Traders Pvt. Ltd. and the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Smt. Sunanda Widow of Krishna Machivale and ors.

Decided On : Aug-27-2008

Court : Mumbai

LAW: the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 92A, Section 92A, Section 92A, Section 110, Section 95(1)(b)(i, Section II, Section 95(2)(a).23, Section 92(2, Article 136, Article 142 of the Constitution of India, Chapter VIII, Section 96, Section 95(1)(b)(i, Chapter VIII, Section 95(4, Chapter VIII, Section 95(1)(b)(i, I.M.T. 5, the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 11-1(i, Section 11-1(ii, Section 95(2)(d, Section II(1)(i, the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 95, Section II, Section 95 of the Act, the Constitution Bench, the Constitution Bench, the Constitution Bench, Section 11(1)(ii, Section 11(1)(ii, The Constitution Bench, Section 95, The Constitution Bench, the Constitution Bench, The Constitution Bench, the Constitution Bench, the Constitution Bench, The Constitution Bench, the Motor Vehicles Act, Article 142 of the Constitution of India, Article 136, Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 95(2)(a, Section 95(2)(a, Section 147(2)(a, Section 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 149(2, Section 174 of the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 96, the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 96, Section 149(4, Section 96, Section 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 149(2, Section 96(3, Section 149(2, Section 96(3, Section 149(4, Section 96 or Section 149, Section 96, Section 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 96, Section 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act, the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 96, Section 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act, Section 96 or (, Section 149

PERSON: Ranjana Desai, Krishna Babu Machivala, Krishna, Anil Dwarkanath Chudji, Nariman Point, Sion-Trombay Road, R.K. Studio, Rs.1,50,000/-, Insurer, Rs.2,83,000/-, Rs.7,500/-, Rs.1,50,000/-, Rs.2,50,000/-, Rs.2,50,000/-, Barve, Singh, Patel, Barve, Counsel, Barve, Barve, Barve, Barve, Driver, Cleaner, Barve, Barve, Barve, Insurer, Barve, Srinivasan v. Premier Insurance Co. Ltd., Swaran Singh, Anr, Divisional, Baljit Kaur, Sohan Lal Passi, P. Sesh Reddy, Kokilaben Chandravadan, Deepa Devi, Syed Ibrahim, Anjana Shyam, Itbar Singh, Anr, Kuppuswamy, Anr, Barve, Singh, Rs.1,50,000/-, Rs.1,50,000/-, Singh, Rs.1,50,000/- under Section 95(2)(a, Singh, Rs.16, Singh, Singh, Rs.1,50,000/-, Singh, Singh, Singh, C.M. Jaya, Raj Kumari, Singh, Singh, Rs.1,50,000/-, Singh, Singh, Kusum Rai, Anubai G. Thakore, Diwakar, Singh, Madho Singh, Singh, Patel, Counsel, Barve, Barve, Prem Mannalal Ramne, Time Keeper, Minu Mehta's, Barve, Minu Mehta's, Jugal Kishore's, Minu Mehta's, Act.40, Driver, Driver(a, Driver, Cleaner, Jugal Kishore's, Rs.1,50,000/-, Counsel, Barve, Counsel, Rs.1,50,000/-, Barve, namely:[(a, Rs.1,50,000/- under Section 95(2)(a, Cleaner, isAdd, Rs.16, Jugal Kishore's, Rs.40,000/-, case.54, Jugal Kishore's, Shanti Bai, Jugal Kishore's, C.M. Jaya's, Rs.1,50,000/-, Rs.1,50,000/-, Rs.1,50,000/-, Barve, Jugal Kishore's, Bommithi Subbhayamma, Raj Kumari's, Singh, Anjana Shyam's, Baljit Kaur's, Kusum Rai's, Syed Ibrahim's, Kingaonkar, Nagpur Bench, Prakash Sakharam Dudhankar, Kingaonkar, J., Barve, Swaran Singh's, Barve, Itbar Singh, Barve, Barve, Swaran Singh's, Itbar Singh, Rs.2,000/-, Madho Sen's, Singh, Sohan Lal', Deepa Devi's, Rs.1,50,000/-

NORP: J.1, Rs.15,000/-, Third, Subramania Naicker, Indian, Subramania Naicker's

CARDINAL: 8/3/2000, 807, 1, 4A, one, 827, 16/12/1987.3, 1, 4A, 1, 3, 1, 5, 5, to.4, One, No.2, 3, 2, 1, 1, 2, 7, 5, 3, 5, 5, Rs.15,000/-, 1982]3SCR244, 1960]1SCR168, AIR1989Mad297, 7, Rs.50,000/-, Rs.15,000/-, 270, 2002]1SCR298, 7, 2005(6)BomCR284, two, only Rs.4, two, one, 270, 95(1)(b)(i, 3, 3, 1964]7SCR867, 5, 5, 5, 5, Rs.15,000/-, 5, 5, 4, Rs.15,000/-, 1, one, one, fifty thousand, six, fifty thousand, fifteen thousand, six thousand, 11-1(i, 11-1(ii, one, one, one, 240.00, 16.00, 256.00, 256.00, 2, 1)(i, 2, two, one, one, 1995]1SCR871, 2005)12SCC243, Rs.50,000/-, Rs.50,000/-, Rs.50,000/-, 13, 224, 2006(1, 412, 2/3/1970, 56, 2/3/1970, 3, 4, 3, 4, 5, 4, 5, 2, 3, 4, 4, 5, 2, 2, 3, 4, 4, 5

ORG: Court, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Indian Express Newspaper Ltd., the Indian Express Office, Maruti Motor No, the Rajawadi Hospital, the Indian Express, the Tribunal, Opposite Party Nos.1, Rs.1,50,000/-, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, the Indian Express, M/s. Traders Private Limited, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Rs.1,50,000/-, Tribunal, First Appeal, Tribunal, Learned Single, Learned Single, Learned Single, Learned Single, M/s. Traders Private Limited, the Oriental Insurance Company Limited, the New India Assurance Company Limited, Tribunal, Personal Accident Insurance Cover.16, Tribunal, Third Party, Third Party, a First Party, Third Party, Learned Single, Personal Accidents Insurance Cover, Personal Accidents Insurance Cover under Endorsement, Personal Accidents Insurance Cover nor Life Insurance Policy, Third Party, the Supreme Court, National Insurance Co. Ltd., Punam Devi, New India Assurance Co. Ltd and, National Insurance Co. Ltd., Skandia Insurance Co. Ltd., AIR 1987, National Insurance Co. Ltd., Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., National Insurance Co. Ltd., Ors, British India General Insurance Co. Ltd., the New India Assurance Company Limited, Tribunal, Claimants, Claimants, Third Party, Third Party, M.V. Act, Claimants, Third Party Property Damage, Third Party, National Insurance Company Limited, Jugal Kishore, New India Assurance Company Limited, Oriental Insurance Company Limited, National Insurance Company Limited, Claimants, Claimants, the Supreme Court, Claimants, the Supreme Court, National Insurance Company Limited, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Brij Mohan and Ors, Court, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., New India Assurance Co. Ltd., the Rajasthan High Court, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., Claimants, Claimants, Court, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, Single Judge, Tribunal, xerox, Learned Single, Tribunal, Learned Single, the Supreme Court, National Insurance Company Limited, Jugal Kishore, the Supreme Court, Indian Express Newspaper Limited, the Indian Express, the Indian Express, the Indian Express, the Indian Express, the Indian Express, Tribunal, the Indian Express, the Indian Express, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Court, the Andhra Pradesh High Court, Third Party, The Supreme Court, the High Courts, The Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Third Party, the Supreme Court, Tribunal, Tribunal, The Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Comprehensive Policy, the Supreme Court, Third Party, Third Party, Insurance of Motor Vehicles, Third Party Risks, a Third Party, Third Party, Third Party, a Third Party, Single Judge, the Insured the Company, Insured, Insured, Learned Single, Single Judge, New Asiatic Insurance Company Limited, Learned Single, Insured, a Third Party, the Third Party, the Third Party, Learned Single, I.M.T. 5, Learned Single, Tribunal, Learned Single, a Third Party, the Supreme Court, Tribunal, Court, Tribunal, Claimants, LiabilityLimit, Company, Third Party, LIABILITY, L.L., END, Limit, T.P. LimitsSection II 1(i, Third Party, Third Party Property Damage', Third Party Damage, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Tribunal, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Tribunal, Rs.1,03,360/-, the High Court, The High Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, New India Assurance CO. Ltd., the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, National Insurance Co. Ltd., the Supreme Court, Tribunal, Smt, the High Court, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Insurance Company's, The Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Tribunal, the Insurance Company, the Supreme Court, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Brij Mohan and Ors, Court, First Appeal, National Insurance Co. Ltd., Ors, Tribunal, Tribunal, the High Court, Tribunal, The Supreme Court, the Motor Vehicles Act, The Supreme Court, the Motor Vehicles Act, The Supreme Court, the Motor Vehicles Act, Tribunal, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Tribunal, the Third Party, The Supreme Court, Tribunal, the Tribunal to the Collector, The Supreme Court, Tribunal, the Supreme Court, the Motor Vehicles Act, Third Party, Third Party, the Motor Vehicles Act, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Third Party, the Rajasthan High Court, the Supreme Court, Punam Devi', Skandia Insurance Company's

ORDINAL: First, 2nd, third, first, first, first, first, Third, Third, Third, Third, first, Third, third, third, third, third, third, third, first, third, first

DATE: 1994, 1988, 8335, 8335, MHT 1835, No.2, the 1st, 16/12/1987, up to 75 years, severally.10, 1994, 1923, 2007, 2816, 1988, 2007, 2006, 26/8/2007, 2005, 1953, 1988, 1923, 1923, six calendar months, 1923, 1923, 14, Rs.50,000/-, Rs.10,000/-, Rs.50,000/-, Rs.50,000/-, Rs.50,000/-, Rs.50,000/-, 2004, 2006, 2006, 4/8/2007, 5/4/1970, Rs.50,000/-, 1939, 1939, Rs.50,000/-, 16/12/1987, 1988, 1/7/1989, 1988, 1988, 1939, 1988, 1988, 1988, 1988, 1988, 1988, 16/12/1987, 1988

GPE: Bombay, Bombay, Rs.1,40,500/-, Single, Counsel, Counsel, Counsel, Liability, vehicle.19, Padma, Counsel, Single, England, India, compensation.33, Death, Clause, Rs.1,00,000/-, C.M. Jaya's, Counsel, C.M. Jaya's, Single, Padma, Padma, Padma, Single, order.71

PRODUCT: Maruti Car No, Maruti Car No, Appellant 2, No.1, Rs.2,000/-, Rs.4,20,120/-, the Motor Car, the Motor Car, Rs.20,000/-, Rs.20,000/-, Rs.23,000/-, Rs.20,000/-, Rs.20,000/-

TIME: about 11.40 p.m.

LOC: Pune, Pune, Single Judge, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single, Policy, Single Judge, Single Judge, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single Judge, Single, Policy, Single

EVENT: the Workmen's Compensation Act, the Workmen's Compensation Act, the Workmen's Compensation Act, the Workmen's Compensation Act, the Workmen's Compensation Act, the Workmen's Compensation Act, the Workmen's Compensation Act, the Workmen's Compensation Act

PERCENT: 12%, 12%, only...100%, 100%, 10%

WORK_OF_ART: 'Comprehensive Policy', Limits of Liability', Private Car Comprehensive Policy, Nanjappan and Ors

FAC: Rs.60,000/-