Benedetti and Others Vs. Sawiris and Others

Decided On : Jul-17-2013

Court : UK Supreme Court

LAW: Introduction 1, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, Cressman v Coys of, chapter 17, The Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement Mr, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the First Brokerage Agreement, the "Support Agreement", the First Brokerage Agreement, the Euro 50M, Euro 500M, Euro 75M, Euro 17M, Euro 75M versus Euro, Euro 75M., Euro 50M, the Acquisition Agreement, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the Acquisition Agreement, the First Brokerage Agreement, the Brokerage Agreement, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, the First Brokerage Agreement, REED 84

PERSON: Clarke, Kerr, Lord Wilson, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Sawiris, Sawiris, Cylo, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Rimer, Etherton LJJ, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Cylo, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Cylo, Benedetti, Henderson J. 11, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Sawiris, Peter Birks, Benedetti, Boake Allen Ltd, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Whichever, Sawiris, Robert Goff, Jones, Benedetti, Scott, Benedetti, Graham Virgo, Virgo, Andrew Burrows, 3rd ed (2011, Robert Goff, Scott, Virgo, Benedetti, Neuberger, Virgo, Etherton LJ, Neuberger, Howard, Reed, Peel v Ontario, McLachlin, Andrew Burrows, Burrows, Taylor, Laird, Rabinowitz, James Edelman, Mitchell, Burrows, Jones, Scott, Goff, Jones, Reed, Birks, Jones, Mrs Ashman, Hoffmann LJ, Hoffmann LJ, Glidewell LJ, John Megaw, Goff, Jones, Neuberger, Reed, Virgo, Reed, Reed, Reed, Burrows, Burrows, Burrows, Virgo, Benedetti, Burrows, Benedetti, Benedetti, Enel SpA, Wind Telecomunicazioni SpA, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Wind, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Wind, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Wind, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Mr Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Cylo, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sottile, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sottile, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sottile, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Ross, Sawiris, Mr Benedetti, Benedetti, Weather I., Benedetti, Mr Abdou, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Weather, Weather, Benedetti, Weather, Wind, Benedetti, Weather, Sawiris, Mr Abdou, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Weather, Benedetti, Weather I., Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Weather, Weather Italy, Benedetti, Weather, Weather Italy, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Mr Abdou, Sawiris, Mr Abdou, Benedetti, Nasr, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Weather Italy, Benedetti, Benedetti, Abdou, Weather Italy, Sawiris, Benedetti, Mrs Shimi, Sawiris, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Atkin, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Mr Abdou, Weather, Naguib, Wind, Naguib, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, L'Espresso, Euro, Alessandro Benedetti, L'Espresso, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, para 457, Benedetti, Sawiris, Mr Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Howard, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Sawiris, Etherton LJ, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Etherton LJ, Sawiris, Benedetti, Rabinowitz, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Rabinowitz, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Mr Abdou, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Etherton LJJ, Benedetti, Sawiris, Etherton LJ, Rabinowitz, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Rabinowitz, Sottile, Benedetti, Wind, Benedetti, Sottile, Reed, Benedetti, Rabinowitz, Benedetti, Howard, Benedetti, Sawiris, Howard, Benedetti, Sottile, Rabinowitz, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sottile, Wilson, Sawiris, Benedetti, Weather, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sottile, Benedetti, Benedetti, Rabinowitz, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Clarke, Neuberger, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Patten LJ, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Clarke, Neuberger, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Sawiris, Sawiris, Benedetti, Clarke, Neuberger, Benedetti, sbquo;¬67, Benedetti, Clarke, Benedetti, Sawiris, Clarke, Benedetti, Benedetti, Clarke, Neuberger, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Benedetti, Sawiris, Benedetti, Peel, McLachlin, Wright, Fibrosa Spolka, ¦

ORG: Court, Orascom Telecom Holding SAE, the Egyptian Stock Exchange, Global Depositary Receipts, the London Stock Exchange, Cylo Investments Ltd, BVI, April Holding, OS Holding, Orascom, Orascom, Orascom, Orascom, Orascom, Benedetti ‚¬75.1, the Court of Appeal, Cylo, The Court of Appeal, Arden LJ, The Court of Appeal, Court, ‚¬14.52, The Court of Appeal, The Court of Appeal, the Court of Appeal, the Court of Appeal, the Court of Appeal, the Court of Appeal, Cylo, Court, the Court of Appeal, inter alia, Steyn, Investment Trust Companies, EWHC 458, Mummery LJ, Goff and Jones, BP Exploration Co, Cobbe v Yeoman's Row Management Ltd, Virgo, Goff and Jones, BP Exploration v Hunt, Cobbe v Yeoman's Row, Sempra Metals Ltd, AC, Goff and Jones, Goff and Jones, Sempra, Burrows p 44, Pollock CB, LJ Ex 329, Philosophical Foundations, Chambers, Penner, Burrows, Virgo, the House of Lords, Sempra, Government, Burrows, Ministry of Defence v Ashman, HLR 513, The Ministry of Defence, Ministry of Defence v Thompson, HLR, Court of Appeal, Virgo, Virgo p 67, Goff and Jones, Burrows p 60, the Court of Appeal, Virgo, Rain Investments SpA, the Acquisition Agreement, the Court of Appeal, Arden LJ, the Court of Appeal, Arden LJ's, Arden LJ, the Court of Appeal, the Holding Companies, Enel Investment Holding BV, SPA, Wind for ‚¬2.986 billion, SPA, Wind for ‚¬328m, Annexes 2, Arden LJ's, the Acquisition Agreement, between ‚¬12 and ‚¬36.3, Court, The Court of Appeal, the Court of Appeal, Weather Investments SA, Private Equity, IPE, IPE, IPE, IPE, International Technologies Management Ltd, ITM, ITM, a Mr Nounou, Managest Media SA, IPE, Weather Investments II SARL, SPA, SPA, Weather Italy, Weather Italy, SPA, Statement of Facts, ITM, CFO, Orascom, the ‚¬87, ‚¬87, First Closing, ITM, ITM, Weather Italy, ITM, the First Closing, Orascom, Way v Latilla, the Court of Appeal, SPA, OT, BOD, IMI, OT, Emphasis, OTH, OTH, Emphasis, Benedetti, Benedetti, ITM, ITM, ITM, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, the Court of Appeal, Mr Benedetti ‚¬14.52m., ITM, the Italian Government, Defendants, IPE, ITM, Arden LJ, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, ‚¬14.52, the tune of ‚¬81, the Court of Appeal, ITM, the Transaction Value, ITM, the Brokerage Services, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, the Court of Appeal, the Court of Appeal.82, THE ACQUISITION AGREEMENT œCHART, The Court of Appeal, the Court of Appeal, Benedetti ‚¬14.52m. 93, Kingstreet Investments Ltd, the Supreme Court of Canada, AC, Sempra Metals Ltd, AC, Row Management Ltd

CARDINAL: 2, two, 3, 576, 4, 5, 6, 1, 2, 3, 4, 1, 2, 3, 4, 8., 9, 31A, 10, four, 1, 2, 3, 4, 1, 227, three, 12, two, 109, 13, 606, 175, 14, 1, 783, 802, 4, 52, 2008, 1, 41, 15, two, 64, 1, 783, 840, 2004, 561, 116, 17, 98, 140, 145, 4-10, 18, 4, 3, 762, 25, 19, 61, 25, 332, 20, 211-241, 21, 4-08, 48, 116, 180, 231, 147, two, 119, 18, 413, 23, 24, 25, 520, 25, 552, 25, 4, 26, 138, 27, 28, 158, 60, 29, 30, 31, two, 158, 2, two-thirds, 32, 3, 158, 33, 34, 102, 118, 168, 169, 191-225, 2, two-thirds, one-third, two, four, 4, 5, two-thirds, one-third, 5.6, 5.4, 6, 6.1, 6.2, 38, 463, 477, 493, 3, 493, 39, 143, one-third, 15, 1, 40, 226, 41, 493, 16, two, 3, 2, 17, 3, 17, 24, 534, 571, 550, 551, two, 560, 561, 562, 7, 47, 48, 226, one, two, 334, 565, 50, 51, 26, 2, 404, two, 59-63, 424, 432, 55, 568, 57, 570, 570, 571, 187, 58, three, 186, 187, 187, two, two, 1/3, 200 to 300, two, 200 to 300, 188, two, 189, 1/3, 75M., 59, three, 437, 60, 438, 61, 400, 90, 50 thousand, 439, 450, 62, two, 63, 567, 64, 65, 156, 155, 158, two, 66, 570, 447, 67, 69, 563, 564, two, two, 565, 566, 565, 565, 71, 161, 162, 72, 73, 566, 74, two, 552, 75, 82, 387, 566, 561, 44, 74, 7.2, 79, 334, 83, 1, 2, 83, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 1, 2, 3, 91, 94, 95, 96, 97, 1, 32, two, 3, 804, 98, 99, 100, 101, 34, 561, 55, 2008, 1, one, 102, 103

NORP: Italian, Egyptian, American, Egyptian, D., Italian, English, Aristotelian, Mutatis

GPE: Switzerland, Arden, 8th ed (2011, Ashman, Italy, Cairo, Rain, Weather, Weather, Weather, Weather, Rome, Rome, Naguib, Naguib, Naguib, Weather, Naguib, Naguib, Cairo, Cairo, Cairo, Cairo, Arden, Canada, Cobbe

WORK_OF_ART: Orascom, the Holding Companies, the Acquisition Agreement, Patten J, the Acquisition Agreement, The Law of Unjust Enrichment, Goff and Jones, The Principles of the Law of Restitution, Virgo, The Law of Restitution, Burrows, The Meaning of Loss and Enrichment', The Law of Restitution, Weather I, IPE, Brokerage Services, Weather II, the Revised Brokerage Agreement, 3 All ER, Supplemental Agreement, Supplemental Agreement, Brokerage Agreement, CHART

LOC: the Middle East, Africa, South East Asia, Cayman Island, Rain, Rain, ‚¬67, ‚¬67, ‚¬67m and ‚¬75.1m (, ‚¬67, Sempra Metals

DATE: April, April, August 2007, 31 January 2004, 1953, some 31 days, the first half of 2009, 15 June 2009, June 2005, 16 December 2010, 1999, 2012, 38, 1985, 2006, 2006, 4-01, 1979, 26 May 2005, 2008, 1752, 2006, 16, 98, 4-08, 61, 1979, 2004, 2775, 40, 42, 2007, 2008, 69, June 2005, 1992, 68, 1856, 2008, 61, 64, 66-67, 22, 4-07, 2002, 1985, 4-09, 1993, 1993, 72-88, 47-60, 4-11, 2012, 68-69, 90-91, Christmas, Christmas, 35, 31 January 2004, 2002, December 2002, December 2002, January 2004, 37, 2005, 26 May 2005 Enel, 11 August 2005, 8 February 2006, 42, 44, 46, January 2005, March 2005, 23 March 2005, 24 March, the next day, 49, 24 March 2005, the same day, 24 March 2005, 25 March, early to mid April 2005, May 2005, 26 May, 11 August 2005, 11 August 2005, 52, 26 May 2005, 27 July 2005, 54, late July, August, 26 May 2005, about 3 August 2005, about 12 August 2005, 13 September 2005, 12 September 2005, 56, 1937, October, the June and September, 11 June, 12, 13 September 2005, one year ago, Today, today, today, 13 September, months ago, 2005, 2006, January 2006, 3 February 2006, two and a half years, 18 October 2006, 25 May 2005, October 2006, June, July, August 2005, 26 May 2005, 12 August 2005, October 2006, October, January 2006, 70, para 93, 26 May 2005, Day 3, 76, Day 3, July, August, 26 May 2005, October 2006, 80, 11 August 2005 œCHART, 8 February 2006, 2007, 1992, 1943, 64-65, 2007, 2008, 2008, 1752

PERCENT: 4.1%, 34.6%, 17.7%, about 56.4%, 43.6%, the remaining, 62.75%, 0.1% to 0.3%, 99%, 0.7%, 60%, 0.55%, 1%, the 1%, 1%, the 1%, 60%, the remaining 40%, between 0.1% and 0.3%, 0.3%, 0.55%, only 60%, the remaining 40%, 40%, only 60%, the remaining 40%, 40%, only 60%

MONEY: 60 per cent, 60 per cent, 40 per cent, 40 per cent, 472, 95, no more than, hundreds of millions

ORDINAL: first, first, fourth, first, first, second, 2nd, first, first, 2nd, first, first, Secondly, Thirdly, Fourthly, third, third, third, third, third, first, second, First, first, second, first, first, third, third, first, First, second, first, second, first, second, third, first, second, first, third, first, first, third, fourth, third, first, first, first, third, First, Secondly, third, first

PRODUCT: Virgo at pp 67 and, Cressman v Coys, Burrows, Burrows p, the "Broker's, 3 SECOND CLOSING, 762

FAC: Virgo at, Weather Italy, Wind

EVENT: Weather II, the September 2005