Three Star Poultry Farm Vs. Governmnent of Tamil Nadu

Decided On : Apr-25-2014

Court : Chennai

LAW: Pillai 7/107-1, Partner S.N.Nityanandam 5/3, Partner R.Ganapathi 2/97 West, Section 15, Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Puratchi Thalaivar MGR Nutritious Meal Programme, Puratchi Thalaivar MGR Nutritious Meal Programme, Right To Information Act, Rule 31, Rule 13, Constitution, Constitution, the Noon Meal Programme Centres, the Noon Meal Programme, the Noon Meal Scheme, Section 9, the Arbitration Act, Right To Information Act, Article 226 of the Constitution of India

PERSON: JUDICATURE, S.N.Nityanandan 5/3, Vaiyappamalai Thiruchengodu Taluk Namakkal, Farms, K.S.Ponnusamy 3/76, Koilpalayam Sakthinaickenpalayam Thiruchengodu Taluk Namakkal, Azhagu Nagar Namakkal, Feeds, Rasipuram Taluk, Selliyayipalayam Karaikurichipudur Namakkal Taluk, Tamil Nadu, Flat No.3, Abdul Razaq Street Saidapet, K.Duraisamy, Kandan Duraisamy, A.K.Ganguli, A.Sr, Adithiya Reddy, Karthick Mukundan, L.Chandrakumar, G.Masilamani, K.Kumeresh Babu, Sathish Parasaran, Mani Sundara Gopal, M.Kempraj, M.S.Krishnan, Lesi Saravanan, S.Ramachandran, W.A.Nos.574, W.A.No.574/2013, Government Order, Government Order, Nachimuthu, S.N.Nityanandan, Tamil Nadu, Government Order, W.A.Nos.574, Directors, Demand Drafts, Kumarasamy, R.Chinnusamy, Bangalore, Kumarasamy, T.S.Kumarasamy, T.S.Kumarasamy, R.Chinnusamy , W.P.No.13320/2013, R.Chinnusamy, R.Chinnusamy, W.A.No.574/2013, A.K.Ganguli, T.S.Kumarasamy, T.S.Kumarasamy, Lokayukta of Karnataka, Government Order, Government Order, Government Order, Government Order, Nachimuthu, Nachimuthu, K.Kumeresh Babu, Sathish Parasaran, T.S.Kumarasamy, Karthick Mukundan, L.Chandrakumar, decisions:-, V. JARDINE HENDERSON, MANGAL ORAON, LTD.AND OTHERs.and, ANOTHER V. THALLAPPAKA ANANTHACHARYULU, W.P.No.13320/2013, W.A.No.574/2013, T.S.Kumarasamy, W.A.Nos.574, W.A.Nos.574, T.S.Kumarasamy, W.P.No.13320/2013, Villupuram, Thiruvannamalai, Government Order, Government Order, Level Single, Tamil Nadu TIT Act, No.95, Animal Husbandry, MLA, Government Order, Tamil Nadu, Eggs, Eggs, Law, Tenderer, Government Order, Nachimuthu, W.P.No.13320/2013, SHUKLA V. BHARAT PETROLEUM, HODGKINSON, Government Order, factORS.it, R.Chinnusamy, Namakkal, Government Order, Government Order, Chinnusamy, W.P.No.13320/2013, T.S.Kumarasamy, Anganwadi Centres, Backward Classes, Animal Husbandry, Animal Husbandry, Animal Husbandry, Neyveli, Nilgiris, T.S.Kumarasamy, Bangalore, T.S.Kumarasamy, Sathish Parasaran, T.S.Kumarasamy, Bangalore, R.Chinnusamy, Nachimuthu, Wednesbury, SCC287(MONARCH INFRASTRUCTURE, Ulhasnagar Municipal Corpn, SCC287

CARDINAL: 25.04.2014, 776, 2, 7, 1, 2, 5, 1, 4, 637, 641 653, 410, 637, 020, 1/121, 637 407, 188, 001, 13.Subbu, 3/30, 637 408, 15.Gounder, 3/211, 401 16.Sr, 408, 17.Thulasi, 641 653, 637, 020, 405, 20.Raj, 1/25, 600, 600, 2, 776/2013, 600 015, 600, 4, 3/234, 637 401, 2/218, 2/220, 637 214, 9, 7.6.2013, 7, 29.1.2014, 5, 9, 3, 7, 21.3.2013, 1, 2, 3, 18.2.2013, 776/13, 776/13, 776/13, 8, 776/2013, 6, R4, 776/13, 1.5.2013, 2.W.P.Nos.6896 and 7586, 17.10.2012, 18.2.2013, 21.3.2013, 776, 5, 776/2013, 5, 6, 3(i, 17.10.2012, 3(iii, One, 17.10.2012, 10.12.2012, 25.3.2013, 3(v, 10.1.2014, 3(vi, 17.10.2012, 18.2.2013, 21.3.2013, 776/2013, 3, 4, 18.2.2013, 1.5.2013, 3(ix, 17.10.2012, 18.2.2013, 7.6.2013, 1, 2, 18.2.2013, 7.6.2013, 1, 2, 17.10.2012, 18.2.2013, 5, 6, 18.2.2013, 7.6.2013, 1, 2, 17.10.2012, 18.2.2013, 5, 6, 1, 2, 9, 1/2013, 776/2013, 1, 2, 9, 5/2013, 30.4.2013, 5, 6, 5, 17.10.2012, 10.1.2014, 17.10.2012, two, 17.10.2012, 5, 1/2013, 776/2013, 5/2013, one, 3(xiv, 18.2.2013, two, 10.12.2012, 18.2.2013, 3(xv, one, one, 17.10.2012, Three, 1.5.1013, 3(xvii, 5, approximately 3,50,00,000, One, 5, 19.3.2013, 18.2.2013, 18.2.2013, 18.2.2013, 17.10.2012, 17.10.2012, 10.1.2014, 9.Mr, 5, 6, 30.4.2013, 10.It, 11.As, 3,50,00,000, one, 17.10.2012, two, two, 16.Mr, 7, 8, 17.Mr, 5, 6, 6, 5, 8, 10, 19.The, 9, 1, 1, 4, 1, 7, 2, 1, 1, 4, 12, 7, 4, 1, 2, 3, 18.2.2013, 21.In, 17.10.2012, 3, 3, 4, 22.Pending, 23.The, 24.Common, 1, 2, 776/2013, 3, A/2-4695, 3, 4, 3, 4, 200, three, 3, 3, 25.The third, 29.4.2013, 1.5.2013, 26.The, 776/2013, more than 200, 28.The, 17.10.2012, 18.2.2013, 29.QUESTION, one, 3, 4, 5, 6, half, II, half, 8), 9, five to six, 10, two, No.4, No.5, 30.8.2012, 29(iii, 2, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 24(2).VII, 1, 2, 3, 1, 2, X.The, 9, 16.10.2012., 60,00,000, 24, 2, 4, 6, 200, 8(a, three, 29(v, 60, 29(vi, 5, two, 10, 2, 17.10.2012, 17.10.2012, 113, 3, 4, 17.10.2012, 10.1.2014, 29(xii, 3, two, 2, 6, 6, half, 17.10.2012, 29(xiv, 60, 29(xv, 29(xvi, 29(xvii, 2/2013, 776/2013, 5, 17.5.2013, One, 5, 1, 60, 29(xx, 17.10.2012, 2/2013, 30.QUESTION, five, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, fiRs.three, 5, 19.3.2013, 2, 2, 26.05.1989, 13, 2, 3, 4, 5, 60, 6, 45, 30(v, 30(vi, 7, 8, 7.6.2013, 10.12.2012, 23.1.2013, 22.1.2015, 2/2013, 776/2013, 18.2.2013, 18.2.2013, 18.2.2013, 30(x, 17.10.2012, 18.2.2013, 30(xi, 6, 2)The, 4)The, one, 2, 7, 4, 5, 5, 12, 13, 748, Rs.2, one

ORG: HONOURABLE, W.A.No.574 of, Three Star Poultry Farm, N.Pudupatti, Sanampalayam Annur, Coimbatore North Taluk 2.S.S.Poultry Farm, Managing Partner S.Puvanendran, Kuppitchipalayam Maraparai Post, Poultry Farm, Kummampatti Road Valayapatti Post Namakkal Taluk, Namakkal Taluk 11.K.S.P.Poultry, Vanmathi Poultry Farms, Poultry Farm, Rasipuram, Managing Partner P.Kumaravel, Poultry Farm, Partner V.Pownambal 1/260, Poultry Farm, Coimbatore North Taluk 18.Sr, Venkateswara Agencies, Managing Partner, Poultry Farm, Poultry Farm, Managing Partner P.Arumugam, Khadi Board, Poultry Farm, Partner M.Anand 2/96, 1.The Governmnent of, Principal Secretary Social Welfare, NMP-3, Child Development Services Scheme, Food Ltd, Shreevari Apartment, Deal Food Ventures Private Limited G1, Food Products, Muthukalipatti Post Rasipuram, Pullagoundampatty Post Thiruchengodu, Namakkal District 7.Christy Friedgram Industry Private Ltd., A2-A3, Social Welfare Chintadripet, Court, WA7762013 &amp, Court, 27.3.2013, Pandian Additional Advocate General Assisted, RR5 &, Integrated Child Development Services Scheme, IDCDSS, 30.4.2014, Social Welfare and, NMP-3) Department, 27.3.2013, Court, 30.4.2013, Civil Appeals, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, W.A.Nos.574, Court, Social Welfare and, NMP-3) Department, State Level Tender System, Integrated Child Development Services Scheme, Government, the Accountant General, State Level Single Tender, the Tamil Nadu Transparency, R.Chinnusamy, W.P.Nos.32302, W.A.Nos.2011, W.A.Nos.2011, 10.2.2014, Three Star Poultry Farm, 27.3.2013, W.P.Nos.32302, W.A.Nos.574, Civil Appeals, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Court, AGMARK, AGMARK, AGMARK Certificate, State, M/s.Natural Food Products, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd, AGMARK, M/s.Natural Food Products, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd, M/s.Christy Friedgram Industry Private Ltd., 28.4.2013, 30.4.2013, the Director of Social Welfare, Social Welfare, 30.4.2013, Natural Food Products, , 30.4.2013, the Director of Social Welfare, Social Welfare, 30.4.2013, W.A.Nos.574, Court, M/s.Natural Food Products, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd, Tvl, Muthu, Chinnusamy, W.A.Nos.2011, 10.2.2014, the Tamil Nadu Transparency, Department, the Accountant General of, State, State, AGMARK, National Egg Co-ordination Committee, AGMARK, The Tender Inviting Authority, Tender Accepting Authority, the Tender Scrutiny Committee, Scrutiny Committee, 30.4.2014, Tvl, Arogya Food Limited, T.S.Kumarasamy, M/s.Arogya Food Limited, M/s.Fair Deal Food Ventures Private Limited, Thiru T.S.Kumarasamy, Companies, Government, the Tender Scrutiny Committee, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.LTD.It, Chrisaty Friedgram Industry Private Limited, State, the State of Tamil Nadu, Chinnusamy, State, State, the City Civil Court, Section 9 Application, the State of Karnataka, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd., M/s.Natural Food Products, Natural Food Products, Star Poultry Farm, Natural Food Products, State, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd., Directors, the Government of Karnataka, the Board of Directors, Natural Food Products, AGMARK, the Bureau of Indian Standards, Southern Regional Office, National Accreditation Board for Certification, HACCP, TCL Private Limited, the State of Tamil Nadu, State, Social Welfare, ICDS, State, State, Tender Inviting Authority, Tender Accepting Authority, the Tender Scrutiny Committee, M/s.Arogya Food Limited, Thiru T.S.Kumarasamy, M/s.Arogya Food Limited, Arogya Food Limited, Fair Deal Food Ventures Private Limited, M/s.Natural Food Products, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd., AGMARK, Christy Friedgram Industry, ICDS Scheme, Tamil Magazine, FIR, M/s.Christy Friedgram Industry, M/s.Natural Food Products, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd, Additional Advocate General, Court, State, Additional Advocate General, Tvl, Muthu, W.P.Nos.32302, Tvl, W.A.Nos.2011, 10.2.2014, Thiru R.Chinnusamy, Additional Advocate General, Arogya Food Limited, Fair Deal Food Ventures, Additional Advocate General, AGMARK, the State Government, State, ICDS Scheme, State, Court, the State of Tamil Nadu, Natural Food Products, Additional Advocate General, Chinnusamy, 30.4.2014, Court, Thiru T.S.Kumarasamy, High Court, Counsel, Additional Advocate General, M/s.Natural Food Products and M/s., MAL, SUPREME COURT, SUPREME COURT CASES1(NATURAL RESOURCES ASSOCIATION, Additional Advocate General, I., CASES478(NEW HORIZONS LIMITED, ANOTHER V. UNION OF INDIA, INTERNATIONAL, SUPREME COURT CASES19(DIRECTORATE OF EDUCATION, OTHERS).(v, REGD, V. UNION OF INDIA, CASES478(NEW HORIZONS LIMITED, ANOTHER V. UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS).(viii, CASES589(GANPATI RV-TALLERES, STANDARD CHARTERED BANK, Thiru R.Chinnusamy , M/s.Natural Food Products, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd, M/s.Christy Friedgram Industry Private Limited, the Director of Social Welfare, Government Department, AGMARK, Government Department, Natural Food Products, R.Chinnusamy, M/s.Three Star Poultry Farm, M/s.S.N.N.Poultry Farm, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd., Thiru T.S.Kumarasamy, Court, Additional Advocate General, Counsel/Counsel, Social Welfare and, NMP-3) Department, Social Welfare, State, State, NECC, I. Wide, State, State, Zonal, Social Welfare and, NMP-3) Department, Social Welfare, the State Level Tender System, State Level Tender, ICDS Scheme, the Principal Secretaries, Finance Department, Social Welfare and, Nutritious Meal Programme Department, State Level Tender, Government, State, Integrated Child Development Services Scheme, National Egg Co-ordination Committee, Integrated Child Development Services, Integrated Child Development Services, the Tender Inviting Authority, V.A Committee, Tender Accepting Authority, Social Welfare, Finance Department, Animal Husbandry Department, Chennai Region, Integrated Child Development Services, the Tamil Nadu Transparency, Integrated Child Development Services, Tender scrutiny Committee, Department, the Director of Social Welfare, Integrated Child Development Services, District Collectors, District Level Monitoring Committee, Block level Committee, G.O, District level committee, District Level Committee, District Collector, Collector (Nutritious Meal Programme, District Programme Officer, Integrated Child Development Services, The District Collector, Block Level Committee, Panchayat, Child Development Project Officer, Panchayat Presidents/ Councilors, the Finance Department, the Department of Integrated Child Development Services Scheme, Puratchi Thalaivar Dr., Integrated Child Development Services Scheme, the Tamil Nadu Transparency, AGMARK, Directorate of Marketing &, Department of Government, Department of Government, the Chartered Accountant, Department of Government, the Technical Project Consultancy Arrangement, Government Food Research Laboratory, the Project Consultancy Arrangement, Government Food Research Laboratory, Hazard Analysis Critical Control Point (HACCP, National Accreditation Board for Certification Bodies, NABCB, BIS, Clauses, the Earnest Money Deposit, State, State, State, Tvl, R.Chinnusamy, V.Muthu, W.P.Nos.32302, ICDS Scheme, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, State, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, Courts, W.P.Nos.32302, W.A.Nos.2011, 10.2.2014, Thiru R.Chinnusamy-appellant, Court, Counsel/Counsel, Additional Advocate General, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited, the High Court of Patna, the Patna High Court, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, P) LTD.V.METCALFE &amp, Court, State, Departments, State, State, Nutritious Meal Programme, ICDS Scheme, W.P.Nos.32302, W.A.Nos.2011, W.P.Nos.32302, W.A.Nos.574, AGMARK, Table Egg, the Department of Agriculture and Cooperation, Directorate of Marketing and Inspection, Ministry of Agriculture, Government of India, Thiru R.Chinnusamy, Natural Food Products, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises, Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd., Arogya Food Ltd., Ministry of Corporate AffaiRs, Tvl, Question, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, , State, Court, State, W.P.Nos.32302, AGMARK, State, State, Court, Arogya Foods Ltd., Fair Deal Food Ventures PVT.LTD.and, Thiru T.S.Kumarasamy, AGMARK, Bureau of Indian Standards, BIS, BIS, Additional Advocate General, Court, Noon Meal Centres, Anganwadi Centres, District Level, Government, SW &amp, NMP Department, the Tamil Nadu Transparency, District Level Tender, AGMARK, Joint, Noon Meal Programme Centres, Hospitals, Chinnusamy, Theni Districts, AGMARK, BIS, AGMARK, the National Egg Co-ordination Committee, AGMARK, Court, the Tender Document, Partners/Directors/Constituents, Thiru T.S.Kumarasamy, the Civil Court, the High Court, Fair Deal Food Ventures Private Limited, Natural Food Products, FIR, M/s.Christy Friedgram Industry Private Limited, the Director of Social Welfare, Court, the High Court, Court, Certification Marks License, the Tender Accepting Authority, W.A.Nos.574, R.Chinnusamy, State, State, Court, Muthu, W.P.Nos.32302, Chinnusamy, Chinnusamy, the Honourable Supreme Court, the Supreme Court, LTD.).the Supreme Court, Court, State, LTD.).the supreme Court, State, SUPREME COURT CASES19(DIRECTORATE OF EDUCATION V. EDUCOMP DATAMATICS LTD.AND, the High Court, The Hon'ble Supreme Court, Tata Cellular's, Air India's, ULHASNAGAR MUNICIPAL CORPORATION, Court, Monarch Infrastructure, Government, Directorate of Education, the Directorate of Education, the Technical Advisory Committee, the High Court, Government

DATE: 2013, 4, 6, 2013, 2013, 4, 2013, 2013, 2/219, 7586/2013, one year, 2013, 2013, 17130/2013, 4607/2013, 6, 4607/2013, the year 1989, 1998, one year, 32303/2012, 2012/2013, 2012/2013, 32303, 32741/2012, 2012, 7586/2013, one year, one year, November, 2012, February, 2013, 28.4.2013, November, 2012, February, 2013, several months, 6, 2012, 2012/2013, 2012, 6, 2013, the year 2014-2015, the sixth, 2012, 6, 14.5.2012, 6, 2012, 32303, 32741/2012, 2012, 2012/2013, 7586/2013, 2013, 2012, nearly 11 months, 2006, 2000, 2007, 2012, 2011, 1995, 2013, 1999, 2004, 2005, 2009, 2002, 1995, 2009, 1988, 2010, 2011, 2006, 2003, 2013, 32741/2012, monthly, years, November, 2012, February, 2013, 7 years, every month, 4, 4, 14.5.2012, monthly, weekly, monthly, quarterly, weekly, the start of the month, monthly, a six months period, quarterly, monthly, monthly, 17.10.2012, 14.5.2012, 2006, 1998, 2000, one year, one year, month, month, year, year, Tenders 1998 and Rules 2000, 16-06-2004, one year, 1998, every month, the preceding three yeaRs, annual, the preceding three years, the preceding three years, the preceding three years, tenderer. 29(vii, 29(viii, 32303, 32741/2012, 32303/2012, 2012/2013, 2014, 1999, 2012, 2012, 32303, 32741/2012, 2012/2013, 32303/2012, 7586/2013, 6, 6, 2005, 32303, 32741/2012, 29(xxi, 6, 365 days, a year, only 220 days in a year, Tenders and Rules 2000, one year, a month, the year 2004, 2012, 32303, 32741/2012, 2012, 1994, 94, 1999, 2000, 2004, 2000, 2000, the year 2002-03, the last three yeaRs

MONEY: 5/133, 1 SCC492(RAUNAQ INTERNATIONAL LTD.V.I.V.R.CONSTRUCTION LTD.).(2000, 1 SCC492(RAUNAQ INTERNATIONAL

FAC: Namakkal District 6.Suvarnabhoomi Enterprises PVT.Ltd S.F.No.46/1, FiRs, Managing Partner Thiru P.Veera Pillai, the Tamil Nadu Transparency Act, Eggs, Eggs, Eggs, INDIA LTD.V.COCHIN, Bullet Egg

NORP: Tender, Pandian, Indian, Panchayat, Tender, Tender, Rules, Feeds, Indian, Indian, Thoothukudi

PRODUCT: R4, M/s.Three Star Poultry Farm

WORK_OF_ART: R5 in WA574&amp, Districts, The Principal Secretary/ Special Commissioner of Integrated Child Development Services Scheme, Marking) Act &

GPE: India, Nachimuthu, India, Nachimuthu, Nachimuthu, Nachimuthu, the State of Karnataka, the State of Karnataka, Karnataka, the State of Karnataka, States, Karnataka, Counsel, the State of Karnataka, OTHERS).(vii, SINGH V. STATE, Rules, Rule-24, WP, No.3566, India, India, India, India, Tamilnadu, India, India, L1, Nachimuthu, Kanniyakumari, Karnataka, the State of Karnataka, the State of, Karnataka, Nachimuthu, Nachimuthu, India, Delhi, Delhi

ORDINAL: second, 9th, 9th, second, second, second, third, second, third, third, second, fourth, fourth, sixth, seventh, second, eighth, sixth, seventh, fifth, eighth, fifth, sixth, sixth, sixth, sixth, second, second, second, sixth, sixth, sixth, second, sixth, sixth, sixth, sixth, third, fourth, third, third, third, fourth, seventh, seventh, third, fourth, second, sixth, second, second

EVENT: the Noon Meal Scheme, the Noon Meal Scheme

TIME: 15.It, 46 graMs.however

QUANTITY: 3 MLJ675(OVEYAM RANJAN, 46 grams

PERCENT: at least 60%, 60% and, 40%