North Delhi Municipal Corporation and Anr. Vs.munish Anand

Decided On : Mar-22-2018

Court : Delhi

LAW: No 206, Contractor‟s, Order XII Rule 6, Order XII Rule 6, Shri Munish Anand, Order XII Rule 6, Order No.1 - Order, Section 16, Order No.1', Order No.1, Order No.2, Order No.3, Order No.1, Order No.1, Order No.1, Order No.1, Order No.1, Order No.1, Order No.1, Order No.1, the Indian Contract Act, the Indian Contract Act, Article 12 of the Constitution, Article 14, Section 31(1, Section 19A, the Indian Contract Act, Section 16(1, the Indian Contract Act, Section 16(1, the Indian Contract Act, the Indian Contract Act, the Indian Contract Act, Section 23, The Indian Contract Act, Constitution, the Fundamental Rights, Constitution, Condition 8, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Article 14 of the Constitution of India, Section 23, the Contract Act, Section 23, the Contract Act, the Contract Act, Section 46 of the Contract Act, Section 46 of the Contract Act, Section 46, the Contract Act, the Contract Act, Section 46 of the Contract Act, Section 46 of the Contract Act, Order XII Rule 6, Section 3, the Interest Act, Section 3, the Interest Act, the Interest Act, Section 23, the Contract Act, Section 3 of The Interest Act, Section 34, Section 31(7)(a, Section 34, Section 41 and Section 3 of Arbitration Act, the Constitution Bench, the Arbitration Act, the Interest Act, the Contract Act, the Contract Act, Section 25, Section 46

CARDINAL: 24, 1, 61, 9, 45, 45, 2, 61, 6, 29.5.14, 206, 391098.00, 131104.00, 16043.00, 673496.00, 3, 2, 9, 5, 14.7.14, 4,40,407/-(gross, 4, 29.5.14, 30.1.15, 25.9.14, 15, 45, 45, 17, 10, 45.11, 14, 5, 61, 15, 12, 13, 6, 61, 14, 17, 15, 15, 7, 61, 16, No.1, 2, 11,95,698/-, 25.07.2015, 89-91, 192/2016, 8, 61, 2, 6, 9, 61, 10, 61, 18, 14, 15, 11, 61, 16, 16, 19, 12, 61, 15, 13, 61, 16, 14, 61, 840/2017, 3, 01.12.2016, No.4, 3, 01.12.2016, 3, 27.9.2017, 27.9.2017.4, 15, 61, 4, four, 9, 1, 16, 61, two, 24, 25, 17, 61, three, 3, 4, 18, 61, 1, 10, 141, 29, two, 19, 61, 4, 30, 45, 20, 61, 31, two, 32, 9, 9, 9, Twenty thousand, 21, 61, twenty thousand, 22, 61, 23, 61, 5, 5, 33, 24, 61, 7, 9, 9A, 34, 17, 45, 25, 61 4, 9, 35, 1, 26, 61, 27, 61, 7, two, Rs.5, 9, 28, 61, 40, 5, 5, 41, 29, 61, 9, 30, 61, two, 3, 31, 61, 89, 32, 61, four, 33, 61, 92, 34, two, 229, 130, 55, 35, 61, one, 36, 61, 16, 32, 2, 8, 37, 61, 38, 414, 9, 25,000, 2, six, one, 39, 61, 273, 25,000, 52, 25, 40, 61, 53, 5, 11, 41, 10, four, 42, 61, 1, four, 43, 61 57, 44, 61, 17, 45, 61, 46, 60, 45, 17:-"The, 61, 47, 61, 45, 61, 15, 6, two, 134, 49, 61, 15, 1, 5, 8, 50, 61, 67, 5, 68, 224, 51, 61, two, 224, 52, 61, 69, 9, two, 9, 9, 5, 53, 5, 72, 1, 54, 61, 55, 23, 9, 56, 78, 7, 9, two, 57, 61 79, 9, 81

DATE: January, 2018 Date, 22nd March, 2018 +, 9650560021, 19th May, 2006, 10th June 2014, September 2013, 1195698 + 145163, May, 2015, 61, 19.05.2006, the Head quarter, 61 1,47,147/-(gross, April, one year, 23rd January, 2016, 8th February, 2016, 19.05.2006, 19.05.2006, 23rd January, 2016, 1st December, 2016, 24th October, 2016, 49, 16, 1st December, 2016, 17.11.2016, the end of each month, three years, ninety days, 90 days, three years, 90 days, three years, a period of, two years, the end of the third year, day one, 17.11.2016, 17.11.2016, 1st December, 2016, 17th November, 2016, three years, 90 days, three years, 90 days, a period of, two years, the period of two years, day one, 1st December, 2016, 23rd January, 2017, 10055/2015, 23rd January 2017, 27th September, 2017, 25th September, 2017, 25.09.2017, 192/2016, October, 2017, 25.09.2017, 192/2016, December, 2016, three years, 1st December, 2016, 15th September, 2017, the month of November, 2017, the first week of December, 2017, September 2017, 2017, 5th January, 2018, 1st December, 2016, 1st December, 2016, three years, 90 days, 1989, 1989, 1st December, 2016, the 1st December, 2016, December 2016, month, the 30th working day, the day, three months, one month, months, months, 19th May, 2006, 10th June 2014, one year, the 30th working day, 1872, 15th July, 2007, 1797/2007, three months, six months, 1872, three months, one month, months, 6. months, 3 months, 6 months, 6 months and 9 months, the earlier 3 months, 6 months, 1986, today, 1963, 1963, 1872, 61 years J., 1902, the year 1902, Seventy-eight, 1824, 1971, today, 45, 46, 2015, 48, years, 61, 1911 1, 1911, ' January 1, 1898, 1911 1, 2009, 2008, 61 54, 2011, 1 year, 5 years, 10 years, 1981, 2006, May, 2006, 6 months, 9 months, the 6 months and 9 months period, 59, twelve months, six months, twelve months, six months, last day of the month, 3 months, six months, 10th June 2014, one year, 3 months, 6 months, 5th January 2018, 6 63, 2011, 9th January, 2013, 1992, 2004, 2009, 1978, 09.04.2009, 1978, 17th July, 2017, 1978, 9th March, 2016, 14th September, 2017, 17thJuly, 2017, 17th July, 2017, 17.7.2017, 17.7.2017, 2015, 1872, 19th May, 2006, 1978, 2017, 1996, 1996, months, months, 6 months, 9 months, 1992, the years, 61 73, 1940, 1978, 19th May, 2006, 6 months and 9 months, 6 months, 9 months, payable.76, 6 months, 9 months, 6 months - 9 months, 61 77

ORG: RFA4432017 & CM APPL.16182 & 16183/2017, NORTH DELHI MUNICIPAL CORPORATION & ANR, Contractors/Plaintiffs, the North Delhi Municipal Corporation, East Delhi Municipal Corporation, EDMC, Contractors, Corporations, Contractors, Engineer, Contractors, The Trial Court, Contractors, Corporations, Clauses 7, the General Conditions of Contract, Corporations, the General Conditions of Contract for Municipal Corporation, Corporations, Circular, Clause 7 and Clause 9, the General Conditions of Contract, EDMC, Contractors, Rs.13,40,861/-, Corporation, Rs.1,45,163/-, Corporation, NIT, Corporation, Engineer, No.75, Corporation, CPC, the Trial Court, CPC, Corporation, Labour Officer, DW-1, DW-1, the General Conditions of Contract.15, Corporation, RFA4882016, Court, the Trial Court, the Work Orders, Trial, DMC, Nr, DMC, EDMC, Learned Single, Court, the Corporations and Contractors, Non-Plan Expenditure, Division, the Head Quarters, Divisions, Nos.14 to17, RFA7912016, EDMC, Court, EDMC, Court, Corporation, Contractors, Contractors, Contractors, Corporation, the Trial Court, Contractors, EDMC, Contractors, Contractors, W.P., Contractors, Corporation, Corporation, Learned Single, Court, Court, Corporation, 839/2017, Court, Court, Order no.2, Court, Court, Court, Court, Corporation, Clauses 7, the General Conditions, Court, Special Leave Petitions, the Supreme Court, Contractors, the Supreme Court.23, the Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, the East Delhi Municipal Corporation, Corporation, the Supreme Court, Special Leave, the respondent- Corporation, the Supreme Court, the High Court, the High Court, The Supreme Court, Contractors, Court, Supreme Court, The Supreme Court, Learned Single Judges, Court, the Supreme Court, Contractors, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Municipal Corporation, the Supreme Court, Court, Contractors, the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, Contractors, Clause 7 and Clause 9, the General Conditions of Contract, Corporation, Contractors, the General Conditions of Contract, Corporations, General Conditions of Contract, the General Conditions of Contract, the General Conditions of Contract, the Executive Engineer, Corporations, Clauses 7, the General Conditions of Contract, Contractors, Clauses, the Corporation are Clauses 7 and, the General Conditions of Contract, Intermediate Certificate, Engineer, Schedule, Engineer, Engineer, Engineer, Asst, Engineer, Asstt, Engineer, Engineer, Asstt, MCD, Corporation, General Conditions of Contract, Circular, the Office of Chief Engineer, Corporation, the General Terms & Conditions, the General Terms & Conditions, & ADJ Courts, MCD, MCD, Arbitration/Court Cases, Clauses, Circular, Corporation, Corporation, Contractors, the Supreme Court, Principal, the Supreme Court, Engineer, Contractors, Engineer, Engineer, Corporation, Corporation, Corporation, Corporation, Court, MCD, Contract, MCD, Court, Engineer, Engineer, Engineer, Asstt, Department, MCD, Corporation, Court, Corporation, Contractors, Corporation, the General Conditions of Contract, Court, Clause, Corporation, Corporation, State, Corporation, Engineer, Engineers, Contractors, Corporation, Corporation, Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Limited, Brojo Nath Ganguly, the Supreme Court, State, Burrough, A.C. 484"Public, E.R. 294 and 1824, Enderyby Town Football Club Ltd., Football Association Ltd., Equity, Directive Principles, Court, Brojo Nath Ganguly, the Supreme Court, Standard Contract, the General Conditions of the RFA4432017 Page, Indian Oil Corporation Limited v. Nilofer Siddiqui & Ors, the Supreme Court, IOCL, Indane Gas, Court, Court, Brojo Nath Ganguly, the Supreme Court, IOCL, Circular, Corporation, Corporation, State, Corporation, Corporation, Corporation, Corporation, The Punjab & Haryana High Court, Watling v. Lewis, Court, Tewkesbury Gas Company, Sheppard's Touchstone, Warrington, Court, Hungerford Investment Trust Ltd., Haridas Mundhra, Court, the Supreme Court, Mundhra, Court, Mundhra, Corporation, Bank of India, Super Poly Fabriks Ltd., Central Excise, Corporation, Cauvery Coffee Traders, Contractors, the General Conditions of Contract, 7 & 9, Corporation, Corporation, Corporation, Engineer, the Supreme Court's, Corporation, New Bihari Biri Leaves Co., State of Bihar, Corporation, Corporation, the Supreme Court, the General Conditions of Contract, Clauses, the General Conditions of Contract, Corporation, Corporation, Contractors, Contractors, Engineer, Engineer, the Security Deposit, Security Deposit, Labour, Engineer, Deposit, Circular, Clauses, Engineer, Labour, Clauses, the General Conditions of Contract, The Supreme Court, Order XII Rule, Engineer, the Clauses of the General Conditions of RFA4432017 Page 48, the Clauses of the General Conditions of Contract, the Trial Court, CPC, Corporation, Corporation, Himani Alloys Ltd., Tata Steel Ltd., Corporation, CPC, the Trial Court, Order XII Rule, Court, DDA, Delhi & Anr, Varinder Jeet Singh, Ghaziabad Development Authority, SCC507 Sri Venkateswara Syndicate, Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., CPC, NDMC, Court, the General Conditions of Contract, N.K. Garg Co., this Court in Union of India v., N.K. Garg 2015, Court, Corporation, N.K. Garg, Court, FAO(OS, Corporation, N.K. Garg, N.K. Garg, Court, Court, Union of India Vs, M/s N.K. Garg & Co., M/s N.K. Garg & Co., Court, the Division Bench, M/s N.K. Garg & Co., Court, Court, M/s N.K. Garg & Co., Corporation, Corporation, CPC, Court, the Supreme Court, Union of India Vs, Chittaranjan Maity Vs, Union of India, the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, the Supreme Court, MCD, The Supreme Court, Indian Courts, Court, Court, Clauses 7 & 9, Contractors, Corporation, Single Judges, Court, Corporations, Contractors, Corporation, The General Conditions of Contract i.e., EDMC, Corporation, Corporation, Corporation

PERSON: Appellants MUNISH, Renu Gupta, Vinay Kumar, PRATHIBA M. SINGH Prathiba M. Singh, b. c. Refund, Delhi Works, Conditions, Sunil Goel, Mini Pushkarna, Vinay Kumar, Background, Contractor, Contractor, no.206 Dated 13.9.13, Contractor, Engineer-, Principal, passed:-"(i, Sudhir Gupta, Contractor, Order No.1, Principal, Yashpal Gulati v., given.27, Queue, Subsequent Orders No.2, Gurnam Kaur, Yash Sehrawat v. Board of Control for Cricket, Principal, Order Nos.1, Contractor, Jagbir Singh Sharma v., Jagbir Singh, Jagbir Singh, Jagbir Singh, Jagbir Singh, Anr, Anr, Janson, Richardson, Alexander the Great taming Bucephalus, William Holdsworth, Anr, Sibal, Nilofer Siddiqui, Anr, Contractor, I.K., Sohan Singh v. State, Tysoe v. The, Lewis, J., Kapur, Law, Mangalore v. Hornor Resources, Contractor, Veerayee Ammal Vs, Law Lexicon, Varinder Jeet Singh, Varinder Jeet Singh‟, Jagbir Singh, Irrigation Deptt, G.C. Roy, Balbir Singh, Anr, Order XXXVII, Prem Chand Gupta, Prem Chand, G.C.Roy, Thawardas, Jena, Roy, G.C. Roy

FAC: Clauses 17, Clauses 17, Head Quarter, Clauses 17, Clauses 17

PRODUCT: Contractor, N.I.T Tender, 30.4.15 Rs, Queue, Order No.1, Contractors, Queue, Queue, Queue, SCC537to, No.2 - Refund, Order XII Rule 6

ORDINAL: first, first, first, first, first, 9th, third, 15th, first, first, second, second, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, second, first, first

NORP: North DMC, Tender, RFA1922016, NrDMC, NrDMC, English, NrDMC

WORK_OF_ART: ISSUES1 Whether the plaintiff, Shri Jagdish Chander, Contract Act‟, The Master of the Rolls, the Common Law, History of English Law, N.K., Bright Power'

PERCENT: 7.5%, 9%, 9%, 9 %, 9%, 75%, 10%, 24%, 8/9%

GPE: RFA7862016, RFA7012016, RFA7882016, RFA7892016, p.a., p.a., Delhi, India, funds.36, CS(OS, England, India, s.c., same.33, Watting, R.K. Pabbi, CS(OS, Orissa, Prem Chand Gupta, Prem Chand Gupta, G.C., Prem Chand Gupta, Principal

TIME: 7 SCALE638(hereinafter