Dr. Ramcharan Thiagarajan Vs. Medical Council of India and Others

Decided On : Apr-03-2014

Court : Karnataka

LAW: the Indian Penal Code, Section 24, Section 12, the Right to Information Act, Section 2(h, Rule 9(C, Section 12, Section 12, Regulation 7.16 of Code of Ethics Regulations, the "IMC Act, the IMC Act, Section 20A, the IMC Act, the IMC Act, Section 20A, the IMC Act, The IMC Act, Section 24, the IMC Act, Regulations 8.2, Article 14, Article 21, ITR 411 SC, Article 136, Article 227, Constitution

PRODUCT: Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, Transplant Surgeon, Articles 14, 862, Civ 88, CA, UCATT v Brain

DATE: 27.10.2012, one year, the years, the year 2010, a year, the next three days, the third day, 1860, 1994, 22.12.2010, 22.10.2010, 6523/2011, 27.10.2012, one year, 10.12.2012, 19.2.2013, 1995, 2005, thirty days, August 2011, 15.11.2011, tomorrow, 1956, force.xxx 33, 2002, 2002, the first day of April, each year, 1961, 2002, 01) year, 2012, 1811, 21, 1984, SCCp.637para 47, 2010, 346para 27, 46, 1606, 1967, 1606, 1990, 1995, 1989, 1968)AC 1997, 1990, 1975, S.N.Mukherjee, 1984, 1216, 1785, 1173, 1606, 1979, 2009 4, 1998, 2004, 2004)WLR 1953, 2003, 1964, 1985, 1991, 1982, 1971, 1995, 1999, 2001, 2001, 1999, 1997, 2006, 2006, 1986, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2002, 1983, 1984, 1995, 1998, 1995, 1627, 1636, 1996, 1996, 1995, 1995, 1996, 1996, 1037, 1043, 1996, 1460, 1981, 1991, June 9, 1994, 2003, 1293, 1304, 2005, 2006, 1978, 1981, 1985, 2001, 2004, 1953, 2001, 2004, 1953, 1983, 1974, 1984, 1984, 2004]UKHL 33, 1996, 1043, 1976, 1986, 1985, 1975, 1974, 1983, 1983, the early 1980s, 1991, 2001, 2002, 1964, 1975, 1978, 1991, 1998, 1996, 1980, 1984, 1985, 1979, 1460, 1996, 1994, 1996, 1986, 2004, 1364, 1991, several years, four months

ORG: the Indian Medical Register Annexure-A, the Register of State Medical Council, M/s Fortis Hospital, M/s Fortis Hospital, the Zonal Co-ordination Committee of Karnataka (Hereinafter, ZCCK, M/s Fortis Hospital, ZCCK, Smt, ZCCK, ZCCK, Smt, the J.P.Nagar Police Station, Nephrologist, the Karnataka Medical Council (Hereinafter, KMC, KMC, Disputes Redressal Commission, KSCDRC, the Department of Health and Family Welfare Services, Department of Health and Family Welfare, the Appropriate Authority, The Appropriate Authority, the Transplantation of Human Organs, Authority, M/s Fortis Hospital, Appropriate Authority, a Technical Committee, the Appropriate Authority, Committee, the Appropriate Authority, the Appropriate Authority, Authority, M/s Fortis, Order, the Appropriate Authority, the Appropriate Authority, the Appropriate Authority, the Appropriate Authority, Hospital, the Appropriate Authority, an Appellate Authority, Department of Health and Family Welfare, Government of Karnataka, the Appropriate Authority, Hospital, Hospital, KMC, the Medical Council of India (Hereinafter, MCI, the Indian Medical Register, Hospital, the Board of Governors, M/s Fortis Hospital, Hospital, Health and Family Welfare Services, the Transplantation of Human Organs Rules, Cardiac, Committee, the Appropriate Authority, Hospital, the Appropriate Authority, Certificate, HOTA, HOTA, Joint, the Appellate Authority, KMC, "Fortis Hospital, KMC, Council, Smt, the Appropriate Authority, the Appellate Authority, the Indian Medical Council, M/s Fortis Hospital, Hospital, Rule 4A, the Medical Co-ordinator, ZCCK, HOTA, the THO Rules, HOTA, - Hospital, ZCCK, M/s Fortis Hospital, Smt, Certificate of Registration, M/s Fortis Hospital, Kidney, Liver, Heart, Homograft, M/s Fortis Hospital, M/s Fortis Hospital, M/s Fortis Hospital, Hospital, Hospital, Homograft, HOTA, HOTA, M/s, Columbia Asia Hospital, M/s BGS Global Hospital, The Government of Tamil Nadu, Certificate, Global Hospital, Chennai, M/s, Apollo Hospital, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, AIIMS, HOTA, HOTA, HOTA, General of Health Services, Government of India, The Public Information, the Appropriate Authority for Organ Transplantation, Government of Karnataka, HOTA, the Director General of Health Services, the "Informed Consent Form, KMC, Nephrologist, KMC, the Cadaver Kidney Transplantation Pre-Operative Recipient Orders, KMC, Hospital, Hospital, Hospital, Smt, M/s Fortis Hospital, Smt, HOTA, HOTA, MCI, MCI, MCI, MCI, the Indian Medical Council Act, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, the Government of India, Council, MCI, Council, Council, Regulations The Council, the Central Government, MCI, the Indian Medical Council, inter alia, the Ethics Regulations, MCI, State Medical Councils, MCI, State Medical Councils, MCI, State Medical Councils, Medical Council, Medical Council, Medical Council, Register, Medical Associations/ Societies/Bodies, Council, MCI, Register of Medical Practitioners, the Indian Medical Register, State Medical Register, State Medical Council, MCI, the Indian Medical Register, State Medical Register, State, Council, the Indian Medical Register, State Medical Register, the State Medical Register, the Central Government, the Central Government, Council, the State Government, the State Medical Register, the State Medical Register, the Karnataka Medical Registration Act, IMC, Karnataka Medical Council, The Ethics Committee, Karnataka Medical Council, Committee, Fortis Hospital, Competent Authority, the Ethics Committee, the Indian Medical Council Regulations, Committee, the Indian Medical Register, the Register of State Medical Council, The Fortis Hospital, Health and Family Welfare, MCI, Council, U.P., AIR 1991, Court, Consumer Education, AIR 1995 SC, Court, State, this Court in Union of India, AIR 1974, U.P. Financial Corporation, AIR 1993, SC, State of W.B., AIR 1990, Court, AIR 1990, Union of India, AIR 1993 SC 1407, Court, Court, Court, Modern Co-operative Group Housing Society Ltd., Court, Court, Court, Courts, Court, In Institute of Chartered Accountants, AIR 1987, SC, Court, Court, the High Court, Council, Council, a Tribunal of first instance, the Disciplinary Committee, the Disciplinary Committee, Council, Council, Adjudicatory, Siemens, the Supreme Court, Union of India, AIR 1966, Bhagat Raja v. Union of India, AIR 1967 SC, Union of India, AIR 1966, CIT, Bhagat Raja v. Union of India, AIR 1967 SC, the Supreme Court, High Court, the Supreme Court, H.J. Kantharaj, AIR 1995 SC 1770, Acharya, State, the Home Department, AC 531, State, the Home Department, Fayed, Fayed, Cunningham, State for Trade and Industry, Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, State, the Home Department, Fayed, US 560, The Supreme Court of, Union of India, AIR 1978, Union of India, AIR 1990, Union of India, AIR 1991, Co. v. Union of India, AIR 1976 SC, AIR 1978, State, AIR 1990, State, U.P., AIR 1970 SC, Govt, D.B.belliappa, AIR 1979 SC 429, Union of India, AIR 1986, AIR 1974, AIR 1961, Bhagat Raja v. Union of India, AIR 1967 SC, Travancore Rayons v. Union of India, AIR 1971, SC, State, AIR 1979 SC 1918, CE, AIR 1980, Maharashtra State Board of Secondary, Education, K.S.Gandhi,(1991, Disciplinary Authority, Higher Education Funding Council exp Institute of Dental Surgery, State, the Home Department, AC 531,564, Ministry of Defence, Higher Education Funding Council exp Institute of Dental Surgery, Higher Education Funding Council exp Institute of Dental Surgery, R(Asha Foundation, v. Millenium Commission, De Smith's, Judicial Review, the Asha Foundation, The Millennium Commission, Flannery and Flannery v Halifax Estate Agencies Ltd., Westminster CC v, Sons Ltd., State, the Town and Country Planning Act, State, R. v Birmingham City Council, E.L.R, Thompson, State, Lowe) v Family Health Services Appeal Authority, R. v Crown Court, Cantebury Ex, the Crown Court, Curtis v Lodon Rent Assessment Committee, Q.B., R. v Brent London LBC Ex p. Baruwa, State, the Home Department, Ashworth Hospital Authority, Bushell, Tyne Licensing Justice, Alliss, Legal Services Commission, Q.B. 467, R. v Immigration Appeal Tribunal Ex, Q.B. 790, Knights Motors Ltd, State, R. v Mental Health Tribunal Ex p. Pickering, MIT Securities Ltd, State, CA, S v Special Educational Needs Tribunal, R. v Immigration Appeal Tribunal Ex p. Jebunisha Patel, Imm, State, the Home Department, State, E.L.R., R. v Lancashire CC, Compensation Board Ex P. Cook, State, Piggott Brothers, Co. Ltd, I.R.I.R. 309, Times, CA, Bahram, EWHC, Stefan v General Medical Council, Judicial, Acton Youth Court, EWHC 954, Seddon Properties Ltd, State, I.R.L.R.224, BC, State, R. v Mental Health Review Tribunal Ex p. Clatworthy, Ashworth Hospital Authority, Mental Health Review Tribunal, EWHC, EWHC, Varndelll v Kearney, Trecker Marwin Ltd, Thameside MBC, State, Q.B. 227, R. v Criminal injuries Compensation Board Ex p., R. v Mental Health Tribunal Ex p. Pickering, Great Portland Estates Plc, Westminster City Council, State, State, State, Hatfield Construction Ltd, State, M. Couper, œThe Art of Quasijudicial Administration, The Planning Appeal and Inquiry System, State, EWHC, Eagil Trust Co Ltd, Piggott-Brown, Housing and Local Government, R. v Livepool CC, State, R. v Ministry of Defence, C.O.D., BC, State, Westminster City Council, State, Grenfell-Baines, State, Kentucky Fried Chicken Pty Ltd v Gantidis, C.L.R., State, R. v Lancashire CC, R. v Civil Service Appeal Board Ex p. Cunningham, Council, MCI, MCI

CARDINAL: 1, 2, five, one, 1.5.2010, 2.5.2010, 2.6.2010, 2.6.2011, one, three, 12.9.2011, 9.9.2011, 8.9.2011, 12.9.2011, 24.11.2011, 2.6.2011, 3., three, 18.1.2010, 25.3.2010, more than one, 4., 3.2.2011, about 9.45PM, 1.5.2010, 3.2.2011, 1.5.2010, 2, 1, 7, 8, 8.2, 8.3, two, 24, 2, 8.3, one, 4, 38, 36Every, 40, 935, 41, 7, 42, 43, 47, 44, 13, 27, 3, 45, 30, One, 1610, 63, 4, 178, 6, 289, 1994)1, 1993)3, 154, 1993)3, 1998)1, 763, 228, 311, 1, 525, 1, 2, 1998)1, 763, 228, 421, 597, 2, 2, 368, 118, 134, 765, 2002)EWCA Civ.554, 219, 263, 257, 33, 36, 2003]EWCA, 27, 2000]1, 377, 382, 2, 2, 477, 673, 1, 153, 165, 47, No.2, 305, 311, two, 538, 41, 128, 18, 32, 118, 29, 915, 929, 535, 18, 1, one, 923, 1, 127, 81, 41, 65, 1964]2, 1986]1, 3, 75, 161, 167, 592, 58, 67, 159, 201, 28, 302, 224, 228, 313, 8, 1999]1, 170, 42, 26, 548, 77, 33, 2004, 36, 77, 33, 2004, 36, 693-694, 120, 122, 180, 2004, 1, 36, 1, 1, 499, 1, 673, 31, 31, 130, 605, 454, 1, 153, 167, one, 901, 1985]3, 122, 605, 2002, 1, 19, 1, 410, 1, 706, 1, 134, 104, 39, 27, 29-30, 256, 140, 675, 1, 4

PERSON: Laparoscopic Surgery, Bangalore, Seema Rai, Rai, Rai, Rai, Raju, Lokayuktha, Lokayuktha, Lokayuktha, Order, Order, Order, Kidney, Pankaj Rai, Rai, Kidney, Homograft, Liver, a. Smt, Seema Rai, b., Kannada, Seema Rai, c., Rajanna Sreedhara, Kidney, Rajanna Sreedhara, Venkatesh Cardiologist, Venkatesh, g. Suppression, Seema Rai, Seema Rai, Schedule, Etiquette, PUNISHMENT, Etiquette, Pankaj Rai, Pankaj Rai, Ramacharan Thiagarajan, Bangalore, Ram Charan Thiagarajan, Ram Charan Thiagarajan, P.Prasannaraj, Y.K.Gupta, Chander, Atul Sood, G.K.Sharma, Ravi Yashwant, Mohan Lal Capoor, Mahesh Chandra v., Atul Krishna Shaw, Krishna Swami v., Lal Gupta, L.K. Ratna, para30, Pilliah, Shri M.R.Malick, D.B. Raji, M.J. Shirani, Durga Das Basu, MUSATILL, Doody, Lmbro Plc., Dunlop, Bachowski, Maneka Gandhi, Seimens Engg, Maneka Gandhi, Atul Krishna Shaw, Ram Chandra, Harinagar Sugar Mills, Shyam Sundar, Bharathan Thampuran, Shri Swamiji v. Commissioner, Git Singh, Rani, Kshetriya Gramina Bank, Jagdish Sharan Varshney, Mark Elliott, Robert Thomas, Murray, Matson, Porter, Save Britains Heritage, Edwin H. Bradley, Bolton MBC, Scott Baker J., R., William v Wandsworth, J.P.L. 584, Bolton MBC, R. v Islington LBC Ex p. Hinds, Donaldson M.R., Ex p. Ross, Maurice Kay J.: œwhat, Alexander Machinery, R. v Chief Registrar, Hope, Ellis, A. Barker, Phillips M.R., Iveagh, Preston BC, J.P.L. 548, Save Britains Heritage, Jowitt J. at, R. v Criminal, R. v Criminal, Donaldson M.R., Order

GPE: India, the State of Karnataka, WP, WP, Liver, Narayana Hrudayalaya, Delhi, Liver, India, India, Karnataka, Shrilekha Vidyarthi, L.I.C., Research Centre, S.N., India, Karnataka, Padfield, USA, India, Nambudiri, Kerala, South Buckinghamshire, C.R., Newcastle, C.R., Arulandandam, L.G., I.R.L.R., C.R., West Midlands, North West Region, South Bucks DC, South Bucks, C.R., England, pp, E.R., C.R., P.I.Q.R.

ORDINAL: third, third, third, third, third, third, third, third, second, third, third, first, third, first, third, first, first, first, third, third, firstly, secondly, first, first

WORK_OF_ART: ZCCK, Certificates of Registration, Liver, 20A. Professional Conduct - (1, Writs Law and Practice, Commentary on the Constitution of India, The English Law, State of Punjab, 6th Edition, 3 All E.R. 699, English v Emery Reimbold, CA, 2 All E.R.941

TIME: the night of 1.5.2010, the early morning, the morning, 6 Urban Law and Policy 363

NORP: Rules, contra, Pancreas, Pancreas, d., Cardiologist, R., R., R., R., R., R., R., R., R., R., R., R., R., R., R.

LANGUAGE: English

QUANTITY: 8.15 A.M. f.

EVENT: SC 87, SC 671, SC 87

LOC: Shri M.P.Jain and Shri S.N.Jain

MONEY: 1994)1 WLR 242, 1994)1 WLR 242, 1994)1 WLR 242, 3 P.L.R.37

FAC: Ashworth Hospital, Ashworth Hospital