Shamanur Sugars Limited Vs. M/S. Bangalore Electricity Supply Company Limited and Others

Decided On : Jan-07-2014

Court : Appellate Tribunal for Electricity APTEL Appellate Jurisdiction

LAW: the Appellants Notice, This Amendment Petition, Section 73, the Contract Act, Section 57, the Sale of Goods Act, the Contract Price, Section 57, the Sale of Goods Act, Article 5.01 of the PPA, Article 11, Article 5 of the PPA, Article 5 of the PPA, Article 4 of the Supplemental PPA, the Article 5, Supplemental PPA, Article 5 of the PPA, This Article 5, the Termination Notice, Article 5.01 of the PPA, Article 5 of the PPA, the Article 6 of the PPA, the Article 6.01 of the PPA, Article 4 of the Supplemental PPA, Article 5, Power Purchase Agreement, Article 4 of the Supplemental PPA, the Electricity Act

PERSON: M. Karpaga Vinayagam, Sugars Limited, Order, OP No.14, Petitioner, Petitioner, Seller, Buyer, Buyer, Seller, Seller, Petitioner, Order, Rs.3.71, Appellant, Impugned Order, OP No.14, Distribution Licensee, Kilowatt Hour, Petitioner, K.R Circle, Bangalore, Ugar Sugars, Renuka Sugars, Prabhulingeshwara Sugars, Bangalore, Marc, Bangalore, Copy, Kaveri Bhavan, Bangalore, CERC Order, Bangalore, Bangalore Copy, Bangalore, Prayer WHEREFORE, OP No.14, OP No.14, Petitioner, Petitioner, OP No.10, OP No.14, OP No.14, Distribution Licensee

CARDINAL: 1, 2., 3, 31.03.05, 2,04,24,018/-, 24.10.2005, 24.01.06, 01.04.03, 31.12.05, 01.04.03, 10, 1.7.2008, 04.12.08, 26, 14, 26, 26.11.2010, 05.03.06, 10, 72, 24.1.2013, 24.1.2013, 3., 26.11.10, No.3, 4, 14, 26, 26, 14, 5, 1, 5.3.2006, 11, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8), 9, 10, 6, 11, 19, 8., 9, 3.37, 10, 11, 12, 3, 13, 14, 15, 07.03.1998, 6.01, 16, 17, 21.09.1999, 18, 19, 20, 06.01.2004, 02.02.2004, 23.07.2005, 21, two, 24.03.2005, 24.10.2005, 01.04.2005, 31.12.2005, 22, 10, 23, between 05.08.2006 to 08.12.2006, 24, 8.7.2008, 25, 5.6.2008, 8.7.2008, 26, 26, 8.7.2008, 26, 27, 26, 28, 14, 29, 14, 30, 72, 26, 24.01.2013, 44, 31, 32, 5.6.2008, 8.7.2008, 20, 33, 34, 35, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 21.9.1999, 20.9.2009, two, 1.4.2001, 1.4.2003, 1.4.2003, 20.9.2009, 7.3.1998, 42., Three, 31, 31-3, 31-3, 31-3, 31, 5.6.2008, 5.6.2008, 001, 31.03.2005, 31.03.2005, 01.04.2005, 01.04.2002, 31.03.2005, 001, 48, 50., 5.6.2008, 51, 14, 1, 20.6.2008 2, 14, 52, 8.7.2008, 30.11.2008, 5.6.2008, 15, 002, 1, 56, 57, 5.6.2008, 59, 1.7.2008, 5.6.2008, 60, 61, 1, 8.7.2008, 2, 5.5.2005, 3, 2, 20, 63, 5.6.2008, 64, 65, 7.3.1998, 5.3.2006, 20.9.2009, 66, 2, 3., 67, three, 5.3.2006, 3, 68., 69, 71, 73, 74, 11, 12, 75, 79, 81, 8.7.2008, 30.11.2008, 82, 5.6.2008, 5.5.2008, 83, 84, 5.6.2008, 86, No.3, 88, 90, 91., 92, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98

LOC: the Appellant herein, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent, Respondent

ORG: Appellant, the Karnataka Electricity Regulatory Commission, Petition, the Respondent Distribution Company, the Power Purchase Agreement, the Respondent Company, The Appellant Company, M/s. Bangalore Electricity Supply Co. Ltd., BESCOM, Karnataka State Commission, The Appellant Company, Karnataka Electricity Board, Appellant, the Electricity Board, the 1st Respondent Company, the Appellant Company, the Appellant Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, Appellant Company, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, Appellant, State Load Despatch Centre, the Open Access, the Appellant Company, the 3rd Respondent, the Respondent Company, the State Commission, the State Load Despatch Centre for Open Access, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the State Commission, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, Interim Application, the Power Purchase Agreement, the Respondent Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, Tribunal, the State Commission, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the State Commission, the State Load Despatch Centre for Open Access, the Appellant Company, the Respondent Company, Appellant, the Respondent Company, the Original Petition in OP No.26 of, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the Appellant Company, the Power Purchase Agreement, the Appellant Company obtained, Appellant, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Distribution Company-Respondent, the Respondent Company, Open Access, the State Load Despatch Centre, The Appellant Company, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Power Purchase Agreement, Appellant, Open Access, the Distribution Company, the Appellant Company, the State Commission, Amendment Petition, the Main Petition, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, the Power Purchase Agreement, the Respondent Company, The State Commission, the State Commission, the State Load Despatch Centre, Central Commissions, the Respondent Company, The Respondent Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, Open Access, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Respondent Company, the Appellant Company, the State Commission, the Respondent Company, the Appellant on 05.06.2008, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, 03.05.2009, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the State Commission, Appellant, The State Commission, Appellant, the Respondent Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Central Commission, the State Load Despatch Centre, Open Access, The State Commission, the Respondent Company, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, the Appellant Company, the Generating Company, NOC for Open Access, NOC for Open Access, Commission, Order, Commission, Respondents, Petition, the Generating Company, Contract, Contract, Contract, Contract, Contract, Breach of Contract, Contract, Agreement, the Market Price, Contracts, IEX, CERC, Rs.3.71 per Unit, the State Load Despatch Centre for Open Access, the 3rd Respondent, the 3rd Respondent, CERC, the State Commission, the State Load Dispatch Centre, the State Commission, the Central Commission, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Generating Company, BESCOM, the Generating Company, BESCOM, BESCOM, BESCOM, BESCOM, CERC, BESCOM, Rs.7.08 &ldquo, State Commission, State Load Dispatch Centre for Open Access, the Generating Company, Tribunal, Karnataka State Electricity Board, the Distribution Company, 1st Respondent, the Electricity Board, Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Ltd., Electricity Board, the Respondent Company, Appellant, the Respondent Distribution Company, The Respondent Distribution Company, BESCOM, kWhr, the Distribution Company, the Respondent Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, O.P. No. 10 of 2006, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, Appellant, the State Commission, Commission, the Appeal (Petition, the Appeal (Petition, the Distribution Company, the Respondent Company, the Appellant Company on 05.06.2008, Rs.1,89,01,695/-, the Distribution Company, Appellant, State Load Despatch Centre for Open Access on 01.07.2008, the Respondent Company/Distribution Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Respondent Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, the Open Access, Appellant, Reliance, 3rd Respondent, the Appellant Company, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, Respondent Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Appellant Company, Appellant, the Respondent Distribution Company, the Respondent Distribution Company, 03.05.2009, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, Tribunal, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Power Purchase Agreements, Appellant, the State Load Despatch Centre for Open Access, The Distribution Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Termination Notice, the Distribution Company, BESCOM, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Reliance Company, the Distribution Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Respondent Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Generating Company (Appellant, the Distribution Company, MW, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, the State Load Despatch Centre for Open Access, the Generating Company, the Distribution Company, the Generating Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, Application, the Main Petition, the Generating Company, the State Commission, Application, the State Commission, Application, State Commission, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, the Amendment Application, the State Commission, Petition, the Generating Company, the Generating Company, the Generating Company, the State Commission, the Generating Company, Counsel for the Respondent Company, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Generating Company, the Generating Company, the Generating Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, Appellant, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, Energy Charges, Base Tariff, the State Commission, Commission, Appellant, the Distribution Company, BESCOM, the Distribution Company, BESCOM, Bangalore Electricity Supply Company, Karnataka Electricity Board Bangalore, KEB, KEB, Power Purchase, Davangere Sugars Co., Ltd., Company, the Original Power Purchase Agreement, KEB Bangalore, Shamanur Sugars Ltd., Sd/- (S S Bakkesh, Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Ltd., the Distribution Company, BESCOM, the Generating Company, Clause 5.01 of the PPA, the Distribution Company, BESCOM, the Generating Company, the State Load Despatch Centre on Open Access on 01.07.2008, the Distribution Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, CEE, BESCOM, MW Power, STOA, CERC, MW, M/s. Reliance Energy Trading Limited, RETL, STOA, Sd/-, BESCOM, the Generating Company, Open Access to Generating Company, the Respondent Company, the Respondent Company, the Generating Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, the Reliance Company, Appellant, the Respondent Company, the Generating Company, the Termination Notice, BESCOM, 4th Main, Karnataka Sir, Karnataka Electricity Board, BESCOM, KPTCL-Reg, BESCOM, KPTCL, BESCOM, BESCOM, BESCOM, BESCOM, Tech),BESCOM, RLPP/EBC/BPPC, BESCOM, Generating Company, the Generating Company, Rs.1,89,01,695/-, the State Load Despatch Centre, the State Load Despatch Centre, BESCOM, Open Access, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Default of the Generating Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, this Honble Commission, 3rd Respondent (Annexure-C, Direct Respondents 1, Power Procurement, MW, the Distribution Company, the Open Access, the State Load Despatch Centre, the State Load Despatch Centre, the State Commission, Appellant, the Generating Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Respondent Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Generating Company, the State Commission, the Generating Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company for Amendment, Application, This Application for Amendment, the Generating Company, the Distribution Company, the Generating Company, the Power Purchase Agreement, BESCOM, the Power Purchase Agreement, the Appellant Generating Company, the Open Access, the State Commission, Commission, NOC for Open Access, Contract, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Generating Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, the Distribution Company, the Respondent Company, the State Load Despatch Centre, the State Commission, Commission, Petition, the State Commission, the State Commission, the State Commission, the State Commission, State Load Dispatch Centre, The State Commission, the State Commission, the Application for Amendment, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, the State Commission, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Termination Notice, the Respondent Company, Appellant, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Respondent Company, the State Commission, the Appellant Company, the Respondent Company, the Amendment Application, the State Commission, the State Commission, the State Commission, OP No.14, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, the Distribution Company, Appellant, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, 3rd party, Appellant, State Load Despatch Centre, the State Commission, the State Load Despatch Centre, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Open Access, the State Load Dispatch Centre, the Distribution Company, the Distribution Company, Open Access, the State Commission, OP No.14, the Distribution Company, The Cause of Action, the Cause of Action, the State Commission, the State Load Despatch Centre, the State Commission, the 3rd party, the State Load Despatch Centre, The Distribution Company, the State Load Dispatch Centre, the State Commission, the State Load Despatch Centre, The Distribution Company, the State Commission, Petition, the State Commission, the Amendment Application, the State Commission, The State Commission, The State Commission, The State Commission, the Distribution Company, the State Commission, Distribution, The State Commission, the State Commission, the Distribution Company

PRODUCT: Appellant, Respondent, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Respondent, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Respondent, No.1, No.1, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Respondent, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Agreement, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Application, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant

ORDINAL: third, third, first, first, third, third, third, third, first, third, third, third, third, first, third, third, 1st, third, third, 3rd, 1st, second, third, third, third, first, third, third, third, 5th, 5th, 7th, 5th, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 5th, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, 3rd, first, 3rd, 3rd, third, third, third, third

DATE: the 1st Respondent, the 2nd Respondent, the year 1997-98, 2004-05, 04.04.2002, 24.03.2005, the next five years, 2006, the period of 5 years, 2006, 8.7.2008, about five months i.e., 2008, 2008, 2009, 2008, 2008, 2009, 2006, 2013, 2008, 2008, 8.7.2008, 4th December, 2008, 2008, June, 2008, 2008, 2008, 2006, four months period, 20.09.2009, 15.07.2008, 2009, 2008, 4th December 2008, 2009, 2008, 2006, 18.05.2006, 2009, 2006, 15.07.2008, 7.3.1998, 5.5.2006, 7.3.1998, 5.6.2008, April, 2002 to March, 2005, 18.5.2006, 5.5.2006, the 1st, the 1st, the 1st Respondent, the 1st, 1930, the months of July to November, 2008, the 1st, the months of July, August,, September, November, 2008, the 1st Respondent, those months, those months, the months of July, August, September, November, 2008, the 1st Respondent, Rs.7.08 - Rs.3.71, the 1st Respondent, the months of July, August, September, November, 2008, the 1st, the months of July, August, September, November, 2008, six) weeks, 8.7.2008, July, August, November 2008, July, August, September, November, the year 1997-98, the year 2004-05, 30 days, 10 years, the period of, 10 years, 20.09.2009, 15.05.2004, the year 2004-05, 7.3.1998., 7.3.1998, 2006, 18.05.2006, 15.07.2008, 2008, 2008, 26.11.2010, 2008, 2009, 2008, 2009, 02.11.2012, 2006, 2013, 2008, 2012, 1.7.2008, 8.7.2008, 5.6.2008, 15.7.2008, 15.7.2008, 4.12.2008, 8.7.2008, 5.5.2006, 2008, 15.7.2008, 2008, earlier., 36, 2006, 2009, 2006, 2009, 2006, 5.6.2008, 2006, 30 days, 30 days, a period of, 10 years, the year 2004-2005, 2006, 24.1.2006, 7.3.1998, 5.5.2006, 43, 44, 2006, 18.5.2006, 45, 7.3.1998, between 5.8.2006 and 8.12.2006, 46, 47, the 5 June, 2008, March, 1998, May, 2006, 7th March, 1998, 10 years, 10 years, 5 years, over 12 months, 2006, 01.04.2005, this day, 7th March, 1998, today, April, 2002 to March, 2005, 1998, May, 2006, 5.5.2006, 7.3.1998, 5.5.2006, 49, 8.7.2008, 30.11.2008, 54, 55, 15.7.2008, 7th March, 1998, May, 2006, 5th June, 2008, 2003, 5.5.2006, 58, 20.6.2008, 8.7.2008, 15.7.2008, 8.7.2008, 1.7.2008 to 30.11.2008, 2008, 8.7.2008, 2008, 17.01.2002, 62, 2008, up to 20th September, 2009, 7.3.1998, 5.6.2008, 70, 2006, 2009, 2009, 72, 5.6.2008, 8.7.2008 to 30.11.2008, 2009, 18.5.2006, 5.5.2006, 2006, 18.5.2006, 2009, 76, 2008, 7.3.1998, 5.5.2006, 80, 5.6.2008, 1.7.2008, 8.7.2008, 15.7.2008, 7.3.1998, 2008, 2006, 18.5.2006, 2009, 5.5.2006, 5.5.2006, 85, 87, 2003, 5.6.2008, 2008, six months, five months, 89, 2006, 2009, 2006, 2009, 2009, 5.6.2008, 8.7.2008, 4th December, 2008, 8.7.2008, four months, 15.7.2008, 2008, 4.12.2008, 2006, 7.3.1998, 5.5.2006

PERCENT: 5%, 5%, 5%, 2%, 2%, 2%, 2%, 2%

WORK_OF_ART: Open Access, an Amendment Petition in OP No.26 of 2008, Power Purchase Agreement, OP No.10 of 2006, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access, the Amendment of the prayer, Supplemental PPA, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access throughout the Open Access Period, Open Access, the Open Access, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access, Appellant, OP No.10 of 2006, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access, Open Access

FAC: the Open Access, the Impugned Order, the Metering Point, BESCOM

GPE: O.P., O.P., O.P., OP, O.P., OP, O.P., O.P., O.P., O.P., O.P., Contract, Bagasse, O.P., O.P., O.P., O.P., O.P., OP, OP, OP

EVENT: OP No.14/2009, the Open Access

NORP: Supplemental, Memo, Supplemental, Supplemental, Supplemental, Supplemental, Supplemental, Supplemental