Union of India and Ors. Vs.pradeep Mathur and Ors.

Decided On : Oct-31-2019

Court : Delhi

LAW: Indian Societies Registration Act, the Constitution 2, Page 11, Page 12, Article 12 of the Constitution, the Governing Body of NWDA, Article 21 of The Constitution.30, the Governing Body, Page 17, Article 12, Constitution, Article 12 of the Constitution, Article 12, Page 19 of 28 old, Page 22, the Pension Scheme of the Central Government, Page 28

CARDINAL: 14, 15, three, 1, 2, two, 28, 3, 1967.7, 55, 238, 497, 4.35, 1.60, 28, 12, 1, 2, 28, 2.14, 2, 1, 49, 14, 6, 4, 1, 153, 68, 28, 11, 20, 9, 2019.21, 10, 3, 12, 7, 1, Two, 1, 1, 13, 6, 12, 3, 28, 3, 12, 117, 463, thousands, only 26, 25, 26, 26, 27, two, 3, 2, 3, 28, 28, two, 28, 8, two, two, 18, 28, 4, 1, more than one, one, more than one, 2, 20, 28, 28 41, 261, 4.5, 28, 3, 8.1, 8.2, 8.3, 13, 5, 28, three, three, 28, 28

DATE: October, 2019, October, 2019, 4115/2014, 10453/2019, + + +, 4599/2019, 20458/2019, 4115/2014, 4115/2014 1, 2nd January, 2014, 01.01.2004, 4115/2014, 2 months, one month, 1972, 1860, 1st January, 2004, 1972, 4115/2014, the mid 1980s, 1st May, 1987, 1st January, 1986, 2nd January, 1966, October, 30th July, 1992, 4115/2014, 28 8, 16th March, 2000, 1st January, 2004, 1st January, 2004, before 1st January, 2004, 30th June, 2009, 1st January, 2004, the year 2000, 4115/2014, 2013, February, 1985, 1972, April, 1987, 2nd April, 1987, 1 2nd April, 1987, 18, 4115/2014, 25th September, 1986, 18th September, 1997, 12th October, 2001, 4115/2014, 2nd March,, 2009, 4th June, 2010, 30th September, 2010, 4th June, 2010, 22nd August, 2012, 4th June, 2010, 18th February, 2013, 19th September, 2013, 2nd January, 2014, 4115/2014, 1995, 14th January, 1961, 2015, 2006, 2005, 2004, 1995, 2007, 4115/2014, 2008, 2015, 2006, 20th May, 2013, 4th January, 2018, 23rd April, 2nd April, 1987, 4115/2014, 2nd April, 1987, May 01, 1987, 1962, 4115/2014, 28 5, May 01, 1987, 2006, April 12, 2010, May 01, 1987, 4115/2014, 4th January, 2018, 23-04-2019, 303 days, 4115/2014, 20th January, 2015, about three years, 4115/2014, July, 1982, 1972, 1st May, 1987, 4115/2014, 16th March, 2000, 1st May, 1987, 4115/2014, 2001, 30-10-2007, 1982, 2007, 1982, 4115/2014, 28 32, 1982, 1st May, 1987, 1st May, 1987, 4115/2014, 1st May, 1987, 1972, 2004, 1st January, 2004, 1st January, 2004, 4115/2014, 2004, 14th January, 1961, 4115/2014, 38, 2nd January, 2014, 40, 1972, 4115/2014, 1995, 1994, 1st May, 1987, 1st May, 1987, 4115/2014, 24th February, 2014, 45, 31st January, 2019, 13th April, 2012, 1st November, 1982, 28th March, 1989, 1st November, 1997, 2000, May, 2010, 4115/2014, 28 47, 37400-67000+, more than 11 years, more than 11 years, 48, 1st, 4115/2014, 28 14, four weeks, a period of, three months, today, a period of, four months, 4115/2014, the second 50, 2000, more than 11 years, 4115/2014, 31st January, 2019, 13th April, 2012, 2000, 2011, 4115/2014, 13th April, 2012, 31st January, 2019, 2019, 4115/2014

ORG: UNION OF INDIA, ANR, REGD, UNION OF INDIA, MATHUR, ANR, Page 1 of 28, the Union of India, the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (Petitioner No.1, Ministry of Finance, the Association of Employees of Indian Institute of Mass Communication, the Indian Institute of Mass Communication (Contesting Respondent No.2, The Indian Institute of Mass Communication, Proforma Respondent/Respondent No.3.2, the Central Administrative Tribunal, CAT, TA, Ministry of Finance, GPF, Autonomous Bodies, National Council of Educational Research & Training, Indian Council of Social Science Research, The National Institute of Health and Family Welfare, UGC, Page 2, the Central Civil Services, Autonomous Bodies, Government, Memorandum of Associations/Rules, the Indian Societies Registration Act, Parliament, Central Government, GPF, Contributory Provident Fund, the New Pension Scheme, NPS, Central Government, CCS, IIMC, CPF Scheme, GPF, Page 3 of 28 5, 4th Central Pay Commission, CPC, 4th Pay Commission, the Pension Scheme, Central Government, GPF, Central Government, OM, the New Pension Scheme, NPS, the Pay Commission, Autonomous Bodies, IIMC, IIMC, Executive Council, IIMC, LIC, GPF, the Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance, Page 4, the Department of Expenditure, Pension Scheme, Pension Scheme, Trust, Pension Fund, the Pension Scheme in ABs.9, Annuity Scheme, NPS, Central Government, NPS, the Ministry of Finance, GPF, the Pension Scheme, IIMC, Ministry of IB, the Pension Scheme, GPF, Page 5, Rs.30.00, Government of India, Pension Schemes, Dearness Allowance, R-1 Association, Pension Scheme, Department of Pension and Pensioners‟ Welfare, Pension Scheme, the NOC of Ministry of Finance, Department of Pension and Pensioners‟ Welfare, Indian Institute of Mass Communication, Page 6, No.1/MCI, Pension, IIMC, the Finance Ministry, Pension Scheme, IIMC, the Pension Scheme, the Pension Scheme, Pension Scheme, the Indian Institute of Mass Communication, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Finance, Pension Scheme, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Finance, Pension Scheme on Government of India, Pension Scheme for IIMC, Page 7, CAT, TA No.1101/2009, Learned CAT, the Pension Scheme, Tribunal, Court, Ministry of Finance, CAT, the Transaction of Business Rules (TOBR, Apex Court, Government of A.P. & Ors, Ministry of Finance, IIMC, NOC, Association, CAT, the Government of India Transaction of Business Rules, Supreme Court, T.M. Sampath and Ors, Ministry of Water Resources & Ors, Union of India, Union of India, State of M.P., A.P., University of Allahabad and Others, Sanchar Nigam Ltd., Pune Municipal Corporation Transport, RESPONDENTS, Supreme Court, SCC540 Union of India & Ors, SL Verma & Ors, Amit Mukherjee & Ors, Supreme Court, SLP, CAT, the Memorandum of Association of IIMC, Pension Scheme, Society, IIMC, Society, the Government of India, Pension Scheme, Page 10 of 28 Pension Scheme, Finance Ministry, the Pension Scheme, CAT, the Ministry of Finance, Pension Scheme, IIMC, the Ministry of Finance, IIMC, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, the Ministry of Finance, CAT, The Ministry of Finance, CAT, the Ministry of Finance, CAT, Court, Union of India & Ors, Amit Mukherji & Ors, Central Pay Commission, the Department of Pension and Pensioners Welfare, Administrative Ministries, the Contributory Provident Fund Rules, Contributory Provident Fund Rules, the Department of Pension and Pensioners Scheme.‟ W.P.(C, the Supreme Court, SCC53UOI & Anr, S.L. Verma & Ors, The Central Government, the Pension Scheme, the Pension Scheme, Tribunal, Autonomous Bodies, Tribunal, OM, the Supreme Court, the NCR Planning Board, Ministry of Urban Development, the NCR Planning Board, Tribunal, the Central Government, DTC, the Central Government, Union of India, SLP, Court, SLP, Union of India, the Review Petition, Delhi Urban Arts Commission, the Central Government, Bodies/Subordinate, the Central Government, Page 13 of 28 Pension Scheme, the Central Government, Tribunal, the High Court, Court, the Review Petition, This Review Petition, Court, Union of India, Amit Mukherji, Delhi Urban Art Commission, the CCS Pension Rules, Supreme Court, Ministry of Water Resources, Bench, Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Union of India, Supreme Court, supra).28, Supreme Court, Appellants, National Water Development Agency, NWDA, Page 14, Ministry of Water Resources, Government of India, NWDA, NWDA, Ministry of Finance, NWDA, 4th Pay Commission, 4th Pay Commission, Government of India, the Supreme Court, S.L. Verma, the Central Government, Government, Central Government, NWDA, 4th CPC, Page 15, Department of Expenditure, 4th CPC, Central Government, Central Government, State, Central Government, the Union of India, Supreme Court, the Central Government, NWDA, 4th Pay Commission, OM, Nodal Ministry, Ministry of Finance, Department of Pension and Pensioners‟ Welfare, Page 16, NWDA, CCS, OM, the Ministry of Finance, Department of Pension and Pensioners‟ Welfare, NWDA, NWDA, Union of India, Supreme, Supreme Court, NWDA, NWDA, the Ministry of Water Resources, Court, SRTC, Supreme Court, Appellants, Central Government, GPF, NWDA, Central Government, OM, NWDA, State, the Central Government, the Central Government, NWDA, Supreme Court, NWDA, State, Appellants, State, State, NWDA, Central Government, NWDA, Central Government, Central Government, GPF, the Respondent No.1 Association, the Central Government, the Central Government, Supreme Court, The Ministry of Finance, CAT, the Central Government, Court, CCS Pension Rules, Central Government, the Administrative Ministries, the Controlling Ministry of IIMC, the New Pension Scheme, Central Government, the New Pension Scheme, the New Pension Scheme, The Government of India Transaction of Business Rules, Inter-Departmental Consultations, Cabinet, Department, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Finance, the Department of Personnel, Petitioner No.2/ Ministry of Finance, the Pension Scheme, Government Department, IIMC, Pension Scheme, CAT, TA No.1101/2009, W.P., No.10453/2019, Central Pollution Control Board, CPCB, Central Government, CCS, the Ministry of Environment and Forest, Ministry of Personnel and Public Grievances and Pensions, Ministry of Finance, CPCB, Page 21, CPCB, RESPONDENTS, OA No.2805/2012, CAT, the Pension Scheme, 4th Pay Commission, CPCB, CAT, the Central Government, GPF, Pension Scheme, the Contributory Provident Fund, the Ministry of Finance.42, CAT, TA No.1101/2009, Indian Institute of Mass Communication, CAT, Court, Central Government, the Ministry of Finance, GPF, CAT, TA No.1101/2009, OA No.2805/2012 titled, CPCB, OA No.2805/2012, W.P., CAT, CPCB, Ministry of Environment and Forest, MEF, CPCB, MEF, MEF, Applicant, MEF, MEF, Page 23, CAT, the Ministry of Environment & Forests, the Ministry of, Ministry, the Ministry of Environment & Forests, the Ministry of Environment & Forests, CPCB, CPCB, the Ministry of Environment & Forests, CPCB, CPCB, Applicant, CAT, NPS, Page 24, NPS, NPS, CPCB, NPS, NPS, NPS, Applicant, RA, CAT, MEF, MEF, CAT, Tribunal, Page 25, CAT, Applicant, Court, CPCB, MEF, MEF, MEF, CPCB, MEF, MEF, CAT, OA No.2805/2012, Pradeep Mishra & Ors, CPCB, CPCB, Page 26, NPS, the New Pension, Pradeep Mishra & Ors, CPCB, OA No.2805/2012, CPCB, GPF, CAT, OA No.2805/2012, CPCB, CPF/NPS, CAT, MEF, MEF, MEF, CAT, CPCB, MEF, CPCB, MEF, Pension Scheme, New Pension Scheme, CAT, Page 27 of 28, W.P.

PERSON: Appellant Through, Jasmeet Singh, Srivats Kaushal, Jayant K. Mehta, Shaurya Kuthiala, W.P.(C, Appellant Through, Ruchir Mishra, Mukesh, Kumar Tiwari, Naresh Kaushik, Vishwendra Verma, Ajay Digpaul, Arti Bansal, JUSTICE S. MURALIDHAR, W.P.(C, Birbal, Principal Bench, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, Review, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, Petitioner No.1, S.L. Verma, Amar Nath Goyal and Others, B. Rama Rao, Rajendra Singh, Videsh W.P.(C, Kumar Kar, Vasant Gopal Bhagwat, Mahendra Nath Sharma, Anr, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, T.M. Sampath, T.M. Sampath, W.P.(C, T. M. Sampat’s, W.P.(C, Jai Dev Vig, M.D Kerala, K.O. Varghese, W.P.(C, T.M. Sampath’s, W.P.(C, Page, Petitioner No.1, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, Petitioner No.4, W.P.(C, Applicant, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, No.3863/2011 W.P.(C, J.OCTOBER31 2019 pa W.P.(C

GPE: C.M. APPL, Advocate, C.M. APPL, Singh, New Delhi, OA, New Delhi, New Delhi, RA, Rama Rao, India, India, State‟, No.20458/2019, OA, OA, PV, OA, OA, OA, OA, OA, RA, OA, OA, RA, CAT.54, SINGH, J.S.

PRODUCT: Respondent No.2, Abs, Annuity Scheme, Respondent No.3, Respondent No.1, Page 8 of 28, Page 9 of, No.8682/2015, Respondent No.3, S.L.Verma, Respondent No.3, Bench

WORK_OF_ART: Scheme, ABs‟, the Pension Scheme:, Bench

ORDINAL: 7th, 4th, firstly, Secondly, second, 2nd, third, 2nd, second, 2nd, first

EVENT: Another 2006

PERCENT: 12 SCC53and Union of India & Ors, more than 50%

NORP: Rules

FAC: the Fourth Central Pay Commission, TA No.1101/2009.44, 5th September,, 5th September

LOC: Central Government.33