Disposafe Health and Life Care Ltd. And Anr. Vs.hindustan Syringes & Medical Devices Ltd.

Decided On : May-03-2019

Court : Delhi

LAW: the Indian Companies Act, the Companies Act, the Trade Marks Act, Section 17, Section 15 of the Act, Section 17, Section 17, the T.M. Act 1999, Section 17 of the Act, Section 17 of the Act, Section 17 of the Act, Section 29

CARDINAL: 02.2019, 272/2018, 272/2018, 1, 29, 1, two, 2018.2, three, 2, 29, 48, 18, 3, Hindustan‟s, 166.77, 24.02.2016, 4, 29, 5, 29, 7, more than 3500, Hindustan‟s, more than 4500, 250, 170, Hindustan‟s, 6, 7, tabular, 38699.50, 26, 2007/2008.27, 8, 139/2016, 170, 32, 9, 29, 16, 10, 29, 126, 11, 29, two, 12, 29, seven, Hindustan‟s, 139/2016, 13, 29, millions, more than 18, 14, 29, 15, 29, DISPOSAFE.30, Hindustan‟s, 16, 32, Millions, 17, 29, 17, 18, 49, 28, two, two, 19, 94, 38, 107, 20, 29, one, 1, 39, one, one, 40, 18-145, 259, 18, 21, 16, 69, 42, 41, two, 22, 29, two, 23, 29, 9, one, 2, 12, 3, 24, 29, 2, 25, 29, one, two, 3, 4, 3, 26, 29, 43, two, Hindustan‟s, 27, two, 47, 28, 29, 29, 29

MONEY: FAO(OS, multi-million dollar, up to USD $ 1.5' million, Hindustan‟s marks, Hindustan‟s trade marks, 31 marks, 19 marks

DATE: 269/2018, 48680-48681/2018, 48934-48935/2018, 1494/2016, four weeks, November 28, the year, 2007, 1956, 2007, 2011, 2013, 2007, the first eight months, 2013, 24, July 25, 2013, 29 4, February 17, 2016, 2654034, January 03,2014, December 24, 2013, 2014-15, the year 1986 and, 2006, 2013-14, 1986/2007, 1986, 2007, 1956, the year 2006, the year 2013, 2016, three years, 29 10, the year 1959, 2013-14.12, the year 1959, 1971, 1986, 1987, 1989, 1991, 1992, 2001, 2007, 2008, 2014, 29 14, 1986, 2006, 2016, the year 1986, the year 1986, 2006, April 01, 2011 to August 27, 2008, April 01, 2011, December 18, 2007, the year, 29 2569927, the year 1986, 2006, Call 2017, 70, the year 1986, 1986, February 7, 2018, the year 2013, October 27, 2017, 1999, 2013, February 7, 2018, last many years, 2007, the first eight months, years, July 17, 2006, July 21, 2006, 1291326, March 2016, 2016, 2007, January 13, 2014, the year 1986, the year 2006, February 24, 2016, 1951, 1956, 1989, 1986, 2006, 1986, 2007, 2013, 29 35, 2012, 36, 29 37, 2010, 42, 1968, 29 41, 1989, 1946, 63, 42, 1981, 2009, 1899, 30, 1950, the day, the year 1959, 1986, 2586568, 29 45, 2 weeks

ORG: CAV10742018 & C.M. APPL, DISPOSAFE HEALTH & LIFE CARE LTD & ANR, SYRINGES & MEDICAL DEVICES LTD, CAV10792018 & C.M. Appl, DISPOSAFE HEALTH & LIFE LTD & ORS, RESPONDENTS Counsel, FAO(OS, JALAN MR, FAO, Disposafe Health & Lifecare Ltd, DHL, Disposafe Healthcare, DH, DH, Hindustan Syringes and Medical Devices Ltd., DHL, DHPL, Hindustan, DISPO, Hindustan‟s, DISPOVAN, I.V. Cannulas, Stop Cock, Disposafe Health and Life Care Limited', DH, DISPOSAFE, DISPOSAFE, Association of Indian Medical Device Industry, Ashoka Estate, the Trademark Registry, FAO, the Trade Marks Register, Hindustan, Disposafe Health and Life Care Limited, Disposafe Healthcare Private Limited, Healthy Life, DISPOSAFE, DISPOSAFE, DISPOCANN, Hindustan, DISPOSAFE, DISPOVAN, DISPOCANN, DISPOSAFE, DISPO, Hindustan, DISPOSAFE, FAO, DISPOCANN, DISPOVAN, DISPOSAFE, Hindustan, Hindustan, DISPOCANN, DISPOVAN, Hindustan, DHL, Hindustan, FAO, DISPO, DH, Hindustan, DISPOSAFE, DISPOCANN, Hindustan, DISPO, DISPOSAFE, DISPOVAN, European Union, FAO, Hindustan, Japanese Corporation, USD2273 million, K1 Design Auto Disposable, DISPOCANN, DISPOCANN, Hindustan‟s, DISPOSAFE, DISPO, I.V, I.V, FAO, Hindustan, the Global Vaccine Alliance, Plaintiff, IV Cannulas, DISPOCANN, Hindustan, DISPOCANN, DISPO, DISPOVAN, DISPOSAFE, DISPOSAFE, DISPO, FAO, DISPOFLEX, the Trade Marks Registry, DISPOSAFE, DISPO, the Trade Marks Registry, DISPO, DISPOSAFE, No.2569950, No.2569923, DISPOFLON, No.2569926, DISPOWAY, DISPONEO, No.2569929, DISPO, the Trade Marks Registry, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, Pvt Ltd 2005(3, Court, Godfrey Philips India Limited, Girnar Food & Beverages"4, Court, FAO, Court, Court, FAO, DISPO, Hindustan, Hindustan, Hindustan, Appellants, DHL, I.V. Cannulas Way Stop Cock, DH, Hindustan, the Examiner of Trade Marks, Examiner, Examiner, DH, DISPOSAFE, FAO, DISPOSAFE, DHL, DHPL, DH, Hindustan, Hindustan, Hindustan, DISPOCANN, Disposafe, Hindustan, DISPO, Generic/Descriptive, DISPO, DISPO is Disposable Medical Device, Court, FAO, Disposafe, DISPOSAFE, DISPO, DISPOSAFE, DISPO, the Trade Marks Registry, Hindustan, DISPOWAY, Hindustan, FAO, DH, DH, DH, Hindustan, Hindustan, DISPOCANN, DISPO, Dispocann, DISPOCANN, DISPO, Hindustan, DISPOCANN FAO, DISPO, DISPOCANN, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, Hindustan, the Trade Marks Registry, Plaintiff, Veidehi Surgicals Private Limited, Veidehi Surgicals Private Limited, Notice of Opposition, Hindustan, Aggarwal Surgicals, the Trade Marks Registry, Aggarwal Surgicals, Hindustan, DH, CS, DH, DISPOSAFE, Hindustan, the Trade Marks Registry, Hindustan, DISPOCANN, DH, FAO, Hindustan, Hindustan, Plaintiff, DISPOCANN, DISPO, Hindustan, DISPOCANN, DH, DISPOVAN, DISPO, FAO, Hindustan, DISPOCANN, Hindustan, DISPOSAFE, Hindustan, FAO, FAO, Carlsberg India Pvt, Radico Khaitan Ltd., Court, Britannica (https://www.britannica.com/topic/portmanteau-word, FAO, Schering Corporation & Ors, Alkem Laboratories Ltd., TEMOKEM, KEM, ALKEM, KEM, Alkem Laboratories, Getwell, TEM, TEM, TEM/TEMO, TEMOKEM, TEMOGET, TEMOKEM, TEMOGET, TEMODAL, Court, FAO, TEM, DAL, TEMODAL, TEM, claimant‟s, Bristol Pharmaceutical, FAO, Equity Access v. Westpac, Office Cleaning v. Westminster, McCain International v. Country Fair, Court, Cadila Healthcare Ltd, Milk Marketing Federation, FAO, Cellular Clothing, A.C. 326, FAO, Sections, Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, FAO, mark.--(1, FAO, FAO, Hindustan, Hindustan, DISPOFLEX, DISPOFLON, DISPON, DISPOWAY, DISPONEO, DISPO-ONE, FAO, DISPOSAFE, DISPO, Hindustan, DISPO, Hindustan‟s, Hindustan, DH, FAO, DH, S. RAVINDRA BHAT, JALAN, FAO

PERSON: Respondent FAO(OS, Amit Sibal, Hemant Daswani, Soham Kumar, Aisvary Vikram, Saksham Dhingra, Peeyosh Kalra, V. Mohini, Udayvir Rana, JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT HON'BLE, JUSTICE, JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT, Injection Stopper, Nebulizers, Rajiv Nath, Hindustan, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPON, DISPO, Sunil Mittal, DISPO, Parties‟, DISPO, V. Himalayan Drugs Co., DISPO, Injection Stopper, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, DISPO, Appellants, Dispovan, Dispo, DISPO VN, DISPO VN, Dispovan, Disposafe, Rothauser, Colin Murdoch, Manuel Jalón Corominas, DISPOVANN, Portmanteau, McCarthy, Unfair Competition, Kerly‟s Law, Ref Bristol-Myers, marks--, DISPO SUCTION SET, DISPO VN, DISPO -CAP, DISPON, DISPO, Dispo

PRODUCT: IA26182016, Disposafe, Hindustan‟s, Disposafe, PALONE8

GPE: C.S., Dubai, Germany, Brazil, USA, India, New Delhi, I.V., I.V., India, USA, India, I.V., I.V., India, India, Bangladesh, People's Republic of China, Kenya, Pakistan, South Africa, Tanzania, WIPO, Ghana, Iran, Morocco, Oman, Philippines, Turkey, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, New Zealand, New Zealand, DHA‟s, isolation.34, Radico, Carlsberg, Radico, Carlsberg, Trade Names, India, India

ORDINAL: first, first, second, first, first, first, third, first, secondary, third, first, third, first, first

WORK_OF_ART: Hindustan, Disposafe For Healthy Living, Disposafe For Safe Lancets, Disposafe for Healthy, DISPONEO, Disposafe, Sugar Free', Sugar Free', Disposafe, Dispo, DISPOVAN, DISPOVAN, DISPOVAN

FAC: Barakhamba Road, Hindustan, Hindustan

LOC: Europe, Middle East, Africa, South- East Asia, question.108, Trademarks, Trademarks

LANGUAGE: legalese, English, English, English, English, English

NORP: Australian, Australian

TIME: 8 PM', 8 PM', 15:45 hours, 35 of the Act