Minoo Framroze Balsara Vs. the Union of India and Others

Decided On : Feb-01-1991

Court : Mumbai

LAW: the Eviction Act, Act 61 of 1980, the Companies Act, the Companies Act, a Central Act, the Eviction Act, the Bombay Rent Act', the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Section 4.(1, Section 5, Section 8, the Eviction Act, the Code of CivilProcedure, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Constitution, the Premises Act, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Article 14 or, Article 19(1)(g, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Article 14, Article 14.13, Article 14, Article 31(5)(a, Article 19(1)(f, Article 31(2, Article 13(2, Article 19(5, Article 19(1)(f, the Industrial Disputes Act, Article 14, Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 141 of the Constitution, Article 14 of the Constitution and it, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Article 14, Article 14, Article 14, the Eviction Act, Article 14, the Eviction Act, Article 14, Article 141, Article 141, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(g, Article 14, The Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(f).19, Article 19(1)(f, the Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(f, Article 19 of the Constitution, Article 19(1)(f, Article 19(1)(f, Article 19(1)(f, Article 19(1)(f, Article, Article 19(1)(f, the Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(f, the Constitution Bench, Article 13(1, Article 13(2, Article 13 of the Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Article 368, Constitution, Article 13(2, Constitution, Constitution, Article 13, Constitution, the Constitution Bench, Constitution, Article 13(1, Article 13(2, Constitution, Constitution, A Constitution Bench, Article 19, Article 13(2, Article 19, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Article 13, Article 13(2, Article 13(2, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, Constitution, the Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(f, Article 19(1)(f, Constitution, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(f, Article 19(1)(f).31, Article 19(1)(f, the Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(f, Article 19(1)(f, the Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(f, the Eviction Act, Article 19(1)(f).33, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Section 2(g, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Section 4, Section 4, Section 8, Section 5, the Rent Act, Section 2(e, Section 2(e, the Public Premises Act, Section 5, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Section 5, Section 4, Section 5, Section 5, Section 4, Section 5, Section 5, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4, Section 4, the Eviction Act, Section 4 of the Act, Section 5 ', Section 4, Section 5 viz., Section 4, Section 4, the Eviction Act, Section 4, Article 254(2) whichreads:'(2, The Eviction Act, Act 61 of 1980, Article 254(2, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Article 254(2, the Eviction Act, Section 2 of Act II, Article 254(2, an Extension Act, the 1967 Act, the Eviction Act, Article 254(2, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Article 254(2, Article 200 of the Constitution of India, Article 254(2, Article 200 of the Constitution of India, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, a Central Act, the Punjab Act, the Central Act, the Punjab Act of, Article 254 of the Constitution in so far, the Central Act, Article 254(2, Constitution, the State Act, Central Act, the Punjab Act, the Eviction Act, Article 254(2, Article, Article 254(2, Article 254(2, the Constitution Section 6-R(2, the U. P. Act, Article 254(2, Article 31 or, Article 31-A, Article 254(2, Article 254, the Punjab Act ', the Central Act, a State Act, Article 254(2, Central Act, the Punjab Act of, Article 254 of the Constitution in so far, the Central Act, Article 254(2, Article 254(2, Constitution, the Transfer of'Property Act, the State Act, Central Act, the Eviction Act, the Eviction Act, Article 254(2, a State Act, Article 254(2, the Principal Act, Article 254(2, the Eviction Act, Constitution, Section 4, the Eviction Act

ORG: ORDERBharucha, the Public Premises (Eviction of Unauthorised Occupants) Act, the Central Government, the Central Government, Arts, Hotel, Lodging House Rates Control Act, Parliament, S. 2(c, and(b, sub-sec, sub-sec, S. 4, sub-sec, EstateOfficer, the Bombay Rent Act, Estate, SupremeCourt, the Punjab Public Premises and Land (Eviction and Rent Recovery, the Supreme Court, the District Board, Municipal Committee, Notified Area Committee, Panchayat, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, the Bombay Municipal Corporation Act, the Bombay Government Premises (Eviction, Municipal and Government, Court, Municipal and Government, Civil, Municipal and Government, Municipal and Government, premises.10, M/s. Jain Ink, Court, Maganlal Chagganlal, Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, the Supreme Court, Ashoka Marketing Ltd., Punjab National Bank, the Delhi Rent Control Act, the Supreme Court, Arts, S. 2(e, The Supreme Court, the Statement of Objects, the Supreme Court, the Municipal Corporation, the Bombay Rent Act, Jain Ink, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Court, Jain Ink, the Supreme Court.14, the Supreme Court, Somawanti v. Slate of Punjab, TheSupreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Court, the Supreme Court, General Mills Co. Ltd., Shambhu Nath Mukherji, S. 10, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Court, Niemla Textile Finishing Mills, the Supreme Court, Union of India, The Supreme Court, Shri Krishna Investment v. Union of India, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Jain Ink, Maganlal Chhaganlal's, Jain Ink, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Bengal Immunity Co., State of Bihar, the Supreme Court, Court, Court, The Bombay Rent Act, The Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, The Supreme Court, Bombay Corporation v., the Bombay Rent Act, the Supreme Court, the City Civil Court, the Colaba Land Mill Chawls, The Municipal Corporation, the State Government, the Bombay Municipal Corporation Act, the Municipal Corporation, The Bombay Rent Act, the Municipal Corporation, the Supreme Court, Hotel, Lodging House Rates Control Act, the Bombay Rent Act, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Bombay Rent Act, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Andhra Pradesh Scheduled Area Land Transfer Regulation, the Supreme Court, U.P., State, Legislature, The Supreme Court, SagirAhmad, U.P., AIR 1954 SC, the U. P. Road Transport Act, J. This, Legislature, State, State, State, Court, the Supreme Court, State, Legislature, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Bombay Rent Act, Government Companies and Corporations, Government Companies and Corporations, the Maharashtra State Law Commission, Rent Restriction Laws, State, the Life Insurance Corporation of India Ltd., LIC, LIC, the Transfer of Property Act, Sections 4, Estate, Estate, a Civil Court, Ashoka Marketing Ltd., the Supreme Court, the Public Premises Act, the Life Insurance Corporation, the Public Premises Act, Court, Sons v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Bombay, the Bombay Rents, Hotel, Lodging House Rates ' Control Act, the Bombay Port Trust, the Public Premises Act, the Public Premises Act, the Rent Control Act, the Public Premises Act, Marfatia, Ashoka Marketing, the Karnataka High Court, The Indian Bank Ltd., M/s. Blaze and Central (P.) Ltd., AIR, Kar 258, Estate, the Karnataka High Court, Sections 4, Sections 4, Estate, Estate, Estate, Union of India, Tribunal, Estate, the Calcutta High Court, Standard Literature Co. v. Union of India, the Calcutta High Court, Sections 4, Calcutta High Court, the Supreme Court, Marfatia, the Legislature of a State, Parliament, Legislature, State, State, the Legislature of the State, Central, The Bombay Rent Act, State, The Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, Court, Legislature, the Bombay High Court, the Allahabad High Court, State of Uttar Pradesh, The Benaras Electric Light, Power Co. Ltd., Court, the Supreme Court, Kerala State Electricity Board, Indian Aluminium Co. Ltd., The Supreme Court, the Electricity (Supply) Act, State Electricity Board's, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, the State of Maharashtra, Court, the Life Insurance Corporation of India, Central, State, the Bombay Rent Act, Court, the State of Maharashtra, the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, the Bombay Rent Act, the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly, the Maharashtra Legislative Council, the Bombay Rents, Hotel, Lodging House Rates Control Act, the Transfer of Property Act, the Presidency Small Cause Courts Act, the Concurrent Legislative List, the State of Maharashtra, the Government of Maharashtra, Law and Judiciary Department, the State of Maharashtra, the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, the Maharashtra Legislative Council, the Maharashtra Legislative Assembly, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rents, Hotel, Lodging House Rates Control Act, the Transfer of Property Act, the Presidency Small Cause Courts Act, the Concurrent Legislative List, the Supreme Court, the Bombay Rent Act, the Supreme Court, the Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, the Administration of Evacuee Property Act, the Supreme Court's, the High Courtshows, the State Government, Court, the High Court, Parliament, the High Court, Clause(2, the State Government, the State Legislature, Parliament, State, the Bombay Rent Act, the Transfer of Property Act, the Bombay Rent Act, the Transfer of Property Act, the Bombay Rent Act, State, the Concurrent List, State, Parliament, Central, State, Parliament, U.P. Electric Supply Co. Ltd., The Supreme Court, Parliament, Central, The Supreme Court, M/s. Hoechst Pharmaceuticals Ltd., State of Bihar, Court, the High Court, Parliament, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the High Court, the Supreme Court, Central, The Supreme Court, the Bombay Rent Act, the Transfer of Property Act, the Bombay Rent Act, The Supreme Court, the Bombay Rent Act, the Bombay Rent Act, the Transfer of Property Act, the Bombay Rent Act, The U. P. Electric Supply Co. Etd.'s, Hoechst Pharmaceutical Ltd., State, the Government of Maharashtra, the Government of India, the Ministry of Home Affairs, the Bombay Rent Act, the Concurrent Legislative List, the Presidency Small Cause Courts Act, the Government of India, the State Legislature, State, the Bombay Rent Act, the Transfer of Property Act, the Government of India, the State Legislatures, the Bombay Rent Act, the State of Maharashtra, us,62, the City Civil Court, the City Civil Court

NORP: J.1, contra, addressee, addressee, addressee, addressee, addressee

DATE: 1971, 1971, 22nd December, 1980, 1956, 1956, 1971, 1947, 1971, 1971, seven days, fifteen days, 1971, less than ten years, 14, 1971, 1971, 1967]3SCR399, 1959, 1971, 1959, 14, 14, 14, 1971, 1958, 1971, 41, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1978)ILLJ1SC, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, S. 12, 1947, '21, 3, 4, 1959, June 20, 1979, 1971, 20th June 1979, 26th January, 1950, 1951, 1951, Article 13(1, 1971, 20th June, 1979, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, July, 1979, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1947, 1971, 1971, 1967, 1971, '42, 1958, 1956, 45, '47, 1971, 22nd December, 1980, 22nd December, 1980, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1971, 1950, 1961, 5 years, 1967, '5 years', 7 years', five years', seven years', 1948, '51, 1971, 1971, 1971, 22nd December, 1980, 3rd January, 1981, 5 years, 31st March, 1981, 1947, 1882, 1881, 13, 46, five years, 4th March, 1981, 7th March, 1981, 30th January, 1986, 3rd January, 1981, 5 years, 1st April, 1986, 1947, 1882, 1882, 13, 46, five years, 25th February, 1986, 23rd February, 1971, 1971, 1953, 1950, 1953, 1950, 1953, 1950, 1953, '55, 1971, 1957, 1950, 1953, 1950, 1971, December 1980, up to 30th March 1986, 13, 46, 1882, 1882, 1989, 11th January 1989, a period of, 10 days, a period of, eight weeks, today, eight weeks

CARDINAL: 2, less than fifty-one, 14, 1971.2, 4, 5, 3, 1, 2, 1, between two, 14, two, two, one, 14, 1975]1SCR1, 7, 1967]3SCR399, 14, 14, 1975]1SCR1, 1990]3SCR649, 2(e, 14, 21, two, 1961CriLJ31, 1963]2SCR774, 1955]1SCR777, two, three, 1988]3SCR738, 1971.15, two, one, one, two, two, 8, 26, 28).16, 1955]2SCR603, 1971.17, 1965]1SCR542, 18, 1, 2, 4A, two, 24, 26, 1955CriLJ215, 128, two, 13(2, 13(2, two, two, 13(2, 1955]2SCR589, 13(2, 1955]1SCR707, 1974]3SCR760, 19, 19, 19, 19, 19, one, 1972]1SCR1055, two, 19, 19, one, 1971.34, 5, two-fold, 2, 3, 2, 3, 5, two, 671, 2, 1, 2, 31-3-1950, 31-3-1952, 1976]1SCR552, 6, 6, two, 1986.54, two, 1969)IILLJ728SC, 1985]154ITR64(SC, 2, 1971.58, 6, 1971.61, 1971.69

ORDINAL: first, Secondly, Thirdly, first, first, second, firstly, secondly, third, first, 5th

WORK_OF_ART: the Constitution of India, Transfer of Property Act, the Constitution of India, the Constitution of India

PERSON: Art, Art, Maganlal Chagganlal, Bench, Bhagwati, J., Khanna, J., Articles 39, Reasons, H. M. Seervai, Maganlal Chagganlal's, Seervai, Ranchhoddas Atmaram v. Union, Maganlal Chagganlal, Bhanji Munji, Somawanti, Delhi Cloth, Kumar Neotia v., Ghosh, Hari Singh, Ghosh, Seervai, Art, Art, Pancham, Pancham, P.Rami Reddy v. State of A.P., Bench, Seervai, MahendraLal Jaini v. State, Behram Khurshed Pesikaka, Stateof Bombay, Bhikaji Narain Dhakras, M. P. V. Sundararamier, Venkatarama Aiyar, Venkatarama Aiyar, J., Seervai, Mahendra Lal Jaini's, Sundara, Art, Art, Bhikaji Narain's, Art, Saghir Admad's, Mathew, J., Art, Art, Art, Mathew, J., Jagannath v. Authorised, Mathew, J., Bench, Rami Reddy's, Art, Mahendra Lal Jain's, Sundararamier, Art, Rami Reddy's, Seervai, Rami Reddy's, Sundararamier, Governnentcompany, Banks, Seervai, Seervai, Seervai, V. D. Tulzapurkar, Seervai, Karnataka, C. J., Heman Alreja's, Seervai, Seervai, Bill, Bill, Bill, Bill, Bill, Bill, Bill, Bill, Bill, Bill, Jamalpur Gram Panchayat v., Malwinder Singh, Gram Panchayat's, Seervai, R. K. Shukla, Gram Panchayat, Bill, an.d, Seervai, Bill, F Colly, Bill

FAC: the Bombay Rents, Maganlal Chagganlal's, Maganlal Chagganlal, Maganlal Chagganlal's, the Bombay Rents, Sections 4, Sections 4

GPE: India, Art, Art, Art, Art, Art, Smt, Bombay, Anil, India, Bombay, India, India, India, Art, Art, Art, Art, Gujarat, Ambica, Ambica, Ambica, Ambica, Ambica, Ambica, Bombay, Clauses, Clauses, Bombay, Chagla, Kerala, New Delhi, Bombay

LOC: Premises, Northern India Caterers, Northern India Caterers, the Northern India Caterers, the Northern India Caterers, the Northern India Caterers', Central Statutes, Northern India Caterers, the Northern India Caterers, Northern India Caterers, Northern India Caterers, the Northern India Caterers', the Northern India Caterers', the Northern India Caterers', the Northern India Caterers'

PRODUCT: Art, the Act XXXI, Interpreting Section 5, Bench, Articles

TIME: the 44th Amendment

EVENT: post-Constitution, pre-Constitution, post-Constitution, post-Constitution, post-Constitution, post-Constitutional, post-Constitution, post-Constitution, post-Constitution, post-Constitution, post-Constitution, post-Constitution, pre-Constitution, pre-Constitution, post-Constitutional, the 1967 Act, the 1967 Act