The State of Jharkhand Through the Secretary Water Resources Department Vs. Ms Cwe Soma Consortium Through Its Authorized Signatory P Subba Roa and Ors

Decided On : Mar-13-2015

Court : Jharkhand

LAW: Article 14, Page 54 to 69

CARDINAL: 1, 309, 2, 034, 20.01.2015, 13, 24.07.2014, 28.02.2014, more than 250, 10, Three, 3, two, 06.06.2014, one, two, 4, only one, 4.2, 4.17, three, more than 250, 26.03.2014, only three, two, two, 4.5(A)(a, 4.5(A)(c, 6, 06.06.2014, 06.06.2014, one, 28.02.2014, two, 8, 31.03.2015, as many as five, only one, 21, 183, 4.17, 9, more than one, 10, three, three, two, 4.17, two, 10, 1, 4.5A(a, 4.5A(c, two, 4.18, 10, 11, 1.50, two, only three, SOMA.27, 12, three, 4.A(c, 28, three, two, 4.17, 4.18, 4.18, one, 4.17, three, 15, 1, 16, 1 SCC492, 10, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 1, 2, 3, 4, two, 17, 36, 06.06.2014, 17.07.2014, one, one, 19, two, 80‟s, two, 4.17, 20

DATE: 2014, East Singhbhum.4, 2014, 2 many years, 24th of March,, 2014, 2014, Para 29, the year 1981, 17.07.2014, a span of four months, 2013-14, the year 2014, 1978, 4.5(A)(a, the last five years, annual, two years, annual, two years, as estimated quantity/ years, 14 33, 1995, 1999, transaction.10, February, 18 2014, August, 2014, year 1981, 1981, February, 2014, July, 2014, 7th of August, 2014, about 8 months, February, 2014, 31st of March,, 2015, 2014, one month, 35 years, 1981, the 13 day of March, 2015

ORG: The State of Jharkhand, Water Resources Department, Government of Jharkhand, P.O. & P.S. Doranda, P.O. & P.S.-Safdarganj, P.O. & P.S. Doranda, Water Resources Department, Government of Jharkhand, Water Resources Department, Government of Jharkhand, P.O. & P.S. Doranda, The Executive Engineer, Kharkai Dam Division, JUSTICE, SINGH, Additional Advocate General, Kumar Sundaram & Chanchal Jail, Respondents, M/s. CWE-SOMA Consortium of Hyderabad, Letters Patent Appeal, Dam, Water Resource Department, Government of Jharkhand, Executive Engineer, Civil, Mechanical, Electrical, SMP, Standard Bidding Documents, SOMA, NIT, SBD, NIT, SBD, M/s SOMA, M/s IL & FS Engineering and Construction Company Limited, M/s, Navyuga Engineering Co., Hyderabad, the Departmental Tender Committee, Tender Committee, Central Vigilance Commission, the Writ Court, the Superintending Engineer, SOMA, the Writ Court, the Tender Committee, CVC, Clause 4.2, CVC, SOMA, CVC, CVC, SOMA, CVC, State, NIT, SBD, SBD, Learned Writ Court, CVC, SOMA, NIT, Writ Court, the Tender Committee, SOMA, Letters Patent Appeal, Additional Advocate General, State, Additional Advocate General, SBD, Cabinet, SBD, Learned State, SBD, SBD, SOMA, the Tender Committee, Clause 4.18(d, CVC, Learned State, Learned State, the Departmental Tender Committee, Writ Court, State, Departmental Tender Committee, CVC, Learned State, the State Government, Learned State, the State Exchequer, Learned State, SOMA, SOMA, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Senior Counsel, Central Government, Accelerated Irrigation Benefits Programme, State, the State of Jharkhand, Learned Counsel, Court, CVC, SOMA, CVC, CVC, Learned Senior Counsel, State, the Writ Court, Learned Senior Counsel, Learned Senior Counsel, State, SOMA, Clause 4.17, CVC, Clause 4.17, SOMA, NIT, NIT, SBD, SBD, Clause 4.5, RCC, PSC, Turn-key &, Court, State, SOMA, Court, SBD, SOMA, Clause 4.17, CVC, CVC, LTE, OTE, Single Tender Enquiry, LTE, OTE, CVC, CFA, CFA, CVC, SOMA, CVC, CVC, Court, Government, Supreme Court, Court, State, Supreme Court, New Horizons Ltd. v., Union of India, Lordships, NIT, State, Raunzq International Ltd., V. I.V.R. Construction Ltd., State, State, State, State, M/s IL & FS Engineering, Construction Company Limited, M/s, Navyuga Engineering Co. Limited, the Tender Committee, SBD, NIT, State, Tender Committee, IFB SBD45A(b, Hindustan Constructions Company, SOMA, the Central Government, the Central Government, the State of Jharkhand, SOMA, Departmental Tender Committee, the Departmental Tender Committee, SOMA, CVC, Tender Committee, Letters Patent Appeal, Tender Committee, SOMA, Ranchi Dated, A.F.R

PERSON: Nepal House, Appellant Versus 1. M/s, P.Subba Rao, Venkateshwarlu, Safdarjung Enclave, Nepal House, Icha Galudih, Adityapur, Nepal House, District Ranchi.5, Icha Chaliama, Adityapur, VIRENDER SINGH, Ajit Kumar, Rajesh Kumar, G.P.-V, Ajit Kumar Sinha, Mukesh Kr, Virender Singh, W.P.(C, Kharkai Dam, W.P.(C, Kharkai Dam Circle, Icha, Chaliama, Ajit Kumar, Rajesh Kumar, Kumar Sundaram, Chanchal Jain, Ajit Kumar Sinha, Mukesh, Vivek Kumar, Ajit Kumar, Icha Galudih, Adityapur, Jamshedpur, Sinha, Ajit Kumar, Kharkai Dam, Icha, Mohinder Singh Gill, Apendix, cum, Kharkai Dam, Ajit Kumar, W.P.(C, Virender Singh, Kumar Singh

GPE: Doranda, District Ranchi, Banjara Hills, Doranda, Distt, Doranda, Distt, East Singhbhum, Jharkhand, SCADA, J.C., A.A.G., tenderer.12, India, Single, Appendix, Para-9, Kharhkai, Kharkai

LOC: Single, Single Judge.16, Single Judge, Single Judge, Single, Single

ORDINAL: second, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, second, second, first

PRODUCT: Clause 4.2, Single

NORP: SOMA, Appendix, Rules

WORK_OF_ART: 4.5(A, 4.17 There, Wednesbury, Wednesbury Principles of, Para (ii, Similar Qualifying Criteria

PERCENT: 50%, 50%, 50%

TIME: minutes