Tajvir Singh Sodhi Vs. The State Of Jammu And Kashmir

Decided On : Mar-28-2023

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: The Advertisement Notice, Order 12/2016, Order 277 of, Order 12 of 2016, Order 134/2016, Order 277 of, Order 277 of, Article 226 of the Constitution, Article 226, the Advertisement Notice, Rule 10 of the 1992 Rules, Article 14, Rule 9, Rule 9, Act (ii

ORG: THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL, Leave Petition (C, SINGH SODHI & ORS, I.A. No.21153/2022, I.A. No.21153/2022, I.A. No.21154/2022, I.A. No.3739/2022, State of Jammu, SLP, SLP, SLP, SLP, SLP, the High Court of Jammu, the High Court of Jammu, the Division Bench, the High Court, Letters Patent Appeal, SLP, the High Court of Jammu, the High Court of Jammu, Kashmir Subordinate Services Selection and Recruitment Board, Board, Kashmir Subordinate Services Recruitment Rules, RBA, Social Categories, Pharmacy or Pharmaceutical Chemistry, Post-Graduate Degree, the Central Government, the Institution of Chemists, University, The Board, Points Institution of Chemists, Institution, P.G. Pharmacy/Medicine 25 Points, Board, Pharmaceutical Chemistry, Chemistry with Pharmaceutical, Associateship, the Institution of 4, Points Laboratory, Institution, P.G. Pharmacy/ Medicine/ 10 Points Pharmaceutical Chemistry 7, Board, the Select List, Food Control Organisation of Jammu, Select List, RBA, The Board, the Health and Medical Education Department, the Office of the Controller, Drug and, Food Control Organisation of Jammu, Appointment Orders, the Pay Scale of Rs.9300-34800, Writ Petition (Service, the Pharmacy Council of India, the Advertisement Notice, University, the Central Government, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, Board, the Interview Committee, the Interview Committee, MBBS, SWP No.1685 of, the High Court of Jammu, the High Court, Committee, the Selection Committee, the High Court, the Select List, the High Court, the Selection Board, Department of Pharmacology, Post, Bachelor, Court, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee/Interview Board, Committee, the Selection Committee/Interview Board, the Selection Process, the High Court, Court, Court, the Selection Board, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Board, Pharmacy/Medicine, the Selection Committee, University, Post, Court, Select List, the Respondent Board, Board, Selection Committee, Selection Committee, the Convenor of the Selection Committee, Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the intending department, the intending department, Board, Letters Patent Appeals, Board, the High Court, the High Court, Department of Pharmacology, Government Medical, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Division Bench, the Selection Committee, the Select List, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, Board, the Respondent-Board, Selection Committee, the Division Bench, the High Court of Jammu, SLP, the High Court, the High Court, Board, Court, Impugned Judgment No, Impugned passed Judgment, SLP, Impugned Judgment No, Impugned passed Judgment, RBA, the High 279/2015 Court, Jammu & 105/2016, SLP, Jammu &, SLP, Impugned Judgment No, Impugned passed Judgment, the High Court, Jammu & 278 of 2015, SLP, Shivani Select List, Bakshi & 08.09.2009, J&K, Residents of Court, RBA, Jammu & Kashmir, SLP, Bhardwaj, Social Category, Court, Jammu &, Impugned Judgment No, Impugned passed Judgment, Jammu & Kashmir, SLP, the State of of, Health and Medical Court, Education Department, Jammu & 279, SLP, Recruitment Board, Impugned Judgment No, Impugned passed Judgment, the High Court of Jammu & Kashmir, SLP, Recruitment Board, Jammu & Kashmir, SLP, Diary No.1194 of, SLP, Additional Solicitor General, Madhavi Goradia Divan, Board, Respondents, the High Court of Jammu, Court, the Selection Committee, Select List, Board, the Selection Committee, fed, Board, Select List, Board, the Board, the Selection Committee, Reliance, Reserve Bank of India, a Selection Committee, Selection Committee, Selection Committee, a Selection Committee, Union of India, University of Mysore, Court, Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation, a Selection Committee, Select List, Board, Indian Railway Construction Co. Ltd., P.P. Sharma, Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., SCC764 Union of India, Selection Committee or Board, Reliance, National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences, Union of India, Reliance, Court, a Writ Court, the High Court, the High Court, State of J&K, Court, Court, Court, Committee, Reliance, Union of India, Bilash Chand Jain, a Writ Court, Appellate Court, the High Court, the Writ Jurisdiction, State of Uttar Pradesh, Reliance, Court, Delhi Subordinate Service Selection Board, State of Punjab, SCC356 Union of India, a Writ Court, Court, Committee, Court, State, Haryana, the High Court, the Select List, the Writ Court, Board, Baba Mast Nath University, Committee, Baba Mast Nath University, Vinayaka Mission under Court Orders, Vinayaka Mission, the Select List, the Select List, Diary No.1194 of, the Actual Line of Control (A.L.C., the High Court, Select List, Board, the Writ Court, the High Court, Diary No.1194 of, Actual Line of Control (A.L.C., ALC, ALC, the Select List, Board, Diary No.1194 of, the High Court, Board, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, Board, Committee, the Selection Committee, Expert/Specialist, Board, the Selection Committee, the Board, IAS, the Board (Kashmir Administrative Officer, the Government Medical College, Board, Committee, Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, Court, Court, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, SLP, Respondents, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, Court, State of J&K, Board, Board, Recruitment and Selection, Board, Board, the Selection Committee, Board, Reliance, the 42 Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the High Court, the Selection Committee, Serial No.14, Board, Serial No.17 to Serial No.4, Respondents, the High Court, the High Court, Court, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, Pharmacology, the Central Government, the Selection Board, the Selection Committee, Board, the High Court, the Selection Committee, the Selection Board, State, Umadevi, Court, the High Court, Court, the High Court of Jammu, Selection Process for Public Employment: Interference, Court, Secy, Health & F.W., the Public Service Commission, Court, Union Public Service Commission, the Selection Committee, an Appellate Authority, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, Tribunal, an Appellate Authority, Selection Committee, Tribunal, the Selection Committee, Tribunal, the Selection Committee, the High Courts, Selection Committee, Appellate Authority, Court, Delhi Stock Exchange Association Ltd., Court, the Delhi Stock Exchange, the Selection Committee, Court, the Expert Committee, the Expert Committee, Committee, the Expert Committee, the Central Government, a Selection Committee, Courts, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee, the Selection Committee/Interview Board, Court, the Advertisement Notice, State of Bihar, SCC576 this Court, the Uttar Pradesh Medical Health and Family Welfare Department Physiotherapist, Occupational Therapist Service Rules, Court, Court, the General Rules, Board, State of Bihar, The High Court, the Select List, the High Court, Select List, Court, Court, Court, Court, Union of India, S. Vinodh, SCC100 this Court, Court, the Selection Board, the High Court, Court, UP Public Service Commission, Allahabad, the State of Uttar Pradesh, the Public Service Commission, Court, Court, Court, Select List, the General Administration Department, Board, the Selection Committee an Expert/Specialist, Committee, Board, Committee, Board, Committee, Committee, Committee, Board, Committee, Board, Committee, Board, Committee, Board, District Level Selection Committees, Patwaris, Government, the State/Divisional/District, I. State Cadre, Board, Department, Administrative, Board, Convenor, Board, Committee, Board, District Employment, Board, Committee, the Divisional level Selection Committee, Selection Committee, Divisional/District, Committees, Board, Board, Committee/Committees, Board, The District Employment, Selection Committee, Board, Interviews, Committee, Selection Committee, The Final Award Roll, Board, the High Court, Board, Select List, the Selection Committee, Select List, the Selection Committee, Committee, fed, Board, Select List, the Selection Board, the High Court, The High Court, Reliance, the Selection Board, Department of Pharmacology, Post, 6th Edition, the Oxford Concise Medical Dictionary, 7th Edition, Post, the Selection Board, Selection Committee, Board, the High Court, Court, State of, State of J & K, Court, State, the Advertisement Recast Criteria, Chemistry with Pharmaceutical, the Institution of Chemists (, Institution of Chemists, Graduate in Medicines, Science of University, Science of a University, Institution, Institution, P.G. Pharmacy/, P.G. Pharmacy/ Medicine/, Viva, Across the Board Total, Corrigendum, Selection Committee, Select List, the Selection List, the High Court of Jammu, the Division Bench, the High Court of Jammu, the High Court of Jammu

DATE: 2164-2172, 2021, 2182-2190/2023, 2191-2199/2023, 2173-2181/2023, 2201-2203/2023, 2204-2212/2023, 2213-2215/2023, 8th September, 2009, 12th November, 2009, 2021, 20790-20798, 2021, 20799-20807, 2021, 2022, 12th November, 2009, 18th December 2015, 2009, 29th October, 2021, 2015, 2022, 6th July, 2017, 18th December, 2015, 05th May, 2008, 1992, 2008, at least one year, daily, 31st May, 2009, 12th June, 2009, at least one year, 8th September, 2009, 15th October, 2009, 12th November, 2009, 2009, May, 2008, 12th June 2009, 2009, 2009, 2009, 2009, 2009, 1846, 2009, 1535, 2009, 18th December 2015, 18th December 2015, seven years, Rs.9300-34800, four weeks, 8th September, 2009, six months, 18.12.2015, 29th October, 2021, 29th October, 2021, 8th September, 2009, the last seven years, 2008, May 2008, September 2009, May 2008, six months, 29th October, 2021, 6th July, 2017, September 2009, 2021, 29th 98/2016, October, 134/2016, 2021, 08.09.2009, 20798, 2021, 29th, October, 2021 134/2016, 08.09.2009, 2015, 2021, 29th 12 of 2016, October, 2021 98 of 2016, 08.09.2009, 2016, 2015, 2016, 1685/2009, July, 2022, 29th 97 of 2016, October, 2021 134 of 2016, 08.09.2009, 29th, October, 135/2016, 2021, 2642-2650, 2022, 29th 12 of 2016, October, 2021 98 of 2016, 2016, the High 135 of 2016, 2015, 2016, 2022, 29th, October, 2021, 4359-4364, 29th 12/2016, October, 2021, 135/2016, 20781-20789, 2021, 2022, 20790, 20798, 2021, 29th October, 2021, 2004, 2006, 2008, 1964, 2007, 2003, 1992, 2005, 2005, 30 7.4, 1992, 2008, 2020, 1995, 2009, 2020, 2017, 2021, 2006, 2003, 1985, 12th November, 2009, 13 years, 2001, 34, 30th November, 2010, 35, 42, 14, 2022, 8th September, 2009, 2022, May, 2008, 2022, 29th October, 2021, 18th December 2015, 13.67, 18th December, 2015, 2003, February 2015, 6 years, 30th November, 2010, 4310, 2006, long years, 8th September, 2009, 12th November, 2009, 48, 1996, 2008, 21, 1994, May, 2008, 12th June, 2009, 2010, 2013, 1998, 2017, 2007, 1991, 2006, 12, 1991, 58, 14.5, 1992, 1992, the year 1995 – 96, June 2009, 07th September, 2009, 6415, 1992, 1971, 1980, 05th May, 2008, 12th June, 2009 01, 05, at least one year, at least one year, 25 06, 07, 07, 12th June, 2009, 65, 12th June, 2009, six months, 18th December 2015, 29th October, 2021, 6th July, 2017, 18th December, 2015, 8th September, 2009, 12th November, 2009, 28th March,, 2023

PERSON: APPELLANT(S, I.A. No.21154/2022, Diary No.1194/2022, Backward Areas, i. Degree, Pay Band, Notification, Srinagar Bench, Samina Farhat, Graduate Degree, Graduate Degree, Order, Samina Farhat, Vinod Chatterji Koul, Vinod Chatterji Koul, Vinod Chatterji Koul, Ladakh, Areas, Ladakh, Ashish, Gupta, Rumessa, Mohammad, Pankaj Malhotra, Ladakh, Srinagar 4, Order, Gagan, Ladakh, Srinagar, Schedule, Caste, Schedule Tribe, Ladakh, U.T., Ladakh, Ladakh, Ladakh, Sri Ranjit, Kumar, Sri Shoeb Alam, Sri Sanjay Hegde, S. Janani, Sri Shoeb Alam, Ladakh, ’s Order, C.L. Toora, Bikash Kuanar, Sadananda Halo, Momtaz Ali 29 Sheikh, C.D. Govinda Rao, Himanshu Ghanshyambhai, Himanshu Ghanshyambhai, Ajay Kumar, Supp, Ashok Kumar, K. Kalyana Raman, Supp, R. Venkatasubbaiah, Baidyanath Yadav, Aditya Narayan Roy, Mohd, Mustafa, Mustafa, Sadananda Halo, Madan Lal, Madan Lal, Anupal Singh, Sadananda Halo, Mohd, Mustafa, R. Helen Thilakom, Sri Shoeb Alam, Rajesh P.U., P.U., Madan Lal, Kumar Yadav, Buddhi Nath Chaudhary, Abahi Kumar, Patwalia, Pankaj Malhotra, Ashish Gupta, Rumeesa Mohammad, Rumeesa Mohammad, M. Pharma, Order, M. Pharma, M. Pharma, Pankaj Malhotra, M. Pharma, M. Pharma, Sri Sanjay Hegde, Scheduled Tribe, Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe, Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe, Caste, Scheduled Tribe, Scheduled Caste, Madhavi Goradia Divan, Order, wherein, Jasvinder Singh, Trivedi Himanshu Ghanshyambhai, Rumessa Mohammad, Ashish Gupta, Pankaj Malhotra, M. Pharma, Rumessa Mohammad, Rumessa Mohammad, Ashish Gupta, S. Janani, Samina Farhat, M. Pharma, Courts:12, Dalpat Abasaheb Solunke, B.S. Mahajan, Anita Puri, M. V. Thimmaiah, Rajesh Kumar Maheshwari, Chandra Shah, Anil Joshi, Chandra Prakash Tiwari, Shakuntala Shukla, Munindra Kumar, Rajiv Govil, Rashmi Mishra v. M.P. Public Service Commission, Sadananda Halo, Bench, Anamica Mishra, Rajesh P.U., Cadre, District Cadre, Divisional Cadre, District Cadre, Cadre, Salma Hamid, Samina Farhat, Trivedi Himanshu Ghanshyambhai, Samina Farhat, P. Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon, Minor A. Peeriakaruppan, Tamil Nadu, Nishi Maghu, SCC95, Lila Dhar

PRODUCT: VS, the Srinagar Bench, SWP Nos, Order 97/2016, Order 98/2016, SCC601to, Malhotra, Rule 9

CARDINAL: 6337-6339, 2, sixty-four, 967-975, 3, 1., 4, twenty, 549, 72, 42, 14, 16, 5, at least one-year, 5.2, 55, 55, 55, 55, 6, 20, 100, 5.3, 65, 7, 2, 65, 3, 65, 65, 5, 65, 6, 05, 8, 20, 100, 8 5.4, sixty-four, 42, 22, 14, 5.5, 5.6, 56, 9, 10, 20, 5.7, three, 11 ii, 5.8, 13, 14, 15, 5.9, three, 16, 17, 5.10, nine, nine, three, 278/2015, 12/2016, at least one, three, three, three, 97/2016, 105/2016, 5.11, 18, One, 19, 20, 21, 22, 5.12, 1, 23, 20789, 12/2016, 135/2016, 278/2015, 2, 135/2016, 3, 20799-, 20807, 97, 134, 24, 135, 105, 5, 967-975, 277, 98, 135, 279, 2015, 105, 25, 6, 1194/202, 2, 97, 134, 278, 105, 8, 3930-3932, 105/2016, 26, 9, 278/2015, 7.1, seven, two, 28, 4, 7.2, 8, 4, 4, 8, 4, 1, 7, 8, 2, 14, 16, 2022, 7.5, 31, 7.6, 16, 7.7, 2, 32, 9, 7.8, 4, 11, 7, 7.9, 33, 4, 7.10, 3, 7.12, three, three, three, 17, 17, 14 to 29, 2, 42.8, 368.1, 8.2, seven, six, two, 37, only three, two, sixty-four, Four, seven, three, six, 8.3, 38, 9.1, 9(1, one, 39, one, 9.2, three, three, 11.67, 11.33, 9.3, 40, 9.4, 2, 419.5, 10(i, 9.6., 16, 10.1, 4410.2, 10.3, 10.4, 45, 11, 20, three, 19, 20, 10.5, 10.6, 4, 4610.7, 84, 65, 65, 4, 25, only 17, 47, 6, 49, 30, 2, 5, 50, only 20, two, 12.1, 51, 20, 12, 52 ii, 11, 24, 4, 53, 27, twenty-seven, 14, fourteen, 45, 6, six, 4, four, 54, 8, 3, 13.1, 55, 13.2, 56, 14.1, three, 4, 57, 14.2, 1, 54, 14.3, 31, 9, one, 59, 9, 9A, 9, one, less than three, 60, one, 1, II, 1, three, 62, seven, Two, seven, 1:5, 63, 14.6, sixty-four, 9A, 15.1, 3, 65, 15.2, 66, 15.3, 67, 1, 4, 16.1, 55, 65, 02, 65, 03, 55, 65, 04, 55, 65, 55, 65, 06, 10, 20, 05, 100, 08, 20, 100, Only 20, 69, 16.3, 80, 70, One, 71, 18.1, 7218.2

LOC: Kashmir, Kashmir, Single, Kashmir, Single, Kashmir, Single, Kashmir, Jammu, Jammu, Kashmir, Kashmir, Jammu, Kashmir, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single, Single Judge, Single Judge, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single Judge, Single, Single, Single, Kashmir, Kashmir, Kashmir, Kashmir, Kashmir, Services Selection, Kashmir, Single, Single, Single, Single, Kashmir, Kashmir, Single Judge, Kashmir, District, district.3, Single Judge, Corrigendum, Single, Single, Single, Kashmir, Kashmir, Single, Kashmir, Kashmir

GPE: Srinagar, Jammu, Srinagar, India, India, P.G., Chemistry, India, P.G., India, Jammu, Srinagar, MD, 98/2016, Srinagar, Srinagar, 98/2016, Jammu, Jammu, Jammu, Srinagar, Jammu, Jammu, Srinagar, Bihar, Srinagar, Pankaj, M.D., Karnataka, Srinagar, the State of Jammu, India, Manish, Shahi, Ashok, Kumari, MD, MD, Rajasthan, Pharmacy, Chemistry, India, India, Srinagar, Jammu, Srinagar, the State of Jammu, New Delhi

WORK_OF_ART: Graduate in Medicines or Science of 55 Points a University, Graduate in Medicines or Science of a University, Ph.D. in Pharmacology, Judgment LPA Nos, Judgment LPA Nos, Ph.D. in Pharmacology, SCC282 this Court, SCC724, Ph.D. in Pharmacology, Ph.D. in Pharmacology

ORDINAL: 5th, 5th, 5th, 6th, 5th, Secondly, Thirdly, 5th, first

MONEY: 10 marks, 18 marks, 20 marks, 20 marks, 20 marks, 20 per cent, 10 marks, 18 marks, 20 marks, 10 marks, 85 marks, 15 marks, 90 marks, 10 marks, 100 marks

PERCENT: 100%, almost 20%, 85%, 15%, only 20%, 80%

EVENT: the Open 2017 Ors, Serial No.2, 9-A. Notwithstanding

LANGUAGE: U.T.

FAC: Kashmir Subordinate, Mohinder Sain Garg

QUANTITY: 3 SCC486(Madan Lal

NORP: D., Sarojakumari, Ashish, Petitioners, Convenor, Convenor, d.

TIME: 90:10 and