Oil India Limited Vs. Essar Oil Limited

Decided On : Sep-29-2016

Court : Delhi

LAW: Article 15.2, Section 34, Rule 63, Article 5.1 of the Agreement, Article 5.2 of the Agreement, Section 14(1, Article 5 of the, Article 5.1, Article 5.1 of the, Article 5.2, Article 5.1 nor Article 5.2, Article 3.4 and Article 6.9, Article 9.9B, Article 6.9, Article 9.9B, Article 5.1 of the, Article 5.1 of the, Article 5.1 of the, Article 1.3, Article 2.3, article 5.1, Article 1.3, Article 2.3, Article 15.2, Article 5.1 or Article 5.2, Section 34

DATE: July 19, 1993, December 06, 1993, February 20, 1995, May 08, 1995, one year, Number of days, days, 163 days, 1 day, 15 days, July 16, 1996, August 29, 1995, March 31, 1997, August 29, 1995, July 16, 1996, October 12, 1996, three years, 1 August 1996, 16.10.1996, 12.1.1996, 12.1.96, November 1995, December 1995, 1/96/009, January 1996, April 1996, 1.12.1995, 1 July 1996, Rs.29,800/- per day, 1 January 1997, only one month, 1996, the plea of three years, three years, 2009, 2 years, two years, 2008, May 08, 1995, 2012, 1996, October 12, 1996, 4, 15, 16, 17, 20, 22, October 12, 1996, 30 days, 15 successive days, July 16, 1996, September 03, 1996, September 24, 1996, September 24, 1996, December 31, 1996, 163 days, October 01, 1996, the number of days, December 31, 1996, July 16, 1996, July 31, 1996, August 26, 1996, September 02, 1996, 16, September 03, 1996, September 24, 1996, September 21, 1996, September 23, 1996, the same day, September 23, 1996, September 25, 1996, September 26, 1996, September 28, 1996, October 01, 1996, L-4, September 03, 1996, September 24, 1996, 9.9(B, July 17, 1998, April 27, 1996, July 25, 1996, August 02, 1996, August 08, 1996, August 19, 1996, September 11, 1996, September 16, 1996, September 25, 1996, October 01, 1996, December 31, 1996, October 18, 1996, October 11, 1996, 16 35 N, July 15, 1995,, July 18, 1995, September 08, 1995, September 21, 1996, September 21, 1996, October 18, 1996, October 12, 1996, March 31, 1997, August 20, 1996, August 26, 1996, September 2, 1996, August 26, 1996, September 2, 1996, September 3, 1996, August 26, 1996, September 2, 1996, September 24,1996, October 1, 1996, October 5, 1996, October 1, 1996, October 5, 1996, October 8, 1996, 30 days, October 12, 1996, October 1, 1996, October 11, 1996, August 20, 1996, January 1997, between October and December, December 31, 1996, 163 days, 12 October 1996, 12 October 1996, between 1 October 1996, 11 October 1996, 1 October 1996, 12 October 1995, 1 October 1996, 1 October 1996, July 16, 1996, 15 days, December 1996, as early as August 13, 1996, August 20, 1996, January, 1997, July 16, 1996, September 3, 1996, 170 days, July 16, 1996, September 24, 1996, August 22, 1996, January, 1997, September 20, 1996, September 13, 1996, September 25, 1996, September 24, 1996, October 1, 1996, October 3, 1996, October 07, 1996, L-4, September 24, 1996 or, October 1, 1996, 18th October, 1996, October 07, 1996, October 07, 1996, 30 days, November 07, 1996, 30 days, 15 consecutive days, the 30 days, October 01, 1996, July 31, 1996, October 03, 1996, October 07, 1996, the 33rd day, the 33rd day, the 33rd day, October 07, 1996, October 01, 1996, October 12, 1996, December 31, 1996, 163 days, September 23, 1996, October 01, 1996, December 31, 1996, 163 days, October 12, 1996, October 18, 1996, 1996, 1996, 37, January 22, 2013

CARDINAL: four, three, three, 135, 28, three, 2, 3, seven, 1, 2, 3., 5., 4., 25.9.1996, 019, 17.10.1996, 10.3.96, 29.3.96, 7.7.1996, 12.2.96, 1, 8, 1.12.95, 12/95/08/Supplement, 12.3.96, 1.4.1996, 1.7.1996, 20.7.1996, 013, 1.5.1996, 15.Deduction, 8, 009, 1.3.1996, 1.4.1996, 13, 1.5.1996, 6, 31.3.2001Rs.8,58,72,150Rs.7,31,178NIL25.Expenditure, 5, 6, 50, 58, 146, 543, 8, 573, 2, 9, 10, tabular, 4, No.1, 11, 5.2, two, 5.2, 12, 13, three, two, one, two, one, 92, 14, 15, two, two, one, 17, 18, 19, 20, 20, 87, 21, 13, 22, 23, three, 996, 24, 25, 20(a, 20(j, 26, 2, two, two, one, one, one, 27, 13.2, 13.4, 13.7, 20(a, 20(j, 13.2, 13.4, 13.7, 28, 3, 14.2, 14.3, 14.4, 14.9, 14.12, 14.15, 14.16, 14.18, 14.23, 14.2, 14.3, 14.4, two, two, two, 14.9, 14.12.However, 14.15, 14.16, 14.18The, 14.23, 29, 30, 4, 31, 4.3, 3.3, 25.1, 3, 4, one, 2.3, 1.3, 4, 5.1, 32, 18 3/4, 33, 34, two, 35., 6.9, 7.2, 20(a, 20(j, two, 36, 1 to 3, 38, two

ORG: Offshore Oil/Gas Wells, Saurashtra Offshore, NIT, ESSAR, L-2, L-2, L-2, Arbitral Tribunal, the Arbitral Tribunal, DRDO, Claimant, Claimant, the Arbitral Tribunal, ESSAR, ClaimAmount, ESSAR Oil Ltd., Interlocation, ESSAR, ESSAR, Location L-1, TIW, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR/DISC/11/95/, -1, ESSAR, Invoice No, ESSAR/DISC/11/95/ 009, Invoice No, ESSAR, ESSAR, Liquidated Damages, ESSAR/DISC/11/95/ 00, ESSAR/DISC/12/95/ 008, ESSAR/DISC/01/96/, Claimant s InvoiceESSAR/DISC/11/95/ 007INV ESSAR/DISC/11/95/, ESSAR, Location L-2, Bank, Claimant, Works Pvt, M/s Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd., ESSAR, the ICA Rules, the Arbitral Tribunal, the Arbitral Tribunal, DLT, Reliance Industries Ltd., Madan Stores Pvt. Ltd., ESSAR Discoverer, ESSAR, Court, Niko Resources, the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, Oil India Limited, ESSAR, ESSAR, the contractor s office and/or, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, L-2, Saurashtra, BOP, OSV, the Offshore Supply Vessels, the Government of India, the Indian Navy/Off-Shore Defence Advisory Group, Defence Research Development Organization, ESSAR, ESSAR, Abu Dhabi, Offshore Supply Vessel, ESSAR, ESSAR, DRDO, DRDO, ESSAR, the Naval Authorities, ESSAR, DRDO, Ministry of Defence, BOP, the Offshore Supply Vessel, Abu Dhabi, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, Naval Authorities, L-1, ESSAR, Naval Authorities/ODAG, ESSAR, ODAG, ESSAR, DayRates, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, BOP, ESSAR, Paradip, ESSAR, Clause 6.9, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, Defense Research and Development Organisation, Offshore Defense Advisory Group, ESSAR, Arbitral Tribunal, Tribunal, DRDO, ODAG, DRDO, Easter Naval Command, Ministry of Defence, DRDO, Location L-1, e. Fax, DRDO, L-1, Location L-1, Government of India, Kalam, Scientific Advisor, Raksha Mantri, Ministry of Defence, ESSAR, g. Letter, Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas, DRDO, i. Letter, DRDO, j. Letter, the Naval Authorities, ESSAR Discoverer, Paradip, ESSAR, ESSAR, Government, the Petroleum Exploration License, the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas, the Petroleum Exploration License, DRDO, ESSAR, Paradip, ESSAR, DRDO, Navy, Locations L-2, ESSAR, DRDO, the Eastern Naval Command, Court, ESSAR, the Arbitral Tribunal, Court, DRDO, ODAG, DRDO, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, L-2, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR s competence, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, L-1, ESSAR, the Petroleum Exploration License, the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas, NEC, NEC, DRDO, Navy, ESSAR, L-1, ESSAR, ESSAR, Drilling Unit, BOP, ESSAR, Drilling Unit, the Drilling Unit, L-2, ESSAR, BOP, OSV, ESSAR, BOP, ESSAR, BOP, OSV, ESSAR, BOP, BOP, OSV, ESSAR, L-2, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, L-2, ESSAR, ESSAR, DRDO, Navy, ESSAR, DRDO, the Arbitral Tribunal, ESSAR, Government, DRDO, Location L1, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, Location L1, Contract, ESSAR, Contract, Contract, ESSAR, ESSAR, Contract, ESSAR, Location L-1, BOP, ESSAR, ESSAR, Contract, BOP, BOP, Abu Dhabi, the Arbitral Tribunal, Contract, OSV, BOP, OSV, BOP, Location L1, BOP, Contract, ESSAR, BOP, OSV, Arbitral Tribunal, BOP, Location L1, The Arbitral Tribunal, Contract, the Arbitral Tribunal, ESSAR, BOP, ESSAR, ESSAR, L-1, BOP, OSV, ESSAR, L-1, DRDO, ESSAR, the Drillship Unit, ESSAR, the Drilling Unit, the Drilling Unit, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, the Paradip Port, ESSAR s, ESSAR s persistent, Contract, OSV, BOP, ESSAR, ESSAR, BOP, OSV, ESSAR, TMI, ESSAR, BOP, ESSAR, BOP, OSV, ESSAR, BOP, OSV, TMI, ESSAR, BOP, Abu Dhabi, BOP, BOP, ESSAR, BOP, OSV, BOP, OSV, BOP, OSV, L-1, ESSAR, L-2, L-1, ESSAR, L-1, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR, BOP, Abu Dhabi, BOP, Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi, ESSAR, BOP, BOP, BOP, Abu Dhabi, DRDO, ESSAR, DRDO, ODAG, ESSAR, ESSAR, ESSAR s refusal, Paradip, Arbitrators, the Registrar General, Court, the Registrar General, Court

PERSON: Orissa Offshore, L-3, L-1, L-3, L-3, L-3, L-4, Counsels, Rajinder Sachhar, Retd, Bhubaneswar, Rs.8,58,72,150, Award, Harji Engg, L-4, Ciccu Mukhopadhyay, Sandeep Sethi, L-3, L-1, L-1, Paradip, Paradip Port, c. Letter, L-1, DRDO, Articles, L-3, L-3, Tradip Kataky RW-2, Paradip, Nos.2, L4 ESSAR, Tradip Kataky, Location L1, Location L2, L-1, L-3, No.12

NORP: Saurashtra, Paradip, d., Petroleum, Paradip, Paradip, Paradip, Paradip

GPE: L-4, L-4, India, Naval, Rajkot, litigationRs.40,00,000/-Rs.15,00,000NIL28.Loss, p.a., p.a., Delhi, Del., L-4, Orissa, Rajkot, Gujarat, Delhi, Naval, L-1, Naval, L-4, Naval, Naval, L-4, L-1, L-1, Abu Dhabi, L-1, L-1, L-1, L-1, Naval, Naval, Naval, Naval, L1, Rajkot, Delhi, L1, Naval, L-1, L-1which, L-1, L-4, L-4, L-1, L-1, Abu Dhabi, L-1, L-1

ORDINAL: first, first, first, second, second, second, third, first, first, first, first, second, second, first, Firstly, secondly

PRODUCT: Respondent, Respondent, Location L-4, Oil India Limited, Drillship, Location L-1, No.1, No.1, No.1, ESSAR Drillship

MONEY: 83,69,339, 4,416,047, 1,325,422/-, 750,000/-, US$ 750,000US$ 750,000NIL3.Invoice, 3,000,000/-, 3,000,0004.Invoice, 900,000/-, US$ 900,000US$, 2,166/-, US$ 112,338/-for, 2,580US$ 2,580US$, 2,580INTEREST, 124,277/-, US$ 124,277US$, 12,740, US$ 12,740US$ 12,740NIL13.Invoice No, US$ 3,478, US$ 3,478US$ 3,478NIL14.Invoice, US$ 27,707/-, US$ 27,707US$, 27,707NILDEDUCTIONS, 595,781.25, 595,781.25US$ 595,781.25NIL16.Invoices, 292,101.95, US$ 11,250 and US$ 94,375, US$ 897,726.95US$, 897,726.95, US$ 94,374.30US$ 94,374.30US$, US$ 259,375 and US$ 22,500US$ 281,875US$ 259,375NIL19.Invoice, US$ 50,625US$ 50,625NILNIL20.Invoice, US$ 102,083.33US$ 353,589.38NILNIL21.Invoice, US$ 1042US$ 1042NILNILCLAIM, 837,292, 313,985, US$ 4,350,674/-US$ 4,350,674US$ 349,423.51NILDAMAGES, 8,369,339, 4,416,047, US$ 3.5 million

PERCENT: 882,101.95NIL17.5%, 12%, 8%

LOC: Single Judge, the Orissa Coast, Single, Single

WORK_OF_ART: L-1, L-1, L-1

FAC: Paradip Port