M/S. Adani Power (Mundra) Ltd. Vs. Gujarat Electy reg.commission .

Decided On : Jul-02-2019

Court : Supreme Court of India

LAW: Section 63, the Electricity Act, the Fuel Supply Agreement, the Electricity Act, Article 3.1.2 of the PPA, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Article 8 3.1.2, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Article 3.4.2 and Article 14.1, Article 14.2, Article 3, Article 3: CONDITIONS SUBSEQUENT TO BE SATISFIED BY THE SELLER AND THE PROCURER31 Satisfaction, Article 3.4, Article 3.1 3.4.1, Article 3.4.3, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4.1, Article 3.4.1, Article 3.1.2, this Article 3.4.2, Article, Article 3.1.2, the Condition Subsequent, Article 3.1.2, Article 14, Article 8, the Due Date, the Due Date, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.1, the Due Date, Article 14.1, the Capacity Charge of the Seller, Article 14.3.4, Article 14.2, Article 11.5.2, Article 14.4.1, Article 14.2, Article 3, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4, Article 3.1, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.1.2, Article, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.1.2 of the PPA, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2 (i, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2 (i, the Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2 (i, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2 (i) and (ii, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2 and Article 3.1.2, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Article 3.1.2 of the PPA, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Article 3.1.2.27, Article 14, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.1.2, The Constitution Bench, Constitution, Section 47, Article 14, Article 14.1, Article 14.3, Article 14.2, Article 14.4, Article 3.4.2, Article, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 14, Article 3.4.2, Article 3.1.2, Article 3.4.2, Article 14 of the contract.35, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, the Notice of Termination of PPA, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Article 3.1.2, Morga-II Block, Article 3.4.2 of the PPA, Section 62, the Electricity Act, Section 62, the Electricity Act

CARDINAL: 1, 07.09.2011, Three, three, No.2, No.2, 11.01.2007, 1000, 2.35, 1000, 3, 2.89, No.2, 1000, No.2, No.2, 01.05.2008, 4, No.2, 15.11.2008, 5, 28.04.2009, 6, 25, 75, 25, 86(1)(f, 95, 07.09.2011, 7 8, No.2, 10, 100, 1000, 5, 16, 12, 9, No.2, 3, 3.1.2The, Twelve, three, eight, at least seven, 10.00, 3.4.3In, 12, at least seven, 14, twelve, two, three, sixty five, twelve, 12, twelve, 12, 13, thirty six, 1, three, 1, six, 10, at least thirty, thirty, 14, thirty, 14.2, thirty, 9, at least thirty, thirty, 16, 14.3, 14.3.3, seven, three, 14.4 Termination, 18, 14.4.3, 14.4.4, seven, three, 19, three, 15, 20, 5, 23, two, two, 8, 9, 14, 14-15, 13-15, 13, 21, 14, 15, 17, 4, 10, two, 18, 23, 11, 1, 17.The, one, 19, 3, 19, 2, 158, 4, two, 7, 7, two, 25, 48, 8, 143-44, 33-35, 33, 26, 10, 51, 51, 2, 2, 227, 1, 2, 609, 268, five, 2, 2, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 28, 1, 1, 1, 20, 29, five, 1, 2, 3, 4, 30, 5, 4, 31, 10, 10, 85, 32, 89(vi, 10, 34, 8, two, two, two, 2, 1, 2, one, 36, one, 12, two, 2)The, one, two, one, 37, 8, one, one, 30, 3.4.2, 14.1, 14.2, 14.3, 14.4, 14.2, 10, 14.2, 39, 5(a, 10, 5(a, 23, 33, 4, 20, 34, 3, 1.2, 37, 15.11.2008, No.2, 42, 1000, 39, 43, 1000, 1000, 41, 44, 2.35, two, No.1, No.2, No.2, 2.35, 2.89, No.2, two, 9.9.2006, No.2, 47, No.2, 15, 12, 13, 48, 48, 49, 50

ORG: THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL, Court, the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, the Appellate Tribunal, the Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission, Commission, Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd., MW, RFQ, LOI, MW, the Power Purchase Agreement, MW, Korba, Chhatisgarh, Mundra Power Project, Chhatisgarh Project, MW, Mundra Power Project.5, Gujarat Mineral Development Corporation, the Government of Gujarat, FSA, FSA, the Government of Gujarat, FSA, the Government of Gujarat, FSA, FSA, the Government of Gujarat, FSA, GMDC, FSA, FSA, the Government of Gujarat, the Government of Gujarat, Government, FSA, PPA, Sections, Commission, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, the Appellate Tribunal, FSA, MW.10, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, Reliance, Court, Indian Oil Corporation, Amritsar Gas Services Ltd., Savji Haribhai Patel & Ors, the Appellate Tribunal, Reliance, Court, Solar Semiconductor Power Company, FSA, Reliance, English Courts, Court, Reliance, Court, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, the Effective Date, Letter of Intent, Performance Guarantee, Performance Guarantee, MW of the Contracted Capacity, the Performance Guarantee, MW of the Contracted Capacity, Performance Guarantee, the Performance Guarantee, the Performance Guarantee, the Other Party, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, Seller Event of Default, a Force Majeure Event, Seller Event of Default, Commission, Scheduled Commercial Operation Date, Project, the Seller’s Construction Contractors, Project, Commissioned, Rated Capacity, the Effective Date, Tested Capacity, the Tested Capacity of the Unit(s, Commercial Operation Date of Contracted Capacity, Average Availability, Rupees One, an Event of Default, Procurer Event of Default, a Force Majeure Event, the Event of Default, the Collateral Arrangement and Letter of Credit, an Event of Default, Seller Event of Default, Seller Event of Default, the Seller a Procurer Preliminary Default Notice, Procurer Preliminary Default Notice, the Consultation Period of, the Consultation Period, the Seller Event of Default, the Contracted Capacity, Capacity Charges, Normative Availability, the Consultation Period, the Contracted Capacity, Lenders, Lenders, Lenders, Schedule 14, Lenders, Seller Event of Default, Procurer Event of Default, Procurer Event of Default, the Procurer a Seller Preliminary Default Notice, Seller Preliminary Default Notice, the Consultation Period of, the Consultation Period, the Procurer Event of Default, the Contracted Capacity, Available Capacity, Capacity Charges, Normative Availability, the Consultation Period, the Energy Charges, the Contracted Capacity, Available Capacity, Tariff, Court, Rajasthan State Industrial Development and Investment Corporation, Diamond & Gem Development Corporation Ltd. & Anr, Vide United India Insurance Co. Ltd., Polymat India, National Insurance Co. Ltd., DLF Universal Ltd., Town and Country Planning Deptt, Court, Court, Bharat Aluminium Company, Kaiser Aluminium Technical Services INC, Court, Nabha Power Ltd., NPL, Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd., Court, Court, the Privy Council, Belize Telecom Ltd., Nabha Power Ltd., Nabha Power Ltd., High Courts, Court, Dhanrajamal Gobindram, the House of Lords, Hillas & Co., Arcos Ltd., the Judicial Committee, the House of Lords, the House of Lords, Adamastos Shipping Co. Ltd., Anglo-Saxon Petroleum Co. Ltd., AC, Union of India, D.N. Revri & Co.{(1976, Bench, J., Court, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., Court, Trollope, Colls Ltd., North West Metropolitan Regl, Hospital Board, WLR, Court, the Officious Bystander Test, B.P. Refinery, Proprietary Ltd., the Officious Bystander Test, Investors Compensation Scheme Ltd., West Bromwich Building Society, Belize v. Belize Telecom Ltd., Court, Nabha Power Ltd., the Appellate Tribunal, FSA, Letter of Intent, MW, The Appellate Tribunal, the Appellate Tribunal, Appellant, the Power Purchase Agreement, the Power Purchase Agreement, Procurer, the Power Purchase Agreement, MW, the Appellate Tribunal, the Appellate Tribunal, the Officious Bystander Test, the Appellate Tribunal, Tribunal, Court, Calcutta Gas Company, State, Lists, State, the Government of India Act, Court, Court, Court, CPC, Court, Court, 4)The Courts, 5)To, Court, U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction, Court, MW, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, the Appellate Tribunal, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, J.K. Cotton Spinning, Weaving Mills Co. Ltd., State of Uttar Pradesh, the U.P. Government Order, Court, Maharashtra State Board of Secondary, the High Court, Adani Enterprises Ltd., the State of Chhatisgarh, M/s Coal Orbis Trading GMBH, M/s Kowa Company Ltd., Project, FSA, Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd., Energy, Petrochemicals Department, Government of Gujarat, Government of Gujarat, Industries, Mines Department, Government of Gujarat, Naini, Morga-II, M/s. Adani Ltd., MW, Torrent Power Ltd., Gujarat’s, Naini Block, M/s. KSK, FSA, Naini, the Government of Gujarat, The State Government, Morga block.40, the Executive (Finance, Energy, Petrochemicals Department, Government of Gujarat, Government of Gujarat, MW, FSA, MW, the Government of Gujarat, FSA, GMDC, Project, FSA, the Appellate Tribunal, Adani Enterprises Limited, the Gujarat Mineral Development Corporation, the State of Chhatisgarh, Appellant, the Appellate Tribunal, the Appellate Tribunal, the Order of the Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, this Court by Interlocutory Application, Civil Appeal, Court, Respondent(s, CERC, CERC, Bench, J.Chelameswar, Court, Government of Gujarat, CERC, State Govt, CERC, Court, Court, Court, Commission, the Appellate Tribunal, the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission, CERC, CERC, CERC, CERC, CERC, CERC, CERC, CERC, CERC

PERSON: APPELLANT(S, RESPONDENT(S, JUDGMENT B.R. GAVAI, J.1, Kwh, Naini, Morga- II, 04.01.2010, Gopal Jain, M.G. Ramachandran, Mega Watt, Jain, Jain, Shanti Devi Gaekwad, Jain, Ramachandran, Shri Ramachandran, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Rupees Rs, Procurer, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Procurer, Seller, Rupees One, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Bid, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Seller, xiii)The Seller, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Bill, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Law, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Power Station, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Power Station, Procurer, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Anr, Harchand Rai Chandan Lal, trumps, Anr, Shamji Kalidas, Wright, Viscount Simonds, P.N. Bhagwati, Satya Jain, Anis Ahmed Rushdie, Ranjan Gogoi, Bowen, LR14PD64(CA, Bowen, LR14PD64(CA, Manubhai Dharmasinhbhai Gajera, KB, Sanjay Kishan Kaul, LR14PD64(CA, Ranjan Gogoi, Bystander Test, Articles 3, Seller, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Procurer, Lakhs, Procurer, Seller, Seller, Seller, Seller, Mega, Patanjali Sastri, J., Narothamdas Jethabhai, List, List, Order XXI, Sultana Begum, Prem Chand Jain, Anwar Hasan Khan, Mohammed Shafi, Articles 3.1.2, Bhupeshkumar Sheth, Articles, MoUs, Morga, Seller, Memorandum, Abhay Manohar Sapre, JJ.It, Order, 04.01.2010, J.[B.R. GAVAI, J.[SURYA KANT].

DATE: 2010, 01.02.2006, 2003, 2000, 24.11.2006, 06.02.2007, No.1.4, 12.02.2007, 18.04.2007, 21.05.2007, the month of June, 2008, 17.01.2009, 27.02.2009, 17.01.2009, 15.11.2008, 17.01.2009, 28.12.2009, 30.12.2009, 28.12.2009, 05.01.2010, 28.12.2009, 2003, 01.02.2010, 31.08.2010, 7 days, 1991, 2001, 2007, 2017, 12), Months, Fourteen, 14), Months, 3) Months, 8) months, 7) days, ten (10) days, the end of eight, Months, ten (10) Months, 7) days, 12), Months, Months, 30) days, less than ninety two, Months, Months, Months v, 36) Months, 3) Months, 6) Months, 30) days, 30) days, 30) days, thirty (30) days, 8 Months, Monthly, Monthly, 90) days, 30) days, thirty (30) days, 30) days, 30) days, 90) days, 7) days, 3) years, the eighth day, the three year 17, three year, 90) days, 7) days, 3) years, the eighth day, three year, three-year, 3) days, three-year, three year, 2013, 2004, 2005, 2010, Today, 2016, 2018, 2009, 46, 1961, 1291, 1932, 1959, 1958, 47, 2013, 1889, 1889, 34, 2008, 27, 1973, 1973, 35, 49, 1889, 1926, 1977, 1977, 1998, 1998, 2009, 12 months, 14 months, the period of 3 months, 8 months, at least 7 days, 33 25, 1951, 1935, 1)It, 38, Articles 14.1, 1984, 41 36, 2006, 21st Dec 2006, 27.02.2009, 30.12.2009, 28.12.2009, 2nd February, 2007, January, 2012, 28.12.2009, 45 43, 70, 70, 44, 46 45, No.4 of 2015, 47, 23.11.2015, next month, March 2014, next month, March 2014, 2003, 2009, 23.11.2015, 28.12.2009, 49, 2009, a period of, three months, a period of, three months, 23.11.2015, JULY2 2019

GPE: the State of Gujarat, the State of Gujarat, Gujarat, Vermagiri, Transco, Shri Ramachandran, Belize, India, Bombay, Germany, Gujarat, so.46, I.A.

WORK_OF_ART: RFQ, Request For Proposal, Fuel Supply Agreement, 3.4 Consequences of non-fulfilment of conditions under, Anson’s Law, The Moorcock, Articles of the PPA, 1.2 Fuel: The, the Fuel Supply Agreement

FAC: Nani Khakhar, Procurer, the Delivery Point, Capacity Charge, the Delivery Point, Capacity Charge

PRODUCT: No.1, SCC101 11, No.1, Agreement, Rupees 10.00, Agreement, the Power Station, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Agreement, Morga II, Morga- II, No.1, Appellant, Respondent, Appellant

QUANTITY: 4 million tonnes, 180 CLR266(Aus

LOC: Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Procurer, Articles 14.1, the Respondent No.2

ORDINAL: first, first, third, third, third, third, third, second, first, first, second, third, 9th

PERCENT: 65%, 15%, less than 50%, 50%, 20%, 50%, 50%, 50%, 50%

EVENT: the Consultation Period, the Consultation Period, List II

LANGUAGE: English, English

NORP: Australian, Australian, Shirlaw, Lists, Lists, Gujarat, Morga

MONEY: 50 per cent