Videsh Sanchar Nigam Limited Vs. Telecom Regulatory Authority of

Decided On : Nov-28-2005

Court : SEBI Securities and Exchange Board of India or Securities Appellate Tribunal SAT

LAW: Section 11(2, Section 11(4, the TRAI Act, Tariff Order, Chapter 11, section 12, the TRAI Act

CARDINAL: 1, half, 4, half, 11-3-2005, 5, 28-4-2005, 3362, 200, 2MBPS, 45, 155, 21, 63, one, half, three, 2, 45, 155, Half, 13, 105, 299, 16-9, half, three, 8.56, 13.09, 13.09, 13.09, 5, 25, 677, only 56, 6, 375, 181, 66, 126, 3.10.2005, 4.10.2005, 24.10.2005, 11.11.2005.On, one, one, one, four, five, only three, only two, 5, 2005.In, 5, 6., 1, 8, 13, 14, 15, 16, half, two half, half, half, 17, nearly two to three, 8-10, 2, 45, 155, 2, 45, 155, about 17, 53, only about 7, 18, 12, half, three to four, 18, one, 19, 20, 21, 28, 22, 24, 6.7.2005, 12.3, 1, 2., 2005.12.5, 12.6, more than 1, one, 8.56, 13.09, 13.09, 11.84, 18.16, 7.4, 9.0, 28, 10-6-2005, two, 7, 625, 3-3-2005, 16, two, 40 to 42, 11-3-2005, 40, 41, 1, 42, two, 7, 7, 64, 19, two, 15, 51, 13, 8, 2times, 52, 63, one, 27, three, 1:21:63, three, 1, less than 3, 22, only four to eight, about 76, only three to 15, 8, 15, 55, 1 2, 0.2, 33, 41, 1:17:44, half, 56, 57, 15.2, 54, 10-6, 27-6-05, 14-6, 10-7-05, 15-7-05, 20-6, 27-6-05, 1, 27-6, 29-6, 27-6-05, 5, 18, 8, 19, 25, 21, 4-8-05, 22, 25, 22, 8, 3-8, 4, 11-8, 16-8, 25-8, 26-8, 30-8, 1-9-05, 1, 7, 7, 8, 17.1, two, 1951, two, two, two

ORG: Videsh Sanchar Nigam Limited, VSNL, the Tariff Order of Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, Cable, International Private Leased Circuit, IPLC, International Long Distance Voice Telephony, Information Technology, Business Process Outsourcing, BPO, Information Technology Enabled Services, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, IPLC, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, VSNL, Tribunal, TDSAT, TDSAT, E1, DS-3, VSNL, Tribunal, VSNL, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Hon'ble Court, the Hon'ble Court, Hon'ble Court, Appeal, Tribunal, Tribunal, M/s Ernst &, VSNL, TTO, LAN, MBPS, MBPS, DS-3, E-1, E-1, The IPLC Circuit, the Supreme Court, Tribunal, Cellular Operators, Ors, v. Union of India and Ors, the Apex Court, Tribunal, Tribunal, IPLC, VSNL, VSNL, the Books of Accounts, VSNL, E-1, Telecommunication Tariff Order, E-1, DS-3, E-1, DS-3, VSNL, VSNL, Central Government, Public Sector Company, VSNL, Appellant, Tribunal, E-1, E-1, E-1, Tribunal, Tribunal, E-1, E-1, this Tribunal of, M/s Ernst &, Appellant, Tribunal, E-1, Ernst &, International, Appellant, M/s Ernst &, M/s Ernst &, Ernst &, VSNL, India-USA, Japan-USA, the Pacific Route, Pacific Route, IPLC, E-1, DS-3, VSNL, Open House Discussions, VSNL, NASSCOM, National Association of Software, Service Providers Association of India, Business Process, the Tariff Regulation, ILD, Videsh Sanchar Nigam Ltd., VSNL, Cochin and Chennai, Bharti Infotel, Reliance Infocomm, Bharti Infotel, Chennai, Reliance Infocomm, VSNL, Non-Facility, VSNL, International, Business Processing Operations, Gartner, Inc 2004, Gartner, ISP, TDSAT, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, International, the International Long Distance, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Independent Reports Classify Indian Market for IPLC, VSNL, Gartner, Gartner Report, Gartner, Inc 2004, VSNL, Comparison of Markets, VSNL, E-1, VSNL, VSNL, PRIMETRICA, INC, VSNL, NASSCOM, NASSCOM, MB, MB, MB, E-1, E-1, DS-3, STM-1, SLA, NASSCOM, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Boston Consulting Group, Ernst &, TDSAT, BCG, Ernst &, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Primetrica Inc., International Bandwidth Report, the Business Process Outsourcing Industry, VSNL, VSNL, TIC, FALCON, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, a Historical Basis, VSNL, India-USA, Japan-USA, the India -USA Atlantic, the Learned Senior Counsel, the India - USA, VSNL, VSNL, International, Bandwidth, PRIMETRICA, PRIMETRICA, Compounded Annual Growth Rate, DS-3, E1, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Internet Service Providers, ISP Service, BPO, IT Enabled Services, NASSCOM, ISPAI, IPLC Service, VSNL, IPLC Services, IPLC, TTO, IPLC, Tribunal, E-1, Appellant, Tribunal, E-1, E-1, E-1, E-1, E-1, M/s Boston Consulting Group, E-1, the Tariff Order of, VSNL &amp, Tribunal, this Tribunal of, Tribunal, E-1, Tribunal, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Auditor, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Auditor, VSNL, VSNL, the Inspection Team, Tribunal, VSNL, VSNL, TTSL, VSNL, the Forward Looking Cost Approach, VSNL, the Inspection Team of TRAI, VSNL, Consultation Paper, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, WDV, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Inspection of Books of Accounts, VSNL, Tariff Order, TTO, E-1, VSNL, Capacity Utilisation of the Tariff Order, VSNL, CAPEX, VSNL, E-1, DS-3, Capital, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, E-1, VSNL, CWIP, Federal Communications Commission of USA, FCC, Total Element Long Run Incremental Cost, Total Service Long Term Incremental Cost, LRAIC, the Least Cost Technologies, Historical Cost, ILDOs, M/s Reliance and M/s Bharti, Tate Indicom, TDSAT, TDSAT, the Accounting Separation Guidelines, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Tribunal, VSNL, VSNL, E-1, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, the Cost Record Rules, VSNL, IPLC, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, TTSL, VSNL, TTO, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, E-1, DS-3, the Explanatory Memorandum, VSNL, E-1, E-1, DS-3, STM-1, VSNL, E-1, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, E-1s, E-1, NLD, BSO/UAS Licensee, E-1, VSNL, VSNL, DS-3, DS-3, E-1, E-1, DS-3, DS-3, E-1, E-1, DS-3, E-1, E-1, PriMetrica Inc., International Bandwidth Report, E-1, DS-3, E1, E1, E-1, DS-3, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, TDSAT, E-1, E-1, ERNST &amp, VSNL, India-USA, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, E-1, VSNL, DS-3, VSNL, VSNL, E-1s, VSNL, VSNL, DS-3, E-1, DS-3, E-1, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, E-1, VSNL, VSNL, Tribunal, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, ITU, Gartner on International, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, the Books of Accounts, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, the Books of Accounts, VSNL, Authority, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, TTO, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, TTO, the Bombay High Court, Gordhandas Bhanji, TTO, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, the "Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Access to Information Regulation, this Tribunal of the, Authority, the Bombay High Court, the Respondent Authority, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Bombay High Court, AIR, the Bombay High Court, the Supreme Court, Court, The Respondent Authority, Authority, Authority, Tribunal, Authority, the Respondent Authority, Authority, Tribunal, the Respondent Authority, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Internet Service Providers Association of India (ISPAI, ISPAI, MA 227

DATE: 8th September 2005, 2005, 1997, January 2004, 8th September 2005, 14-9-2005, 16-9-2005, one week's, another five days, 30-4-2004, July 2004, 13th May 2005, summer, 22nd July 2005, 28th April 2005, 10th June 2005, March 2005, the far end half, March 2005, about two years ago, 2002, 11th March 2005, March 2005, 28th April 2005, the last five months, 28th April 2005, September 2005, 8th September 2005, 2005, 28th April 2005, 4 year, 2000, 26.10.2005, September 2005, April 2004, 2002, 2004, 2000, 2002, 2002, The year 2002, 2000, 2004, 2004, the Farther-end, 2005, 2005, 2004, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2005, 2005, 2005, 6 to 12 months, more than five years, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2003, 2002, 2003, the previous year, 2003, 2005, the year 2004, the period 2002 to 2005, June, 2005, 2001 to 2002, September 2005, 11th March 2005, 11 March 2005, 11 March 2005, 28th April 2005, the last five months, 28th April 2005, September 2005, 8th September 2005, 7-9-2005, 1-7-2005, 8-7-2005, about three months, Annual, more than 18 months, April 2004, between 10 and 25 years, 10th October 2003, March, July, 2004, the period April to July 2004, 2003-2004, July 2004, end-March 2004, July 2004, March 2004, September 2004, September, 2004, July 2004, July 2004, 2003-04, 2004, 2005-2006, more than 18 months, March 2004, 1996, 8th September 2005, 2005-06, almost a year ago, March 2005, 3319, March 2004, recent years, 2004, 1:8:15., 23 0.10, 23 0.10, June 2005, 58, 7-9-2005, Ten days, November 2002, 2004, 2003-04, 7-9-2005, 8-9-2005, just one day, 8-9-2005, 3 of 2005, 2005

TIME: Thirty Ninth Amendment, 8-9-2005.6, 8-9-05.11, the minutes, the minutes

NORP: IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, Indian, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, Lakhs, IPLC, IPLC, Indian, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, Indian, Indian, Indian, IPLC, IPLC, Indian, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, Indian, IPLC, IPLC, Indian, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, Asian, IPLC, Indian, Bandwidth, Bandwidth, IPLC, Indian, IPLC, South Asian, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, Median, IPLC, Indian, Indian, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, Inspection, Inspection, IPLC, IPLC, European, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, E-1s, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, IPLC, Indian, Bandwidth, IPLC, IPLC

GPE: Broadband, India, India, Delhi, India, India, India, Broadband, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, South Korea-USA, Hong Kong - USA, India, Broadband, India, India, Mumbai, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, Hong Kong, Singapore, Japan, Taiwan, South Korea, Indonesia, India, Malaysia, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, India, Hong Kong, Singapore, Japan, Taiwan, South Korea, Indonesia, India, Malaysia, California, India, Mumbai, US, India, US, Singapore, China, India, Philippines, Japan, China, US, Hong Kong-, US, Singapore, India, India, Singapore, India, India, India, India, India, Thailand, Malaysia, Philippines, Indonesia, Vietnam, UAE, Saudi Arabia, New Zealand, Egypt, South Africa, India, US, India, India, India, South Korea-USA, Hong Kong - USA, Singapore, India, Singapore, Hong Kong, China, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, India, India, India, India, USA, India, India, USA, India, Vol, GDR, Delhi, India, India, 1:4:8South Korea, Singapore, India, Telecommunication, Mumbai, Mohd

PERSON: Tariff Order, Malhotra, Bangalore, Parks, Rs, Rs, Order, Young, Young, VSNL, VSNL, Young, Primetrica, 45.9 Gbps, VSNL, Shri Kapur, Appellant, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Network, VSNL, VSNL, Resale, STM-16, VSNL, VSNL, VSNL, Mohinder Singh Gill, Mohinder Singh Gill's, Oomer v. S.M. Noorudin, Sayed Yakoob, Sector

LOC: Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, the Appellant on, Europe, Respondent, Europe, Asia, Asia-Pacific, Middle East, Asia-Pacific, Europe, Asia, trans-Atlantic, South, South East, East Asia, Atlantic, Pacific, Pacific, STM-1, Trans-Atlantic, Trans-Pacific region, the Europe-Asia region, Asia, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, STM-1, Respondent, STM-1, Atlantic, STM-1, Atlantic, Respondent, Respondent

PRODUCT: Appellant, Respondent, Tariff Order, Respondent, Appellant, Respondent, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Respondent, Memorandum, STM-1, Shri C.S Vaidyanathan, STM-1, STM-1, Appellant, Appellant, Respondent, Appellant, Respondent, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, E1, STM-1, STM-1, Bandwidth, STM-1, STM-1, E1, STM-1, STM-1, STM-1, Respondent, Respondent, M.A. 227 of 2005

PERCENT: 29%, 64 %, 59 %, 88%, 4 to 20%, 200-300%, 70%, 65%, 26%, 25%, 56%, 40%, approximately 42%, 50-60%, about 12.5%, 12.5%, 15.7%, 40%, 40-45 %, 33%, 23.66%, less than 60%, more than 96%, 30%, only 70%, the remaining 30%, at least 70%, about 60%, 70%, 50%

ORDINAL: 11th, 7th, 7th, first

FAC: the India-USA, the Appellant on, the Impugned Order

QUANTITY: 8-9-05, 12.8 Gbps, 16-2-2005, 8-9-2005.This

WORK_OF_ART: The Explanatory Memorandum, The Explanatory Memorandum, the Top Down Fully Allocated Cost Method, No Evidence of Consortium Imposed Constraint

MONEY: 45 MB/155, $ 500 million, US$'000 US$Million US$ Million

EVENT: Bombay 156