Sadbuddhi Brahmesh Wagh, Vs. Sheela Mahabaleshwar Wagh (Since Deceased Ganesh Mahabaleshwar Wagh and Shilpa Wagh W/O Sharad Shrikhande),

Decided On : Mar-28-2003

Court : Mumbai

LAW: Section 30, the Arbitration Act, the Bombay Rent Act, Section 30, the Arbitration Act, Article 106 of the Limitation Act, Section 30, Article 106 of the Limitation Act, Article 110 or Article 113, Article 106, Article 110, Article 113, Article 116 of the Limitation Act, Article 110, Section 52 of the Code of Civil Procedure, Section 50, Section 52, Section 52 of the Code, Section 15(b, the Arbitration Act, Section 15(b, Section 15(b, the Bombay Rent Act, Section 5(11)(c, Section 5(11)(c, Section 5(11)(c, Section 5(11)(c, Section 5(11)(c, Section 5(11)(c, the Rent Act, Section 5(11)(c, Section 15, Section 5(11)(c)(i, Section 5(11, Section 5(11)(c)(i, Section 15, Section 15 of the Rent Act, Section 5(11)(c)(ii, the Rent Act, Section 5(11)(c)(ii, the Rent Act, Section 28, Section 5(11)(c, Section 15-A of the Rent Act, the Rent Act, Section 28, Section 28, the Rent Act, the Rent Act, the Rent Act, Section 28, the Rent Act, the Rent Act, Section 28, the Rent Act, Section 5(11)(c, Section 15(1, the Bombay Rent Act, Section 5(11)(c)(i, the Rent Act, the Maharashtra Amendment to Section 69, the Partnership Act, Section 28, Section 28, Section 15(1, Section 5(11)(c)(ii, the Rent Act, Section 28, the Rent Act, Section 5(11)(c, Section 5(11)(c)(ii, Section 5(11)(c)(ii, Section 28, Section 28

PERSON: H.L. Gokhale, Petitioners, Shri Vinayakrao, limitation.(B, Raghavendra - Died, Sheela-Respondent, Kamlabai Tinaikar - Died, Sushilabai J. Karande - Died, V. Wagh - Died, Radhika M. Dhume - Respondent, Mangla V. Wagh - Died, Shri Mahabaleshwar Wagh, Chowpatty, Bapat Marg, Mahavir Jain Vidyalaya, Brahmesh, Arts, Painting, Shri Vinayakrao, Mahabaleshwar, Brahmesh, Shri Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Caveat, Brahmesh, Shri Vinayakrao, G. Subsequently, S.H., Award, Defendant Nos, Appellant Nos, Defendant Nos, Direction Nos, Bapat Marg, Mahavir Jain Vidyalaya, Defendant Nos, Defendant Nos, Award, Tulzapurkar, Award, Award, Award, Setalwad, Award, Award, N. Chellappan, Anr, Setalwad, Setalwad, Mahboob Sirfraz, Bhadrachalam, Palavancha, Caveat, Shri Vinayakrao, Award, Award, N. Chellappan's, Award, Award, Award, Tulzapurkar, Nos, Award, Award, Tulzapurkar, Rani Brijraj Kumari v. Manranjan Prasad Singh, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Setalwad, Defendant Nos, Naraindas L. Adnani v., Narsingdas N. Adnani, Nos, Brahmesh, Brahmesh, Chowpatty, Brahmesh, Brahmesh, Govalia Tan Road, Tulzapurkar, Mehroo S. Cooper v., Rajaram B. Upadhyaya, Ramraj R. Upadhyaya, L.J. 792, C.J. Ghadialli, Z.B. Wadiwalla, Rajaram B. Upadhyaya, Ramraj R. Upadhyay, Anant Trimbak Sabnis, Will, Tulzapurkar, Shri Vinayakrao, Brahmesh, Anant, Tulzapurkar, Hindu Law, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Shri Vinayakrao, Brahmesh, Vinayakrao, Award, S. Mandare v., Laxminarayan M. Mundade, Gazette, Tulzapurkar, Award, Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Award, Tulzapurkar, Brahmesh, Brahmesh, Tulzapurkar, Small Causes, Award, Anr, Natraj Studio, Sabavva Kom Hanmappa Simplger v., Basappa Andaneppa Chiniwar, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Appellants, Tulzapurkar, Setalwad, Award, Award, Setalwad, R.H. Shah, H.J. Joshi, Kalyanji G. Bhagat v., Virji Bharmal, Anr, Gian Devi Anand, Jeevan Kumar, Setalwad, Shri, Setalwad, Melanie Fialho, Francis Pereira, Anr, Defendant Nos, Award, Award, Petitioners, Award, Award, Roy, Anr, Corpn, Award, Setalwad, Setalwad, Setalwad, Award, Brahmesh, Brahmesh, Award, Setalwad, Award, N. Chellapan's, Award, Award, Setalwad, Shri Vinayakrao Wagh, Brahmesh, Brahmesh, Setalwad, Melanie, Appellants, Law, Award, Brahmesh, Shri Vinayakrao, Brahmesh, Brahmesh, Appellants, Melanie, Brahmesh, Vinayakrao, Brahmesh, Chowapatty, Bapat Marg, Mahavir Jain Vidyalaya, Raymond, Pai, Shah, Shah, Award, Raymond, Pai

NORP: J.1, -(These, Statute, Hindu

ORG: Petitioners, Respondents, Respondents Nos, the Court of Small Causes, Heirs, persons:-5, Vyankatesh, Sculptor of Mumbai, WFAS, Chowpatty, Girgaum, Suit, WFAS, Girgaum, Charring Cross Compound, Govalia Tank, WFAS).(4, the Ground Floor of the above, Chowpatty, Late Shri Vinayakrao, Suit, Mahabaleshwar Wagh, Mahabaleshwar, WFAS, WFAS, WFAS, Punjab National Bank, Firm - WFAS, Firm, Firm, the Ground Floor, Mahim, WFAS, Court, WFAS, WFAS, Suit, WFAS, Exhibit 'K', Exhibit 'L', Court, WFAS, WFAS, Court, Suit, Suit, the Sole Arbitration of Senior Advocate, Suit, Arbitrator, WFAS, I. Thereafter, Plaintiff, the Plaintiff-Mahabaleshwar, WFAS, Chowpatty, Govalia Tank, Plaintiff, Suit, Court, Charring Cross Compound, Govalia Tank, Wagh Fine Arts Studio.(C, Plaintiff, Clause A, Plaintiff, Plaintiff, J. This Award of the Arbitrator, Arbitration Petition No, the Apex Court, Special Leave Petition, Suit, Suit, Suit, the Arbitration Petition, Appellants, Respondents, Court, Respondents, the Apex Court, Kanpur Nagar Mahapalika v. Narain Das Haribansh, The Apex Court, the Apex Court, The Apex Court, the Apex Court, Kerala State Electricity Board, the Apex Court, Respondents, Suit, the Privy Council, Sri Rajah, Plaintiff, Plaintiff, the Privy Council, Mahomedally Tyebally and Ors, Saflabai and Ors, Firm, Appellants, Suit, Suit, Plaintiff, Suit, Suit, Plaintiff, Suit, Suit, Plaintiff, Suit, Kanpur Nagar Mahapalika's, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, Award, Court, Suit, Appellants, Patna High Court, Smt, Court, Court, Court, Respondents, Court, the Apex Court, Ors, the Apex Court, Court, Court, Court, Arbitration, Court, the Apex Court, Naraindas, the Court of Small Causes, Suit, Plaintiff, Court, WFAS, WFAS, Defendants, their Written Statement, the Written Statement, WFAS, WFAS, WFAS, Chowpatty, Mahim, WFAS, Punjab National Bank, Mahabaleshwar at Mahim, Chowpatty, WFAS, WFAS, Hotel, Lodging House Rates (Control) Act, the Bombay Rent Act, Court, the Apex Court, Shashikant Shinde, SC, Court, Hotel, Lodging House Rates Control (Amendment) Act, Court, Court, Court, A.N. Modi, Ors, the Apex Court, Vasant Pratap Pandit, Appellant, Suit, the Civil Court, the High Court, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, Court, the Bombay Rent Act, WFAS, Court, the Apex Court, Vasant, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, King's Bench Division, Solicitor, the Division Bench, L.J. 362, Court, WFAS, the Government Notification, the State Government, the Bombay Rents, Hotel, Lodging House Rates Control (Amendment) Act, the State Government, Mahabaleshwar, Mahim, Suit, WFAS, the Written Statement, the Small Causes Court, the Bombay Rent Act, Court, Court of Small Causes, Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, Court and(b, the Court of the Civil Judge (Junior Division, the Court of the Civil Judge (Senior Division, Section, the Court of Small Causes, the Court of Small Causes, Reliance, the Apex Court, Natraj Studios, Navrang Studios, AIR 1981, SC, Court, the Apex Court, The Apex Court, the Court of Small Causes, Court, Respondents, the High Court, the Apex Court, Deccan Merchants Cooperative Bank Ltd., Dalichand Jugraj Jain, AIR 1969, SC, Court, Court, Court, the Court of Small Causes, Court, the Court of Small Causes, Court, Court, Court, Court, B.L.R., Division, Apex Court, the Bombay Rent Act, a Court of Law, Rajasthan State Mines & Minerals Ltd., Eastern Engineering & Anr, the Apex Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, the Bombay Rent Act, the Court of Small Causes, Court of Small Causes, Respondents, Respondents, WFAS, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, Housing Society, the Bombay Rent Act, Bombay Rent Cases, the Apex Court, Ors, Court, Ors, Respondents, Petitioners, Plaintiff, Respondents, Petitioners, the Apex Court, The Calcutta Metropolitan Development Authority, Directors, Respondents, the Apex Court, The Apex Court, The Apex Court, Arbn, Calcutta, Arbitrator, Appellants, Punjab National Bank, WFAS, WFAS, Respondents, Suit, WFAS, the Bombay Rent Act, Natraj Studios, WFAS, Vasant Pratap Pandit, the Court of Small Causes, the Rent Act.26, WFAS, Appellants, the Written Statement, the Court of Small Causes, Civil Court, Natraj Studio (Supra, the Written Statement, WFAS, WFAS, Central, Mahim, Suit, the Small Causes Court, the Small Causes Court, Court, the Statute (Rent Act, the Court of Small Causes, the Court of Small Causes, the Small Causes Court, the Bombay Rent Act, Court, Small Causes Court, the Bombay Rent Act, the Small Causes Court ', Court, the District Court, the Small Causes Court, P.V. Raheja v. Life Insurance Corporation of India and Ors, AIR1982Bom523, Court, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, Charring Cross Compound, Govalia Tank, Court, Appeal, the Apex Court, Appellants, Appellants, Appellants, Respondents, Respondents

ORDINAL: 15th, 11th, 11th, 11th, 7th, 15th, first, 7th, secondly, First, first, first, second, 26th, 3rd, Firstly, secondly, 26th, second, third, third

DATE: October 1997, 1940, November 1958, 1990, 15th March 1991, 16th June 1997, November 1958, 9.1.1978, 12.3.1996, 14.4.1993, 29.1.2001.5, 18.10.1996, 1940, 1950-51, November 1955, April 1957, November 1958, 1963, February 1988, 22nd February 1988, 22nd September 1988, 31st August 1988, 1990, September 1990, 15th March 1991, 1990, 11th February 1993, 16th June, 1997, 400 007, 5, 1997, 1940, October 1997, November 1958, that year, 1963, 12 years, the year 1990, 1940, whereafter 12 years, August/September 1988, 29th February 1988, August 1988, 22nd September 1988, October 1990, 12 years, 3 years, August/September 1988, 1963, the year 1958, 12 years, August/September 1988, September 1990, 1940, the year 1963, the year 1958, about 1964, 1963, the year 1955, the year 1957, about 1963-64, 1947, 23rd October, 1978, 1978, 1978, '12, 1963, 19th August 1964, 1977, 1981, 1978, 23-10-1978, 1994, 1450, '14, 1949, the year 1997, 1983, para-11, September 1948, 1973, September 1948, '17, 1997, the year 1958, 1963, the year 1990, the year 1997, 1997, 1887, 1st February 1973, 1955, the year 1997, 1995, 1993, 1784, 4 weeks, October 1990, December 1991, the year 1985, '23, 1991, November 1955, 24th April 1957, 29th February 1988, 1932, one year, Para 13(k, 1958, 1963, 1963, 1988, 1990, 1988, it.29, the year 1958, '31, a period of, eight weeks, this period of, eight weeks

CARDINAL: one, One, 1A, 1C, three, follows:-(A, two, 2, 5.3, 1, 6.4, 1.2.2000, 1A to 1C., 1A, 7.5, 9.12.2000, 7A to 7J.2, 24.5.1994, 6.3, 6.9.2000, 9, one, two, two, 400007.(2, 19, 11, 164, 400, One, three, 2, two, two, two, 1/8th, 1, 1, 3, 1, 1/8th, two, two, one, one, 1A to 1F, 1 to 6, 1A to 1F, two, 11, 164, one, three, 1A, 7, 1A to 1F, 3, 6, 4, 2A, 2D, 12,500/-, 1A to 1F, 172, Three, three, 4., 1970]2SCR28, 10, Three, 1975]2SCR811, 12, 8, 1A to 1F, 1, 1, 50 and 52, 13, 1A to 1F, 4, 1A to 1F, one, 1, 9, 1, 1A, 1F, 10, two-fold, 5, 6, 13(k, 2, 2, 1200, 100, 15, 19, 15, 19, 218, 23.10.1978, 23.10.1978, 164, 13, 14, 876, 13, follows:-'14, 2, 266, 267, 276, 1, 15(1, follows:-'15, 2, two, 57, 201, 17, two, 21, 219, 34, two, five, one, two, 2/7, 5/7, 1, 3 to 6, 35,000/-, one, 488, 1987]3SCR569, 14, 74, 9, two-fold, 27, 74, one, two, more than one, one, 2, 2, two, two, 11, 164, 400 016, one, 1B, 2 to 5, eight, 1B, 2 to 5, eight

GPE: Shri Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Mumbai, Mumbai, Senapati, Matunga, Mumbai, Mumbai, Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Branch, Fort, Mumbai, Mahabaleshwar, Shri Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Mahabaleshwar, Mahabaleshwar, Mahabaleshwar, Shri Vinayakrao, Mahabaleshwar, Mahabaleshwar, Mahabaleshwar, Mahabaleshwar, Mahabaleshwar, Shri Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Mumbai, Senapati, Matunga, Mumbai, Mumbai, law.5, P.C., Mahabaleshwar, Mahabaleshwar, C.P.C., Brahmesh, Matunga, Mahabaleshwar, Matunga, Shri Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Matunga, Brahmesh, Brahmesh, Mahabaleshwar, Matunga, Brahmesh, Mahabaleshwar, Matunga, Mahabaleshwar, Shri Vinayakrao, Wagh, Brahmesh, Matunga, Brahmesh, Ganpat, Ladha, Tarabai, Tarabai, Shri Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Shri Vinayakrao, Mahabaleshwar, Apex, Prasun, Mahabaleshwar, Rajasthan Mines, Shri Vinayakrao, Mahabaleshwar, Shri Vinayakrao, Brahmesh, Mahabaleshwar, Mahabaleshwar, Senapati, Mumbai, Mumbai

LOC: Single, premises, Single Judge, Single, Respondent, Single Judge, Single, Single Judge, Single, Plaint, Respondent, Single, Greater Bombay, Greater Bombay, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Respondent

WORK_OF_ART: Wagh's Fine Art Studio', Brahmesh and Mahabaleshwar, Brahmesh and Mahabaleshwar, Brahmesh and Mahabaleshwar, Brahmesh, Mahabaleshwar, 'The Arbitrator, Written Statements, Brahmesh and Mahabaleshwar, Firm of M/s. WFAS, Brahmesh, Law of Succession, Appellant as the Executor, Law of Succession, Stuchbery and Ors, Notification of 24th, Brahmesh, Brahmesh, Notification under Section 15 of the Act, Russell on Arbitration, Nineteenth Edition, Brahmesh and Mahabaleshwar, Brahmesh and Mahabaleshwar, Brahmesh and Mahabaleshwar, Firm, Firm, Brahmesh, Brahmesh under Section 5(11)(c, Brahmesh

QUANTITY: about 800 square feet, about 1200 square feet

FAC: Bench View, Beach View, Beach View Building, Senapati Bapat Marg, Beach View, Beach View, Beach View, Beach View, Govalia Tank Road, the Bombay Rents, the Bombay Rents, Beach View, Late Shri Vinayakrao, Beach View

PRODUCT: Plaint, Plaint, Award, Article, Schedule, Article, Award, Respondent, Appellant, Appellant, Agreement, Calcutta Metropolitan

TIME: 13(j

EVENT: the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act