17, 19, 9(1, 6, 12, 31.01.96, 2, one, 23.01.95.6, 23.01.95, 16, three, 17, 23.01.95 to 22.01.96, 17 and, 18, 03.12.99, 22.01.96, 1, 2, 3.9, 23.01.95, 23.01.95, 22.01.96, 1, two, 2, three, 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 1, 2, 3, 4, 4, 1, 2, 1, 1, 2, 9, 1, 3, 5, 3, one, 2, 1, 23.01.95, 19, nineteen, sixteen, three, three, 19, 2, 3, two, 3, 5(3, 1, 31.12.97, 5(1, 31.12.97, 31.12.97, 5(1, 23.1.95, 5(1, 7, 84, 28.07.93).The, 5(1, 8, 2545/96, one, 23.01.95, one, 23.01.95, 23.01.95, 16.03.95, 12.01.96, 12.01.96, 1, 36, 12.01.96, 7, 38, 271, 1999(3, 5(1, 2001(2, three, 12.01.96, 5(1, 12.01.96, 1, 4, 4, 1, 2, 4, 5(6, 20.03.92, 31.03.1992, 13.9.1996, 3, four, four, 1, 1, 304, 12.01.96, 23.01.95, 16.3.95, 17 and 18, 16, 1995(4, 543=1996(1, 34, 587, 5, 1, one, two, 1, 103=1997(1, 22.01.1996, 2, 2, 1, 2

ORG: Rajasthan Administrative Service, RAS, Indian Administrative Service, IAS, the Selection Committee, Tribunal, the Department of Personnel, Training, Government of India, the State Civil Service, IAS, the Indian Administrative Service (Appointment by Promotion) Regulation, Committee, the Selection Committee, the Union Public Service Commission, Promotion Regulation, The Government of India, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of Personnel, Annexurc, RAS, IAS, IAS, S/Shri Ramesh Kumar Jain, S.S. Rajvi, Shri Naranga Ram Yadav, SC, the Selection Committee, Bench, Shri R.K. Jain, Tribunal, IAS, IAS, DOP&T, Government of India, IAS, the Selection Committee, IAS, Union of India, Union of India, AIS, IAS, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, State, State, the State Government, IAS, UPSC, the State Government, State, S/Shri G.L. Verma, IAS, the Selection Committee, RAS, the Review Selection Committee for Rajaslhan, Hon'ble Supreme Court, IAS, The State of Rajasthan, the Union of India, the High Court, S.B. Civil Writ Petition No, Shri D.K. Vijay, RAS, the Selection Committee, the Union of India, the State Government, the Selection Committee, IAS, S/Shri R.K, Jain, S.S. Rajvi, IAS, S/Shri R.K. Jain, S.S. Rajvi, IAS, S/Shri R.K. Jain, the Union of India, Union Public Service Commission, RAS, RAS, RAS, the Selection Committee, RAS, SC, the Selection Committee, RAS, the State Government, RAS, Commission, RAS, the Selection Committee, IAS, RAS, Tribunal, RAS, Tribunal, RAS, the State Civil Service, IAS, the State Civil Service, Committee, the State Civil Service, the State Civil Service, Committee, the State Civil Services, Committee, the State Civil Service, Selection Committee, the State Civil Service, the State Government, the State Government, the Selection Committee, UPSC, the State Civil Services, the State Civil Services, the State Government, the Selection Committee (Regulation, Commission, the Central Government, the State Government, the Central Government, the Committee to the Commission, Commission, Committee, the State Government under Regulation 6, the Central Government, Commission, the State Government, Commission, the State Government, the State Government, Commission, the State Civil Service, Committee, State Civil Service, the Central Government, the State Civil Service, Regulation 2, State Civil Service, the State Civil Service, the State Government, Commission, the State Civil Service, the State Civil Service, the Central Government, the State Government, the State Civil Service, the State Civil Service, the State Civil Service, Commission, the State Government, the State Government, Central Government, Commission, the State Civil Service, the State Civil Service, the State Government, the Central Government, the State Government under Regulation, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the State Civil Service, a State Civil Service, the Selection Committee, IAS, Selection Committee, the State Civil Service, the Selection Committee, the State Civil Service.12, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, T.N. Administrative Service Organisation v. Union of India and Ors, AIR 2000 SC 1898, the State Civil Service, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Apex Court, the State Governments, IAS, the Apex Court, a State Civil Service, the Apex Court, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, State, the Selection Committee, IAS, Committee, Committee, the State Civil Service, Committee, the State Civil Service, IAS, The Apex Court, Khalid Rizvi v.Union of India, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Kasturi Rangan v. Union of India, the State Government, the Selection Committee, the State Government, the Apex Court, the State Government, the State Government, the Selection Committee, the High Court, S.B. Civil Writ Petition No, Shri D.K. Vijay, RAS, the State Government, Selection Committee, Committee, Selection, the Selection Committee, Commission, the Union of India, the Government of India, the Union of India, the Government of India, Chandigarh Tribunal, M.S. Rao v.Union of India, ATC, CAT, Union of India and Ors, ATC, CAT, Tribunal, Division Bench, Union of India, the Apex Court, Nepal Singh Tanwar, the Government of India, the Union of India, the Government of India, the Selection Committee, the Central Government, Commission, the State Civil Service, IAS, Committee, the Selection Committee, Commission, IAS under Regulation, Committee, Commission, the next Selection Committee, the Apex Court, Nepal Singh Tanwar v.Union of India, 09.12.96, Nepal Singh Tanwar, Nepal Singh Tanwar, the Selection Committee, IAS, the Tribunal on the ground, Tribunal, the Apex Court, the State Government, Shri Nepal Singh Tanwar, the Apex Court, the next Selection Committee, Supp, Court, H.R. Kasturirangan v. Union of India, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, Court, the Selection Committee, the next Selection Committee, Department, Department, Apex Court, Nepal Singh Tanwar, S. A Engineer v. Union of India and Ors, the Selection Committee, UPSC, the next Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Government of India, Union of India, the next Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, IAS, the last Selection Committee, Commission, the Selection Committee, Commission, S/Shri Ramesh, Commission, S/Shri Ramesh, S.S. Rajvi, the State Government, Union Public Service Commission, CAT, the Principal Bench, the State Government, Commission, the State Government, the State Government, Commission, the State Government or, Central Government, IAS, the Central Government, UPSC, IAS, the State Government/Central Government, IAS, ATC, CAT, the Central Government, IPS, the State Government, State, the Central Government, IAS, IAS, Commission, the State Government, the State Government, Commission, the State Government, IAS, the State Government, the Apex Court, Union of India, SC, the State Civil Service, the Union Government, the State Government, the Central Government, IAS, the Apex Court, S.R. Engineer v.Union of India and Ors, the State Government, Union of India and Union Public Service Commission, IAS, the Selection Committee, the State Government, Commission, IAS, the State Government/Central Government, the Promotion Regulation.22, the State Government, IAS, the State Government, State

GPE: Jaipur, O.A., Rajasthan, Jaipur, Rajaslhan, Sl, O.A., O.A., New Delhi, O.A., IAS, S.S., the State of Rajasthan, RAS, O.A., RAS, O.A., Regulation, India, Rajasthan, Hyderabad C. A.T., V.R.K., Regulation, M.S. Rao, R/4, O.A., Rajasthan

DATE: 1985, 12thJanuary, 1996, 1995, 1955, 1994-95, 16th March, 1995, 22.03.1995, twelve months, 1996, the period of, 12 months, 23.01.95 and 1995, 1995, twelve months, 18, 1995, twelve months of the date, 1993, twelve months, 1995, the period of, 12 months, 12 months, 1996, 18, the period of 12 months, twelve months, 22.01.96.7, the year 1999, twelve months, 20 years, 1995, one year, the period of 12 months, the age of 54 years, the first day of April of the year, twelve months, 1 st day of April of the year, the 1st day of April, less than eight years, eight years, 1st day of April of the year, the age of 54 years, the 1st day of January of the year, the first day of January of the year, twelve months, the 1st day of January of the year, six months, the 1 st day of January of the year, one year, the next year, 1 st January of the year, 1994-95, 19(16+3, the 19th, twelve months, twelve months, 1995, one year, 1994, the existing year, a particular year, 3891 of 1991, every year, the year 1995, twelve months, twelve months, twelve months, 1997, 1998, twelve months, 12.01.96.15, twelve months, every year, 1996, the year 1991-92, 1992-93, 1993-94, 12.08.92, every year, the year 1992-93, the subsequent years, the year 1991-92, year, 1993, every year, 3891-94 of 1994, the subsequent years, 26.03.1992, 12.08.1992, 12 months, 12 months, 1999, twelve months, twelve months, twelve months, twelve months of the date, the year 1999, 1995, twelve months of the date, 1996, 1995, 1995, 1995, 1997, 1995, 22nd January, 1996, twelve months, 1995, a period of, three months

LOC: IAS

WORK_OF_ART: Promotion Regulations, "Very Good, 'The Union Public Service Commission

PERSON: Rajasthan Cadre, DOP&T, Shri G.L. Verma, Shri G.L. Verma, Shri G.L.Verma, S.S. Rajvi, Nos, K.P. Singal, Shri Keshri Singh, P.P. Mathur, R.L. Agarwal, BhanwarBagri, Articles Hand, Khalid Rizvi's, Mohan Rao v., Jaipur Bench, Motilal Gupta v., Anr, Mohan Rao, Motilal Gupta, Nepal Singh Tanwar, Nepal Singh, Nos, Mohan Singh Rathore, M.S. Rao, Mohan Rao, Motilal Gupta, Kumar Jain, Articles 14, Kehar Singh v., V.K. Lambodaran Nair v. Union, R/5, R/6, Mohan Singh Rathore, Anr

EVENT: Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5(2, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 5, Regulation 7, Regulation 7(3, Regulation 5, Regulation 7(4, Regulation 7(4, Regulation 5, Regulation 5 of the Regulations, Regulation 5, Regulation 10

PERCENT: 20%, 20%, 20%, twenty percent, 20%

ORDINAL: second, third, first, third, third, third, first, firstly, first, secondly, thirdly, second, second, first

PRODUCT: Regulation 5, Regulation 9, 22.01.96, Regulation 9, Regulation 5, Regulation 9, Regulation 9, Regulation 9

FAC: H.R. Kasturi Rangan's