Ajay Gandhi and Ors. Vs.union of India and Ors.

Decided On : May-03-2019

Court : Delhi

LAW: the Cadre Allocation Policy, Constitution, Rule 3 of the Civil Services Examination Rules, Constitution, Constitution, a Constitution Bench, Phase-II, the IPS Officers of, the Income Tax Act, Rule 18, Maxwell 12th Edn., Cal 7, the IPS Officers, the IPS Officers, Constitution

DATE: 11454/2019, 11597/2019, 3903-3905/2019, 3906-3908/2019, 3922-3923/2019, 1954, 2017, 2017, 2017, 03.12.2018, 19.12.2018, 2017, 86/2019, 62 5, 2017, 2017, 2017, the earlier years, 2017, 2017, 2017, 19.12.2018, 19.12.2018, 19.12.2018, 1954, 11.12.2018, 14.12.2018, 19.12.2018, 62 3, 62, the 1st, the 1st, the 1st preferred Zone, 99 99, 99 99, 99 99 99, 1 14, 62 15, the 1st, the 1st, the 1st, the 2nd, the 1st, 2017, 2017, 2017, Para 4, Para 8(iii, Para 8(iii, 62 22, 23, Para 8(iii, 2008, 2017, 2017, 2017, 2017, the subsequent year, 2011, 1985, 1985, 1985, 62, Articles 14 and 16(1, 2004, 1985, 1999-2003, 1985, 2006, 2007, 2001, 99‖ 29, 62 32, 1994, 1954, 2017, 2018, 07.12.2018, 10.05.2019, 15.05.2019 to 15.05.2020, February 2019, April 2019, May 2020.34, 2017, 2018, 2017, weeks, 15 weeks, 07.12.2018, 42-week, 17.12.2018, 62 36, 2018, May 2019, 2017, 2016, 2008, 33-37, 62 34, 2002, 2002, 1993, 1992, 1993, 36, 2004, 2003, 2003, 1993, 1992, 1993, 37, 1993, 1992, 1993, Spring 2007, 1979, 1908, 1915, 1916, 1908, 1989, 1979, 1981, 1981, 40, 1991, 2017, 22.02.2017, 2017, 2008, 2008, 1986, 1949, 1972, 1077, 1981, 1981, 1981, 1975, 1976, 1984, 46, 2011, 27-7-1999, 1999, 2001, 1998, 1985, 1998, 62 48, 19.12.2018, 19.12.2018, May, 62 2019, December 2018, the year 2020.50, 2010, 2012, 17, 1981, 1975, 1979, the year 1973, 52, 1974, 1974, 1974, 19.12.2018, 1954, 19.12.2018, 27.07.1999, 02.10.1999, the year 2001, 1998, a couple of days, 2017, 62 61, 2017, 62 65, 31.05.1985, 2017, 76, 2017, 62 77

CARDINAL: 04.2019, 3, 3, 3, 3, 62, two, 20.12.2018, 19.12.2018, 20.12.2018, four, 06.12.2018, 62, 5(1, 20.12.2018, 20.12.2018, 62, 62, 05 .09.2017, five, 8, one, 5.6.7, 8, three, 7, 8, 9, 10, 4, 62, 8, 2017/, 13, No.2, two, 676, 196, 62, No.2, 2, 12, 4, No.2, one, No.2, 198 201, 13, 62, 17, 14, 62, 12, 2017/, 3, one, five, one, 4, 15, 62, 4, 4, 8, 8, 16, 62, 10, 4.21, 2, 17, 62, 18, 19, 25, 19, 62, one, two, 20, 62, 23, 3 and Note 4, 3, 24, 21, 62, 99, 22, 62, 7, 31, 2, 1, 2, 31, 3, 31, 23, 16(1, 25, 3, 31, 30, 30, 9, 31, 24, 62, 8, 1, 101, 277, 27, 4, 4, 4, 62, 99, 99, 99, 99, 26, 62, 330, 27, 6, 5, 33, 27.08.2018, 10.12.2018, 18.05.2020, 26.06.2020, 62, 180, 99, 71, 71, 47, 24, 4, 99, one, 109, 27.08.2019, 28.08.2020, 17.06.2019, 40, 150, 50, 99, 150, 50, 27, 23, 4, 100, 150, 30, 62, 1 SCC780, one, 12, 478- 79, 31, 4, 3, 1, 2959, No.2, 1, 3, 600, 3, 1, 32, 62, 3, 1, 1, 26, two, 572-73, two, 268, 219, 393-95, 33, 62, 35, 43, 136, 35, two, 34, 62, 39, 8, 4, 131, 1, 41, 35, 62, One, one, 36, 62, 6.1, 2 SCC237, 2, 164, 62, 13, 1, 38, 62, 16, 4, 293, 4, 200, 2, 1 SCR451, 2, 8, 23, 39, 62, 2, 36, 31, 36, 47, 40, 41, 208, 31, about 360, one, 99, two, 42, 62, one, three, three, three, 17, 1982.‖, 43, 62, One, 44, 62, 4, 2, 3, 1, about 120, 15, 3, 296, 16, 56, one, 45, 62, two, 5(1, 46, 62, 36, two, 47, 62, 99, one, 48, 49, 62, 50, 51, 62, 31.05.1985, 52, 62, 99, 53, 62, two, 3, 4, one, 99, 54, 62 73, 4, one, 10, 4, 4, one, 55, 62, 5.3.1, 8, 56, 19

ORG: VERMA, ANR, UNION OF INDIA, Shailesh Madiyal, UNION OF INDIA & ORS, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 1 of, 864/2019 & CM APPL, UNION OF INDIA, 869/2019 & CM APPL, UNION OF INDIA, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 2, the Central Administrative Tribunal, O.A. No.4576/2018, the Indian Police Service, the Central Government, the Indian Police Service, the Civil Services Examination, CSE, IPS, CSE, the Office Memorandum, Court, Original Applications, Tribunal, W.P., the Indian Administrative Service, CSE, Central Government, W.P.(C., 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 3 of 62, Court, IPS, CSE, Court, Tribunal, Tribunal, O.A. No.4576/2018, Tribunal, the Tribunal in O.A. No.4576/2018.4, Court, Tribunal, Tribunal, Tribunal, O.A. No.4576/2018, Tribunal, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 4, CSE, IAS, IPS, CSE, CSE, IAS, IPS, CSE, IAS, CSE, IPS, CSE, IAS, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 5, IAS, Court, the Indian Police Service, Tribunal, the Tribunal in, O.A. No.4576/2018, the Central Government, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 6, No.13013/2/2016-AIS.I Government of India Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions Department of Personnel & Training ― North Block, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 7, the All India Services- IAS/IPS/IFoS — Reg, the Central Government, State Governments, the All India Services-Indian Administrative Service, The Cadre Controlling Authorities, the Department of Personnel and Training (, Ministry of Home Affairs, Ministry of Environment, Unreserved, Outsider, States/Joint Cadres, Himachal Pradesh, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Zones, zones/, the Zones/Cadres, Zones, x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x x, Home, W.P.(C., 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 9 of, Outsider, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 10, Cadre Controlling Authority, CCA, Outsider, IAS, the Foundation Course, LBSNAA, the Civil Services Examination, Indian Forest Service Examination - 2017.‖, W.P.(C., All-India Ranks, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 11, State, Joint Zones Cadres, 2nd Preferred 3rd Preferred, 6th Preferred Cadre Uttarakhand Punjab, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Maharashtra, Cadres, the States/ Cadres Tamil Nadu, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, TN, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Haryana, W.P.(C., 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Civil Services Examination, Indian Forest Service Examination, zones/, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, zones/, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, CSE, the Zones/Cadres, Zones, Zones/Cadres, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Cadre Allocation Policy, the Cadre Allocation Policy, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Cadre Allocation Policy-2017, Rank 4, Rank 5, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Cadres, Jammu & Kashmir, the Cadre Allocation Policy-2017, the All India Services, IAS, IPS, AIS, Zonal, The All India Services, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, All India Services, AIS, the All India Services.‖, Indian Administrative Service, Indian Police Service, Detailed Application, the Civil Services, the Civil Services Examination Rules, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, CSE, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, C.M., Government, Court, Court, Court, the All-India Service, Clause, State, Joint, the Central Government, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the All-India Service, State, Joint, the Civil Services Examination, State, the High Court, Civil Services Examinations, The High Court, Court, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Court, M. Nagaraj v., Union of India, L&S, Gurudevdatta VKSSS Maryadit and Ors, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 25, zones/, Court, zones/, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Central Government, the State Government, the State Government, IAS, IPS, All-India Services, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Supreme Court, Union of India, IAS, the Supreme Court, an All India Service, State Cadres, State, State, The Central Government, the Indian Administrative Service, the Central Government, the Central Government, The Supreme Court, IAS, State, the IAS Officers, CSE, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 28, State, the Indian Administrative Service, CSE, CSE, LBSNAA, Mussorie/, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 29, IB Module, Traffic Management Module, Academy, Academy, IPS, CSE, O.M., 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Spentex Industries Limited Vs, Central Excise & Others, The Supreme Court, the Central Government, the Central Government, Government, CIT, the Central Board of Direct Taxes (, the Tax Authorities, Court, CBDT, CBDT, Parliament, W.P.(C., 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the House of Lords, Westminster City Council, National Support Service, WLR, Parliament, Craighead, Wilson, First County Trust Ltd., WLR, Pepper v. Hart, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Parliament, Court, Delhi Stock Exchange Assn. Ltd., Crawford on Statutory Construction, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Bagarti, ILR, ILR, ILR, Government, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Principle of Contemporaneous Expositio, the Supreme Court, State, Mahi Traders & Others, Court, Delhi Stock Exchange Assn. Ltd., ITR597, Ajeet Singh Singhvi Vs, UPSC, CSE, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, O.M., Jammu & Kashmir, CSE, CSE, the All-India, IFoS Services, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the All India Services, Statute, Court, Court, Court, the Supreme Court, inter alia, Seaford Court Estates Ltd., Plowden, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page 37, Parliament, Parliament, Parliament, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Parliament, State Bank of Travancore v., Som Prakash Rekhiv, Union of India, L&S, CIT, Nasik Merchants Coop, Bank Ltd., Union of India & Others, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Tribunal, IPS, Civil Services Examinations, The High Court, Tribunal, Court, IPS, the Civil Services Examinations, O.M., IAS, W.P.(C., 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Court, Court, Tribunal, Tribunal, O.A. No.4576/2018, IAS, IAS, IAS, IAS, Court, IAS, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the IAS Officers, Court, Union of India, the Spentex Industries Limited, the Supreme Court, the Central Government, The Supreme Court, the Central Government, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, The Supreme Court, Prem Parkash Pahwa Vs, United Commercial Bank & Another, the Supreme Court, Office Organisation, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, The Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, the Union Government, the Union Government, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Union Government, L&S, L&S, the Union of India, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, IPS, the Court/ Tribunal (Petitioners in WP(C, IPS, IPS, the Indian Police Service, the Tribunal/ Court, Court, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Reliance, IPS, Civil Services Examination, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, IAS, IPS, CSE, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Principle of Contemporaneous Expositio, Government, CSE, Reliance, Spentex Industries Limited, Government, Government, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Principle of Contemporary Expositio, Spentex Industries Limited, Government, the All India Character, the All India Services, Jammu & Kashmir, Naxal, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Government, the Supreme Court, an All India Service, State, State, State, The Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, the Central Government, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, Government, Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India.68, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, an All India Service, State, Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution, The Supreme Court, the High Court, The Supreme Court, Court, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, All India Services, Government, Government, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, OM, OM.72, zones/, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, zones/, first &, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, the Cadre Allocation Policy, the Cadre Allocation Policy, 864/2019 & 869/2019 Page, anomaly

PERSON: Sandeep Sethi, Neeraj Malhotra, Parmatma Singh, Madhur Jain, K.M. Nataraj, Suparna Srivastava, Debasish Raut, Advs R-1, Naresh Kaushik, Rajshekhar Rao, Ankur Khandelwal, Utkarsh Sharma, Gowrang, K.M. Nataraj, Manish Mohan, Manisha Saroha, Shailesh Madiyal, Debasish Raut, Naresh Kaushik, Petitioners Through, Rajshekhar Rao, Ankur Khandelwal, Utkarsh Sharma, Gowrang, K.M. Nataraj, Manish Mohan, Manisha Saroha, Shailesh Madiyal, Debasish Raut, Advs R-, Naresh Kaushik, Petitioners Through, Rajshekhar Rao, Ankur Khandelwal, Utkarsh Sharma, Gowrang, K.M.Nataraj, Manish Mohan, Manisha Saroha, Shailesh Madiyal, Debasish Raut, Advs R-, Naresh Kaushik, VIPIN SANGHI HON'BLE MS, W.P.(C, Principal Bench, W.P.(C, Nos, 864/2019, W.P.(C, No.869/2019, W.P.(C, 864/2019, W.P.(C, No.869/2019, 864/2019, 864/2019, Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe, Rajasthan, Haryana, Jammu Zone-II, Madhya Zone-IV Meghalaya, Sikkim, Tamil Nadu, Cadre, Cadre, Cadre, Zone Zones Order, Jharkhand Odisha Uttar, Tripura West IV Meghalaya, Karnataka Kerala, Cadre Karnataka, Cadre Kerala Chattisgarh Himachal, Cadre Not, Cadre, Rajasthan, Roma Srivastava, Haryana, Lodha, Pushkar Sharma, Tamil Nadu, Rajat Chaturvedi, Tamil Nadu, Tamil Nadu, Harsh Singh, Tamil Nadu, Tamil Nadu, Sandeep Sethi, Sethi, Sethi, Sethi, Sethi, Sethi, Cadre Allocation, Sikkim, A, B, A, Zone, Cadre, IFoS, Cadre Allocation Policy -, Sethi, Sethi, Rajshekhar Rao, 864/2019, Sethi, Rao, Vikrama Varma v. Avinash Mohanty and Others, Avinash Mohanty, Vikrama Varma, Avinash Mohanty, Vikrama Varma, Avinash Mohanty, Andhra Pradesh, Vikrama Varma, Vikrama Varma, Avinash Mohanty, Vikrama Varma, Vikrama Varma, Neeraj Malhotra, Malhotra, K.M. Nataraj, Nataraj, Rajiv Yadav, Rajiv Yadav, Nataraj, Batch, Nataraj, 864/2019, Batch, Nataraj, Mussorie, Nataraj, Nataraj, Nataraj, Bill, Bill, Steyn, AC816, Hansard, Francis Bennion, Bandhu Gupta, Mathuramohan Saha v. Ram, Kumar Saha, Mookerjea, Baleshwar Bagarti, Bandhu Gupta, K.P. Varghese v. ITO, Supp, Nataraj, Nataraj, Nataraj, Natatraj, Nataraj, Balbir Nath Mathur & Others, Asher, Simon, K.P. Varghese v. ITO, Mohd, M. Khan, Ravula Subba Rao v., Govindlal, Babaji Kondaji v., Nataraj, G. Srinivas Rao Vs, Nataraj, Sethi, Wednesbury, Sethi, Nataraj, A. Janardhana v. Union, AIR1983SC769, Articles 14, Nataraj, 864/2019, Natraj, G. Srinivas Rao, Nataraj, Nataraj, Nataraj, Nataraj, Government/, Nataraj, Nataraj, Rajiv Yadav, Vikrama Varma, Nataraj, Sethi, Nataraj, Cadre Allocation Policy

GPE: Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, New Delhi, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, 869/2019, 869/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, New Delhi, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Uttarakhand, Bihar, Jharkhand, Odisha, Gujarat, Manipur, Tripura, Nagaland, West Bengal, Kerala, Telangana, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Outsider, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Outsider, Outsider, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nagaland, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Telangana, No.2.16, Nagaland, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, forms.19, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, West Bengal, Assam- Meghalaya, Manipur, Tripura, Nagaland, Zone-IV, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, India, States, India, India, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, India, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, 869/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Clause, States, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, States, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, 05.10.2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, 06.04.2019, 869/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Pepperv, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Baleshwar, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Tamil, Rajasthan, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, States, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, India, India, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, OA, States, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, O.A., Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, G.M., Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, 869/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, C.M., Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019, Nos.109/2019, 862/2019

NORP: J.1, Forests, Zones, Punjab, Maharashtra, North Eastern, Note4, Rules, R., Secundrabad, Statute

ORDINAL: first, first, first, second, First, Second, first, first, first, first, 2nd, 5th, 2nd, first, 2nd, 4th, 5th, first, 3rd, 2nd, second, first, first, fifth, 5th, 4th, 4th, first, secondly, firstly, secondary, Firstly, first, Firstly, Firstly, Secondly, first, first, firstly

PRODUCT: No.1, Para 7, Para 7, 229, No.1, Para 5.3, Para, Para, Para 5.2, Articles 14, Para 3, the IPS Officers, SCC466, AC593, AC593, AC593, Respondent 4, Respondent 1

TIME: 10.12.2018 i.e., 40 minutes

LOC: Single, Single, Kashmir, North East, the Scheduled Castes, the North-East, North East, South Central Railway, the North-East

FAC: Pradesh Zone 2 Chhattisgarh Gujarat Madhya, Roster, the Manipur-Tripura Cadre, the Government/ State, the Government/ State

EVENT: the Constitution of India, the Wednesbury Principle of Reasonableness

PERCENT: 27%, nearly 37%, 37%

QUANTITY: 1 SCC449:1981

MONEY: 3) marks, 3) marks, 3) marks, 3 & 4

WORK_OF_ART: LLJ312