Garware Polyester Limited Vs. 3M Company and Another

Decided On : Jul-12-2016

Court : Mumbai

LAW: Classes 16, Section 32, the Companies Act, Section 29, Section 9(d, Classes 16, the Notice of Motion

CARDINAL: 1, 2, 15, 40.)and, 46)respectively, 42, 44)where, 48)Garware, 32, B1, 50, 3. 3, at least one, 4, 3, 3, 10).On, 257).3, 261).Further, 269, 271).The, 30(2, 35, 3, 6, 3, 3, 3, No.1, 12, 31, 34, 36, 38, 39, 8, one, 44).This, 9, 10, two, 11, 1, 1, 53).Central, 1, 267, 1, 288)use, 172, 1, 269).There, 1, 218)and, 1, 219)and, 1, 256, 263).An, 1, 283, 12, 40, 42, 44, 46, 48).The, 6316531B1, 1, 1, 307, 13, 1, 106)and, 1, 104, 1, 107, 14, 15, 12.13, 2, 33, 2, 16, 7, 611, 17, two, one, 18, 19, 25, 30, 1, 2, 35, 20, 51, 21, 3, 22, 3, 1, 54).In, 3, 3, 23, two, two, 24, 52, 600, 24, 29(1, 407, 920, 25, 65, 499, two, two, 39, 4, 26, two, 3, 28, 6, 29, 25, 12, One, 27).There, 29)UK, 29)WIPO, 30)and, 30, 17, only one, 33

PERSON: Garware, GARWARE SUNCONTROL, Garware, Garware, Garware, Garware s, Exhibit A2, Exhibit A3, Garware, Garware, Garware, Motion, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, V-Kool, Rejoinder Affidavit, Exhibit F, Rejoinder Affidavit, Rejoinder Affidavit, Exhibit H1, Rejoinder Affidavit, Exhibit H2, Garware, V-Kool, V-Kool, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, GARWARE SUNCONTROL, Garware s. For, Garware, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Garware, Tulzapurkar, Garware, Exhibit A3, Garware, Garware, Garware, Garware, Tulzapurkar, McCarthy, Thomas McCarthy, McCarthy, Tulzapurkar, Anr, Anr, Parker J., Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Garware, Tulzapurkar, Garware, Garware, Tulzapurkar, Garware, Tulzapurkar, J., Anr, Garware s, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Garware s. 27, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Garware, THERMOBEL SUNCONTROL, Tulzapurkar, Tulzapurkar, Kishanlal Gupta, Garware, Garware, Tulzapurkar, Garware

PRODUCT: 3M India, 3M, CLASSIC, CLASSIC, 3M Co, 3M Co, 3M or SCOTCHTINT, 3M s, 3M s, 3M s, 3M Co, Plaint, 3M s, 3M s sun, 3M s

ORG: SUNCONTROL, SUN CONTROL, SUN CONTROL, SUN CONTROL, SUNCONTROL, SUN CONTROL, SUN CONTROL, SUNCONTROL, SUN CONTROL Classic, GARWARE SUN CONTROL, SUNCONTROL, the Madrid Protocol (Plaint, B32, 3M Co., Post, SUNCONTROL, Plaint, Exhibit H, Plaint, Exhibit K, 3M Co, M, V-Kool Films, Sun Control Film, Garware s mark, SUN CONTROL, Garware s mark, Defendants, Defendant s Compilation, Defendant s Compilation, Defendant s Compilation, Defendant s Compilation, the Gujarat Motor Vehicles Rules, Defendant s Compilation, the All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Defendant s Compilation, Defendant s Compilation, Defendant s Compilation, Plaint, Exhibit A2, Defendant s Compilation, Defendant s Compilation, Emphasis, Defendant s Compilation, Defendant s Compilation, the Trade Marks Registry, SUN CONTROL, Garware Plastics and Polymers Limited, Sun Control, Sun Control, Defendant s Compilation, SUN CONTROL, the Examiner of Trade Marks, SUN, SUN CONTROL, Unfair Competition, say:(J., Unfair Competition, Schering Corporation, M/s, United Biotech Ltd, the Delhi High Court, Marico Limited, Agro Tech Foods Limited, SUN, British Vacuum Cleaner Company Ltd., New Vacuum Cleaner Company Ltd., Emphasis, Irvings Yeast-Vite Ltd., F.A. Horsenail, Garware s mark, M, Garware, ITC Ltd, Vazifdar, Sopariwala Exports and, Shreenathji Overseas, Notice of Motion No, Suit No, Court, Sapat International Pvt. Ltd., Girnar Food and Beverages Pvt. Ltd., T.V. Venugopal, Ushodaya Enterprises Ltd., Nestle India Limited, M, Court, the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, Satyam Infoway Ltd., the Supreme Court, SUN CONTROL, SUN CONTROL, American Sun Control Commercial Division, SUN CONTROL (, SUN CONTROL I.V., Sunanda Chemicals, Garnier Sun Control, Sun Shine Electric Co. Pvt. Ltd., HOTSPOT Sun Control

DATE: Class 17, Class 16, 1976, 1982, 1983, 1999, 1998, 17, 2002, Class 17, 95 203)and, April 2014, April 2014, 1999, TMA 1999, 1982, 2006, 1976, 1978, 1989, Class 17, 1993 to 2000, 2006, 2010, 2010, 44, 1999, the day, 2012, 25, 1994, 2013, March 31st, 2016, 2011, 2010, 42, 1980, 1958, 2004, 1969, 30 32, 9015132, 1977, 1st January 2013, 2087705, 1574496, Class 03, Class 17, 31, 32

ORDINAL: first, 26th, first, First, second, third

GPE: Aurangabad, India, pp, pp, US, Garware, Garware, Garware, Garware, Garware, Overdrive, India, UK, pp, Garware, America, Garware, Garware, Hem Corporation, Sapat, Garware, India, Garware, USA, pp, Belgium, Singapore, France, Garware, Singapore

PERCENT: 70%, 80%

LOC: Asia, Europe, South America, North America, Africa, Trademarks, Trademarks, Central Camera v Registrar of Trade Marks

NORP: Indian, Garware, Garware, Hindu, Indian, Indian

WORK_OF_ART: Ennore Port (Defendant s Compilation, 4th edition

FAC: Plaint, Exhibit A5, Sapat v Girnar

LANGUAGE: English

MONEY: two marks, two marks