S R Kalal Vs. State Of Karnataka

Decided On : Jun-15-2021

Court : Karnataka Dharwad

LAW: Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Rule 12, Section 71, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, SCC188 25, Section 71 of the Act, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71 of the Act, Section 71(2)(e, Rule 12, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71(2)(e, Section 71, Rule 12, Section 71, Section 71, Section 71(3)(e, Rule 3, Section 71, Article 14, Article 14 of the Constitution, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Article 14 of the Constitution of India".17, Section 71(2)(e, Article 19(1)(g, Rule 12, Rule 12, Rule 12, Section 71(3)(e, Rule 3, Rule 5, Article 14 of the Constitution of India.23, Article 14 of the Constitution of India

ORG: THIS THE15H DAY OF JUNE, JUSTICE HEMANT CHANDANGOUDAR W.P No.147875/2020, Shri Raju S/o, Ramachandra Tikute, The State of Karnataka Represented, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, Excise Chikkodi Range Chikkodi, The Mysore Sales International Ltd, Sales International Ltd, Galataga, Taluk Nippani, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, W.P No.106715/2018, Occ: Business, Proprietor of Suresh Wines Sammasagi, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, Tq. & Dist, Tq. & Dist, The Mysore Sales International Limited, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Occ: Business, Kerur Proprietor, Occ: Business, Manjula Wines, Occ: Business, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, The Mysore Sales International Limited, Mysore Sales International Limited, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, Renuka W/o, 7 Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, Tq. & Dist, Tq. & Dist, The Mysore Sales International Limited, The Mysore Sales International Limited, Haveri, Tq. & Dist, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, Partner, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, The Mysore Sales International Limited, Mysore Sales International Limited, CTS No.477/1, Desai Cross Pinto Road, Hubballi-580020, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarnim AGA, R4, R5 & R6, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, Bengaluru-560001, The Mysore Sales International Limited Rep., Mysore Sales International Limited, CTS, Desai Cross, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, Hirekerur, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, Tq. & Dist, Haveri, Tq. & Dist, Haveri, The Mysore Sales International Limited, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, R4, Sri M S Hallikeri, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, Tq. & Dist, Haveri, Tq. & Dist, Haveri, The Mysore Sales International Limited, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, R4, Sri M S Hallikeri, CTS No.1001 & 1002/A Door No.3950/28, Haveri, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, Tq. & Dist, Haveri, Tq. & Dist, Haveri, The Mysore Sales International Limited Rep., K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, R4, Sri M S Hallikeri, M/s. Regal Wines, Department of Finance, The State of Karnataka Represented, Department of Excise, The Excise Commissioner Office, House, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, NYR, M/s Sarovara Wines Represented, M/s Sarovara Wines, Darur, Department of Finance, The State of Karnataka Represented, Department of Excise, The Excise Commissioner Office, Belagavi-590001, House, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, Occ: Business, The State of Karnataka Represented, the Department of Finance, The State of Karnataka Represented, the Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, The Mysore Sales International Limited, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayaka S Kulkarni, AGA, Occ: Business, Department of Excise, M S Building, Excise 2 Floor, TTMC Building, Tq. & Dist, Tq. & Dist, The Mysore Sales International Limited, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayak S Kulkarni, AGA, Occ: Business, Excise BMTC Building, Mysore Sales International Limited, K Vidyawati, Additional AG, Sri Vinayak S Kulkarni, AGA, R1 to R4 & R7 & R8, R5 & R6, Annexure-K, Authority, the State Government, Government, CL, State, the State Government, State, State, State, the Apex Court, STATE OF T.N., the Apex Court, Court, NAGARAJ, Authority, Court, the Apex Court, K.S. SHYAM SUNDER, Court, MARTIN, Court, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, M.S.JAIRAJ, SAI CHALCHITRA, Sri K N Phaneendra, the Apex Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, State, Mandya District Wines Merchant Association, Court, the Apex Court, Learned Additional Advocate, the State Government, State, the State Government, State, The State Government, the State Government, (Indian Liquor, State, State, State, State, State, State, the State Government, Government, fixed.-, the State Government, Supreme Court, SLP, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, the State Government, State, Government, State, The Apex Court, the State Government, State, State, The Apex Court, The Apex Court, Sections 13, this State Legislature, the State Legislature, Indian Express News Paper, P) Ltd., Union of India, Court, Court, The Apex Court, Khoday Distilleries Ltd., the Apex Court, Khoday Distilleries Ltd., Act.18, Government, the Apex Court, Khoday Distilleries Ltd., State, Government, Court, STATE, MANDYA, the Licensing Authority, the Division Bench, the State Government, Act, Court, Court, MARTIN, FINANCE DEPARTMENT, State, State, State, the Apex Court, the Apex Court, State, State, State, State, State, State, State, State, State, Government, Martin, the Apex Court, Khody, CL-2, The Apex Court, the Apex Court, Sd/-

DATE: 2021, 106956/2018, 102705/2019, 146644/2020, 147315/2020, 147472/2020, 147539/2020, 147559/2020, 147637/2020, 147638/2020, 146935/2020, 147962/2020, 147867/2020, Age 43 years, Age 47 years, 1968, 1965, Age 49 years, 45, 1968, 1965, Age 60 years, Age 54 years, Age 50 years, Age 24 years, Age 53 years, 1968, 1965, Age 30 years, Age 37 years, 1968, 1965, Age 53 years, 1968, 1965, Age 53 years, 1968, 1965, Age 36 years, 581111, Age 56 years, 581111, Age 33 years, 581111, 580 110.5, R5 12, 1968, 1965, Age 39 years, 1968, 1965, Age 74 years, 581106, 580 110.5, 1968, 1965, Age 38 years, Age 22 years, 591304, 1968, 1965, Age 26 years, 1968, 1965, 46 years, 1910, 1968, 1965, Age 70 years, 1968, 1965, Age 47 years, 19.4.2021, this day, 1968, 23.9.2016, 1968, 1965, Rule 12, 2006 4, 1998, 1986, ILR1999Kar. 2903, 2011 8, 2012, 2000 7 SCC552and, 2005 3, 1976, 1996 10, 12.6.2003, 1965, 1968, Rule 12, 27 June, 2017, 31 December, 2017, the Excise year 2017-18, 12166 of 2016, 2016, the year, annual, 4) xxx.].10, 1995, 37, 15, 38, 2343, 2003, 2018

PERSON: Sri Shivaraj, Belagavi, Sai Plaza Nippani, Cunningam Road, District Liaison, Sri Malappa, Sri Mrutyunjay S Hallikeri, Sri Harshawardan M Patil, Hale Sammasagi, Haveri, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Haveri, Haveri, Haveri, Cunningham Road, Sri Mrutyunjay S Hattikeri, Geeta Bar, Badami Dist, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Bagalakote, Bagalakote, Cunningham Road, Sri Mrutyunjay S Hattikeri, Shamiulla, Shaila Ningappa, Kallapur Tq, Irappa Koragar Age, Kallapur Tq, Haveri, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Haveri, Haveri, Cunningham Road, Zilla Samparka Adhikari Beverage Division, Haveri, Sri Mrutyunjay S Hattikeri, Sri B S Goutham, Dharwad, Narayan Chandrashekar Kalal, Dharwad Tq, Dharwad-580007, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Dharwad, Dharwad-580007.4, Dharwad, Cunningham Road, K-2, Floor, Dharwad, Hubballi Dist, Dharwad, Narayan Chandrashekar Kalal, Hubballi, Dharwad-580001, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Dharwad, Dharwad, Dharwad, Cunningham Road, Mahalakshmi, Floor, Hubballi, BETWEEN1 Nagaraj D, Hirekerur, Haveri, Hirekerur, Hirekerur, Haveri, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Haveri, Haveri, Cunningham Road, Partner, Sri Manohar, Haveri, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Haveri, Excise Haveri, Cunningham Road, Krishnaji Ramanna, Byadagi Tq, Byadagi, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Haveri, Excise Haveri, Cunningham Road, Shri Anil, Bhimarao Kapali, Vikrampur Athani, Sri Jagadish Patil, Vidhan Soudha, Vidhan Soudha, Shantinagar, Belagavi District, Mysuru Sales, Cunningham Road, Uday Kasappa Nimbaragi, Nimbaragi Tota, Athani Rural, Sadashiv Butali, Sri Jagadish Patil, Vidhan Soudha, Vidhan Soudha, Shantinagar, Belagavi District, Mysuru Sales, Cunningham Road, Amol Deelipkumar Naik, Sri Vithal S, Devanna, Devendra Kamblekar Age, Jamakhandi, Vidhan Soudha, Belagaum District, Excise Belgaumi District, Cunningham Road, Nehru Nagar, Chikodi-590001, Raibag Circle, Maruti Karigar Age 45 years, Occ, Gram Panchayat, Sri Vithal S, Ramachandra Kalal, Vijaya Nagar, Haveri Town, Haveri, Sri F V Patil, Ambedkar Veedhi, Haveri, Haveri, Cunningham Road, Sri Mrutyunjay S Hattikeri, Ramagouda Narasagouda Patil, Kagawad, Department of, Belagavi, Cunningham Road, District Liaison, Mujawar Building, Kagwad Circle, Kagwad, Kagwad Dist, F.V. Patil, Bench, Kar, LJ16, Bench, Martin, F.V. Patil, HAJI BASHIR AHMED, Bench, Martin, Martin, XXXX, Rule, Rule, Rule, Bench, individuals.22, Sai Chalchitra

CARDINAL: 001.2, 2, 201.6, 3, 5, 6, R6, 8, 001.2, 580, 3, 9, 001.2, 103, 580 001.5, 3, 112, 560, 001.2, 580, 110, 135, 001.2, 143, 15, 001.2, 16, 001.2, 176, R6, 001, 182, R6, 203, 21, 1, 590010.7, No.4, 5, 13.11.2018, 17.12.2018, 7.9.2020, No.4, 5, 22, 6.10.2016, No.2, 1.7.2003, 23, 12, No.1, 11, 24 ii, 12(3, 8, two, 12, 2011(3, 26, 7, 27, 29.03.2016, No.5, 1, 28, 30.6.2003, No.1, 4, 29, 30.6.2003, 12, 71, 1, 2, 3, 3, 1-A, 32, 11, 11, 11, 11, 1, 12, 1, one, 33, 15-12-2016, 2, 3, One, 7,500, 3,500, One, 15,000, 7,500, 3-a, 34, 12, 11, 35, 2, 11, 2, 3, 1, 39, 40, 3, 11, 3.9.2003, 43, 29.03.2016, 12, 29.03.2016, four, 45, two, 29.03.2016, 29.03.2016, 11

WORK_OF_ART: A’ Block, Managing Director.8, A’ Block, A’ Block, Jamakhandi, Dist: Bagalakot, A’ Block, 27.9.2018, the Constitution of India

PRODUCT: Shantinagar, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Shantinagar, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, B S Bannur, Shantinagar, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Shantinagar, R6, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Shantinagar, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Shantinagar, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Shantinagar, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Shantinagar, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Shantinagar, Managing, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Shantinagar, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Managing, Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, No.1, VS, Rule 3(11)(c, VS

GPE: Belagavi District, Karnataka, Bengaluru, Halapet, Badami, Kerur, Badami, Badami, Badami, Kerur, Karnataka, Bengaluru, Kallapur, Karnataka, Belur, Occ, Karnataka, Occ, Varur Village, Karnataka, Occ, Chikkerur, Occ, Occ, Karnataka, Occ, Karnataka, Occ, Karnataka, Bengaluru-560002, Karnataka, Karnataka, BMTC, Belagavi District, Karnataka, Bengaluru, Bengaluru, Karnataka, Belagavi District, Shirguppi village, the State of Karnataka, Karnataka, Rules, Bombay, England, India, England, India, MSIL, Judges, Jasbhai

NORP: Indian, Dist, Indian, Dist, Dist, Dist, Dist, Indian, Dist, Dist, Dist, Indian, Indian, Dist, Dist, Indian, Dist, Medur, Dist, Dist, Indian, Dist, Indian, Dist, Indian, Indian, Dist, Indian, Indian, Dist, Indian, Dist, Dist, Indian, Indian, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, KARNATAKA, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Taluk, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, Rules, KARNATAKA, Rules, Rules, Rules, Legislative, Rules, Rules, CL2

FAC: Pinto Road

MONEY: 002.2, 1) xxxx, 2) xxxx, 3) xxxx, 4) xxxx, 5) xxxx, 6) xxxx, 7) xxxx, 8) xxxx, 9) xxxx, 10) xxxx

LOC: Shantinagar, Respondent

ORDINAL: 1st, 5th, 5th