Great-west Life and Annuity Ins. Co. Vs. Knudson

Decided On : Jan-08-2002

Court : US Supreme Court

LAW: the Administrative Procedure Act, the Administrative Procedure Act, Section 502(a)(3, the Judiciary Act's, the Seventh Amendment, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Seventh Amendment, Fair Labor Standards Act, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, Title VII, Title VII's, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, Title VII, the Seventh Amendment and Judiciary Act

ORG: Great-West Life & Annuity Ins, Knudson - 534, Syllabus, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INSURANCE, THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS, Earth Systems, GreatWest Life & Annuity Insurance Co., Plan, Plan, Knudsons, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, Plan, Knudsons, The District Court, Knudsons, Plan, The Ninth Circuit, Government, Court, Harris Trust, Bank, Salomon Smith Barney Inc., Court, Government, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, Court, REHNQUIST, THOMAS, J., STEVENS, BREYER, Acting Solicitor, Court, Court, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, the American Association of Health Plans, AARP, the National Association of Subrogation Professionals, Inc., the Self-Insurance Institute of America, Inc., the Maryland HMO Subrogation Plaintiffs, Earth Systems, the Health and Welfare Plan for Employees and Dependents of Earth Systems, Inc., Plan, Janette, Great-West Life & Annuity Insurance Co., Plan, Plan, Plan, Plan, Knudsons, Hyundai Motor Company, Supp, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, California Medicaid, MediCal, ERISA, Medi-Cal and, Plan, Knudsons, Earth Systems, Plan, The District Court, the District Court, Knudsons, Plan, The United States Court of Appeals, the Ninth Circuit, ERISA, Nation, Nachman Corp., Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, ERISA, Congress, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., Wells, Posner, Contracts § 359, Contracts § 1142, Corbin § 1142, § 502(a)(3)(A, Reich v. Continental Casualty Co., Dobbs, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, State, Medicaid, Congress, Department of Army, the Federal Government, the Federal Government, Corbin § 1102, Reich v. Continental Casualty Co., Posner, Restatement of Restitution, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, KNUDSON , Plan, the Special Needs Trust, Great-West, Medi-Cal, ERISA, Reich v. Continental Casualty Co., Harris Trust, Bank, Salomon Smith Barney Inc., Harris Trust, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, KNUDSON , GINSBURG, STEVENS, Congress, GINSBURG, Dobbs, Restatements, Grupo Mexicano de Desarrollo, Curtis, Congress, Congress, Congress, Westlaw, the United States Code, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, KNUDSON , Congress, Congress, Congress, Congress, Congress, Court, Curtis, Teamsters, Congress, GINSBURG, Congress, Amicus Curiae, Restatement of Trusts, Grayson v. Wickes Corp., Slack v. Havens, Georgia Highway Express, Congress, Curtis, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, KNUDSON , ERISA, ERISA, the Special Needs Trust, the District Court's, Congress, Congress, Congress, the Court of Appeals, Congress, Varity Corp., Varity Corp., § 502, Varity Corp., Varity Corp., ERISA, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, Court, ERISA, Congress, Court, Hewitt Associates, Court, Court, Congress, ERISA, Court, Congress, Varity Corp., Court, Congress, Court, Correctional Services Corp., Narcotics Agents, Bell, Light, Court, Congress, Congress, Congress, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, JUSTICE, Congress, Court, Congress, Congress, Court, Court, Court, the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Fed, Federal Practice, Federal Courts, Congress, Wright & Miller, ERISA, ERISA, Posner, Hewitt Associates, ERISA, Congress, Court, the Special Needs Trust, Knudsons, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, States Marine Lines, Inc., Plan, Knudsons, Special Needs Trust, District Court, Knudsons, Hyundai, the District Court, the Special Needs Trust, the District Court, the District Court, Plan, Knudsons, The Ninth Circuit, the District Court's, Court, the Ninth Circuit's, Knudsons, the District Court, Plan, Court, the District Court's, Congress, Court, Congress, ERISA, Court, Maryland HMO Subrogation Plaintiffs, ERISA, Congress, ERISA, State, Fort Halifax Packing Co., Congress, Court, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, Congress, Court, the Courts of Equity, Albemarle Paper Co., Moody, Congress, Grupo Mexicano de Desarrollo, GINSBURG, Congress, Congress, Knudsons, See Curtis, Porter v. Warner Holding Co., Knudsons, Knudsons, Teamsters, District Court, Macferlan, Court, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, KNUDSON , Legislature, Congress, Congress, Congress, Court, Congress, The Courts of Appeals, Court, Congress, Court, EEOC, Detroit Edison Co., Hubbard, EPA, Teamsters, Congress, Emphasis, Curtis, the Courts of Appeals, Congress, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, KNUDSON , Court, Court, Court, Court, Restatement of Restitution, Court, Court, Congress, Congress, GINSBURG, Congress, Boulting v. Association of Cinematograph, Television, Allied Technicians, Court, GINSBURG, ERISA, GREAT-WEST LIFE & ANNUITY INS, Court, Reich v. Continental Casualty Co., Pomeroy's, Court, Congress, Congress

DATE: 2002, 2001, October 1, January 8, 2002, 1974, JJ, JJ, 1974, 1994 ed., June 1992, 58, 58-59, late 1993, 3611, West 1991, 1993, The day, Great-West, 2000, 1258, 1997, 2001, a decade, 1993, 1980, 1985, 1994, CA7 2000, 1988, 1979, 1964, monthly, 117118, 1994, 2d ed. 1993, 1994, 1999, the days, 36-37, 1995, 1975, CA7 1994, 1936, 1978, Mertens, 36, 2000, today, 1999, 1974, 1964, 1974, 1990, 1994 ed., 1959, 1194, 1196, CA7 1979, 1978, 1091, 1094, 1975, 30-31, 1994 ed., 1974, 1996, today, 1974, 1993, 1996, 2001, 1971, 1946, 1803, Today, the "days, 1974, the "days, nearly 40 years earlier, 1974, 1041, 1987, 2d ed. 1970, 93d, 1041, CA7 1999, 1993, today, 1970, 2001, today, 1987, 29933, 1974, 1946, 1960, 1839, 1975, 1999, 1946, 2d ed. 1993, today, 1987, 1990, 1964, 1994, today, years, 1977, 1110, 1121, CA7 1972, 1974, CADC 1991, CADC 1992, 1990, 1974, 1987, today, today, 1936, 1970, 48, 1961, 1789, 18th-century, 1791, 1974, 1999, 1963, 1980, CA7 1994, 1941, Today

PERSON: KNUDSON ET AL, Janette Knudson, Janette, Eric Knudson, Mter, Janette, money-§, Bowen, Mertens, Mertens, J., C. J., KENNEDY, STEVENS, J., GINSBURG, James F. Jorden, Waldemar, J. Pflepsen, Stephen H. Goldberg, David C. Aspinwall, Thomas H. Lawrence, John M. Russell, Paul R. Q. Wolfson, Underwood, Kneedler, Beth S. Brinkmann, Judith E. Kramer, Allen H. Feldman, Nathaniel L. Spiller, Gary K. Stearman, Richard G. Taranto, Jeffrey S. Pop, Janette Knudson, 88 Stat, Stephanie W Kanwit, Louis Saccoccio, Robin S. Conrad, Jeffrey Gabardi, al, Paula Brantner, Mary Ellen Signorille, Melvin Radowitz, John A. Kukankos, James L. Coghlan, Francis E. Stepnowski, Debra M. Cyranoski, William J. Nellis, Mark D. Spencer, George J. Pantos, Arthur H. Bryant, F. Paul Bland, Leslie Brueckner, Janette Knudson, Eric Knudson, Janette, lien, Prob, KNUDSON Janette's, Judgt, Owens, Mertens v. Hewitt Associates, Massachusetts Mut, Russell, Russell, Bowen, J., A. Corbin, Corbin, Bowen, J., e. g., KNUDSON Bowen v., Bowen, Supp, Bowen, Blue Fox, Bowen, Bowen, Bowen, e. g., Muir, Muir, Mertens, Mertens, GINSBURG, GINSBURG, STEVENS, J., J., Corbin, e. g., S. A. v., GINSBURG, GINSBURG, Terry, Terry, J., Mertens, Harmon v. May Broadcasting Co., Johnson, Terry, GINSBURG, Terry, Terry, Petitioners, GINSBURG, Howe, KNUDSON STEVENS, J., Mertens, Mertens, e. g., e. g., Howe, e. g., Malesko, J., Alexander v. Sandoval, J., e. g., Bivens v. Six Unknown Fed, Madison, Tennyson, GINSBURG, Rule Civ, e. g., 4 C. Wright & A. Miller, C. Wright, Mertens v., KNUDSON , Moragne, Janet Knudson's, Coyne, Congo Rec, KNUDSON GINSBURG, J., Holmberg v. Armbrecht, Mitchell, Robert DeMario Jewelry, Clark v. Smith, S. A. v., J., e. g., Terry, W]e, Mitchell, Terry, e. g., Rogers, Loether, Terry, Terry, Mertens, Ross v. Bernhard, Damsky, Zavatt, Clark, J., Grupo Mexicano, Terry, Grupo Mexicano, J., Mertens, Medforth v. Blake, A]ll, Pettkus v. Becker, Grupo Mexicano, J., Terry, J.

CARDINAL: 99-1786, 209-221, 205, 508, 256, 255, 879, 210, 502(a)(3)(B, 256, 238, 253, 212-218, 256, 219, 208, 221, 206, 206, 221, 532, 891, 1132(a)(3, 59, 45, 208, 208, 209, 208, 221, 122, 508, 251, 361, 134, 147, 254, 146, 258, 8, 210, 210, 257, 256, 213, 398, 401, 879, 918, 255, 211 , 1 See, 3, 199, 5A, 119, 918, 3, 200, 5A, 502(a)(3)(B, 15, 6, 33, 754,756, 1 D., 1.2, 11, 212, 212, 1396b(d, 525 U. S. 255, 261, 889, 502(a)(3)(B, 1, 11, 556, 564-565, 570, 5, 550, 81, 213, 70, 528, 33, 754, 756, 1, 571, 37, 160, 641-642, 1, 587, 160, 1, 1.4, 17, 3.7, 262, 214, 214, 215, 867, two, 1, 588, 608, 256, 249, 33, 756, 33, 756, 81, 238, transferee, 253, 250, 216, 216, 228, 502(a)(3)(A, 217 , 224, 222, 3, 233, 318, 415, 189, 192, 223, 3, 77, 218, 218, 234, 4, 230, 415, 189, 197, 572, 197, 570, 230, 17-19, 255, 256, 252, one, 2000e-5(g)(1, 197, 607, 583, 410, 411, 522, 417, 572, 197, 572, 220, 220, 255, 261, 221, 254, 5, 512, 409, 507, 508, 222, 222, 502(a)(3)(B, 508, 256, 502(a)(3)(B, 256, 209, 512, 515, 75, 275, 294, 392, 678, 684, 403, 397, 1, 137, 163, 3, 217, 224, 224, KNUDSON, 218, 212, 214, 215, 212, one, 2, 415, 189, 195, 135, 67, 282, 4, 131, 187, 703, 508, 257, 220, 214, 226, 226, 375, 405, 1, 4, 2, 9, 120, 228, 228, 220, 261, 392, 396, 291, 13, 195, 203, 405, 417, 336, 256, 197, 402, 557, 3, 12.1(1, 9, 214, 424, 255, 570, 291, 2, 1012,97, 681, one, 402, 197, 572, 255, 219, 4, 213, 218, 4, 515, 301, 467, 231 , 212, 213, 256, 415, 189, 949, 453, 462, 982, 531, 2000e-5(g)(1, 572, 415, 189, 197, 570, two, 572, 571, 424, 232, 256, 217, 160, 645, 1, 4.3(2, 595, 597, 531, 538, 289, 46, 59, 224, 217, 233, 318, 593, 217, 336, 257, 606, 636, 834, 847, 3d, 257, 273, 336, 212, 234, 234, KNUDSON, 216, 209, 258, 8), 255, 33, 754, 756, 181, 257, 217, 256, 576, 221

MONEY: 411,157.11, 13,828.70, 13,828.70, 207 , 411,157.11, 75,000, 650,000, 256,745.30, 373,426, 5,000, 13,828.70, 13,828.70, 3 Restatement, 641-642, 215 distinction, 250-251, 219 , 223 , 225 , 227 , 229 , 676, 230 230, 232

ORDINAL: third, third, third, third, first, third, third, first, third, third, third, Second, Second, Second, first, 5th

FAC: Great-West, Great-West's, Great-West, Great-West, Great-West's, Great-West, Great-West, Plan"which, Great-West, Great-West's, Great-West, Knudsons, Great-West's, Great-West's, Great-West's, Great-West, Great-West's

EVENT: Plan, Plan, Great-West, Great-West, Great-West

NORP: §, §, §, §, amici, Southeast, amici, §, §, §, §, §, d., d., d., §, d., §, §, d., §, §, §, §, §, Trusts §, §, §, d., §, §, §, §, §, §, §, §, §, §, §, §, §, §, Amici, §, §, §, §, §, d., d., §, d., ian, §, d., §, §

PRODUCT: Mertens v. Hewitt Associates, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, the 2, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, 711, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens, Mertens

GPE: Id., Massachusetts, Pp, Pp, the United States, Id., Id., California, the United States, California, the United States, California, Id., Massachusetts, the United States, §, Massachusetts, Massachusetts, Iowa, Redish, Id., Muir, Iowa, Id., Id., the United States, the United States, United States, Id., Id., Id., §, Marbury, Ill., Washington, United States, United States, England, Brennan

WORK_OF_ART: KNUDSON SCALIA, Plan, Plan, KNUDSON Thus, Dobbs §, Dobbs § 12.8(2, Dobbs § 1.2, Restatement of Restitution, Great-West, Mertens, Title VII, 3 All E. R. 97

LOC: the Central States, the Central District, the Central District, English Chancery

PERCENT: 28 U. S. C. § 1441 (, 531 U. S., 446 U. S. 359, 29 U. S. C. § 1132(a)(3, 5 U. S. C. § 702, 42 U. S. C. §, 508 U. S., 527 U. S. 308, 494 U. S. 558, 42 U. S. C. § 2000e-5(g)(1, 29 U. S. C. § 1132(a)(1)(B, 403 U. S. 388, 398 U. S., 508 U. S., 361 U. S. 288, 527 U. S. 308, 415 U. S., 481 U. S. 412, 508 U. S., 494 U. S. 558, 361 U. S., 42 U. S. C. § 2000e-5(g)(1, 415 U. S., 494 U. S., 508 U. S., 431 U. S., 494 U. S. 558, 494 U. S., 481 U. S. 412, 527 U. S., 494 U. S., 527 U. S., 508 U. S., 527 U. S., 508 U. S., 1 S. Symons, 494 U. S.