Shri Saurabh Tripathy vs.competition Commission of India & Anr.

Decided On : Oct-10-2019

Court : Delhi

LAW: Section 4 of the Competition Act, Page 1, Section 4 of the Act, Section 26(8, Section 4 of the Act, Page 2, Section 4 of the Act, the Companies Act, the Companies Act, Page 3, Section 19(1)(a, Section 4(1, Section 19(1)(a, Section 4, Section 26(1, Page 4, Section 4(1, Section 4(2)(a)(i, Page 5, Section 26(8, Section 27(d, Section 26(2, Page 10, Conclusion 23, Section 26(8, Section 26 of the Act, section 19.—(1, section 19, section 19, Page 11, Section 26, Section 19, Section 26(2, Section 26(1, Section 26(4, Section 26, Section 26 of the Act, Section 3 and Section 4 of the Act, Section 27 of the Act, Section 27 of the Act, section 3 or section 4, Page 14, section 4, Section 26 of the Act, Page 15, Section 26(3, Section 26 of the Act, Section 3 and 4, Section 27, Section 27 of the Act, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Section 4(2)(a)(i, Section 27(d, Section 3 or 4, Section 4(2)(a)(i, Section 4(1)(a)(i, Section 4(2)(a)(i, Page 21, Page 28, Page 32, Page 33, Section 4(2)(a)(i, Section 4(2)(a)(i, Section 4(2)(a)(i, Section 26(3

DATE: 10.2019 + W.P.(C, 2079/2018, 2002, 2079/2018, CCI, 1956, 1956, the year 2007, 16.09.2019, sixty days, 28.12.2015, the three previous years, 15.05.2017, 45, CCI, 2079/2018, 16.05.2017, 45, 2079/2018 Page 12, 45, 2079/2018 Page 13, each year, each year, 2007, 2007, 45 29, 15.05.2017, 2079/2018 Page 17, 4.3, 10, 11.2, 11.2, 2079/2018, 45 days, the day, 25) years, 2079/2018, seven) days, 2079/2018 Page 23, monthly, 26 working days in a month, three) months, fifteen) days, quarterly, 45 days, No.of days in a quarter, daily, a quarter, N days, 2079/2018 Page 25, No.of days in, No.of days in a quarter 75 days, the quarter, quarterly, 14) consecutive days, 2079/2018, 14 days, 30 days, each Financial Year, 1) week, days, 2079/2018 Page 27, 45, the partial shutdown days, 15 days, a Financial Year, 1) week, 2079/2018, 2079/2018 Page 29, 45, 15) DAYS, 2079/2018 Page 30, May 11, 2012, one year, 45) days, 18th day, the same month, Six days, 1st, particular month, Six days, 2079/2018 Page 31, quarterly, quarterly, 7 working days, fourteen, 14) DAYS, one month, 31 days, April 30, 2034, 2079/2018 Page 36, 45 46, a period of, three months, 2079/2018 Page 37, 45, CCI, 11, 2079/2018, 2079/2018, 45 58, 2079/2018 Page 43, 45 61, 2013, 23.05.2014, June 2014, August 2014, September 2014, 2079/2018 Page 44, 45 65, 15.05.2017, almost nine months, sixty days, 2019, 2079/2018 Page 45

PERSON: Gourab Banerji, Saurav Agrawal, Anirudha Agarwala, Anshuman Chowdhury, Ms Raka Chatterjee, S.P. Mukherjee, Ms Purnima Singh, Ms Shibani Khuntia, Rajshekhar Rao, Ram Kumar, Vinayak Mehrotra, Dhruv Dikshit, VIBHU BAKHRU JUDGMENT, W.P.(C, DG, W.P.(C, Factual Background, Sagar Bhanga, Tamil Nadu, W.P.(C, CCI, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, Gourab Banerji, Banerji, W.P.(C, DG, Banerji, W.P.(C, Banerji, W.P.(C, GAIL, DG, Rao, Rao, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, contract.38, W.P.(C, CCI, W.P.(C, Buyer, Regulating W.P.(C, W.P.(C, Debit Note, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, FORCE MAJEURE, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, Format, W.P.(C, CCI, W.P.(C, DG, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, Banerji, CCI, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, CCI, W.P.(C, W.P.(C, VIBHU BAKHRU

FAC: R-2, BUYER, BUYER, BUYER, BUYER, BUYER, BUYER

ORG: VIBHU BAKHRU, the Competition Commission of India, no.2, Great Eastern Energy Corporation Ltd., CCI, the Director General, Competition of Commission of India, GEECL, M/s SRMB Srijan Ltd., CBM, CBM, CBM, CBM, CBM, GEECL, CBM, CCI, GEECL, Asansol-Raniganj-Durgapur Region, GSPA, GEECL, Clause 5.2, GSPA, Act.10, CCI, GEECL, GEECL, GEECL, the Competition Appellate Tribunal, CCI, Clauses 4.4, GSPA, GSPA, GEECL, GSPA, MGO, Clause 5.2, GSPA, GEECL, GSPA, GEECL, GSPA, CCI, CBM, GEECL, CBM, GEECL, GSPA, GEECL, GEECL, the State Government, the Government of India, MGO, GEECL, CBM, CBM, CCI, MGO, CBM, CBM, CCI, CCI, Shri Rathi Steel, Dakshin) Ltd., CCI, CCI, GEECL, GSPA, GEECL, CCI, the Supreme Court, 45 Corporation for Greater Bombay v. Lala Pancham, GEECL, GSPA, CCI, CCI, the Central Government, Commission, Commission, the Central Government, Commission, the Central Government, the State Government, Commission, Commission, the Central Government, the State Government, Commission, the Central Government, the State Government, Commission, the Central Government, the State Government, Commission, the Central Government, the State Government, Commission, CCI, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, CCI, CCI, rejected.33, Court, GEECL, CBM, SMRB, GSPA, GSPA, Court, GSPA, GSPA, GEECL, Sections 3 and 4 of the Act, GSPA, Court, inter alia, GEECL, CBM, GSPA, GEECL, GSPA, GEECL, CCI, GSPA, GSPA, Clauses 4.2, GSPA, Clauses 2, GEECL, GSPA, GSPA, SELLER, the Bank Guarantee, ROU, CBM, CBM, GAS, GAS, Intake Arrangements, GAS, SELLER, the Minimum Guaranteed Offtake, GAS, GAS, BUYER, BUYER, SELLER, BUYER, BUYER, GAS, GAS, Contracted Quantity, GAS, SELLER, 8.3 & 9, the Contracted Quantity of GAS, BUYER, GAS, the Contracted Quantity, SELER, MGO, CBM, Contracted, CBM, the Minimum Guaranteed Offtake, BUYER, BUYER, MGO, BUYER, SELLER & BUYER, the Minimum Guaranteed Offtake in Clause 5.2, DCQ, MGO, DCQ, SELLER, MGO, GAS, BUYER, GAS, GAS, SELLER, GAS, BUYER, SELLER, GAS, Floor Price, BUYER, MGO, GAS, SELLER, Bankers at Asansol, GAS, Bank Guarantee, BG, BG, VAT, SELLER, Bank Guarantee, GAS, GAS, GAS, GAS, SELLER, GAS, BUYER, GSPA, GEECL, GEECL, GSPA, GSPA, GSPA, GEECL, GEECL, GEECL, GEECL, GEECL, CCI, Court, Clause 4.4, GSPA, GEECL, GSPA, GEECL, GSPA, GEECL, GSPA, GEECL, GEECL, CBM, MGO, MGO, GEECL, CBM, GEECL, MGO, MGO, GEECL’s, MGO, GSPA, Essar, MGO, GEECL, GEECL, GEECL, GEECL, MGO, GEECL, CBM, MGO, GSPA, MGO, unsubstantial.53, GEECL, MGO, GSPA, GSPA, GSPA, GEECL’s, Clause 8.3, GSPA, GSPA, GEECL, CBM, MGO, CBM, MGO, GSPA, CCI, CCI, GEECL’s, GEECL, CCI, GEECL, GEECL, Court, GSPA, GSPA, Court, Court, GEECL, GSPA, ESSAR, CBM, MGO, ESSAR, CBM, GEECL, MGO, CBM, GEECL, GEECL, MGO, GEECL, Court, the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas, Government, GEECL, CCI, Court

CARDINAL: J1, 45 2, 3, two, two, 45 one, 2011- 2012.6, 11.05.2011, 45, 4.4, 6.1, 9.2, 29.03.2016, 16.05.2016, 29.03.2016, 14.07.2016, 22.07.2016, 16.08.2018, 12.12.2016, 45, 28.02.2018, 14, 6, 6.0, 11.0, 15.0, one, 45, 412, 88, SRMB.19, 8, 45, 26(6, 9, 45, 2, 3, 1, 4, 3, 3, 3, 5, 6, 5, 5, 8), 3, 24, 1, 2, 5, 5, 45, three, 45, up to three, 3, 8), 26, 27, 8), 16, 45, 26, 27, 45, two, 18, 45, two, one, 19, 45, 4.4, 5.1, 5.2, 6.1, 9.2, 15, 4.4, 5.2, 6.1, 8.2, 9.2, 15, 20, 45, twenty five, 10.1, 10.2, 4.0, 5.2, 4.3, 22, 45, 4.2, 4.4, 7, 45, 5.0, 35000, Thirty Five Thousand, 910000, Nine, more than 3, 24, 45, 5.2, 4.2, 5.1, 8.0, 5.1, 5.1, 45, more than fourteen, 26, 45, 5.2, 6.0, 6.2, 8.0, SUPPLY:8, 1, one, Half, 1/2, 5.2, 8.3, 45, 8.4, 9.0, 9.2, twenty four, 9.3, more than six, 6, fifteen, 45 10.2, 10.1, at least forty five, 11.0, 11.1, 45, 11.2, 45, 11.3, 11.4, 11.5, 15.0, 34, 45, 43, one, 35, 45, 38, 45, only one, one, 50, 39, 45, 6, 40, 45, one, 9.2, 15, 41, 45, 15, 42, 11.05.2011, 22.04.2014, 24.04.2014, 25.04.2014, 45

GPE: Durgapur, West Bengal, Raniganj, West Bengal, belt.5, the State of West Bengal, CCI, India, Municipal W.P.(C, Bombay, Provided, CCI, BUYER, Notwithstanding, k%, k%, BUYER, W.B., GEECL.64

PERCENT: 100%, 10%, 12.25%, more than ten percent, ten percent, 15%, 80% to 75%

LOC: South

PRODUCT: Mannargudi, Act.32, Act.35

ORDINAL: first, First, third, Secondly, third, third, third, third, first, second, 3rd, third, third, third, third, third, third

WORK_OF_ART: Gas Metering cum, SELLER, SELLER, SELLER, SELLER

TIME: 24 hours, 24) hours, 2nd fortnight of month, 24 hours

MONEY: 5/-, 5/-, 5/-, 50,000/-