Nandu Ahuja and Others Vs. Competition Commission of India and Another

Decided On : Jan-17-2014

Court : Competition Appellate Tribunal

LAW: Section 3(3, the Competition Act, the "Act, Section 3(3)(a, Section 3(3)(b, Section 3(3)(c, Section 27, Section 3(a)(b, Section 19(3, the Competition Act, the Copyright Act, the Competition Act like Section 3, the Copyright Act, the Copyright Act, the Copyright Act, Section 3, Section 19(3, Section 3(3)(a, Section 3(3)(b, Section 3(a, Section 3 of the Act, Section 3 of the Act, Section 48 of the Act, Negotiable Instrument Act, Section 141, Section 48 of the Competition Act, Section 141, Negotiable Instruments Act, Section 3 of the Act, Section 138, Section 3, Negotiable Instruments Act, Section 3 of the Competition Act, Section 3, Section 141, Section 3 of the Competition Act, Section 3, Section 141, Section 141, Section 141, Section 141(2, Section 3 of Competition Act, Section 3, the Companies Act, Negotiable Instruments Act, the Negotiable Instruments Act, Section 3, Section 43, Section 3

PERSON: V.S. Sirpurkar, Shri Sunil Arjan Lulla, Nandu Ahuja, Jyoti Deshpande, Multiplexes, Hindi, Multiplex, Multiplex, Sunil Arjan Lulla - appellant, Nandu Ahuja, Jyoti Deshpande, Jyoti Deshpande, Sunil Arjan Lulla, Nandu Ahuja, Jyoti Deshpande, Sunil Arjan Lulla, Manu, Hindi, Shri Sunil Lulla, Nandu Ahuja, Shri Sunil Lulla, Shri Nandu Ahuja, Shri Nandu Ahuja, Jyoti Deshpande, Juhu, Juhu, Jyoti Deshpande, Aneeta Hada Vs, Aneeta Hada's, Shri Arjan Lulla, Jyoti Deshpande, Eros, Shivaji Raje Bhosle Boiltoy, Eros

DATE: 1, 2011, 2011, 2002, the first week, the second week, third week, early 2009, all weeks, 09.06.2009, 12.06.2009, 25.9.2009, 4th April, 2009 to 12th June, 2009, 2011, 2011, 16.03.2009, 7th of April, 2009, 09.10.2009, weeks25-30%25-, 4th April, 2009, 12th June, 2009, 9th June, 2009, 9th June, 2009, 09.06.2009, 09.05.2009, the 1st, 2nd,, 4th week, 20th May, 2009, 20th May, 2009, 20th May, 2009, April 2009, 16, 09.05.2009, 12th June 2009, 1998, Sept. 14, 1998, 2005, 1973, 1975, 1957, September-October, 2009, April, 2009, 20th May, 2009, April 4, 2009, 12.6.2009, 20th May, 2009, 27th March, 2009, 4th April, 2009, 12th June, earlier to 20th May, 2009, 20th May, 2009, 09.05.2009, 7.4.2009, 2012, 1956, 1 of 1956, April to 12th June, 27th March, 2009, 12th June 2009

CARDINAL: three, one, 12, 11, 13, 25.05.2011, 2., more than 17, 26.05.2009, 3, one, three, 4, 27.03.2009, 09.05.2009, 27.03.2009, 9.5.2009, 8.5.2009, 99, 5, 29.05.2009, 18.06.2009, 19.06.2009, 6, 30.6.2009, two, two, as many as 16, three, three, three, three, 12, one, 11, 13, 9, three, three, two, 27.03.2009, 10, as many a 16, 11, 09.05.2009, 27.03.2009, 12, 13, about 16, three, 14, 15, 27.03.2009, 2(l, 27.03.2009, 09.05.2009, 27.03.2009, 1, 2, 3, 1, 2, 28.05.2009, 3, 719, 38, 36, 410, 422, 151, 156, 17, 18, 19, 15 to 20, 20, 9.5.2009, 9.6.2009, 9.6.2009, 21, three, 22, 9.5.2009, three, 23, three, 7.4.2009, 14.3.2011, three, three, 24, three, three, three, 5, 661, 25, 1, three, 26, three, 2, one, three, three, three, three, 28, 15, 29, two, 30, three

ORG: The Competition Commission of India, the FICCI Multiplex Association of India, United Producers/Distributors Forum, UPDF, the Association of Motion Pictures and TV Programme Producers, the Film and Television Producers Guild, UPDF, AMPTPP, UPDF, Indian Film Industry, Notice, UPDF, UPDF, State, State, UPDF, AMPTPP, UPDF, AMPTPP, the Motion Pictures Association, MPA, the Eastern India Motion Pictures Association, M/s. People Pictures, AMPTPP, UPDF, AMPTPP, FTGP, UPDF, Commission, Commission, UPDF, Commission, Act, AMPTPP, Commission, Rupees One, Eros International Media Ltd., Eros International PLC, a Group Company of Eros Group, the Eros International PLC, the Eros Group, Club Andheri, Hotel Marriot, UPDF, Commission, FilmsBig Budget FilmsMedium Budget FilmsLow Budget Films1st Week48%45%40%2nd, UPDF, UPDF, UPDF, AMPTPP, Eros Group, Commission, AMPTPP, AMPTPP, Commission, Commission, UPDF, AMPTPP, UPDF, Commission, Commission, Association, Commission, Commission, High Court, Supreme Court, Super Cassette Industries Ltd., Girdhar and Co., Super Cassette Industries Ltd., Manu/SC/2179/2008, Microsoft, WL 614485, DDC, Otter Tail Power Co., Twentieth Century Music Corp., Aiken, Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc., Santosh V.G., Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, UPDF, AMPTPP, the Hindi Motion Pictures, UPDF, AMPTPP, the Hindi Motion Pictures, UPDF, AMPTPP, Sections 3 and 4, Sections 3 and 4, the Cinemax Groups, Sections 3 and 4, AMPTPP, UPDF, the Eros Group, AMPTPP, AMPTPP, Hotel JW Marriot, Eros Group, Eros Group, the Press Conference, Hotel JW Marriot, Commission, the Eros International, the Supreme Court, Directors, Eros International, Eros International PLC, Travels, P) Ltd., Supreme Court, Eros International, Eros International PLC, Eros Group, Sections 141(1, Eros International, Eros International PLC, Central, Sections 3 or 4, Commission, the Eros Group, AMPTPP

WORK_OF_ART: CCI, Eros International, Tera Mera Ki Rista, Aa Dakhen Zara

GPE: India, Hindi, India, Hindi, D.G., D.G., D.G., D.G., India, Hindi, India, Hindi, India, Hindi, India, United States, the United States, U.S., U.S., India, Mumbai, Mumbai, India, India, India, Hindi, Hindi

PERCENT: almost 100%, 48%, 38%, 30%, 25%, 40% to 44%, around 32%, 50%, 50%, 42.5%, 37.5%, 30%, 2%, almost 100%, 100%

ORDINAL: fourth, 3rd, firstly, Firstly, Firstly, first

LOC: Maharashtra

FAC: Eros International, Hove Kamp et al, Notice

EVENT: 4th Week

TIME: 01.07.2010

PRODUCT: Section 138, Section 138, Section 138

MONEY: 3(3

NORP: Hindu