Engineering Projects (India) Ltd., New Delhi Vs. K.P.R. Reddy

Decided On : Feb-19-1999

Court : Andhra Pradesh

LAW: Section 20, the Arbitration Act, Section 17, Section 30, the Indian Arbitration Act, Section 30, Section 30, Section 70, the Indian Contract Act, Section 20, the Arbitration Act, Section 30, Section 30 - Proceedings under Section 30, Section 30.'39, Section 30.'40, Section 34, Section 34, Section 41 and Section 3 of Arbitration Act, the Interest Act, the Interest Act, the Interest Act

PERSON: Hanumanthappa, M/ s. Engineering Projects, Sri, Contractor, Contractor, Contractor, Contractor, dated30, Contractor, Shri Madhusudhana Rau, Madhusudhana Rao, Asthana, Contractor, Shri Jagbali Sharma, Sri Jagbir Singh, Contractor, OP No.306/92.9, Award, Dhirendranath Sen, Jagcmnath Ashok Kumar, Unique Erectors, V.P. Jolly, Sri, V.R. Reddy, Counsel, Sri V.R. Reddy, No.5.3, V.R, Reddy, Addendum, Indian Rupees, Forasol, Frank, Foraxol, Frank, Frank, Award, Award, Sri D.V. Subba Rao, Award, Award, Sri Subbarao, Sri Subba Rao, Award, Addendum, Sri Subba Rao, Claim Nos.3, Sri Subba Rao, Sri Subba Rao, =, Subba Rao, Forasol, Sri Subba Rao, Nehru, Claim Nos.3, Contractor, E.l(MW/3, EI(W/1, EI(SW/3, EI(SW/7, Claim Nos.2.6, Claim No.14, Award, Counter-Claim, Counter-Claim No.5, Counter-Claim, Counter-Claim, Counter-Claim No.14, Counter-Claim, Counter-Claim Nos.16, Award, Award, Forasol, G.C. Roy, Thawardas, Jena, Jugal Kishore, Vijayendra, G.C. Roy, B.N. Agarwala, Bench, B.N. Aganvala, G. C. Roy, Counsel, Award, Award, Award, Order, Award, Order

CARDINAL: 1, two, 26, two, 26, one, 5-3-1980, two, 20-8-1981, 31-5-1984, 5, 5-3-1980, 14, 5-3-1980, 5-3-1980, 17, 5, 20-8-1981, 30-5-1984, 20-8-1981, 31-3-1984, 31-3-1986, 11-8-1987, three, 5, 20, 3, 11-8-1987, one, 26, 4-3-1990, 11-10-1991, 1293/91, 11-8-1987, 22, 2.1extra, 2.2variation, 2.4temporarybills, 13,837,151 2.5extraitems, 2.6variation, 13,260.339 2.8extra, 35,779.566 2.10othercontract, 3, 8,08,764.790 4, 6, 1986ID 4.493.136 10, 11, 12, 61.07, 9,40,000.00 19, 13-8-1988, 21, 1.Performance, 2.Performance, 3.Performance, 10.30, 4.Mobilisation, Rs.6, 23, 5, two, adhoc, 8, 10, 11, 17, 500, 18.Recoverv, 6, 2, 4., 5., 6, 7, 4,86,887.732, 3.377778, 1-8-1986, 1-8-1986, 1, 30-6-1986, 3, 13, 92, 1-8-1986, 1964]3SCR410, one, 1988]1SCR180, 1988]3SCR426, one, 890, 1989]1SCR318, two, one, 1994)6SCC485, 1991]2SCR924, three, two, one, 3.377778, Rs.24.26, one, 3.377778, No.3, 13, 5.11, 6, 31, 91,000, 13, 2, 31, No.2, 3.377778, 20-8-1981, 19-8-1992, three, 5-3-1980, 20, 31, No.2, 3, 13, 31, 5.4, three, two, two, two, 7,53,014.856, 20-8-1981, 20-8-1981, one, two, 31, 982, 17-11-1987, 15-3-1989, 5.2.3, 5.2.4, No.2, 164, 13, 13, 13, 266, one, 5-3-1980, one, 20-8-1981, one, 28.57, one, 31, one, one, one, 13-8-1988, 1, 1, One, 1984]1SCR526, 1, 17, 24, 17-4-1986, 30, 29, No.3, No.3, 13, 3, 13, No.3, 4,43,000, No.3, 1, 30-6-1986, 60,000, 126%.27, No.2, 208.380, 5, 16,533.390, 1143.430, 2.3, 2.4, 2.5, 5, only ID 1809.447, 239.000, 2.7, 4 to 10, 11, 12, 25, 19, No.4, No.2, 3, No.4, 10, 11, 2, 13, 15, 18, 1,57,374.000Claim, No.3, 4,86,887.732, one, 1, 185, 1999)1SCC63, two, one, three, 3, 13, two, 1955]2SCR48, 1988]1SCR253, 2, 1, three, 1997]1SCR704

ORG: the Principal Subordinate, OP Nos.306/92, No.662/96, OP No.306/92, Engineering Projects, Stale, Buildings, Ministry of Housing of the Republic of Iraq, M/s. K.P.R., Aravind, ACCPL, ACCPL, KPRR Contractor, ACCPL, EPIL, the Contractor the Company, Company, Company, Bank Guarantees, Bank Guarantees, EPI, the Court of Principal Subordinate, Court, Court, Court, the Principal Subordinate, Court, Court, Court, Arbitrator, High Court, A.P., CRP No, Court, Lawyer, contractsID, Company, Iran Government, Company, Company, City Hospital, KPRR, Issues:1, the Arbitrator the Contractor, Court, Court, the Reserve Bank of India, the Court of Visakhapalnam, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, the Supreme Court, Court, Kerala Slate Electricity Board, the Supreme Court, Hindustan Tea Company v., Sashikant & Co., the Supreme Court, Delhi Municipal Corporation, Court, the Supreme Court, Indian Oil Corporation, Indian Carbon Limited, Court, the Supreme Court, K.V. Subba Rao v. Government of AndhraPradesh, AIR 1988, SC, Court, the Supreme Court, Gujurat Water Supply & Sewerage Board, P) Ltd., the Supreme Court, Court, the Supreme Court, State, Rajasthan v. Puri Constructions, Court, Company, the Supreme Court, Associated Engineering Co v. Government of A.P., the Supreme Court, State, Chahal Engineering & Company, Fertilizer Corporation of, Court, the Supreme Court, Chahal Engineering Co., Irrigation Department, the Supreme Court, High Courts, Court, Court, Court, Company, the Iraq Company, The Lower Court, Courtgranting, Company, Court, grounds.17, Court, Court, Indian Rupees, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, U.S. Dollars, Court, Mudmat, Item EI, Item CC/MW1, CC, Company, Contract, Court, Company, Court, Court, U.S. Dollar, Indian Rupees, Contract, Indian Rupees, Rupees, U.S. Dollars, Indian Rupees, U.S. Dollars, Indian Rupees, Court, ONGC, Counsel, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, Counsel, Company, Court, Company, the Delhi High Court, the Supreme Court, the Delhi High Court, the Supreme Court, Delhi Development Authority, AIR 1980 Delhi, Paul Singh & Bros., State of, Indian Rupees, Company, Company, RW2, U.S. Dollars, Court, Company, the Indian Rupees, U.S. Dollars, Bank, Indian Rupees, Indian Rupees, Court, the Supreme Court, Oil and Natural Gas Commission, Renusagar Power Co. Ltd., General Electric Company, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, the Court, Register, Company, Company, Company, Iraq Government, Company, Chartered Accountant Report, ID 6,13,309, Company, Iraq Government, Iraq Government, Company, Company, Court, Court, Company, ID 1123.720.30, E.l(MW/4, RCC, ID 90.353, ID 35,131.440, ID 29,540.00, Company, CC(MW/13, RCC, CC(MW/20, Arbitrator, ID207.090, EI(SW/4, Arbitrator, Arbitrator, El (MOD)/1, ID 704.479, Issue No.5, Bank Guarantee, No.23, rejected.34, the Counter-Claim No.7, Arbitrator, Nos.3& 13, Company, Arbitrator, Court, the Supreme Court, Stale, U.P., Lordships, Arbitrator, the Supreme Court, Chahal Engineering & Construction Co., v. Irrigation Department, Court, Court, Arbitrator, ECCL, the High Court, Company, Iraq Government, the Supreme Court, Renusagar Power Co. Ltd., CPC, the Supreme Court, Irrigation Department, the Supreme Court, CPC, Court, Indian Courts, Court, The Supreme Court, Court, the Supreme Court, State, Hindustan Construction Co. Ltd, State of J & K, A.P., Court, Court, Court, State, U.P., Chandra, the Supreme Court, Court, State, Court, Irrigation Department, Government of Orissa, Durga Ram Prasad v. Government of A.P., Court, payment.51, Court, Court, Court

GPE: Visakhapatnam, New Delhi, Visakhapatnam, Visakhapatnam, Iraq, Iran, Iraq, Iran, Visakhapatnam, p.a., Iraq, K.P.R.R., K.P.R.R., Chellappan, Kerala, Iran, Iraq, I.D., U.S., I.D., I.D., U.S., Iraq, Iraq, US, India, Counsel, AIR, Delhi, Haricharan, Singh v. Union of India, Counsel, Gujarat, U.S., U.S., U.S., US, US, Iraq, Iran, Iraq, Iran, India, p.a., p.a., Issue, US, US, US, p.a., p.a., Chandra, Delhi, Iraq, Iran, p.a., p.a., AIR1993SC864, Orissa, P.L., Orissa, p.a.

DATE: 291/92, 24 months, ten months, 14-5-1981, 14-5-1981, 1980, January, February 1981, June 1981, upto31-12-1984, August 1982, 1986, four weeks, 1,95,147.548 2, January 1986 to June 1986ID 54,256.065 5, January 86 to June 1986ID, January 86 to June 86ID, January 86 to June 86ID, January, 86to June, January, 81 to June, January, 86 to June 1986ID, July 86, Jan. 1986, 6,04,586.78 13, Sep. 82, Nov. 87, 6,13,309.839 14, the Hon'bleArbitrator 15, 16, 17, 22, 78,890.280 6, 8,807.000 9, 57.000.000 12, 8,299.00 13, 1,84,701.055 15, 58,718.302 16, 21-10-1992, 16,44,598-00, the day, fourteen thousand five hundred and twenty seven, 291/92, 98,000-00, 1940, 1990]2SCR638, 1992, 1992, 45, annual, the year 1987, 1st, August 1986, the month, the period between August, 1982, August, 1986, August, 1982, August, 1982, 1982, 13-8-1988, 24-4-1986, the past three months, 8-5-1986, six months, the 13th, the year 1982-83, 250,000/-, the year 1980-81, July, 1986, 18, 3,10,000.000 36, 8,448.658 37, 1940 - Section 30, the years, '45, 1996, 1978, '48, 1978, 1978, '49

WORK_OF_ART: the Award of the Arbitrator as 'Rule of the Court, the Principal Subordinate, the Award of the Arbitrator.3, Subordinate, the Award of the Arbitrator, the Award of the Arbitrator, the Award of the Arbitrator

LOC: Proprietary, Arbilrator

ORDINAL: first, first, second, third, first, first, first, second, second, 2nd, 2nd, second, third, second, third, second, second, first, 11th, third, second, third, third, first, third, third, third, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, first, second, third, first, first, first, second, second, first, second, first, 15th, first, second, second, first, first

NORP: Rs.93, Indian, Gujarat, Supplemental, Item, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, French, French, French, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, Iraqi, Indian, Iraqi, Indian, Arbitrator.33, Iraqi, Punjab, English

PRODUCT: 768.175 9, USS 11,55,954,10 3, USS 29,537.71 4, E1, MW)/2, ID 271.014, ID 837.748, Rs.25

PERCENT: 18.5%, 44,236.133 5.Amount, 14%, fourteen percent, 18%, Eighteen percent, 14%, 126%, 126%, 126%, 14%, 18%, 24.79%, 30.32%, 7.02%, only 15.62%, 30%, 70%, 14%, 18%, 126%, less than 75%, 126%, 126%, 126%, less than 75%, 126%, 14%, 18%, 14%, 14%, 18%, 18%, 18%, 15%

QUANTITY: four crorcs sixty one, 6-2-1986, 8 mm, 40 mm

FAC: Santa Sila Devi

EVENT: U.S. Dollars'', the Iraq Dinars, U.S. Dollars, the War Claim of ID 1,95,147.548

MONEY: 3.377778, 3.377778 U.S. Dollars, 3.377778, 3.208889 U.S. Dollars, 3.377778 U.S. Dollars, 3.377778 U.S. Dollars, 1 US $, 3.377778, 3.377778, 28537.71, 16,44,598.00applying, 3.377778

TIME: the minutes, minutes, 9-12-1985, 30-9-1981