Walter Bushnel Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Mankind Pharma Pvt. Ltd. and Another

Decided On : Oct-31-2013

Court : Intellectual Property Appellate Board IPAB

LAW: Section 29, Section 11, Section 20, Section 11, Section (1, Section 11, Section 23 of the Act, Section 57, Order XXVII Rule 3 of Code of Civil Procedure, Section 18 of the Act, Section 20, Section 9 of the Act, Section 11, Section 2, RPC 102 AT P. 109, Section 10, section 11, Section 20, Section 18, Order 17 Rule 3 of Code of Civil Procedure, Order 9 Rule 9, Lahore 385, Order 17 Rule 3, Order 17, Section 11, Madras 404, Section 11, Allahabad 36, Madras 404, Order 17 Rule 3, Section 11, Madras 404, Order 17 Rule 3 Civil Procedure Code, Order 17 Rule 3 of the Civil Procedure Code, Order 17 Rule 3, Order 9 Rule 9, Order 17 Rule 3 of Code of Civil Procedure

CARDINAL: 236, 125, 2., 3., 3.2.1997, 1, No.1, 1, 1, 2, 11, 1, 11, 2, 11, 3, 5, 30.3.2005, 20.09.2004, No.2, more than 2, 5., 5, 3.2.1997, 2.4.1997, 25.6.2008, 6, 30.3.2005, 4”, 28.05.1997, 19, 4.2005, 9, 3, No.1, 20.09.2004, 57, 2, 222, 1958, 27, 525, 50, 3, 385, 250, 9, 3, 300, 1, two, 10, 772, 34, 469, 31, 11, 12, 13, No.1, 15, 16, 3.2.1997, 17, 18, 1, 19, 3, 20, 100, 21, 146, two, 9, 209, 22, 61, 19, one, three, 1, 2, 3, two, three, 23, 50, two, two, two, two, two, 1, 2, 222, “RUSTON”, 25, 4, 27, 525, 532, 27, 7 to 10, 92, 27.63, 346.11, 8, 1, 1, 2, 1, 9, 10, 137, two, three-fold, 29, 30, 23.6.2008, 1, three, 271, 13, 22, 2, 20.09.2004, 33, 34, 1, 4, 37, 38, 1, 2, 1, 40, 3, 40, 3, 300, 41, 3, 300, only section 11, 43, 385, 9, 1, 563, 1, 10, 11, 114, 74,259.60, 9

PERSON: K.N. Basha, mark “DROTIN”., Exhibit, “DROTIKIND-80”, Exhibits, Exhibit, Amarjit Singh, Laxman Dhara, Walter Bushness Pvt, ROSHAN LAL DUGGAR, Vikramjit Banerjee, Exhibit, Amarjit Singh, No.1309918, Walter Bushnell Pvt, Walter Bushnell Pvt, Walter Bushnell Pvt, Walter Bushnel Pvt, “Ambal”, “Andal”, Radha, Radha, Radha, Stamp J., Radha, Radha, Radha, Sri Ambal, C.63, Amiritdhara, Lakshman, mark “DROTIN”., Amridharas, Walter Bushnel Pvt. Ltd., Exhibit, decisions:-, Ram Ghyuam, Abdul Azeez, Vs, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Kartar Singh, Order XVII Rule 3, Govindoss Krishnadoss Vs, Karvetnagar, M. P. 61, Kartick Chandra Pal, ¦, Punjab

DATE: 57, 1999, February, 1997, 2.4.1997, April, 1997, 1999, 1997, 2005, the Year, 2005, October, 2005, 1999, seven years old, December, 2005, 11, 1999, February, 1997, 1997.” 4, the year 2004, the year 2004, 15.12.2005, more than 3 years 9 months, 26.12.2003, April, 1997, 19.4.2005, 2005, 2005, 2005, 2005, 12.11.2007, 02.04.1997, the year 1997-98, class 5, 2005, 12.5.2006, 12.5.2006, 12.5.2006, 15.12.2005, July, 2008, 1970, 45 C. 21, 2003, 1997, 23 June 2008, 2008, 2001, 2010, 42, 2007, 2005, 14, the year 1997, 20th September, 2004, 1999, 11, 1950-67, 1969, 1970, “RUSTAM”, “RUSTAM”, “RUSTON”, between “RUSTON”, “RUSTON”, “RUSTAM”, 1958, the past 40 years, law.” 26, 2003, 1997, the year 1988, 25th July, 1989, the year 1989, the year 1994, 1989, November 25, 1992, 1992, 12.11.2007, 2008, the Act.” 31, class 5, 32, 15.12.2005, the month of July, 2008, 2005, 35, 36, 12.05.2006, i)AIR 1936, ii)AIR 1944, 2001, 2004, 39, 2nd June, 1926, 1929, ten days, 1926, 1929, 42, 1966, 1936, 1929, 1886, yesterday, morrow, 44, 1996, (1996, 18th October, 1985, 1st July, 1972 to 30th June, 1983, A.I.R. 1936, 45, 46, 2013

ORG: DROTKIND-M, the State Drug Controller, Naptha, The Trade Marks Act, the Trade Marks Journal, the Trade Marks Act, Registrar, Register, Register, Sections 11, the Trade Marks Act, Windias Biotech Limited, M/s. Windias Biotech Limited, the Trade Marks Journal, Naptha, ISI, this Honble Board, Dhydro Eithereine Chloride, DROTAVERINE, DROTAVERINE, Registrar of Trade Marks, the Drug Licence, the Chartered Accountant Certificate, the Windias Biotech Limited, Windias Biotech Limited, the Delhi Court, Windia Biotech Limited, IPAB, Registrar, CAL – 208384, M/s. Life Star Pharma Private Limited, M/s. Life Star Pharma Limited, M/s. Life Star Pharma Private Limited, Journal, Drug Licence, Applicant, the Drug Licence, Applicant, the Chartered Accountant, Windias Biotech Limited, the District Court, Order IX Rule, No.1301198, the Honble Supreme Court, AIR 1960 SC 100, the Honble Supreme Court, Amirt Dhara Vs, AIR 1963, SC, Applicant, this Honble Board, No.1309918, No.732349, AIR 1960 SC 100, AMBAL, AIR 1970 SC 146 (Vol, CHETTY Vs, K.VENKATESA MUDALIAR, AIR 1974 MADRAS 7 (Vol.61 C.5, HORNSBY LTD, CIBA LTD, S.SUBRAMANIAM, NUTRACEUTICALS PVT., DEL, WIN-MEDICARE LTD, SOMACARE LABORATORIES, AIR 1963 449, Bombay High Court, MAPRA Laboratories P. Ltd., NILA, PUNUN, AIR 1936 Lahore, CO, AIR 1978, the Honble Supreme Court, SMT, KUNWAR, AIR 1966 SCR, AIR 1966, Registrar, Registrar, Registrar, “public, Register, Harris Laboratories Ltd., CADILA HEALTH CARE LTD, CADILA PHARMACEAUATICALS LTD, SC, ALKEM LABORATORIES LTD, UK LTD, CHEMICALS, PHARMACEUTICALS LTD, NOVARTIS AG Vs, WANBURY LTD, No.732349, Martin and Harris Laboratories Ltd., Martin and Harris Laboratories Ltd., Martin and Harris Pvt. Ltd., Walter Bushnel Pvt. Ltd., Martin and Harris Laboratories Ltd., Walter Bushnel Pvt, Windias Biotech Limited, The Trade Marks Act, LIKELY, Emphasis, KIND, KIND, KIND, the Honble Apex Court, AIR 1960, Supreme Court, the Honble Apex Court, the Apex Court, The Honble Apex Court, AIR 1970 Supreme Court, No.126808, No.146291, Brodheads Application, Court, Registrar, the Divisional Bench, AIR 1974, the Vicks Vaporub, Vaporub, The Honble Apex Court, AIR 1963, nectar, The Honble Apex Court, The High Court, the High Court, the High Court, the Honble Apex Court, AIR, Ciba, Ciba, Ciba, Ciba, The Delhi High Court, DICMOL, the Honble Apex Court, LO, the Notice of Motion, TM, Board, the Bombay High Court, MAPRA Laboratories Pvt, The Bombay High Court, DROT, DROTIN, the Appellate Board, the Appellate Board, the Honble Apex Court, Harris Laboratories Limited, the Walter Bushnel Private Limited, Walter Bushnel Private Limited, Martin, Harrish Laboratories Private Limited, the Walter Bushnel Private Limited, Walter Bushnel Private Limited, Registrar, District Court, the Civil Court, Karnataka 104, Saurashtra Chemicals, Court, Court, Allahabad, the Honble Apex Court, DARYAO KUNWAR AIR 1966 SCR, the Honble Supreme Court, CPC, AIR, Court, Sridhar Mandal, Court, Court, Court, Court, Court, ORIENTAL ELECTRICALS INSULATION Vs, Haryana High Court, PLR 215, Court, Nila, Court, the High Court of Lahore, Madras High Court, Haryana High Court

ORDINAL: first, first, 3rd, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, third, third, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, second, first, first, first, first, first, first, first, second

PRODUCT: DROTIKIND-80, DROTIKIND-80, No.1, DROTIKIND-80, No.1, Respondent No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, No.1, Bulova, the Order 17 Rule 3 of

NORP: Rules, J-174”(series, Imperfect, Indian, Cibol, Punjab, Teh Bazari

WORK_OF_ART: The Application No.1309918, BOMBAY 56 (Vol, No.732349, Accutron, Sri Andal, BOMBAY 56 (Volume 45 C.21, Dielofenac Sodium, Paracetamol, Miscellaneous Petition No.125 of

GPE: Suit, suffix, suffix, I-314”(series, Delhi, Suit, suffix, suffix, NARAYAN, RUSTON, suffix, Delhi, Delhi, Delhi, suffix, suffix, suffix, India, ‘dhara, England, India, England, RUSTON, suffix, Betalong, Betalong, O.S.No.87, Delhi, C.P.C., “Court, C.P.C.

MONEY: two marks, two marks

LOC: Single Judge

EVENT: the Act.” 24, the Notice of Motion, Gujarat 83

FAC: Betaloc, Betaloc