Surinder Singh Barmi Vs. Ipl and Another

Decided On : Feb-08-2013

Court : Competition Commission of India CCI

LAW: the Competition Act, section 26(1, section 19(4, section 4, section 4(2, section 4, section 2(h, section 2(h, Article 12 of the Constitution of India, section 2(r, section 4, section 4(1, section 3(3, the Initial ITT-2010, the Initial ITT-2010 on, section 4(2, section 4(2, section 4(2, section 2(h, section 4, section 3, section 2(h, section 143, the Income Tax Act, the Income Assessment Order of BCCI, section 2(h, the Competition Act, the Competition Act, section 2(u, section 4, section 2(r, section 2(s, section 4

PERSON: M.L. Tayal, Shri Surinder, Singh Bermi, Shri Lalit Modi, Shri Lalit Modi, Shri Modi, Shri Modi, Rajasthan Royals, Kolkata Knight Riders, Kings XI Punjab, BCCI, IPL, IPL, IPL, DG, DG, BCCI, Shri Lalit, Kumar Modi, BCCI, Shri Modi, IPL, DG, “enterprises‟which, Ranji Trophy, Dulip Trophy, Ranji Trophy, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Further, IPL, Bangalore, Ahmadabad, Kanpur, Ahmadabad, Nagpur, BCCI, BCCI, Shri Lalit Modi, Shri Modi, Shri Lalit Modi, BCCI, Shri Modi, BCCI, Shri Modi, BCCI, BCCI, Shri Lalit Modi, Shri Modi, Shri Modi's, Shri Modi, BCCI, Shri Modi, Shri Modi, Shri Modi, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Bid, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, MoU, MoU, SAIL, SAIL, BCCI, BCCI, Shri Modi, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Shri Lalit Modi, Shri Lalit Modi, Shri Modi, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, I. Whether BCCI, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, kind”, exceptions…, BCCI, Test Matches, BCCI, Anr, BCCI, BCCI, DG, IPL, BCCI, BCCI

ORG: BACKGROUND, Indian Premier League, Board of Control for Cricket, inter alia, IPL, IPL, IPL/BCCI, the Office of BCCI, IPL, IPL, IPL, IPL, IPL, IPL, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, Commission, BCCI, the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, BCCI, IPL, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, Indian Premiere League, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI-IPL, IPL, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, IPL, IPL, ITT, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Multi Screen Media, Sony Pictures Entertainment, World Sports Group India, WSG Pte Ltd, MSM, WSG, BCCI, BCCI-IPL, BCCI, FCT, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Commission, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, BCCI, Memorandum of Association, Test Matches, MoA, BCCI, BCCI, MoA, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, Champions League T20, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, the Honble Supreme Court, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India and Ors, Cricket Association of Bengal, Arun Kumar Tyagi, The Software Engineering Institute, BCCI, BCCI, the Honble Supreme Court, Commission, BCCI, Act, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, IPL, IPL, IPL, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, the European Union, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, the International Cricket Council, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, ITT-2008, the Times of India, Hyderabad, Mohali, the Governing Council of the IPL, ITT, the Hindustan Times, GC, BCCI, IPL, ITT-2008, ITT-2008, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, ITT-2008, BCCI, BCCI, ITT, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, ITT-2008, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, ITT, IPL, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, the League Marks, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Show Cause Notice, Show Cause Notice, BCCI, the Show Cause Notices, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, ITT, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, ITT, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, ITT, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Media Rights, BCCI, the Media Rights License Agreement, BCCI, MSM, inter alia, MSM, the Media Rights License Agreement, BCCI, WSGI, inter alia, Media Rights, BCCI, BCCI, Commission, Kingfisher Airlines Limited v. Competition Commission of India, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Commission, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, WSGI, NDTV, ESPN Star Sports, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Media, ITT, BCCI, WSGI, BCCI, WSGI, MSM, BCCI, the Media ITT, MSM, WSGI, BCCI, WSGI, MSM, WSGI, BCCI, WSG-MSM, WSGI, MSM, ITT, WSGI, MSM, WSGI, MSM, WSGI, MSM, BCCI, BCCI, WSGI, MSM, the Media ITT, Media Rights, WSGI, Media Rights, WSGI, MSM, IPL, BCCI, the Media ITT, BCCI, the Media ITT, the Media ITT, BCCI, the Media ITT, the Media Rights, the Media ITT, the Media ITT, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, IPL, BCCI, Media Rights, BCCI, BCCI, Restraints European Commission Notice, EU, BCCI, Commission, Consumer Guidance Society, Hindustan Coca Cola Beverages Pvt. Ltd., Ors, AAEC, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Jindal Steel and Power Limited v. Steel Authority of India Limited, Commission, Indian Railways and Steel Authority of India Limited, Commission, Commission, BCCI, Commission, MSM, WSGI, the Media ITT, ITT, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, ITT, the Supreme Court of India, Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Limited, Brojo Nath Ganguly, AIR 1986, Limb, Lion, the Media ITT, BCCI, the Media ITT, ITT, ITT, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, the Media ITT, the Media ITT, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Shri Lalit Modi, Media Rights, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, the Cricket Network, Live Current Media, BCCI, the Web Portal MoU, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Shri Modi, BCCI, DLF, the IPL GC, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, FCT Rights, IPL, Entertainment and Sports Direct, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, FCT Rights, BCCI, BCCI, FCT Rights, Indian Cricket League, M/s Essel Sports Pvt. Ltd., BCCI, ICL, BCCI, ICL, ICL, BCCI, BCCI, ICL, ICL, BCCI, ICL, BCCI, ICL, IPL, BCCI, Kingfisher Airlines Limited v. Competition Commission of India, Commission, Commission, ICL, BCCI, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court, BCCI, ICL, Commission, BCCI, ICL, BCCI, BCCI, ICL, BCCI, ICL, BCCI, ICL, ICL, BCCI, BCCI, ICL, ICL, BCCI, BCCI, Commission, Commission, Shri C.A. Sunderam, BCCI, Determination of Issues Whether BCCI, BCCI, IPL, BCCI, the Income Tax Assessment Order, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, the Income Tax Authority, Income Tax, Exception, the Income Tax Assessment Order 2008-09, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, the Central Government, inter alia, BCCI, the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, the Memorandum of Association of BCCI, BCCI, Test Matches, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Test Matches, BCCI, BCCI, the Honble High Court, W.P., Ors v. Union of India and Ors, the Honble Court, the Chess Federation, the Central Government, “29, Commission, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, State, Cricket Associations, Inter-State, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, Commission, Jupiter Gaming Solutions Private Limited v. Government of Goa, BCCI, Commission, IPL, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, BCCI, IPL, Media Rights, BCCI, IPL, Test Matches, Commission

CARDINAL: 1, 2., two, three, 3, eight, 4., eight, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 10, 14, 2, 15, 16, 2, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 70, 23, 24, 25, 2, 161, 26, 19, 30.09.2011, 27, 28, 4, 649, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, one, more than one, 37, one, 38, 39, 40, 41, 8, 14, 10, 43, 2, 5, two, five, 45, 2.3.2, 4, 48, 8, 8, 2, 49, 50, 8, one, 51, 52., 5.5, 5.5, 5.5, 3, 56, only 2, 2, 2, 5, 57, 3, 4, 59, zero, 60, 61, 62, 10.6, 63, only two, two, 64, 65, two-fold, 66, 67, 69, 99, 71, 72, 73, one, 74, one, 75, only one, 6, 80, 81, 82, 84, 85, 3, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 3, 92., 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 2, 2, one, 2, 101, one, 102, 103, 15, 104, 105, 20, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113

GPE: India, Mumbai, India, US, USA, Singapore, India, India, India, India, India, Zee, India, the United States of America, the United Kingdom, India, India, India, India, Mumbai, Delhi, Kolkata, Jaipur, IPL‟, India, Kanpur, Kochi, IPL, “bid, India, India, India, IPL, India, India, India, India, India, UK, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, India, Delhi, “of, India, India, “of, India, India

DATE: 2002, April 2010, 09.12.2012, 17.01.2012, 02.02.2012, the last three financial years, one day, 14.01.08, one year, a period of, 10 years, 10 years, 1975, One Day, the past 4 years, 1995, 2011, 2005, 42, 2007, 2008, 24 January 2008, 2008, 9 March 2010, March 2010, 21 March 2010, 44, 46, 47, the incipient years, the first three years, 2008, 26th April 2010, 54, 55, 2010, 2010, 7 March 2010, 22 February 2010, 58, 2008-2012, a further 5 year, 2008-2017, 20 May 2009, monthly, past 3 years, 14 January 2008, 10 years, a 10 year, a further 5 years, 10 years, only 2 months, 70, 2009, 2009, 2011, 76, 17 December 2011, a period of, 4 years, 16 April 2008, a period of, 10 years, 26 April 2010, 13 February 2008, 79, 2-5 years, 10 years, 2007, 2007-08, 20 May 2009, at least 2 years, IPL season, IPL season, 11.07.2012,, 01.08.2012, 1961, the assessment year 2008-09, the assessment year 2008-09, 28.12.2009, 1975, One Day, One Day, 5770, 2011, 2010, 12.05.2011, One Day

PRODUCT: T-20, T-20 IPL, T-20, the T-20 Contracts, the “relevant market‟in the

FAC: the T-20 Contracts, “ordinary‟industries, the Show Cause Notice, the Show Cause Notice, WSGI Bid, WSGI Bid, T20, the T-20 Contracts

WORK_OF_ART: the DG Report, Live Current Media

MONEY: $ 50 million

PERCENT: 70%, 70%, 70%, 45%-65%

NORP: Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, Indian, “enterprise‟means, Hemant Sharma

ORDINAL: first, 1st, 1st, 2nd, first, 1st, 1st, first, first

LOC: Pune, MoA

TIME: 11:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m., the minutes, 4 of the Act i.e.

EVENT: India Territory Agreement