Bombay Environmental Action Group and anr. Vs. State of Maharashtra and ors.

Decided On : Oct-12-2001

Court : Mumbai

LAW: Section 150(1)(e, Section 37, Rule 3 of Collector's Rules, Rule 16, the Main Bungalows, Rule 36, Bungalows, Section 37, Section 336, Section 37, Section 31, Section 31, Section 31(1, the M.R.T.P. Act, Section 154, Section 157-A of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, Section 157-A(1-A, Rule 3, Section 45, the Lease Deed, Plot 19, the M.R.T.P. Act, Rule 32, Rule 32, Rule 13, Rule 32, Rule 36, Rule 36, the M.R.T.P. Act, Rule 4, Rule 9, Rule 11, Section 37, Section 37, Section 336, Section 336, Section 37, Section 31, Section 22A(f, Rule 36, Rule 32, Rule 36, Rule 36

PERSON: S. Radhakrishnan, Rules';(b, Appendix 'S', Petitioners, Appendix 'S', Neem, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Karl Khandalawala's, Appendix 'S', Appendix, Appendix 'S', Appendix, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Pantbalkundri, Exhibit, Petitioners, Rule N. 2.2, Pantbalkundri, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Karl Khandalawala, Sawant, Sawant, Petitioners, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Order, Collector, Karl Khandalawala's, Sawant, Sawant, Meherbai Karl's, Desai, Appendix 'S', Karl Khandalwala's, Desai, it.22, Rule, Anturkar, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Karl Khandalwala's, Appendix 'S', Anturkar, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Rule N. 2.2, Gazette, Appendix 'S', Rule N. 2.2, Anturkar, Pantbalkundri, Appendix, Anturkar, Gazette, Appendix 'S', Rule N. 2.2, Anturkar, Vijay Ramchandra Karulkar, Pantbalkundri, Anturkar, Appendix 'S', Anturkar, Anturkar, Appendix, Appendix, Anturkar, Appendix, Appendix, Appendix 'S', Main Bungalow, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', P.M.C., Appendix 'S', Tulzapurkar, Appendix 'S', Tulzapurkar, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix M-2.2.1, Appendix 'S', Petitioners, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Rutty Wadia, C.K. Mehta, Appendix 'S', Mezzanine Floor, S.B. Tamaskar, Petitioners, Petitioners 2, Petitioners 2, Nos, Plot Nos, Appendix, Appendix 'S' of Development Control, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix, Appendix, Appendix 'S', Appendix, Appendix 'S', Pantbalkundri, Appendix 'S', Pantbalkundri, Exhibit, Rule N. 2.2, Appendix 'S', Exhibit, Rule N. 2.2, Pantbalkundri, Appendix 'S', Karl Khandalawala's, Sawant, Sawant, force.69, Karl Khandalawala's, Desai, Karl Khandalawala's, Act.72, Appendix 'S', Karl Khandalawala's, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Anr, Bench Judgment, Nivara Hakk Suraksha Samiti v. State of, Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'S', Appendix 'M', Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Seervai, Sohan Lal Sachdev, Stroud, Seervai, Seervai, Seervai, Radhey Shyam Sahu, Mahapalika, Mahapalika, Mahapalika, Mahapalika, Seervai, Mezzanine Floor, Mehta, Mezzanine Floor, Mezzanine Floor, Nos, Petitioner Nos, Nos

NORP: J.1, Rules, Petitioners, Hon'ble, Rules, Rules, Rules, Hon'ble, Plot, contra, Punjab, Rules, Hon'ble, Hon'ble, Hon'ble, Plot, Hon'ble

DATE: 2000, 19, 27, 35, 62, 92, 93, the year 1920, Paras 5, 18.9.1986, 18.3.1987, 23.1.1987, the year 1921, the year 1921, 1879, 15th February, 1950, 5.2.1987.7, 1976, 1988, quarter, 1921, 1987, the year 1921, this area.17, February 1950, 15th February, 1950, 1982, 1879, 1966, 1879, 1966, 5.1.1987, Rule 32, 8, 9, 10, 11, 1966, 1966, 1950, 1966, 29th January, 1987, 23.1.1987, 23.1.1987, 1966, 1966, 2139, 14th May, 1998, 2089, 1203, 1985, 1986, 35, 9, 62, February 1997, 13th August, 1997, three years, 1998, a period one year, 7th October, 2000, 25th August, 2000, 1976, 11.1.2000.50, the year 1994, 50 years old, 2000, 8, 1966, 35, 17th August, 1999, 14, 15th October, 2157 of 1991, 1203, 1985, 9, 26.8.1997, 1992, 88, 4, 57, one year, 1203, 1985, one year, 26th June, 1998, 31st July, 1990, 20th September, 1988, 21st August, 1990, 23rd January, 1991, 5710, 1991, 57,, 88, 50-51, 4, 22, 12, 1203, 1985, 57,, 88, 50-51, 4, 22, 5710, 1991, 1344, 1992, 1966, August, 2000, 5th January, 1987, 18th September, 1986, 21st September, 1987, 2000, 18th March, 1987, August, 2000, 5.1.1987.68, 1966, 1966, 15th February, 1950, 1982, 1879, 1879, 1966, 1879, 1966, 1, 33, the year 1987, 1966, 1994, 1991, October, 1996, October, 1996, October, 1996, October, 1996, 5.6.1997, 33, 1951, years, 2000, October, 1996, 2000, 2000, 2000, 2000, a period of, three months, today, 2000, 8, staff-quarters, 1991, 2157 of 1991, 1203, 1985, 1991, the year 2000, 8, 2000, 5710, 1991

ORG: Bombay Environmental Action Group, Respondents 1 to 3, Pune, Petitioners, Petitioners, the 'Building Rules', the Collector of Pune, the Development Control Rules of Development Plan Pune (Revised, the Collector of Pune, the State of Bombay, Lease, Collector's Rules, Citrea, Gulmohar, Pune, Respondents, the Development Control Rules, Petitioners, Development Control Rules, Petitioners, State Government, Petitioners, the State Government, B.E.A.G., the State Government, the Collector's Rules, Petitioners, Town Planning, D.C. Rules, Petitioners, Development Control Rules, Counsel for the Petitioners, the Ministry of Environment, Petitioners, Petitioners, the Government of Maharashtra, the Collector's Rules, Petitioners, Development Plan, Development Control Rules.6, State, the 'Collector's Rules', the Bombay Land Revenue Code, the Pune Municipal Corporation, the Petitioners the Collector's Rules, the Development Control Rules, Petitioners, Court, The Competent Authority, Ors, L.J. 543, the Collector's Rules, the Collector's Rules and Building Rules, The Building Rules, Citrea, the Collector's Rules, F.S.I., F.S.I., Respondents, Respondents, Petitioners, F.A.R., Petitioners, Outhouses, the Main Bungalow, Petitioners, the Main Bungalow, Petitioners, Collector's Rules, Petitioners, Petitioners, N.O.C., Petitioners, N.O.C., Petitioners, Petitioners, Collector's Rules, Petitioners, Petitioners, the Pune Municipal Corporation, N.O.C., Petitioners, Collector's Rules, the Development Control Rules, Petitioners, Petitioners, the State Government, 5th February, Petitioners, the State Government, State, Petitioners, Exhibit 'A', Civil Application, Petitioners, the State Government, Petitioners, the Pune Building Regulations, the Collector's Rules, the Collector's Rules, Respondents, Pune Municipal Corporation, Court, Legislature, Court, the Collector's Rules and Building Rules, The Building Rules, Petitioners, Respondents, the Draft Development Rules, Respondents, Bombay Land Revenue Code, Petitioners, Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, Petitioners, State, Council, Petitioners, the Bombay Land Revenue Code, Koregaon Park.21, Petitioners, Development Control Rules, Respondents, Manek Davar, the Collector's Rules, Petitioners, Collector's Rules, D.C. Rules, Authority, the D.C. Rules, the D.C. Rules, Respondents 4, the Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Maharashtra Regional and, Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Court, the D.C. Rules, D.C. Rules, Second Proviso to Section 31(1, Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, Counsel for the Respondents, the State of Maharashtra under, Maharashtra Regional, Counsel for the Respondents, Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, the State Government, the State Government, Shri Pantbalkundri, the Municipal Commissioner, Pune, Town Planning, Pune, Development Control Rules, Counsel for the Respondents, Government, State Government, Development Plan, Town Planning, Pune, the Government of Maharashtra, Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, D.C. Rules, Maharashtra Regional and, the State Government, Government, Urban Development and Public Health Department, Development Control Rules, Petitioners, the Pune Municipal Corporation, N.O.C., the Pune Municipal, Petitioners, Units, the Main Bungalow, Petitioners, the Pune Municipal Corporation, Commencement Certificate, the Collector's Rules, Commencement Certificate, Petitioners, No Objection Certificate, Petitioners, Petitioners, the Pune Municipal Corporation, Petitioners, Appeal, the Pune Municipal Corporation, Petitioners, the Pune Municipal Corporation, N.O.C., Collector, N.O.C., N.O.C., Yeravada, Divisional, Divisional, the High Court, Pune Municipal Corporation, N.A., Divisional, Collector, Divisional, the Pune Municipal Corporation, N.O.C., Collector, N.O.C., Main Buildings, Building Bye-laws, Petitioners, Petitioners, Petitioners, N.O.C., N.O.C.34, Plot No, Petitioners, N.O.C., N.O.C., Pune Municipal Corporation, Pune Municipal Corporation, Petitioners, Petitioners, the Main Bungalow, Petitioners, Petitioners, Petitioners, the Pune Municipal Corporation, Main Bungalow, N.O.C., Plot No, Pune, Pune Municipal Corporation, the No Objection Certificate, the Collector of Pune, Pune Municipal Corporation, Petitioners, Petitioners, Pune Municipal Corporation, the Pune Municipal Corporation, Petitioners, Collector's Rules, Plot No, Petitioners, Petitioners, Pune Municipal Corporation, Petitioners, Respondents, N.O.C., Appeal, Counsel for Respondent No, Development Control Rule, The Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, the Development Control Regulations', The Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, Maharashtra Regional and, Development Control Regulations, the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, the Development Control Rules, Counsel for Respondent No, the Development Control Rules, Development Control Regulations, Rule 14.2 of Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Counsel for Respondent No, Counsel for Respondent No, Divisional, Collector, The Divisional Commissioner's, Petitioners, the Divisional Commissioner, the Divisional Commissioner, The Pune Municipal Corporation, Collector, Collector, the Town Planning, Counsel for Respondent No, Divisional, the Pune Municipal Corporation, N.O.C., Counsel for Respondent No, N.O.C., the Pune Municipal Corporation, N.O.C., Petitioners, Petitioners, Counsel for Respondent No, Plot No, the Collector's Rules, the Development Control Rules, the D.C. Rules, Counsel for Respondent No, Pune, Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation, Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation, Petitioners, Clubhouse, Respondents, Collector, Pune Municipal Corporation, Counsel for Respondent No, Blackhill Investments Private., Investments Pvt. Ltd., Greypoint Investments Ltd., the Deepak Fertilizers, Petrochemicals Ltd., Plot Nos, Development Control Rules, Plot No, Counsel for Respondent No, Plinth, The Municipal Corporation of Pune, Counsel for Respondent, the Commencement Certificate, Plot Nos, Petitioners, the Writ Petition, Respondents 1, the Development Control Rules, Petitioners, N.O.C., Respondents, Development Control Rules, Court, Respondents 13, Plot No, Counsel for Respondents, Town Planning, Pune, Court, Trust, Plot No, No Objection Certificate, Respondents, Plot, Plot No., the Commencement Certificate, No Objection Certificate, Petitioners, Plot No. 4, Petitioners, Petitioners, Respondents, N.O.C., Municipal Corporation of Pune, the Pune Civil Court, the Civil Court, the Pune Municipal Corporation, Petitioners, Plot Nos, Respondents, Petitioners, Commencement Certificates, Plot Nos, Plot No, Petitioners, Petitioners, Petitioners, the Collector's Rules, the Development Control Rules for Development Plan, the Judgment of this Court, Petitioners, Plot Nos, Respondents 1 to 6, Respondents, Petitioners, Respondents, Development Control Rules, Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act, Respondents, the Development Control Rules, Collector's Rules, Development Control Rules, Collector's Rules, the Development Control Rules, the Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Collector's Rules, the State Government, Bombay Environmental Action Group, the State Government, Collector's Rules, Development Control Rules, Exhibit 'A' to the Petitioners affidavit, Town Planning, Collector's Rules, the Development Control Rules;(iv, Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Respondents, the Development Control Rules, the Development Control Rules, Ministry of Environment, Petitioners, the Government of Maharashtra, the Central Government, Maharashtra Regional, Collector's Rules, the Development Control Rules, Counsel for the Respondents, Pune Municipal Corporation, the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, Counsel for the Petitioners, Respondents, the Division Bench, Court, the Pune Building Regulations, the Collector's Rules, the Collector's Rules, Counsel for the Pune Municipal Corporation, the Pune Municipal Corporation, the Division Bench, Legislature, Court, the Collector's Rules and Building Rules, The Building Rules, Collector's Rules, Development Control Rules, F.S.I. 1, Court, the Collector's Rules, Development Control Rules, the Collector's Rules, the Pune Municipal Corporation.71, the Bombay Land Revenue Act, Government, Bombay Land Revenue Act, the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, Code.(emphasis, the Collector's Rules, the Bombay Land Revenue Code, Court, Court, the Collector's Rules, Court, the Development Control Rules, Development Plan, F.S.I., F.S.I., F.S.I., the Maharashtra Regional Town Planning Act, Counsel for Petitioners, Court, Court, F.S.I., Nagrik Vikas Parishad, Collector's Rules, F.S.I., greenery, Court, the Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, Development Plan, Petitioners, Hotel, the Respondents Pune Municipal Corporation, Collector's Rules, Development Control Rules, Development Control Rules, the Development Control Rules, Respondents, the Development Control Rules, Appendix 'M', Counsel for the Respondents, Counsel for the Petitioners, Collector's Rules, Development Control Rules, Counsel for the Petitioners, Development Control Rules, the Pune Municipal Corporation, Respondents 5, Counsel for the Petitioners, Counsel for the Petitioner, the Respondents - Pune Municipal Corporation, Counsel for the Petitioners, the Collector's Rules, Counsel for the Petitioners, the Government of Maharashtra, Counsel for the Petitioners, Counsel for the Petitioners, Counsel for the Petitioners, Apex Court, Counsel, Jugalkishore, the Apex Court, Legislature, Court, Court, O.G.B. Syndicate Ltd., the Apex Court, Counsel for the Petitioners, New Delhi Municipal Council, Judicial Dictionary, 5th Edn, contra, The High Court, The High Court, Supreme Court, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay v., Mafatlal Industries and Ors, the Apex Court, the Bombay High Court, Court, Kalavati, Court, Counsel for the Petitioner's, Court, Petitioners, Collector's Rules, M.I. Builders Pvt. Ltd., the Apex Court, The High Court, Court, Judicial, Justice, Court, this Court the Mahapalika and the State Government, the High Court, the State Government, the State Government, Court, the No Objection Certificate, Appeal, the Pune Municipal Corporation, the Pune Municipal Corporation, Collector, N.O.C., Plot No, Collector's Rules, Collector's Rules, the Collector's Rules, the Development Control Rules, Appendix 'M', Plot No, Government, Collector, Development Control Rules, Mezzanine, Collector's Rules, Plot No, F.S.I., F.S.I., F.S.I., Court, Charitable Trust, Court, Plot No, No Objection Certificate, Appellate, Plot No, Plot No, Plot Nos, the Pune Municipal Corporation, the Collector's Rules

CARDINAL: 4 to 13, 7, 2, 122, four, 5.1.1987, 5.1.1987, 2.20a, 7.8.2000, 5.1.1987.5, 122, 122, 2, 2, 2, 2, 0.66, more than one, more than one, four, five, more than one, one, one, 25, two, more than one, 3, 3, Only one, two, 16, more than one, more than one, 122, more than one, 2.1, 25.6.1993, 1, 7.8.2000, half, One, 548, 2, 2, 2, 2, 2, 122, 122, 36, 13, 1987.26, 5.1.1987, 5.1.1987, 6.1.1987, 23.1.1987, one, 447, 5.1.1987, 1, 2, 4, three, one, one, two, five, 4.1.2000, 19, 5, one, 8, one, two, 3, 16, 27.12.1999, 8, 4.3.1999, 6, 7, five, 3, 8, 10, 20.8.1999, four, two, six, one, one, four, 62, 11, 11, four, four, five, 92 and 93, 12, two, more than one, 122/1, 13, 1525, four, one, 2, 5, 36, 36, two, 1966.42, 14.2, 113, 5, 11, 13, one, one, 2.85, 2.85, one, one, one, 5, 7, 27, 1000, 4000, 1 Acre, 3000, four, 1000, 4000, 3, 4.49, 35, 62, four, 92 and 93, 12, 12, three, 2, 92 and 93, two, 122/1, 13, one, one, only one, 2.1.1997, four, 656, 1, 5, 15, 9, 15, more than two, 27, 1999.54, 15, 1, 2, 3 and 4, 3, 4, 35, 11.1.2000, 3, 4, 10, 5, 62, 923, four, 50-51, 88, 88, 3.57, 4, 21, two, 10, 50-51, two, four, 10, only two, 6, 50-51, 2, 3, 106, 15, 57, four, two, five, two, three, four, only one, More than one third, 5.61, 1 to 6, 106, 15, 12, 227, three, 5.1.1987?(b, 5.1.1987:(i, 5, 8, 2.20, 23.1.1987, 15.2.1950, 548, 549, 2, 2, 15.2.1950, 2, 2, 2, 122, only 0.66, only 122, 0.66, 2.56, 1, 2.56.1, 2.56.1, 7.77, 2.56.1, only one, 5, 19, 2.56.1, two, 1955]1SCR1369, 6, 1964]5SCR387, 2000]1SCR731, 12, two, two, 5, 73, 2, 5, one, three, 2, 19, one, 8, 5.6.1997, 2.56.1, 5, 19, 27, four, 1000, 35, four, two, 62, four, 92-93, two, 2, 122/1, four, one, 656, 7, 9, 15, 2.0, five, 51000, two, five, four, 51000, 2.0, two, 9, 2, 2, 2, 3, 4, 11.1.2000, 2000, 5, 62, 2.35, 62, 3691, 50-51, four, three, two, one, five, four

GPE: Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Pune, Mango, Meherbai, Bombay, Koregaon Park, Meherbai, Koregaon Park, Gulmohar, Neem, Mango, Koregaon Park, Meherbai, Koregaon Park, Gulmohar, Neem, Mango, Meherbai, Municipality, Meherbai, Panchanama, occupied.33, Municipality, isolation.47, Koregaon Park, the Pune City, Koregaon Park, South Court, B.E.A.G., Meherbai, Meherbai, Koregaon Park, Gulmohar, Neem, Mango, Meherbai, Meherbai, Pune City, Pune city, Pune City, F.S.I., Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, the City of Pune, N.D.M.C., Kishinchand, green area.84, B.E.A.G.

FAC: Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Regulation 227, Koregaon Park, the Main Building, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Wilson Garden, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Regulation 227, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Main Building, the Main Building, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park Scheme, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, the Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Regulation 227, the Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Nivara Hakk Suraksha Samiti v. State of, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park, Koregaon Park

WORK_OF_ART: Collector's, the Lease Deed, Main Bungalow', the Lease Deed, Scheme, Officers, Officers, the Lease Deed, Appendix 'M', Appendix 'M', Appendix 'M', Mezzanine Floor'

QUANTITY: approximately 194 acres, 1 acre, one acre, one acre, less than 10 feet, 1 acre, 1 acre, 1 acre, 1 acre, about 1.32 acres, 1.18 acres, 1.14 acres, one acre, about 1.24 acres, one acre, 1.58 acres, 1.29 Acres, 1.32 Acres, less than 1 Acre, about 1.24 acres, 1 acre, 1.58 acres

LOC: the North Main, Pune, Pune, Pune, Pune, Pune, Pune, Pune, Respondent, Pune, Municipality, R-2, R-2, Pune, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Pune, Pune, Pune, Pune, Greater Bombay, Greater Bombay, Pune, aside.87, Respondent

PRODUCT: the Collector's Rules, Respondent, Appellant, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Rules 5, Rule 3, under:.The, Pune, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent

ORDINAL: third, Secondly, first, 15th, Firstly, second, first, second, first, third, third, second, third, 5th, 10th, 4th, second, first, 7th, 7th, 7th, second, third, third, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, Firstly, Second, first, first, third, 3rd, first, first, first

EVENT: Proviso to Section 31(1, Respondent - Collector

PERCENT: 80%