Lml Limited Vs. Bajaj Auto Limited

Decided On : May-02-2013

Court : Intellectual Property Appellate Board IPAB

LAW: the Companies Act, the Appellate Bench, section 26(1, Page 4, Section 10, the Patents Act, Section 64(1)(h, section 10. 57, the Patents Act

CARDINAL: 96, 2, 3., two, 27.04.2004, 4, 2, two, one, two, 5, two, 6., two, 8., 85, four, Two, four, two, 9, 10, four, 1, 2, two, one, 2., 1, 2, 3., 1, 4., 2, 11, 12, three, 13, 14, 15, two, 16, 17, two, 18, 26.09.2012, 19, two, 4,408,579, two, 4,345,551, two, 5,613,458, two, 100, 50, 104.30.87.00.00, 5,291,866, 21, 78 and 79, one, 5,291,866, 731, 50, 775, 51, 52, 2, 48, 27.09.2006, 203936, 731, 26, 297, 1, 6, 62, two, two, 14, 27.09.06, 203936, 107, 15, two, 15, more than one, 16, 17, 20/2009, 3, 131, four, 14, 15, more than one, two, 4, about 1952.”, 1, 23, two, 24, 1, 1, 2/3, 4, 25, two, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 2, 1, 88, 1, two, 2, 2, 24, 26, 24, 1, 29, 27, 25, four, two, two, 31, 31, 32a, 28, 2, 1, 40, 130, 18, one, one, one, 100, one, one, one, one, 1, 2, 1, 2, 33, two, 4, 731, more than one, 18, 21, 6, 34, one, two, one, mosaic, 8-40, “8-40, a mosaic, 1, 35, Four, 1987;Flow, two, two, 3, 37, 85, 3, 6, 4].In, one, 39, four, Two, four, two, 41, four, two, one, 5a, 5b, 7, 115, 528, 567, 531, 532, 531, 532.No, 531, one, 2, 1, 2, 5, 2, 137, 35, an opening 37, 1, 15, 1.A, 39, 15, one, two, 1, 3, 3, 4, 8, 5, one, 43, 1, 1, 731, more than one, 2, § 103, One, 3, 132, 4, 61, 5, two, 8, 125, 133, 9, 34, 419, 10, 3(d, 11, 578, 12, 48, 13, 16, 118, two, two, 85, 1, 2, 3, 4, two, 7, 11, 7, two, 1, 3, 3, two, 1, 3, 3, 4, 8, 5, 8, 50, two, 51, four, two, one, 52, two, 6, 6, two, two, 6, 56.The, 6, two, one, three, 59, 1, 731, 2, 3, 4, 48, 60, two, two, 61, two, 62

DATE: 189097, 2004, 25th May, 2007, 1956, several years, 12th April 2004, CO.NO.3 of 2004, the period of 1990, 857575, 80, 10.04.2012, June 30, 1993, 1453229, October 20, 1976, October 11, 1983, August 24, 1982, March 25, 1997, 871654, the year 1982, the year 1986, the year 1987, Free 50cc, 1995, the year 1980, 25th June 1979, March 8, 1994 20, 4345551, 22, 5613468, 871654, 1).AIR 1982, 1444, decades, 1951, 2011, 203935, 203935, 203936, 1444, 1967, 55, 203935, 18.04.2006, 18.04.2006, 213756, 20.10.2006, 1883, 1456, 1444, 1887, 213756, about 37 years back, 32, 18, 20, 46, 1453229, 4408579, 32b, 5613468, 5291866, 54, 871654, 189097, 1444, 587575, 21 17, 5579735, December 3, 1996, 1978, 4690107, September 1, 4475487, October 9, 1984;Joint, 4964381, October 23, 36, 857575, 80, 38, 40, 1997, 42, 8, 529, 4475487, 4964381, 14a 14, 1453229, 5613468, 5291866, 1937, 2001, 2004, 1956, 2007, 44, 46, 2011, 124 14, 7.50 15, 44, 45, 80, 46, 1453229, 4408579, 5613468, 5291866, 47, 48, 857575, 1960, 49, 4964381, February 6th 2001, 55, 189097, 189097, 189097, 1970, 58, 1970, 1978, 1989, 2011

ORG: Bajaj Auto Limited, Intellectual Property Appellate Board, IPAB, Hon'ble High Court, the Board on 24/09/2012, LML Limited, inter alia, –, Hon'ble High Court, BACKGROUND, LML, Bajaj Auto Limited –, –, un, Respondents, European Patent Application, Nissan Motor Company, United States, Brunswick Corporation, United States, Brunswick Corporation, SAE Paper No, Society of Automotive Engineers, TVS Scooty, TVS Motors, Service/Owner's, TVS, TVS Motors, Kinetic Honda, Kinetic Motors, VIZ, TVS, Kinetic Honda, Documents, Yamaha, Nissan, Brunswick, Yamaha, SAE, Service/Owner's, TVX, Kinetic Honda, SC, Hindustan Metal, Court, Court, Court, the House of Lords, the Court of Exchequer Chamber, IPAB, Chandra Das Vs, Guhathakurata, Trade Dress, the Trade Dress of the, IPAB, AIR 1982, SC, Hindustan Metal Industries:- “24, Salmond L.J., Judges of, RPC, NYE, N. and Co e, the US Supreme Court, Fed, AIR 1982, The Supreme Court, Court, Nye, Polar Industries Ltd., Jay Engineering Works Ltd., Morgan and Co. v. Windover and Co.., the Repots of Patent, Design and Trade Mark Cases, Windover and Co., Trial Court, the Appeal Court, the House of Lords, The House of Lords, – Unique Transmission Co. Ltd. Vs, Respondents, Internal Combustion, Air/Fuel, Bajaj Patent, Bajaj Patent Specification, i)an, that:- European Patent 0548993, European Patent 0548993, BAJAJ, Anticipation, Bajaj, Bajaj, Bajajs, Bajajs, SAE Publication, vehicle Technical Specification, TVS, Bajaj Patent, SC, Hindustan Metal, the Patent Office, Scarf, IPAB, Society of Automative Engineers, Bajaj Auto Limited, Bajaj Auto, SAE Publication, carburetor).And carburetor housing, BAL Application, LML, Bishwanath Prasad Radhey Shyam, Hindustan Metal Industries, KSR International Co., Teleflex Inc, the Federal Circuit, TSM, the Court of Appeals, TSM, RPC 121, Pfizer Ltd.'s, FSR, Hallen Company v Brabantia, Bilcare Ltd., Amartara Pvt. Ltd., Clochem Industries Ltd., Cadila Healthcare Ltd., sec, Enercon India Ltd., Aloys Wobben 2011, IPAB, IPAB, 4th Edition, Bajaj Auto, Intake, Engine, Anticipation, LML, Piaggio Patent 857575, LML, BAL, LML, SAE, the Court of Session, House, Lordships, Alba Diagnostics Ltd., the Central Motor Vehicle Rules, the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, Bishwanath Prasad Radhey Shyam Vs, Hindustan Metal Industries, SC, Unique Transmission Co. Ltd., Polar Industries Ltd. Vs, Jay Engineering Works Ltd., Guhathakurata, IPAB, DEL

GPE: Delhi, Bajaj, India, India, India, United States, US, UK, Harwood, Narayan, Rado, US, Faithful, India, Bajaj, Bajaj, Bajaj, US, Bajaj, US, Bajaj, US, US, Bajaj, Bajaj, Bajaj, Bajaj, Bajaj, UK, United States, United States, United States, United States, Bajaj, US, US, Bajaj, US, US, US, US, US, Bajaj, Bajaj, the United States, Howaldt, UK, Martin, Narayan, Bajaj, US, UK, US, US, US, Buchanan Vs, UK

PERSON: Pratibha M. Singh, Shri M.K. Chakrabarti, Kabushiki Kaisha, Yamaha Hatsudoshi, Kabushiki Kaisha, Zip 50cc, Skipper 125cc, Scooty, Benelli, David R. Kosa, TVS Scooty, Shyam, Sotam Singh, Purshottam, Blackburn L. J., Anr, – “7, Head Scarfs, Scarfs, Head Scarf, Shyam, ¦, ¦, ¦, ¦, Johon Tye, ¦â€¦, Williams, Brady, Johnson 747, Gilbert, Donald, Gilbert, Anr, Faithful, Kupplunsund Gorriebebau, Bajaj, Detailed Comparison, Refer, Refer, Shyam, para 17,18, Law, Law, Law, Narayanan, Glaxo Groul, ¦, Biro Swan, Anr, Law, P. Narayanan, Rodger, Earlsferry, “if, Controller, Anr, Narayan, Anr

NORP: Indian, Piaggio, Yamaha, British, Piaggio, West German, ‘Vulkan, West German, ‘Vulkan, iii)engine, British, British, British, British, British, Indian, BAL, British, addressee, Piaggio, British, Piaggio, Indian, Indian

FAC: Piaggo, Piaggo

LOC: Respondent

PRODUCT: Veicoli CspA, Respondent, Piaggio(ZIP50cc, RPC 62, mosaic, mosaic, mosaic, Method, Reed Valve, mosaic

ORDINAL: third, first, secondly, first, first

WORK_OF_ART: SC, SC, Patents 16th Edition

EVENT: Ors 2010