Indeen Bio Power Limited vs.m/s. Efs Facilities Service (India) Pvt. Ltd.

Decided On : Jul-24-2019

Court : Delhi

LAW: section 37, Section 11, Section 16 of the 1996 Act, Section 16, Section 16, Section 37, Section 34, Article 1.11, the Reference Business Plan, Article 1.22, Article 1.1. 9.4, Article 3.13, Article 3, this Article 3, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Supply Contract to Supply Co., the Contract Agreements, the Supply Contract to Supply Co., the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Supply Agreement, the Contract Agreements, the Supply Agreement, the Works Agreement, Section 65B, the Indian Evidence Act, the EPC Agreement, the EPC Agreement, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, Section 39, the Contract Act, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Supply Contract to Supply Co, the Contract Agreements, the Supply Contract to Supply Co, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Supply Agreement and Civil Works Agreement, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Supply Agreement, the Contract Agreements, Article 3.1, the EPC Agreement, Section 65B, the Evidence Act, the EPC Agreement, the EPC Agreement, the EPC Agreement, the Contract Agreements, the EPC Agreement, the EPC Agreement, the Contract Agreements, the Supply Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreements, the Supply Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements for Termination, the Contract Agreements, Section 8, Section 8, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreement, the Force Majeure, the Force Majeure, the Contract Agreement, HLC238 63, Respondent 1, Article 1.2 of the SCA, Article 3, Article 5.2, Article 2.118, the Contract Agreements, the Services Agreement, the Supply Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Commencement Date, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement, the Contract Agreement

DATE: 28.11.2018, 1996, '1996 Act', 15.09.2016, 21.01.2013, 49, 10.05.2013, 1996, 26.04.2018, 49, two months, August 2, 2010, 2 August, 2010, 2) month, August 2, 2010, 49, 10.03.2011, the sixty day, the sixty day, 49, eighteen months, Indeen, 1996, 49 16, 10.03.2011, 49 19, 30 days, 49, 23.04.2012, 28.03.2012, 23.04.2012, 24, 49, 1872, 10.03.2011, two years, 90 (ninety) days, 16.03.2012, 16.03.2012, 49, 2, 3.2, 4.1, 49, 59, 61-63, 82-83, 2.08.2010, two months, 10.03.2011, 42-44, 80, 2008, May 2010, 28.03.2012, 16.03.2012, 90(ninety) days, between January and April 2011, 10.03.2011, 18 months, 18 months, 1.18,7 28, 6 1.17, Indeen, 49, 1013, 1215, 3) months, 14 11, 49 12.2 War, 14 days, 15 12, 1912, 1968, 49, 1912, July 6, 1952 or, 45, forty five) days, 30) days, 49, 49, five) days, 90 (ninety) days, 45) days, 45) days, 1.6.1(a, Indeen, 90(ninety) days, a period of, 45 days, 16.03.2012, 90(ninety) days, Indeen, 90(ninety) days, five) days, 90 days, 1963, 2 SCR183and, 1963, 1996, 49, 2009, 1966, 28.03.2012, 28.03.2012, 16.03.2012, less than two weeks

CARDINAL: 24.07.2019, 1, 49 2.1, three, 3, 13.2, 2.2, 21.01.2013, 21.01.2013, Indeen, 2, 4.1, 4.2, 17.08.2017, 3, 49, Indeen, Indeen, 12.03.2010.9, Indeen, 4, 9.1, 9.2, 9.3, Indeen, 02.08.2010, Indeen, Indeen, 2 1.2, Indeen, two, 5, 49, 02.08.2010, 18.01.2011, Indeen, 11, 27.01.2011, Indeen, Indeen, 3.80, 11.1, Indeen, two, 3.1, 6, 02.03.2011, Indeen, two, 7, 49, 855.20, 3476.92, 4, 13.1, 06.09.2011, Indeen, Indeen, three, 43,35,71,000/-, 8, 49 14.1, four, four, 1, 1, 14.2, 14.3, Indeen, 08.09.2011, Indeen, three, 9, 15.1, Indeen, 1.1, 1.3 1.16, 18, 2.1, 10, 49 4.2, Indeen, forty three, thirty five, 5.2, Indeen, 5.3, 11, 49 5.6, Indeen, 7.2, 13.2, three, 12, 13.6 Survival, 09.09.2011, 2, 4385.71, 4335.71, 1, Indeen, 16.03.2012, about 20.03.2012, Indeen, 13, 13.2, Indeen, 20.1, Indeen, 20.2, 20.3, 25, 14, Indeen, 02.08.2010, 21.1, Indeen, 13.2, 22.1, 16.03.2012, Indeen, 15, 49, Indeen, 22.3, 102, 103, 25.2, 16, 25.3, 25.4, Indeen, 17, 49 25.6, 25.7, 25.8, 18, 25.9, 26.1, Indeen, 26.2, Indeen, 19, 49 26.3, 1.2, 26.4, 15.06.2012, 26.5, 9, Indeen, Indeen, 26.6, Indeen, 26.7, Indeen, 102, 20, 49, 26.8, 26.9, 4 5, 5.1, 5.3, Indeen, Indeen, 5.2, Indeen, 21, 1, 21.01.2013, 28.2, Indeen, Indeen, 5.5, Indeen, 22, 49, 28.3, 4.2, 13.45, 28.4, 28.5, 28.6, three, 23, Indeen, 28.8, 28.9, 29.1, 1.1.5.9, 29.2, 29.3, 5 13.4, 24, 49, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, 29.5, 29.6, 29.7, 29.8, 25, 49, 29.9, 28.03.2012, 02.08.2010, 30.1, 02.08.2010, 1.2, 30.2, 02.08.2010, 52, 30.4, 26, 27.01.2011, 3.8, Indeen, 18.01.2011, 02.03.2011, two, 13.04.2011, 30.5, 30.6, 84, 135, 27, 49, 37, 30.7, 82, 30.8, Indeen, 30.9, Indeen, 31, 31.1, 28, 31.3, 31.4, Indeen, Indeen, 13.2, 31.5, Indeen, 29, 49, three, 33.1, 27.01.2011, 27.01.2011, 3.8, 33.2, 27.01.2011, Indeen, 33.3, Indeen, 33.4, 30, 49, 4385.71, 33.5, Indeen, 02.03.2011, 02.03.2011, two, 13.04.2011, 33.7, 06.09.2011, Indeen, three, 31, 49, 43,35,71,000/-, 33.8, 33.9, 08.09.2011, 06.09.2011, 34.1, 1.2, 1.3, 32, 49 4.1, Indeen, 4.2, Indeen, forty three, thirty five, 34.2, three, 43,35,71,000/-, three, 34.3, three, 34.4, 33, 49, 1.176, 39, 34.5, 2.2, Indeen, Indeen, 2.2, 7.1, 34, 49, 811, 7.4, 7.5, 7.6, 11 8, Indeen, 8.2.1, 8.2.2, 8.3, Indeen, Indeen, 35, Indeen, 8.3.3, Indeen, 8.3.4, 8.4, 129, Indeen, 9.2, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, six, 6, three, 13 10, Indeen, Indeen, 11.3, 36, 11.1, 11.2, Indeen, 6.6, 11.3, 1.4, 37, 49, 13.2, Indeen, 3, 38, 3, 6, 1, 4, 39, 49, 35.1, 3.316, 5.217, 16, 17 5.2, Indeen, Indeen, thirty, 40, 35.2, one, three, 18, 41, 49, 36.1, 1.1.3.10, 1.6, 42, 5, 1.6.2, 1.6.3, 90, forty five, 43, 49, Indeen, 36.3, 36.4, 36.5 One, 36.6, 1.6.3, 36.7, 44, 49, 36.8, 15.06.2012, 36.9, 5, 19 5, 45, 49, 37.1, 37.2, Indeen, 3, 20, 1, 46, 1, 2, 10, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, two, 47, 49, one, one, one, 38.1, Indeen, Indeen, 4, 4, three, 48, 49 38.2, 102, 49, 49

ORG: No.39/2016 & I.A.No.14153/2016 INDEEN BIO POWER LIMITED, Garg, M/S. EFS FACILITIES, Indeen Bio Power Ltd., Court, Court, Dalkia India Pvt. Ltd., SPA, DIPL, Dalkia International S.A., DIPL, EFS Facilities Services, EFS Facilities Services Mauritius Ltd., DIPL, EFS Facilities Services, EFS, EFS, EFS, EFS, EFS, EFS, EFS, Biomass Plant, District Tonk, DIPL, Veolia Environment Group, DIS, DIPL, 02.05.2010, Project Development Agreement, PDA, DSCL Energy Services Company Limited, DIPL, DSCL, Operation, DIPL, DIPL, inter alia, Detailed Project Report, DIPL, the EPC Agreement, the O&M Agreement, PDA, PDA, DIPL, inter alia, an EPC Agreement, an O&M Agreement, PDA, Dalkia, EPC Agreement, Plant, Dalkia, Plant, Dalkia, Plant, the "Final Business Plan, EPC & O&M, the Reference Business Plan, EPC, O&M Agreements, IRR, Project, the Reference Business Plan, C44, PDA, the EPC Agreement and O&M Agreement, the EPC Agreement, DIPL, EPC, the].bank, FII, DIPL, the State Bank India, SBI, DIPL, PDA, EPC Agreement, DIPL, EPC Agreement, DIPL, the Managing Directors, DIPL, the Supply Contract, SBI, DIPL, DIPL, SBI, EPC, Indeen Bio Power Limited, Grand Total Taxes & Duties, DIPL, the EPC Agreement, SCA, inter alia, DIPL, Supply Contract, Civil Works Contract, DIPL, Notice to Proceed, DIPL, SCA, Notice, Synchronisation, Project, Price, the Price Revision Principles, Synchronisation Agreement, Dalkia, DIPL, SCA, SCA, DIPL, Contract Agreements, SCA, Works Contract Agreement, Service Contract Agreement and, Consolidated Contract Price, Dalkia, Power Plant, Consolidated Contract Price, the Consolidated Contract Price, Clauses 5.1, Dalkia International, Supply Contract, Supply Co., Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, the Commencement Date, the ARB.A. (COMM) No.39/2016 Pg, SCA, DIPL, SBI, SBI, DIPL, Non Power Block', PDA, EFS, the Civil Works Agreement, DIPL, DIPL, DIS, SCA, DIS, DIPL, DIPL and/or, DIS, the Veolia Group, SCA, EPC Agreement, SCA, DIPL, DIPL, SCA, NTP, SCA, DIPL, DIS, SPA, DIPL, EFS Facilities Services, SPA, DIS, DIPL, SCA, DIPL, SCA, DIPL, SCA, EPC Agreement, DIPL, DIPL, PDA, PDA, Special Conditions, inter alia, FIDIC General Conditions, DIPL, Advani & Co., the EPC Agreement, DIPL, SBI, SBI, SCA, SCA, SCA, SCA, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, NTP, EFS, DIPL, Clauses 1.1, SCA, NTP, DIPL, Praefinium Energy Investments Pte, Indeen‘s, SBI, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, DIS, DIPL, DIS, DIPL, EFS Facilities Services, SCA, Dalkia, DIPL, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Clauses 5.1, Dalkia International, Supply Contract, Supply Co, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, DIS, DIPL, EFS, SCA, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Contract Agreements, Third Party Assignee, the Third Party Assignee, the Third Party Assignee, Project, Agreement, Clauses 1.2, SCA, SCA, Supply Agreement, Services Agreement and, SCA, the Contract Agreements, Supply Agreement, Services Agreement, Civil Works Agreement, Schedules A to, CW-1, SCA, SCA, NTP, EFS, the Commencement Date, NTP, NTP, SCA, EFS, inter alia, NTP, NTP, Indeen ARB.A. (, NTP, CW-1, SBI, NTP, SBI, NTP, Reliance, the Conditions Precedent, NTP, SCA, DIPL, an EPC Agreement, O&M Agreement, the Final Business Plan, PDA, Reliance, PDA, PDA, the EPC Agreement, the O&M Agreement, PDA, DIPL, EPC Agreement, DIPL, EPC ARB.A., DIPL, SBI, EPC Agreement, O&M Agreement, EPC, DIPL, SBI, DIPL, SBI, inter alia, EPC Agreement, Services, EPC Agreement, CW-1, CW-1, Praefinium, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, NTP, SCA, the Commencement Date, SCA, Commencement Date, NTP, DIPL, SPA, DIS, EFS Facilities Services Mauritius Ltd., SCA, NTP, Conditions, PDA, 02.05.2010, the ARB.A. (COMM) No.39/2016 Pg, PDA, DIPL, an O&M Agreement, DIPL, SBI, DIPL, Indeen‘s, SBI, DIPL, EPC Agreement, DIPL, DIPL, the Managing Directors, DIPL, DIPL, SBI, the EPC Agreement, DIPL, SBI, DIPL, DIPL, SCA, DIPL, DIPL, SCA, 06.09.2011, DIPL, SCA, SCA, Clause 4.2, the Consolidated Contract Price, 06.09.2011, Clause 1.2, SCA, Works Contract Agreement, Service Contract Agreement and, Consolidated Contract Price, Project, Works Contract Agreement, Service Contract Agreement and, Consolidated Contract Price, the Consolidated Contract Price, Clause 1.2, Consolidated Contract Price, DIPL, SCA, the Commencement Date, SCA, SCA, Recital C. ''Works Contract Agreement, Dalkia, Power Plant, the Power Plant, the Works Contract Agreement, Dalkia, the Power Plant, the Supply Co., Dalkia, Supply Co., the Commencement Date, Dalkia, Project, the Power Plant, the Commencement Date, Power Plant, Dalkia, SCA, Damages Delay Damages, the Consolidated Contract Price, the Consolidated Contract Price, Dalkia, the Power Plant, the Time of Completion, Power Plant, the Power Plant, Liquidated Damages, the Consolidated Contract Price, the Contract Agreements, Consolidated Contract Price, Net Plant, Consolidated Contract Price, Consolidated Contract Price, the Consolidated Contract Price, Consolidated Contract Price, the Power Plant, Clause, the Consolidated Contract Price, Overall Liquidated Damages Liability, the Consolidated Contract Price, Dalkia, Consolidated Contract Price, Time for Completion, the Contract Agreements, Force Majeure Events, Dalkia‘s, Overall Bonus Liability, the Consolidated Contract Price, Dalkia, LIABILITY ARB.A., Rebellion, Party, Party, Party, Party, Governmental, Party, Party, Party, Force Majeure, Party, the Force Majeure, Party, Party, Neither Party, Party, Party, Contract, the Power Plant, Consolidated Contract Price, the Power Plant, the Power Plant, Consolidated Contract Price, FORCE MAJEURE121 ARB.A., SCA, EFS, EFS, Parker, the Supreme Court, Legal Representatives & Ors, the Supreme Court, Privy Council, Currimbhoy & Co. Ltd., L.A. Creet & Ors, Parker J’s, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Parker, the Supreme Court, PDA, EPC, O&M, Contract Agreements, the EPC Agreement and, the Final Business Plan, the Reference Business Plan, the Final Business Plan, the Reference Business Plan, the EPC Agreement and, EPC, O&M, Dalkia, the EPC Agreement and Fees, the Project Development Fee, VAT, Party, EPC Agreement, SCA, NTP, DIPL, NTP, the Commencement Date, SCA, Conditions of Contract Agreement, the Civil Works Agreement, Dalkia, Power Plant, Employer, Clause 1.6 the Conditions of Contract Agreement, Employer, Project, Employer, Employer, Employer, Employer, Employer, Employer, Party, Party, Party, Party, Employer, Conditions Precedents, Employer, SCA, Conditions of Contract Agreement, SCA, NTP, the Conditions of Contract Agreement, NTP, the Conditions of Contract Agreements, NTP, DIPL, NTP, Conditions Precedent, Conditions Precedent, NTP, the ARB.A. (COMM) No.39/2016 Pg, Conditions Precedent, NTP, Clause 5 of the Service Agreement, NTP, the Contract Agreements Securing, Employer, Project, Employer, Contract Agreement, Employer, Employer, Employer, Employer, Employer, the Conditions of Contract Agreement, SCA, NTP, SCA, DIS, SCA, SCA, NTP, SCA, Khardah Company Ltd., Raymon & Co., Private Ltd., Waverly Jute Mills Co. Ltd., Raymon & Co., Private Ltd., the Supreme Court, Union of India, National Insurance Co. Ltd., Boghara Polyfab, P) Ltd., Bhagwati Prasad v. Chandramaul, Court, Court, Bhagwati Prasad, Dalkia, the Veolia Group, the Synchronisation and Coordination Agreement, EPC, DIS/DIPL, EFS Facilities Services Mauritius Ltd., SPA, DIS, EFS Facilities Services Mauritius Ltd., SPA, NTP, tribunal‘s, I.A. No.14153/2016

PERSON: Hiroo Advani, Shashank, Tariq Khan, Dbeojyoti Sengupta, Dayan Krishnan, Vasanth Rajasekaran, Sukrit Seth, Saurabh Babulkar, RAJIV SHAKDHER RAJIV SHAKDHER, Arb, Tehsil Devli, Maintenance Agreement, Dalkia, Annex A, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Paramdeep, Mahesh Indru Mansukhani, Rs.4385.71 Lacs, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Works, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, MISCELLANEOUS, Mike Rundle, Hiroo Advani, Shashank Garg, Dayan Krishnan, Vasanth, Advani‘s, Paramjeet, Kshitij, Mike Rundle, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dayan Krishnan, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Contract Agreements, Dalkia, Dalkia, Mansukhani, Sohanlal Datta, Krishnan, Dalkia, Articles 1.1, Paramjeet, Paramjeet, Paramjeet, Mike Rundle, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Contract Agreements, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, 8.1.1 Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Subject, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Dalkia, Supplier, Supplier, Works, Works, Dalkia, J.in Von Hatzfeldt-Wildenburg v. Alexander, Von Hatzfeldt-Wildenburg, T. Aswatha Narayana, Kollipara, AIR1933PC29wherein, Kollipara, Ridgway, Wharton, Von Hatzfeldt Wildenburg, Alexander, Gokhale, Articles 3.1, Annex C, Deliverables, Dalkia, Dalkia, Contractor, Contractor, Contractor, Advani, Handover, Kishori Lal Gupta & Bros., Mike Rundle, RAJIV SHAKDHER, JULY24

GPE: Clause, Chandli, Rajasthan, India, Kshitij, Rajasthan, Paris, New Delhi, India, India, India, Clause, India, India, Paris, India, Paris, India, Clause, Paris, Clause, Dalkia, Kollipara Sriramulu, India, Kollipara, albeit, India, India, India, India, India

ORDINAL: First, Second, first, First, Second, Third, Fourth, First, Second, First, second, first, third, Third, Third, firstly, secondly, second, third

PERCENT: nearly 100 percent, 49 31.2 Insofar, 0.5%, 5%, 5 %, 1 %, 2 %, 1 %, 2 %, 0.5%, 5 %, 0.5 %, 5 %, 10 %, 0.5 %, 5%, 10 %, 20%, 5%, less than 23.44%, 23.44%

PRODUCT: Indeen, 8MW Mustard, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Agreement, Indeen, Indeen, Agreement, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, the Contract Agreements, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Contract Agreements, Contract 5.4, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Indeen, Agreement, Agreement, Contract Agreements, Contract Agreements, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Contract Agreements, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Contract Agreements, Agreement, Contract Agreements, Contract Agreements, Indeen, Contract Agreements, Agreement, Contract Agreements, Agreement, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, the Power Plant, Indeen, Force Majeure, Indeen, Contract Agreements, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen, Von Hatzfeldt, Indeen, Indeen, Indeen

NORP: DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, Project, Indian, Indian, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, Consolidated, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, DIPL, Indian, Project, Project, DIPL, hereafter:"

WORK_OF_ART: 222.87 53.59 Total, Contract Agreements, Supply and Works, Supply and Works, Indeen and Dalkia, Time for Completion, Tests on Completion, Contract Agreements, The EPC Agreement, the Contract Agreements, The Contract Agreements, Contract Agreements, The Contract Agreements, Commencement Date, Commencement Date, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, Indeen and Prefinium, Contract Agreements, Indeen and Dalkia, Contract Agreements i.e., Tests on Completion of works, Supply Contract, Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, SCR387, Conditions of Contract Agreement, Commencement Date, Contract Agreement 1.6.1, Contract Agreement, Contract Agreements

LOC: the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, the Contract Agreements, Contract Agreements

LANGUAGE: English, English

FAC: the Contract Agreements, Indeen, the Contract Agreements, Clauses 1.16, Bonus, Indeen, 288

EVENT: between Indeen and Prefinium, Clause 5, Clause 1114, Clause 13, the Contract Agreement, this Contract Agreement, Clauses 1.6.1(b, the Contract Agreement, this Contract Agreement