Western Coalfields Ltd. and ors. Vs. New India Assurance Ltd.

Decided On : Sep-02-2005

Court : Mumbai

LAW: Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the Condition No. 5, Condition No, Article 226 of the Constitution of India.13, Section 64VB(3, the Insurance Act, Section 64VB(3, the Condition No. 5, Condition No, the Condition No. 5, Article 226 of the Constitution of India.16, Article 226 of the Constitution of India.17, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Article 226 of the Constitution, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Article 226 of the Constitution, Constitution, Article 14, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Article 299 of the Constitution, the JPA Policy, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, Article 12 of the Constitution, Article 12 of the Constitution, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, Section 64VB(3, Section 64VB(3, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, Article 12 of the Constitution of India

PERSON: B.R. Gavai, Shri Barve, Nos, Nos, Nos, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, Heard Shri Mehadia, Shri M. G. Barve, Shri A. J. Pophali, Shri Mehadia, JPA Policy, Madhya Pradesh, Nos, Shri Mehadia, JPA Policy, Shri Mehadia, Shri Barve, Insurer, Insurer, Shri Barve, policy.15, Shri Barve, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, Shri Barve, Shri Barve, Amritsar, Bench, J., Nos, Nos, JPA Policy, Staffs, Hazard, Sum Insured, Sector, Mahesh Durle, Rajendra Nistane, 756.25Rs, Nos, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, Long Term Contract, Nos, at.1, Insurer, Insurer, Nagpur, Insurer, Manger, JPA Policy, Biman Krishna Bose v., E.R. Hardy Evamy, Rajiv Kumar Bhaskar, Madhya Pradesh, Nos, JPA Policy, Biman Krishna Bose, JPA Policy

GPE: Counsel, Policy, Policy, Counsel, India, US, Mumbai, India, Employee, G.I.C., G.I.C., Mumbai, Approx, G.I.C., Chandrapur, case.43, Insurer

ORG: the Long Term Group Janata Personal Accident Policy, the Government of India Undertaking, Government of India Undertaking, Group Janata Personal Accident Insurance Policy, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, Memorandum of Understanding, MOU, MOU, JPA Policy, MOU, MOU, Court, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, Unions, JPA Policy, the Personal Accident Policy, JPA Policy, W.C.L., General Insurance Company, Steering Committee, JPA Policy, MOU, MOU, Management to the Insurance Company, W.C.L., Certificate, the Insurance Company, MOU, Scheme, the Union/Management, the W.C.L., JPA Policy, the Apex Court, Motilal Padampat Sugar Mills Co. Ltd., The State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors, Court, State, Court, the Apex Court, ABL International Ltd., Anr, Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Limited and, Court, Shri Barve, Insured, Insured, Postal Money Order, Insured, MOU, MOU, JPA Policy, MOU, MOU, MOU, MOU, JPA Policy, MOU, MOU, MOU, MOU, Credit to Credit Co-operative, Society of the employees, Nagpur Regional Office, Court, the Apex Court, The Central Bank of India Ltd., The Hartford Fire Insurance Co. Ltd., Court, Pune District Central Co-operative, Bank Ltd., National Insurance Co. Ltd., Ors, Court, Yavatmal District Central Co-operative, Bank and Ors, New India Assurance Co. Ltd., Government of India Undertaking, State, ABL International Ltd., the Apex Court, Corporation, Tea, The Kazakhstan Government, Corporation, Government, US Dollars, Kazak Corporation, the Kazakhstan Government, Kazakhstan Government, Tea, the Kazak Corporation, the Kazak Corporation, the Kazak Corporation, the ABL Corporation, the Calcutta High Court, the Calcutta High Court, ABL International Ltd., the Calcutta High Court, the ABL International Ltd., Court, ABL International Ltd., the Apex Court, the Apex Court, Bench, the Apex Court, Apex Court, Court, State, State, Court, Court, Registrar of Trade Marks, Ors, the High Court, Court, State, Court, State, the Apex Court, The Apex Court, M.P. Sugar Mill, Government, the Apex Court, Government, English Courts, the American Courts, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, Government, Govt, Government, Court, the Indo-Afghan Agencies, AIR 1968 SC 718, Court, Government, Government, Government, Government, Government, the Apex Court, Apex Court, Government, Court, Government, Government, Court, Government, Government, Government, Government, Shah, the Indo-Afghan Agencies, Court, Government, Court, the Apex Court, M.P. Sugar Mill, the Apex Court, Union of India, Godfrey Philips India Ltd., Sharma Transport v. Government of A.P. and Ors, Government, Government, Courts, Government, Government, The Apex Court, Sharma Transport, Government, the Apex Court, the Area Managers, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, MOU, MOU, JPA Policy, Financial Aid Schemes and Free Medical Facilities, Sum Insured, DIVISIONAL, Divisional, Divisional, Coal Mines Officers Association of India, Central Executive, Group, Group Slab 7500-1,00,000Group, Trade Union, Associations, the Group Policy, the JPA Policy, LACS, LACS, Divisional, Long Term Group J.P.A. Policy, the Steering Committee Members Management of W.C.L.8, W.C.L., M.P., the Personal Managers, W.C.L. Management and Steering Committee, W.C.L.10, Head Office, MOU, W.C.L., the New India Assurance Co., Unions, WCL Management, MOU, the Group Janata Personal Policy, The New India Assurance Co. Ltd., General Insurance Corporation Ltd., un, the Insurance Company, New India Assurance Co., Ltd., the Union/Management, RI/IV of, the Management of WCL, the New India Assurance Co.15, Chandrapur, R.I-IV, CMPDI, MOU, Insured, M.O.U., Long Term Group Janata Personal, WCL Ltd., the JPA Policy, the JPA Policy, Divisional, JPA Policy, Steering Committee, MOU, MOU, Clause 13, MOU, MOU, Divisional, IR, MOU, Scheme, Scheme, Insured, MOU, Long Term Group Janata Personal, W.C.L., JPA Policy, JPA, Insured, Insured, Company, Insured, MOU, MOU, MOU, MOU, JPA Policy, the Apex Court, the M.P. Sugar Mill's, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, Court, the Apex Court, M.P. Sugar Mill's, Government, Court, Court, Government, Court, Court, Court, Government, Court, the Apex Court, Central Bank of India, the Apex Court, Court, the Apex Court, The Apex Court, Court, Court, the Apex Court, Court, Pune District Central Co-operative, Bank Ltd., Court, Court, the Apex Court, Central Bank of India, the Insurance Company, Court, Court, JPA Policy, MOU, Pune Central Co-operative, Bank, the Division Bench, Yavatmal District Central Co-operative, Bank, the Apex Court, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., Anr, the Apex Court, the United India Insurance Company, General Insurance Business (Nationalisation) Act, State, State, United India Insurance Company Ltd., State, the Apex Court, State, The Apex Court, Hanil Era Textile Ltd., Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Ors, Fire and Motor Insurance, 2nd Edn, Insured, MOU, the JPA Policy, MOU, the Apex Court, Life Insurance Corporation and Ors, AIR 2005, the Life Insurance Corporation of India, Corporation, Corporation, The Apex Court, Corporation, Corporation, The Apex Court, W.C.L., Scheme, the Apex Court, the Life Insurance Corporation, State, JPA Policy, MOU, MOU, MOU, MOU, State, State, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, W.C.L., Madhya Pradesh, MOU, JPA Policy, MOU, JPA, Court, the Apex Court, State, the Apex Court, Hanil Era Textiles Ltd., the Apex Court, Life Insurance Corporation, State, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, JPA Policy, JPA Policy

CARDINAL: 1, 1999.3, 1, more than 61,000, about 2,500, 2, 7, 1, 4., one, 1, 1, 1, 1, 2,500, 1, 1, 10-3-1999, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1 to 6, 1 to 6, 15-3-1999, one, 81/., 1, 2,90,99,714/-, 61,163 nonexclusive, 1, 1, 1, 1, 14, 1, 1, 15-9-2002, 1, 5, one, 1, more than one, 15-3-1999, 14, 1, 1, 1 to 6, 1, 5,00,000/-, one, 81/-, 1979]118ITR326(SC, 2004)3SCC553, 5, 5, two, 1, 14, 1, 2002.18, 1, 1, 1, 26, 28, more than 63,000, 1, 19, 24, 24, 23, 24, 24, 1986]158ITR574(SC, 13, 3 and 4, 1, 2, 7, 1, 1, 1, 63,748, one, 1, one, 5.00, 10, 2.00, 10, 550/-(one, 1, 5.00, 10-3-1999, 144.37NET, 20,45,000/-.Premium, 1375.00, 10, 20.45, 2500, five, 15-3-1999, 29, 1, 2,500, 1, 20,45,000/-, 1, 15-3-1999, 14, 5.00, 5.00, 1, one, 10, one, 5, ten, 1, 7, 15-9-1999, One, one, 14, 60,000.33, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, one, 1, 1, more than one, only one, 1, 1, 1, 14, approximately 60,000, 1, 1, 1, 1, more than 63,000, 2009.35, 5, 5, 1, 1, 1, 5, 1999.36, 1, 33, 1, 2009.38, more than one, 14, 1, 269, 13, 7, 31, 1, 1, 10, 1, 5, 1, one, 1, one, 1, 2 to 6, more than one, 1, 1, one, 14, 1, one, more than 63,000, 1, 1, 2009.51

DATE: a period of, 10 years, 14th September, about January, 1999, 1 year to 15 years, a period of, 10 years, 14th September, 1999, ten years, 14-9-1999, 16th August, 2002, 19th August, 2002, 10 years, 10 years, 29th August, 2002, 4th September, 2002, 29th August, 2002, the month of January, 1999, 10th March, 1999, a period of, 10 years, ten years, 14th September, 1999, 10 years, 10 years.11, 1938, 29th August, 2002, 14th September, 1999, May, 1999, 3715, from 23rd September, 1993 to 30th September, 1995, 10 years, less than 10 years, the period of 10 years, 10th February, 1999, 10th March, 1999, 10 years, 2001, the period of, 10 years, before 15th March, 1999, 15th March, 1999, the period of 10 years, ANNUAL, 10 YEARS Rs, 10 years, Annual, previous years, 10 years, Annual, every year, 10 years period, 14-9-1999, March, 99, 11-9-1999, 14-9-20093, a period of, 10 years, 14-9-1999, 10th February, 1999, a period of, 10 years, the period of, 10 years, a period of, 10 years, a period of, 10 years, 14-9-2009.34, 14-9-1999, September, 2009, a period of, 10 years, September, 14th March, 1999, 14th September, 1999, 14th September, 1999, 14th September, 1999, 14th September, 10 years, September, 10 years, 3715/2002, 2001)6SCC477, 1972, 2001, 10 years, 14th March, 1999, 10 years, 3636, ten years' period, a period of, 10 years, 10 years, 14th September, 2009, 14th March, 1999, a period of, 10 years, 10 years, September, 2009, a period of, 10 years, September, 2009, September, 2009, 29th August, 2002, 29th August, 2002, 29th August, 2002, 14th September

WORK_OF_ART: the Memorandum of Understanding, Scheme, the JPA Policy, Scheme, Condition No

LOC: Policy, Policy, Policy, Policy, Policy, Govt, Traffic Road, Policy, Policy

NORP: Maharashtra, Indian, Maharashtra, Maharashtra, Maharashtra

PRODUCT: AIR1965SC1288, Memorandum

ORDINAL: first, first, first, first, first, first, firstly, secondly

EVENT: US Dollars, Operation

PERCENT: 15%, 70%, 1375.00Less 30%, 962.50Less 15%, 55%, Period)Less 55%, 618.75Less 15%, 70%

TIME: 9-3-1999