Raigarh Ispat Udyog Sangh Vs. Chhattisgarh State Electricity Regulatory Commission and Another

Decided On : Mar-07-2014

Court : Appellate Tribunal for Electricity APTEL Appellate Jurisdiction

LAW: Section 64, the Electricity Act, a Power Supply Agreement for FY, Power Purchase Agreement, Section 64, the Non Segregation of Accounts of the Distribution Licensees Distribution Business, Section 51, the Electricity Act, the Tariff Procedure Regulations, Section 62

PERSON: M. Karpaga Vinayagam, Sangh, Order, Order, Appellants, Order, Distribution Licensee, Distribution Licensee, Jindal Industrial Park, Distribution, Jindal, Divisional, Jindal Steels, Distribution License, Order, Distribution, Impugned Order, the Distribution Licensee, Distribution Licensee, JSPLs non-licensed, Distribution Licensee, Distribution Licensee, Order

CARDINAL: 1, 2., 3, 299, 1.6.2004, 70, 299, 4.10.2007, 27.2.2009, 30.7.2011, 10.01.2012, 4., 5., 1000, 9.2.2010, 23.2.2012, 6, 9, 300, 90, 210, 1000, 10, 300, 90, 29.1.2003, 15.9.2004, 300, 90, 210, 1000, 25.1.2005, 23.4.2005, 29.9.2005, 300, 90, 50, 11, 300, 90, 12, 13, 14, 15, 50, 70, 17, 1, 80, 18, 19, 300, 90, 210, 1000, 300, 100, half, 20 to 80, more than 100, 931, 11, 106, 945, 10, 108, 50, 20, 22, 23, 1, 80, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 17.07.2006, 29.09.2005, 1027.02.2009-, 18.08.2011, 29.9.2005, 27.2.2009, 32, 33, 18.8.2011, 34, 8.1, 7, 37, 18.8.2011, 18.8.2011, 18.8.2011, 39., 41, 42, 43., 1, 2, 47, 48., 49, 50, 29.1.2007, 51, 52, 27.6.2009, 10.1, 12, 14, 57, 59, 60, 61, 8, 3, 5, 931, 223, 193, 63, 65, 66, 67, 68.

ORG: M/s. Raigarh Ispat Udyog Sangh, Appellant, Association, The Chhattisgarh State Commission, the First Respondent, M/s. Jindal Steel and Power Limited-Distribution (Jindal Steel, The Appellants Association, the Jindal Steel, the Appellants Association, Jindal Steel, Raigarh, the Jindal Steel, the Chhattisgarh State Industrial Development Corporation, Government of Chhattisgarh, MoU, the Chhattisgarh State Industrial Development Corporation, the State of Chhattisgarh, the Government of Chhattisgarh, Jindal Steel, The Government of Chhattisgarh, No Objection Certificate to Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, Rules and Regualtions, Chhattisgarh State Electricity Board, 31.5.2003, Jindal Steel, Transmission and Distribution, Jindal Steel, the Industrial Units, Jindal Steel, the State Commission, Jindal Steel, The Jindal Steel, the Tariff Petition for the Financial Year 2005-06, the Jindal Steel, Application, The State Commission, The Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, the Electricity Board, Appeals, this Tribunal in Appeal No.34, Tribunal, the Jindal Steel, Petition No.17 of, ARR, the Retail Tariff for Distribution Business for the Financial Year 2009-10, The State Commission, Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, Industrial Consumers of the Jindal Industrial Park, the State Commission, Jindal Steel, Jindal Steel, Long Term, the State Commission, ARR, Retail Supply Tariff, Jindal Steel, ARR, Retail Supply Tariff for FY 2011-12, Association, the Jindal Steel, the Chhattisgarh State Commission, the State Commission, Appellant, The State Commission, the Jindal Steel, Appellants, Jindal Steel, Tariff Petition: The State Commission, the Jindal Steel, Chhattisgarh State Commissions Tariff Procedure Regulations, Retail Supply Tariff, The State Commission, the Jindal Steel, Distribution Business, the License Regulations, the State Commission, Counsel for the Respondents, the Jindal Steel, MW Independent Power Project, Jindal Power Ltd., Jindal Steel, The State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, Short Term, the State Commission, Tariff Petition: The Appellant, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, ARR, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, The State Commission, The Jindal Steel, the Distribution Business of the Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, Chhattisgarh State Power Distribution Company Limited, the State Commission, Jindal Steel, Tariff Determination, the State Commission, the Jindal Steels, Retail Supply Tariff, Jindal Steel Distribution Business, First Question, the Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, MW, MW, MW, Jindal Power Ltd, the Jindal Steel, Captive Power Plant, the State Commission, Jindal Steel, MW, MW, Jindal Steels Captive Power Plant, the Distribution License, Jindal Steel, NOC, the Government of Chhattisgarh to Jindal Steel, Captive Power Plant, The Jindal Steel, MW, MW, MW, Jindal Power Ltd., Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, Captive Power Plant, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, Application, Jindal Steel, MW, the Jindal Industrial Park, MW, Jindal Steels Captive Power Plant, The State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the State Electricity Board, the Cross Subsidy, Jindal Steel, Captive Power Plant, the State Commission, Jindal Steel, the Jindal Industrial Area, the State Government, the Captive Power Plant, the Jindal Steel, The State Commission, Jindal Steel, MW Power, Captive Power Plant, MW, MW, the Power Project of Jindal Power Ltd, Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, The Captive Power Plant of the Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, The Steel, Jindal Steel, the Chhattisgarh State Electricity Board, the Steel Plant, the Jindals Steel Plant, Captive Power Plant, the Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, the Captive Power Plant of the Distribution Licensee, the Jindal Steel, Discom, Chhattisgarh State Power Distribution Company Limited, MW, MW, Jindal Steel, Steel Plant, Jindal Steel, Captive Power Plant, MW, Steel Plant, Jindal Steel, Jindal Steel, Steel Plant, Steel Plant, Captive Power Plant, Steel Plant whereas Jindal Industrial Park, Power Plant, the Jindal Steel, Jindal Steel, MW, MW, Captive Power Plant, MW Power Plant of Jindal Power, Steel Plant, MW, MW, Jindal Steel, MW, MW, MW, MW, Captive Power Plant, Jindal Steel, State, Steel Plant, Jindal Steel, Chhattisgarh State Electricity Board, Jindal Steel, the State Commission, Board, State, Jindal Steel, MW, Power Plant, the State Commission, the State Commission, Short Term Power Purchase, Jindal Steel, the Distribution Licensees, the State Commission, Appellants Association, Short Term Power, Captive Power Plant, Jindal Steel, the State Commissions, The State Commission, the Steel Plant, Jindal Steel, the Captive Power Plant of Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the Captive Power Plant, Jindal Steel, Jindal Steels Captive Power Plant, The State Commission, Jindal Steel, MW, Jindal Steel, Jindal Steel, the Captive Power Plant to Jindal Industrial Park, the Appellants Association, Tariff Petition, the State Commission, Distribution, the State Commission, Tribunal, the State Commission, the State Commission, the State Commission, DiscomOrders, Commission2006-07No Petition, Discoms License Order, Discom, Tariff Order, Chhattisgarh Commissions website2008-0930.07.2008 &, Chhattisgarh Commissions Order, Discom, First Tariff, Discom, Discoms, DiscomOrders, Chhattisgarh Commissionaccounts &, Chhattisgarh Commission, Tariff Petition, ARR, Determination of Annual Revenue Requirement, Discom, Determination of Retail Tariff for FY 2011-12.30, the State Commission, the Tariff Petition, The State Commission, the State Commission, the Tariff Petition, Distribution Licensees, the State Commission, the State Commission, the State Commission, Distribution, the State Commission, Tribunal, Commissions, the State Commissions, Tribunal, the State Commissions, Every State Commission, every State Commission, ARR, The State Commission, ARR, ARR, the State Commission, the Distribution Licensees, the State Commissions, Tribunal, Chhattisgarh State Power Distribution Company Ltd., Discom, ARR, this Honble Tribunal, Chhattisgarh Commission, State, Jindal Steel, Jindal Steel, The State Commission, the Distribution Licensee Jindal Steel, Tribunal, the Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel Distribution Licensee, the State Commission, Commission, Authority, the State Commission, the Tariff Petition by Jindal Steel, the State Commission, Distribution Business, Tribunal, the Jindal Steel, the Distribution Licensees, the Appropriate Commission, the Distribution Business, Commission, Commission, the Distribution Business, Commission, Sections and Regulations, the Distribution Business, the State Commission, the Annual Revenue Requirement, the Distribution Business, the Jindal Steel, Distribution Business, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the Jindal Steel, Petitioners, this Tribunal in Appeal No.34, Tribunal, Tribunal, CSERC, CSERC, the State Commission: œ?2, Commission, Commission, ARR, Commission, ARR, the Jindal Steel, The State Commission, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the State Commissions, Distribution, the State Commission, ARR, the Jindal Steel, Utility, The State Commission, the Jindal Steel, Tribunal, the Honble Supreme Court, the Regulatory Commission, the State Commission, Regulator, Distribution Company, Appellant, CESC Ltd, Cellular Operators Association of India v Union of India, ELR, APTEL, Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited, Karnataka Electricity Regulatory Commission, ELR, APTEL, Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission, ELR, APTEL, the State Commission, the Jindal Steel, the State Commission, The State Commission, the Petition of Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the Captive Power Plant of Jindal Steel, The State Commission, the State Commission, Petition by Jindal Steel, the State Commission, Petition of Jindal Steel, the State Commission, the State Commission, Court

FAC: the Appellant herein, Jindal Industrial Park, the Jindal Industrial Park, Jindal Industrial Park, the Jindal Industrial Park, the Jindal Industrial Park, Jindal Industrial Park, Jindal Industrial Park, the Impugned Order, the Impugned Order, Jindal Industrial Park, Jindal Industrial Park, Jindal Industrial Park, Jindal Industrial Park, Jindal Industrial Park, Jindal Industrial Park, the Jindal Industrial

DATE: 8.2.2012, 29.1.2003, a period of 5 years, 25.1.2005, 29.11.2005, 2006-07, 28.6.2006, 2007-08, 17.7.2006, 28.6.2006, 29.1.2007, 96 of 2007, 2009, 27.6.2009, 6.7.2009, 27.10.2010, 2010-11, 14.1.2011, 2010-11, FY 2009-10, 2010-11, 2011-12, 20.12.2011, 8.2.2012, FY 2010-11, 8.2.2012, 2003, Annual, 2004, Annual, 27.10.2010, the previous years, the present year, 2010-11, 2010-11, 2009-10, the two years, 2011-12, 2010-11, 27.6.2009, 15.7.2009, 8.2.2012, previous year, Annual, 29.11.2005, 7.5.2005, 23.7.2005, 29.11.2005, 27.10.2010, 2009-10, the intervening years, September, 2007, all the years, 30.3.2009, 2010-11, annual, each day, the day, the months of July, 2010, July, 2011, 22.12.2008, 6.9.2008, 6.9.2008, 22.12.2008, 2010-11, 2011-12, 21, 2011, 30th November of every year, 29.11.2005., 28.06.2006 [, 7 months, 2007-08, November 20062007, 8 months, FY 2009, 20 months, 2008-09, 41 months, 2009-10, 2010-11, 2009-10, FY 2010-11, 2006-07, 2007-08, 2007-08, 2008-09, 30.7.2008 with eight months, 2008-09, 2008-09, 31, 2009-10, 40 months, 2011-12, 8.2.2012, 27.6.2009, 2011, 11.11.2011., 11.11.2011, Annual, Annual, year, year, the financial year, before 1st April, the financial year 2011-12, before 1st April, 2011, the financial year, one month, 35, 36, the past years, the present year, 38, 2006, 40, the year 2005, 2003, 51, 44, the financial year, the first of April, thirty first of March, 45, 46, 2006, 27.6.2009, 29.1.2007, November, 2007, 96 of 2007, 54, 30th July, 2008, the year 2008-09, 15 days, 55, 3 months, 56, year, year, 58, 7152, 2003, 2009, 2007, 2007, 62, 64, 07th day

WORK_OF_ART: The Appellant, A Memorandum of Understanding (MoU, the Distribution Licensee, the Memorandum of Understanding

LOC: the Raigarh District, Petition

EVENT: the Financial Year, Financial Year 2009-10 (ii, the Financial Year, the Financial Year 2011-12, Financial Year, the Financial Year, the Financial Year 2008-09

ORDINAL: first, first, Second, first, Third, first, Second, third

PRODUCT: Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Appellant, Judgment

NORP: Affidavits

TIME: hourly, hours of the day

GPE: Ld, Ld, Ld, Ld, Ld, North Delhi Regulatory Commission