Skip to content

Semantic Analysis by spaCy

Pharmaceutical Research and Mfrs. of America Vs. Walsh

Decided On : Jan-22-2003

Court : US Supreme Court

Notice (8): Undefined index: topics [APP/View/Case/meta.ctp, line 36]
Warning (2): Invalid argument supplied for foreach() [APP/View/Case/meta.ctp, line 39]

LAW: the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, The Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, Title XIX, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Maine Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, The Medicaid Act, the Maine Act, Constitution, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, Constitution, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act's, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act's, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Supremacy Clause, section 1396a, the Supremacy Clause, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, Constitution, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act's, Section 1396r-8(d)(5, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act, the Medicaid Act

PERSON: Mfrs, STEVENS, Baldwin, G. A. F. Seelig, Maine Rx, Lynn Creamery, pp, STEVENS, GINSBURG, P.670, STEVENS, GINSBURG, Maine Rx, Alexander , BREYER, THOMAS, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, C. J., J., J., J., C. J., KENNEDY, J., Carter G. Phillips, Kathleen M. Sullivan, Daniel M. Price, Marinn F. Carlson, Bruce C. Gerrity, Ann R. Robinson, Kneedler, McCallum, Lisa Schiavo Blatt, Mark B. Stern, Mark S. Davies, Alex M. Azar II, Henry R. Goldberg, Janice L. Hoffman, Andrew S. Hagler, G., Steven Rowe, Paul Stern, John R. Brautigam, Cabanne Howard, John G. Roberts, Catherine E. Stetson, Robin, S. Conrad, Bert W Rein, David C. Todd, Deborah J. La Fetra, Daniel J. Popeo, Richard A. Samp, Briefs, Thomas, F. Reilly, Linda A. Tomaselli, Peter Leight, Bruce M. Botelho, Janet Napolitano, Mark Pryor, Bill Lockyer, Earl I. Anzai, Steve Carter, Thomas J. Miller, Albert B. Chandler III, Richard P. Ieyoub, Joseph Curran, Jennifer M. Granholm, Mike Hatch, Mike Moore, Jeremiah W, Nixon, Mike McGrath, Philip T. McLaughlin, Patricia A. Madrid, Eliot Spitzer, Hardy Myers, GINSBURG, GINSBURG, Sheldon Whitehouse, Charlie M. Condon, Mark Barnett, John Cornyn, William H. Sorrell, Darrell V. McGraw, Anabelle Rodriguez, al, Sarah Lenz Lock, Bruce Vignery, Michael Schuster, Robert M. Hayes, Arn H. Pearson, Thomas C. Bradley, Richard Ruda, James I. Crowley, Sheldon V. Toubman, Parham, Cong, 8104 Stat, Tit, Title, Kevin Concannon, Tit, Maine Rx, George Bilyk of, Janssen Pharmaceutica, Howell, Concannon, Clifford, Richardson, Augmentin, Augmentin, David Moules, Howell, Concannon, App, Cert, Maine Rx, Doran, Salem Inn, n. 3, Bowles, Benten, Kessler, Maine Rx, Cert, Alexander , Alexander, Cert, Baldwin, G. A. F. Seelig, Cardozo, Baldwin, Lynn Creamery, Ante, Ante, Arkansas Pub, Servo Comm'n, Rosado, J., E. g.,, App, Ante, Ante, Theodore B. Olson, William K. Suter, Clerk, e. g., e. g., Administrative Law § 14.4, J., E. g., J. Stein, G. Mitchell, Administrative Law § 47.01[1, CA5 , E. g., e. g., MacDonald, CA7, C. Wright, A. Miller, Rosado, Lynn Creamery, J., Maine Rx, Maine Rx, STEVENS, Mfrs, judg-, Maine Rx, J., Maine Rx, Maine Rx, J., Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Smiley, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, N. A., Maine Rx, D. Smith, Dir, Medicaid Dirs, App, Maine Rx, Mfrs, Petitioner, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Mfrs, KENNEDY, J., KENNEDY, Maine Rx's, Cert, non-Medicaid, Maine Rx, Davido, Cert, Alexander , Tit, Maine Rx, Tit, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Ante, Maine Rx, Maine Rx, Tit

GPE: America, U.S., States, Maine, Healy, Maine, Maine, Healy, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Pp, Maine, Maine, Maine, United States, Maine, Pp, States, States, the United States, Maine, the United States of America, Massachusetts, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Hawaii, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, New Mexico, New York, Oklahoma, Oregon, States, Maine, Maine, Maine, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Vermont, Washington, West Virginia, Puerto Rico, Maine, States, ND Ga., Georgia, California, States, States, United States, States, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, West Supp, Maine, Maine, the United States, Nevada, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Id., Id., Maine, the United States, Maine, Maine, Maine, United States, United States, Maine, Maine, Maine, States, Florida, States, Florida, States, Tennessee, Id., Maine, Pennsylvania, Maine, Hillsborough County, States, New York's, New York's, New York, Id., Maine, Maine, Maine, New York, Vermont, Healy, Massachusetts, States, Maine, Maine, Maine, Healy, Healy, Massachusetts, Massachusetts, Massachusetts, States, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Medicaidrelated, California, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, United States, United States, Id., United States, Maine, Chicago Park District, pp, Maine, Healy, America, States, States, States, States, States, States, Maine, States, unambiguous.4 See, States, South Dakota, United States, the District of Columbia, America, Maine, Maine, Maine, America, Maine, States, Maine, Maine, Dedeaux, New York State Dept, States, Maine, West Supp, Maine, West Supp, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, Maine, West Supp

DATE: 2003, 2002, January 22, 2003, May 19,2003, 1990, 67, JJ, JJ, 1990, the last several years, 2000, 1989, Between 1982 and 1988, annual, Mar. 7, 1991, 2002, 1965, 1990, 1977, 1986, 1982, 1993, 1990, 1990, 1990, 14-15, 1396r-8(a)(3, 1990, 1993, 1990, 2000, 22, 2681, 6 months, 11107, 2002, 1990, Several months before January 1,2001, 22, 2002, 50, 53, 76-77, 87, 57, the six months, 22Id, 24Id, 1989, Oct. 26,2000, CA1 2001, 76, ' 42, 1975, September 18, 2002, 1944, 48a, 12, 1084, 1085, 1992, Mar. 2001, 1197, 1990, the first three months, 1198, 1985, annual days, 20 to 14, 14-day, 68, 1977, 1985, 1973, 1968, September 18, 1935, 1989, 81-82, 1994, 1983, 1970, 57, 14, Jan. 10, 2003, 1990, 467 U. S., 1984, 1944, 2002, 48a, 63-65, 1956, 1952, 63-65, 2002, 1496, CAlO 1996, 2002, 2003, 1988, 1306, 1316, 1971, 1997, 2948, 1995, 397 U. S., 1994, 1997, 1981, 1941, 2d 39, 72, 2003, 1396r-8(d)(5, § 1396r-8(d)(2, 1984, 1996, Sept. 18, 2002, 2d 39, 2003, 2d 39, 2003, 1992, 17, 1981, 1997, 1979, 1983, 2002, 1997, 1941, 98 (1992, 51, 1987, 70, 1990, 1973, 1985, 22, 2002, 22, 2002, 22, 2002

ORG: Syllabus, MAINE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SERVICES, THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS, THE FIRST CIRCUIT No, State, Medicaid, Health and Human Services, HHS, Medicaid, Congress, Medicaid, Medicaid, the "Maine Rx" Program, Medicaid, Commerce Clause, the District Court, The First Circuit, Court, VI, Commerce Clause, Beer Institute, Court, the District Court's, Rx Program, Medicaid Plan, Court, Rx Program, non-Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, Medicaid, the District Court, State, Medicaid, Syllabus, Medicaid, the First Circuit, Medicaid, Medicaid, District Court, the District Court, HHS, Medicaid, Medicaid, HHS, the District Court's, State, Medicaid Act, Medicaid, Congress, Hines, Davidowitz, Congress, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., non-Medicaid, Congress, Chevron, J., Court, Court, VI, REHNQUIST, SOUTER, GINSBURG, BREYER, SOUTER, GINSBURG, BREYER, SOUTER, GINSBURG, BREYER, THOMAS, Syllabus, REHNQUIST, Solicitor General Olson, Sheree R. Kanner, the Chamber of Commerce of, the International Patient Advocacy Association et al, the Long Term Care Pharmacy Alliance, the Pacific Legal Foundation, the Washington Legal Foundation, the State of Massachusetts et al, the Attorneys General, Court, Court, VI, JUSTICE, Medicaid, Congress, Medicaid, Medicaid, State, AARP, the Maine Council of Senior Citizens et al, the National Conference of State Legislatures, Legal Services Organizations Representing Medicaid Beneficiaries, Medicaid, Medicaid, Congressional Research Service Report, Congress, Medicaid: Reimbursement for Outpatient Prescription Drugs, Ford, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid, Commerce Clause, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, The District Court, The Court of Appeals, Congress, Medicaid, the Social Security, Medicaid, State, Health and Human Services, The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, CMS, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, Georgia Medicaid, Cowan, Medicaid, House Subcommittee on Health, the Committee on Energy and Commerce, Background Data and Analysis, Ford, CRS-l., California Medicaid, Medicaid, Congress, the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act, Medicaid, Medicaid, State, State, State, Medicaid, Congress, State, the Federal Food and Drug Administration, Congress, State, State, the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act, Congress, the Maine Legislature, the Maine Rx Program, State, State, the Food and Drug Administration, State, State, Medicaid, State, the Department of Human Services, Medicaid, a "Drug Utilization Review Committee, State, State, the Maine Medicaid Program, the Maine Rx Program, agreement.18, State, the Pharmaceutical Research, Manufacturers of America, SmithKline, SmithKline Beecham Corporation, State, Medicaid Medical, HMO/Insurance, State, Medicaid, SmithKline Beecham Corp., MCO, Maine Rx Rebate Agreement, the District Court, Beer Institute, State, Rx Program, the" 'Department of Human Services, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid Medical, The Court of Appeals, the District Court's, Medicaid, State, State, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, The Court of Appeals, J. , Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Court, Commerce Clause, the District Court, Rx Program, The District Court, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid Plan, CMS, Medicaid, CMS, Medicaid, State, State, Medicaid, Medicaid, the Federal Government's, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid Plan, Davies Warehouse Co., CMS, State, State, Medicaid, J. , Rx Program, Medicaid, non-Medicaid, the District Court, Medicaid, the District Court, Medicaid, the District Court, Court, the District Court, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, the District Court's, the Maine Rx Program, The Court of Appeals, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, See Kaiser Commission, Medicaid, J. , Congress, Medicaid, Manufacturers of America, State, Medicaid, the Federal Government, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, State, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, State, the District Court, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid, The District Court's, Medicaid, the District Court, Medicaid, The District Court's, State, State, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, State, Automated Medical Laboratories,, Social Servs, State, Court, the Federal Government, Maine Rx Program, Medicaid, the Drug Utilization Review Committee, Medicaid, the Court of Appeals', Maine Rx Program, Maine Medicaid, Maine Rx Program, CMS, the Maine Rx Program, the Rx Program, Commerce Clause, Court, Beer Institute, the Court of Appeals, J. , the Maine Rx Program, the Court of Appeals, the Court of Appeals, Court, The District Court's, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid, Wyman, Medicaid, Congress, Medicaid, Congress, Medicaid, the District Court, Legal Services Organizations Representing Medicaid Beneficiaries, the District Court's, Medicaid, J. , Health and Human Services, Medicaid, Solicitor General, Court, District Court, FERC, the District Court's, the Court of Appeals', the District Court, the District Court, The Department of Health and Human Services, HHS, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., Swift & Co., THOMAS, J., Medicaid, State, Medicaid, HHS, HHS, State, State, State, Medicaid, CFR, Western Pacific R. Co., Western Pacific R. Co., Williams Pipe Line Co., Empire Gas Corp., Western Pacific R. Co., Wagner &, ANR Pipeline Co., Wheelabrator Corp., CADC, the District Court's, Federal Practice, Court, Court, negativeCommerce-Clause, Commerce Clause, State, Pennhurst State School and Hospital, the Department of Health and Human Services, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, Commerce Clause, Court, Congress, Hines, Davidowitz, J., Medicaid, JUSTICE, Congress, the Department of Health and Human Services, Medicaid, Medicaid, the Department of Health and Human Services', Medicaid, State, § 1396r8(d)(5, State, State, Congress, State, J., Medicaid, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, Court, Congress, Medicaid, Medicaid, State, Maine Rx's, Medicaid, Court, J., the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid Plan, Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., State, State, State, State, the Federal Government, State, the Medicaid Act's, Citibank, Congress, Chevron, Congress, the Department of Health and Human Services, non-Medicaid, Center for Medicaid, State Operations, Centers for Medicare & Medical Services, State, Congress, Chevron, Chevron, the District Court, Pharmaceutical Research, J., Medicaid, Congress, Congress, C Maine Rx, Congress, National Solid Wastes Management Assn, J., Court, Spending Clause, Pennhurst State School and Hospital, Spending Clause, Contracts § 304, Congress, Court, Medicaid, Spending Clause, Commerce Clause, THOMAS, Court, J. , Court, Medicaid, Medicaid, the District Court, the Maine Rx Program, the District Court, Medicaid, Medicaid, Hines, the District Court's, Parts IV, National Solid Wastes Management Assn, Congress, National Solid Wastes Management Assn, Congress, Hines, Davidowitz, Medicaid, State, State, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, Social Servs, State, Medicaid, Medicaid, J. , the District Court, Health and Human Services, Congress, Congress, Medicaid, State, State, Congress, Medicaid, Congress, Medicaid, Medicaid, Congress, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, The District Court, the Maine Rx Program's, Medicaid, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, State, Medicaid, State, non-Medicaid, State, State, non-Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, the District Court, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid, State, the District Court, Medicaid, J. , the District Court, the District Court, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid, State, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, the District Court's, the District Court, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program's, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, Medicaid, the District Court, Medicaid, the Maine Rx Program, Medicaid

CARDINAL: 01, 249, 66, 645, 324, 186, 668, 660, 303, 646, two, 662, 574, Pp.670-674, 647, 674-675, 312, 1396r8(d)(1, 1396r8(d)(1, 467, 842, 675-683, 670, 674, 675, 648, 684, 649, 1, 17, 343, 3, 6, 427, 97, 100, 187, 3d 968, 974, 299, 301, 1396a(a)(10)(A)(i, 5, one, 1396a(a)(1O)(C, 167, 6, 652, 1990).8, two, 2, one, 1388-143, 9, 653 , 1396r-8(d)(2)(C, 1, 2, at least a, 1993,11, 10, 1388-150, 1927(d)(6, 613, 12, 5, 1396r-8(d)(4, 2681(1, 2681(4, 13, 2681(3, 2681(4, 2681(6, two, 2681(7, 13, 2681(2)(C, 655 , 14, 17, 317, 2681(1, 2681(2)(F, 2681(1, 15, 268, 278, 16Id, 149, 17, 18, 62-74, 27, 19, seven, Four, two, Three, one, 21, four, 19Id, 37, 2째Id, 21Id, one, 23, two, four, nearly half, 24, 112, 23, 103, 1, 2, 3, 102, 149-150, 658 , 3 to 6, 26, 324, 336, two, 28, 154, 26Id, 167, 27Civ, 00, 28, 659, 29, three, 249, 66, 75, 29, 78, 931, 661, 144, 153, 31, 9, 968, 972, 663 , three, two, almost two-thirds, 1990.34, 304, 33, 23, 34, 101-881, 98, 35, 304, 1396a(a)(19, 00, 68, 303, 302, 306, 36, 36, 00, 707, 715, two, 421, 318, 413, 422, 2002,38, 38, 30, 521, 324, 249, 186, two-thirds, 659, 667, 375, 389, 422, 687, 1396r-8(d)(1, 651-653, 103, one, 663-665, at least one, 660-661, 506, 673, 134, 680-681, 42, 430, 64, 574, 944, 674 , 76, 1491, 5, 47-5, 47-6, 2, 2:337, 373, 64, 837, 199, 206, 672, 132, 355, 357, 131-133, 406, 668, 675 , 186, 209, 349, 17, 660, 67, 662, 1396a(a)(30, 259, 1396a(a)(19, 665, 1396r-8(d)(1, 677, 1396r-8(d)(1)(A, 1396r-8(d)(1, 1396r-8(d)(1)(B)(i, 1396r8(d)(2)(A, 1396r8(d)(2)(C, 1396r-8(d)(2)(I, one, 1396a(a)(19, 665, 685, 1396r8(d)(2)(B, 1396r-8(d)(2)(C, 679, 688, 2, 3, 660, 842, 1, 2, 4, 681, 735, 739, 842, 1396a(a)(19, 48a.5, 843, 5, 259, 69, 682, 1396a(a)(19, 259, 69, 111, one, 683, 451, 349, 273, 283, 610, 662, 67, 96, one, 652, one, 101-881, 98, 421, 1396b(f, 303, Two, 1396a(a)(19, 2681(7, 2)(F, 662, 2)(F, about three, 663, 663, 664, 663, 662, 689 , 2681(7

LOC: Medicaidrelated, West Supp

WORK_OF_ART: Far East Conference, The "Maine Rx, Arkansas Elec., Far East Conference, Camps Newfound/ Owatonna, Inc., Supplemental Security Income, Maine Rx

PERCENT: 5 U. S. C. § 706(2)(A, 42 U. S. C. §, 179%, only 134%, 9.5 percent, 536 U. S. 956, 42 U. S. C. §, 42 U. S. C. § 1396, 15.1%, 42 U. S. C. §§ 1396r-8(c)(1, 11.1%, more than 75 percent, 49% to, 80%-85%, less than 200%, 100 percent, approximately 55 percent, 95%, 42 U. S. C. §, 42 U. S. C. § 1396, 42 U. S. C. § 1396c, 42 U. S. C. § 1396a(a)(19, 42 U. S. C. §§ 1396a(a, 467 U. S., 42 U. S. C. §, 42 U. S. C. § 1396r-8(d, 42 U. S. C. § 1396, 42 U. S. C. §§ 1396a(a)(1)-(65

NORP: amici, amici, D., §, §, §, §, d., Amici, Halderman, §, Halderman

MONEY: 650 , 651 , 654 , 656 , 657 , 660 Opinion of STEVENS, 662 Opinion of STEVENS, 664 Opinion of STEVENS, 665 , 666 Opinion of STEVENS, 667 , 668 , 669 , 670 Opinion of BREYER, 671 , 672 Opinion of BREYER, 676 THOMAS, 678 , 680 , 684 Opinion, 685 , 686 Opinion, 687 , 688 Opinion

ORDINAL: First, Second, First, Second, third, second, second, first, First, Second, Third, First, Second, third, first, first, first, second, first, first, first, second, third, third, Second, third, third, First, Second, First, Second, Third, first, second, third

TIME: 24 hours, 72-hour, 24-hour, 72-hour, 72-hour, less than 10 minutes

PRODUCT: 104 Stat, PAis

View Full Judgment


Save Judgments// Add Notes // Store Search Result sets // Organize Client Files //